Report cards could make it harder for parents to choose schools, MPs warned
Sam Freedman, who worked as a policy adviser to Michael Gove when he was education secretary, said he had 'a lot of worries' about the proposals.
He told MPs the previous system of single word Ofsted grades for overall effectiveness for schools had been 'helpful' for parents.
The Government announced last year that headline Ofsted grades for overall effectiveness for schools in England would be scrapped.
Previously, Ofsted awarded one of four single-phrase inspection judgments: outstanding, good, requires improvement and inadequate.
Now schools in England would receive gradings – from the red-coloured 'causing concern' to orange-coloured 'attention needed', through the green shades of 'secure', 'strong' and 'exemplary' – for at least eight areas of a school's provision under the new proposals.
On Monday, Bridget Phillipson, the Education Secretary, said she 'fundamentally' rejected the idea that giving more information on where schools need to improve is 'not something that parents want', after education unions and the sister of a headteacher who took her own life following an inspection criticised the plans.
Schools in England could be graded across a variety of different areas – including attendance and inclusion – using a colour-coded five-point scale.
Mr Freedman told the education select committee that Ofsted's problem has been 'reliability of assessments' and the proposed system of lots of graded sub judgments makes this 'harder'.
He told MPs: 'I'm worried that this makes it harder for Ofsted to tackle its real issue which is reliability and consistency of inspection and doesn't actually deal with any of the concerns that schools have, and possibly makes it harder for parents to use them as well. So I have quite a lot of worries about this new model.'
'I don't think the problem with the previous model was that we had single word judgments and a single overarching judgment. I think that was actually quite helpful for parents.'
The reforms follow criticism of the inspection system following the death of headteacher Ruth Perry who took her own life after an Ofsted report downgraded her Caversham Primary School in Reading from the highest to the lowest overall effectiveness rating.
During the committee on Tuesday, Daniel Kebede, general secretary of the National Education Union (NEU), said: 'We now have eight areas of measurement, (a) five-scale grade, that's 40 potential areas of judgment.
'Ofsted were tasked with bringing about a system of inspection that reduced pressure on the school system in quite tragic circumstances. It's our view that this will make things worse, not better.
'We've all got a shared challenge in regards to the crisis in recruitment and retention – Ofsted included. It's our fear that this will drive more teachers and school leaders out of the profession.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
6 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
The Economist Trump Targeted Over ‘Rigged' Jobs Data
About a year into her tenure as the head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Erika McEntarfer stood before the Atlanta Economics Club and laid out what she saw as two obstacles to her job producing the government's economic data: the cost of doing that work was rising, and the number of people responding to surveys was declining. The bureau, she said, would aim to modernize and keep going. 'If we succeed, the U.S. can continue to have this rich set of economic data,' she told the group.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Yvette Cooper's fast-track asylum plan revealed after protests across UK
The Home Secretary plans to introduce a fast-track scheme to tackle the asylum backlog that aims to turn around decisions within weeks. Yvette Cooper said Labour was planning a 'major overhaul' of the appeal process in the hope it would help to make a significant dent in the numbers. 'We need a major overhaul of the appeal [process] and that's what we are going to do in the autumn… If we speed up the decision-making appeal system and also then keep increasing returns, we hope to be able to make quite a big reduction in the overall numbers in the asylum system, because that is the best way to actually restore order and control,' Ms Cooper told The Sunday Times. The aim would be to compress the process so decisions and returns could happen 'within weeks', the newspaper reported, citing a source familiar with the plans. The Government faces pressure to cut how many asylum seekers are housed in hotels while awaiting the outcome of a claim or appeal. The Home Secretary has previously said she was eager to put a fast-track system for decisions and appeals in place so that people from countries considered safe would not sit in the asylum system for a long time. 'We should be able to take those decisions really fast, be able to take those decisions, make sure that they go through the appeals system really fast and then also make sure they are returned really quickly as well,' she told the Home Affairs committee in June. 'That would mean a fast-track system alongside the main asylum system, I think that would be really important in terms of making sure that the system is fair. 'That will require legislation in order to be able to do that, as well as a new system design.' The Government is also seeking to reduce the number of Channel crossings. More than 25,000 migrants have arrived in small boats this year so far. Tensions over asylum hotels have flared up in recent weeks, with a protest and counter-protest taking place on Saturday outside the Thistle City Barbican Hotel in north London, and also in Newcastle. Chancellor Rachel Reeves has pledged to end the use of hotels to house asylum seekers by the end of this Parliament. Asylum seekers and their families are housed in temporary accommodation if they are waiting for the outcome of a claim or an appeal and have been assessed as not being able to support themselves independently. They are housed in hotels if there is not enough space in accommodation provided by local authorities or other organisations.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Cooper: Fast-track scheme to tackle asylum backlog coming
The Home Secretary plans to introduce a fast-track scheme to tackle the asylum backlog that aims to turn around decisions within weeks. Yvette Cooper said Labour was planning a 'major overhaul' of the appeal process in the hope it would help to make a significant dent in the numbers. 'We need a major overhaul of the appeal [process] and that's what we are going to do in the autumn… If we speed up the decision-making appeal system and also then keep increasing returns, we hope to be able to make quite a big reduction in the overall numbers in the asylum system, because that is the best way to actually restore order and control,' Ms Cooper told The Sunday Times. The aim would be to compress the process so decisions and returns could happen 'within weeks', the newspaper reported, citing a source familiar with the plans. The Government faces pressure to cut how many asylum seekers are housed in hotels while awaiting the outcome of a claim or appeal. The Home Secretary has previously said she was eager to put a fast-track system for decisions and appeals in place so that people from countries considered safe would not sit in the asylum system for a long time. 'We should be able to take those decisions really fast, be able to take those decisions, make sure that they go through the appeals system really fast and then also make sure they are returned really quickly as well,' she told the Home Affairs committee in June. 'That would mean a fast-track system alongside the main asylum system, I think that would be really important in terms of making sure that the system is fair. 'That will require legislation in order to be able to do that, as well as a new system design.' The Government is also seeking to reduce the number of Channel crossings. More than 25,000 migrants have arrived in small boats this year so far. Tensions over asylum hotels have flared up in recent weeks, with a protest and counter-protest taking place on Saturday outside the Thistle City Barbican Hotel in north London, and also in Newcastle. Chancellor Rachel Reeves has pledged to end the use of hotels to house asylum seekers by the end of this Parliament. Asylum seekers and their families are housed in temporary accommodation if they are waiting for the outcome of a claim or an appeal and have been assessed as not being able to support themselves independently. They are housed in hotels if there is not enough space in accommodation provided by local authorities or other organisations.
