Higher education minister keeps up stonewalling on 'SETA panel'
Nkabane had until the close of business on Wednesday to submit records and minutes of the meeting of the 'independent panel' that she says advised on the appointments of the chairpersons of Sector Education and Training Authorities that she was last month ordered to reverse by the presidency.
But at the eleventh-hour on Wednesday, it emerged that Nkabane wrote a letter dated June 10 to Tebego Letsie, an ANC MP who chairs the portfolio committee on higher education, asking that the June 10 deadline be extended by a further 20 days, to June 20.
The higher education committee had given her the deadline of June 11 last week after she refused to disclose the names and full details of her 'independent panel' at a heated meeting, with Nkabane citing the Protection of Personal Information Act.
Nkabane landed in hot water several weeks ago after it emerged that she had appointed controversial and politically connected people to chair the boards of the SETAs.
Among them were Buyambo Mantashe, the son of minerals minister Gwede Mantashe who was once deputised by Nkabane in that portfolio. Also on the controversial list were former KZN premier Nomusa Ncube-Dube, former KZN MEC Mike Mabuyakhulu and Johannesburg MMC Loyiso Masuku.
The move has pitted Nkabane against President Cyril Ramaphosa, who first ordered her to withdraw the names and most recently also asked her to submit a report to him on the matter.
Sources in the higher echelons are adamant that Nkabane's stonewalling on this issue is slowly catching up with her and she will soon run out of options, with some casting doubt on the existence of the 'independent selection panel'.
In her letter to Letsie, which has since been shared with all members of the higher education committee, she placed on 'record and confirm my full intention to comply with the portfolio committee's request'.
Again citing the POPIA and the Promotion of Access to Information Act, Nkabane said she needed more time to ensure that the information she was preparing to send to parliament would be disclosed in a lawful manner.
She told her oversight committee that she had been 'assured that I am legally permitted to disclosed the panellists' details in a lawful manner'.
'For these reasons and in acknowledgment of the panellists' rights to privacy, I have written to each of the members of the selection and evaluation panel and advised them of my intention to comply with the portfolio committee's request.
'However, it remains unlikely that my engagements with them will be completed by the 11 June 2025 deadline. In the circumstances, and to allow the panel members an opportunity to respond to my letter or exercise whatever right they may have, I request an extension of the deadline to 30 June 2025.'
The higher education committee was expected to discuss its response to Nkabane's deadline request in the coming days.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Pretoria Sangoma predicts Cabinet reshuffle for Mchunu, not suspension
A Pretoria-based sangoma claims President Cyril Ramaphosa will not suspend embattled Police Minister Senzo Mchunu but will instead implement a broader Cabinet reshuffle, which may include two other under-fire ministers. Solly Mathebula, known as 'Mkhulu Mahlasela' from Mamelodi, said his bone-throwing reading shows that Ramaphosa will opt to reassign Mchunu to a different portfolio rather than suspending him following allegations of interference in police operations. 'The bones are saying that Ramaphosa will not suspend Mchunu,' he said. Political parties have been calling on Ramaphosa to show Mchunu the door after the allegations. 'He will move him to another department to avoid interference with the investigations. This way, he keeps him active while ensuring the investigations continue.' Ramaphosa is expected to address the nation at 7pm on Sunday. Mkhulu Mahlasela's predictions come after Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi last week accused Mchunu of protecting criminal networks and interfering in police investigations. He alleged that Mchunu disbanded the Political Killings Task Team in March, withdrawing 121 active dockets, many linked to political killings. Mkhwanazi presented WhatsApp messages, SA Police Service (SAPS) documents, and cellphone records as evidence of a coordinated effort to dismantle the task team. He also implicated Brown Mogotsi, a 'comrade' of Mchunu, in communicating with suspects, including business tycoon Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala, who secured a R360 million police contract in 2024. However, the controversial contract was later scrapped. According to Mkhwanazi, Mogotsi informed Matlala that the unit was disbanded and that SAPS crime detection head Lieutenant General Shadrack Sibiya had assumed control of the dockets. Financial links allegedly connect Mchunu, Mogotsi, and Matlala to political events and fundraisers. 'This was no accident,' Mkhwanazi said. 'It was a calculated move to shield a criminal syndicate embedded in law enforcement and politics.' Since its formation in 2018, the task team handled 612 cases and secured more than 100 convictions. Mkhwanazi said efforts to disband it escalated after experts linked weapons to high-profile assassinations. In a December 2024 letter to Police Commissioner Lieutenant General Fannie Masemola, Mchunu claimed the unit had 'outlived its usefulness.' However, Masemola later denied authorising its closure. Mkhulu Mahlasela, who has been reading the bones for more than 15 years, said Mchunu is not the only Cabinet minister likely to be moved. He predicted that Higher Education Minister Dr Nobuhle Nkabane will also be reassigned following backlash over the controversial appointments to SETA boards. This comes after the appointment of politically connected individuals to SETA boards, including the son of Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe, Buyambo and former KwaZulu-Natal Premier Nomusa Dr Dube-Ncube, were appointed during the now-reversed process. 'Nkabane will be reshuffled,' said Mkhulu Mahlasela. 'Ramaphosa won't fire her either, but will just assign someone else temporarily while investigations continue.' Social Development Minister Sisi Tolashe, responsible for the South African Social Security Agency (SASSA), may also face consequences due to issues related to delayed social grant payments. 'The bones say Ramaphosa will act on SASSA issues. There's fraud happening inside the department involving tenders and constant social grants payments delays," said Mkhulu Mahlasela. SASSA, however, previously denied claims that grants have been suspended. In a July 7 statement, the agency said the delays were due to a mandatory national review process targeting beneficiaries with potential undeclared income. 'There has been no suspension of social grants,' SASSA said. 'Grants are delayed only until recipients complete the required reviews.' SASSA CEO Themba Matlou added that the process ensures grants are not issued to the deceased or those no longer eligible. Mkhulu Mahlasela further warned that Mkhwanazi 'needs to be protected' following his explosive allegations. He says the bones say that Ramaphosa may elevate Mkhwanazi to a higher position within SAPS to silence him. 'Ramaphosa is very intelligent… If he does not renew Mkhwanazi's contract, it will raise red flags,' he said. 'He will promote him to a much higher position, not to reward him, but to silence him.' Mkhulu Mahlasela also accused Sibiya of interfering with police investigations and withholding crucial information. 'Sibiya is hiding a lot… His name appears in many of these allegations,' he said. Meanwhile, the nation awaits Ramaphosa's response following mounting calls for accountability. [email protected] IOL
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi and the shape of things to come
While the immediate focus is likely to be on President Cyril Ramaphosa's response to the crisis in our policing cluster, the events of the past week might mark the start of a new era in our security services. As the ANC continues to weaken, there is now a greater risk that they become hopelessly politicised and riven with factions. In a worst-case scenario, they could even start to fall outside democratic control. There is no doubt about the seriousness of the disputes within the SAPS. This is perhaps the first time since 1994 that a President has decided to address the nation on issues relating to security, and disputes within that cluster. Perhaps the only incident which comes close to this is Ramaphosa's address to the nation during the violence in KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng in July 2021. While the dynamics that have led to this recent set of claims by KZN Police Commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi are important, it is also important to remember how deep the roots of the politicisation of our police service are. Arguably, they go back to the decision by then President Thabo Mbeki to appoint Jackie Selebi as National Police Commissioner. Political boundaries It was not just that he was found to be corrupt, but that he also played what now appears to be a political role. His decisions to shut down specialised units were not rational at the time, and have never been properly explained. It is also well known that our police and security services played a factional role in the ANC. Aubrey Matshiqi has explained how, in 2007, he met members of the State Security Agency and advised them to remain neutral in the ANC's Polokwane national conference. As he records, they failed to do so. By October that year, the Constitutional Court had to rule in a case brought by then SSA head Billy Masethla, after Mbeki fired him over his apparent support for Zuma. The consequences of that ruling are still with us today. It was the first case in which judges said someone fired from a government position must be paid until the end of their term. Much has already been said, many times, about how former president Jacob Zuma used the security services. Richard Mdluli, his pick for police Crime Intelligence head, clearly played a political role in Zuma's service. Oscar van Heerden has written about an SSA room at the ANC's 2017 Nasrec conference. He says that when Ramaphosa became aware of it, he went to the room during one of his morning walks, burst open the door and asked those inside what it was for. ANC, security services hopelessly intertwined All of this shows how hopelessly intertwined the police and security services have become with the ANC. This also suggests that this dispute, between different people in the police and a politician, could be further proof of both the divisions in the party, and its weakness. There can be many elements in what places boundaries around the behaviour of people in leadership positions in the SAPS and the SANDF. But two related points must be the political authority and the legitimacy of those voted into office. In other words, even if a police minister does not have the legal authority to order a police commissioner to take certain actions, a minister who is seen to have political authority and political power might find the commissioner follows their suggestion. Also, if the president is seen to have legitimacy while SAPS leaders do not, it might follow that they would always follow his or her lead. If there is a leader without legitimacy, it would be easier to disobey them. It would also follow that if, in a society where so many call for tough action against criminals, or illegal immigrants or any other group, those who lead the security services could believe they have more legitimacy than democratically elected leaders. Political authority and legitimacy Especially if, as in the case of Mkhwanazi, they are seen by the public to be successful. This may explain his strange social media campaign. This might increase the potential for police and military leaders to pursue their own agendas. It seems unlikely that someone like Mkhwanazi might have held a public press conference to attack the police minister of a president as powerful as Zuma or Mbeki were at the height of the ANC's power. Unfortunately, it is likely that our politicians will begin to have less and less political authority and legitimacy. This will make it harder for them to exercise authority, whether moral, political or legal, on those who run different units or parts of the military and the police. There is much to be afraid of here. Matshiqi warned on Newzroom Afrika on Friday that a situation could even develop where a particular figure can behave in the way J Edgar Hoover did in the US from the 1940s. While head of the FBI, he kept files and conducted campaigns against many people in public life. No one felt they could act against him – even presidents did not take him on directly. Over time, Hoover came to amass huge power. This was largely because he could use state resources to spy on people, to conduct phone taps and generally monitor people he was suspicious of. KZN dynamics Matshiqi is entirely correct; it is easy to imagine such a figure emerging here. So fraught could our politics, and our coalitions become, that such a person might even accumulate secret political power. It is no accident that this latest set of claims involves dynamics in KZN. While the individuals and their characters and decisions are important, there may be other factors at play. The politics of KZN may point to the future of our national politics. It is a province that has been governed by the IFP, the ANC, and now a coalition of the IFP, the ANC and the DA. Meanwhile, it has another major political actor in the uMkhonto WeSizwe party. Voters there have changed their minds more often than in other parts of the country, partly because it has had a greater number of bigger parties and partly because it has a bigger set of issues (to oversimplify: in most places political contests have been between the ANC and the DA, in KZN it's always been the IFP, the ANC and the DA). As the rest of the country also now has more parties to choose from, so is it likely that more police and military leaders support different groups, or different factions in different parties. This underscores one of the risks of having no central point of political authority. Of course, there are other possible outcomes. Many parties in government may work together to properly depoliticise the security services. That people who are not aligned to any one group or party are appointed, and then continue to conduct themselves in that way. It is also possible that the character of those in these positions forces them to create new conventions that separate their roles from politics. Over time, those coming up through the ranks would adopt this into the culture of these organisations.
The Citizen
5 hours ago
- The Citizen
Video: Police minister on leave amid allegations by KZN police commissioner
After citizens waited with bated breath longer than expected, President Cyril Ramaphosa addressed the nation earlier tonight regarding national security concerns raised by KZN's police commissioner. Some of the allegations made by Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi include interference in investigations, disbanding the Political Killings Task Team, links to criminal syndicates, collusion with accused individuals, and misleading Parliament. Exactly a week on from these scathing remarks, and due to the president's Brics commitments, Ramaphosa announced that Police Minister Senzo Mchunu has been placed on a leave of absence with immediate effect. The president added that Mchunu has promised to give his full co-operation into an investigation launched by Ramaphosa. This contrasts with earlier media reports suggesting the president had three options regarding the minister: Reassigning him, awaiting his voluntary resignation, or applying the ANC's step-aside rule if he is officially under investigation. Furthermore, a judicial commission of inquiry has been established to investigate these allegations and several other matters, including compromised individuals and legislation. It will be chaired by Acting Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga. The commission will provide an interim report after three months and another after six months. Until August, an acting police minister will be appointed from within Cabinet. Thereafter, Prof Firoz Cachalia, a former Gauteng MEC and current adjunct professor at Wits University, will serve in the position until the next steps are taken. Police Minister spokesperson Kamogelo Mogotsi in a statement said Mchunu has welcomed the decision and expressed his full support for the process. 'I welcome and respect the president's decision and pledge my commitment to the process. Honour and integrity are the virtues I personally subscribe to and which we all need to make efforts to uphold. I stand ready to respond to the accusations against me and account to the citizens of the Republic, fully and honestly so.' Watch the full speech by the president: Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel. Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
