Major call after ‘truth-telling' bombshell
The recently tabled Yoorrook for Transformation report is the result of a multi-year 'truth-telling' process, which found systemic discrimination across Victoria's policing, custodial, childcare and education systems.
In the aftermath of the Report's release, key figures from around the country have spoken about the national appetite for authentic, authoritative First Nations voices at the heart of the truth-telling process, and what that process may eventually look like in each state and territory. A welcome ceremony marks the beginning of a Yoorrook hearing. NCA NewsWire / David Crosling Credit: News Corp Australia
What is Truth Telling?
Truth-telling is the process by which historical and ongoing injustices committed against First Nations people are catalogued for public record, particularly in circumstances where those records have largely been left out of common discourse.
Truth-telling in Australia typically involves the gathering of evidence through a Royal Commission or similar authoritative body.
Queensland
In Queensland, a 'Truth-telling and Healing Inquiry' was established with bipartisan support in 2023 after years of preparation.
In May 2023, then-Opposition Leader David Crisafulli addressed Queensland Parliament to express his enthusiasm for the 'Path to Treaty Bill,' which would enact legislation for the creation of the Truth-telling and Healing Inquiry.
'Path to Treaty is a genuine opportunity for our state to improve the lives of Indigenous Australians,' Mr Crisafulli said. Queensland Premier David Crisafulli addresses the media. Dan Peled / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia
'It is an opportunity I believe Queensland should embrace wholeheartedly.'
Just five months later, in the wake of the failed Voice referendum, Mr Crisafulli changed his tune, claiming the pursuit of treaty and truth-telling would lead to 'more division and uncertainty' and promising the LNP government would repeal the Path to Treaty Act if elected.
After the LNP won Queenslanders over in October 2024, Mr Crisafulli made good on his promise, undoing six years of careful preparation in less than a month in government.
Waanyi and Kalkadoon man, barrister-at-law Joshua Creamer, was the Chair of the Truth-telling and Healing Inquiry at the time it was abandoned. Chair of Queensland's truth-telling and healing inquiry, Joshua Creamer, speaks to the media. Lachie Millard Credit: News Corp Australia
'There was a six-year consultation and engagement process that led to the inquiry. It was conducted in consultation with the community and government, and then the implementation of very specific legislation,' Mr Creamer said.
'We were up and running. We had started hearing evidence, we'd started accepting submissions. We heard evidence from Aboriginal witnesses and director-generals and the Commissioner of Police, and we had even produced our first report.
'There was certainly a lot happening at the time that we were abolished.'
Mr Creamer said the LNP's decision came abruptly and took those working on the Inquiry almost completely by surprise.
'Certainly, those last three or four weeks were challenging but also surprising in terms of the lack of engagement and the level of contempt the Premier and the ministers showed towards the Inquiry,' he said. Protesters outside Queensland Parliament rally against the Government's decision to shut down the truth-telling Inquiry. Supplied Credit: Supplied
'I still have not spoken to the Premier or the Minister about why those events occurred in the way they did. There was just a real disregard – not just for the inquiry but the six-year process that led to its establishment.'
Despite this, Mr Creamer remains optimistic.
'Even towards the end of the Inquiry, I was really surprised by how many non-Indigenous organisations and institutions spoke up in support of the need for the truth-telling process,' he said.
'There will always continue to be a desire for this process to happen. It might just mean we'll be waiting for a change in government for that change to occur.
'The fact that Yoorrook has been successful now is a good demonstration of the importance of the process. It's not going to go away.'
New South Wales
In New South Wales, truth-telling has taken a back seat to make way for immediate treaty consultations.
Three treaty commissioners were appointed in September 2024 by the Minns Government to undertake a year-long consultation process with First Nations communities across the state, to understand whether an appetite for a treaty exists and whether truth-telling will be incorporated into the process.
At the time, Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Treaty David Harris said the appointment of the Commissioners was 'central to the process of listening to Aboriginal people on treaty and agreement-making'. Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Treaty of New South Wales David Harris. Christian Gilles / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia
'We get better outcomes when we listen to the needs of Aboriginal people and communities. We must ensure Aboriginal people have a direct say on matters that affect them,' he said.
NSW Legislative Council member Sue Higgins manages the state Greens' First Nations Justice and Heritage portfolio. She said 'all eyes have paid attention' to Yoorrook and how it established the blueprint for truth-telling in the states and territories. Sue Higgins MLC. NCA NewsWire / David Swift Credit: News Corp Australia
'It arguably has been one of the best processes to date,' Ms Higgins said.
'The First Nations leadership around Yoorrook has been incredible, and the self-determined way in which the power of that process has operated has been very compelling.'
Despite the successes witnessed in Victoria, Ms Higgins said NSW was 'incredibly slow' in getting any form of truth-telling or treaty process up and running.
'The Minns Labor Government came to power in 2023 on the promise they would start the treaty process in New South Wales, and when the Voice referendum failed … there was politicisation and backtracking,' she said.
'That was a frightening period in NSW history, and I think it must have been quite shocking for people.' The Treaty Commissioners: Aden Ridgeway, a Gumbaynggirr man, has had a 'long and distinguished career of service' to Aboriginal people and the broader community. He is a respected First Nations leader, policymaker and strategic thinker. NSW Government Credit: Supplied The Treaty Commissioners: Dr Todd Fernando, former LGBTIQ+ Commissioner of Victoria, focuses on navigating 'complex social and political landscapes'. His academic and practical experience drives progressive change. NSW Government Credit: Supplied The Treaty Commissioners: Naomi Moran is a Nyangbal and Arawkwal woman from the Bundjalung Nation of Northern NSW, also connected by blood to the Dunghutti Nation on the NSW mid-north coast. Former CEO of Koori Mail, Naomi has an extensive career in Indigenous media and a strong affinity for grassroots communities in NSW. NSW Government Credit: Supplied
Ms Higgins said the steps taken to appoint Treaty Commissioners were positive, but it was ultimately unclear – at least until consultations reach a conclusion – where truth-telling sits on the agenda.
'Where exactly a truth process sits within this is interesting, because the NSW government narrative doesn't really talk about truth-telling … for some that may be concerning, but obviously you can't predetermine an outcome,' she said.
'Where the truth-telling will sit at the end of this consultation is really still the open question.'
The Territories
The Northern Territory underwent a significant period of consultation between 2019 and 2023 to establish a path to treaty, part of which included a commitment to a truth-telling process.
In early 2023, the NT government announced the Aboriginal Interpreter Service (AIS) would begin recording testimony for the purpose of truth-telling, and in 2024 the government began distributing hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of grants for the facilitation of truth-telling.
In 2025, the Country Liberal Party (CLP) abandoned the path to treaty and, by proxy, truth-telling.
The Australian Capital Territory does not currently have a formalised truth-telling process.
South Australia, WA and Tasmania
South Australia has legislated a First Nations Voice to Parliament, but no explicit mentions of a truth-telling process have yet been made.
While there is no formal truth-telling process in WA, a joint project between First Nations communities and the WA Government known as the 'Wadjemup Project' was launched in 2020.
The project uncovered the history of Aboriginal incarceration and forced childhood removal in WA.
Tasmania has elected to undergo a process similar to NSW by appointing a body of 'truth-telling and healing commissioners,' which will undertake a similar process to the NSW commissioners but with a focus on truth-telling rather than treaty.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Greens demand PM act on toxic bloom
Anthony Albanese is being pressed to declare a toxic algae bloom, which has crippled South Australia's coastline and plunged seafood industries into peril, a 'national disaster'. The naturally-occurring but harmful algal bloom has plagued the state's beaches for months, killing marine life and plunging the seafood industry into crisis. Reports have emerged of dead fish, rays and sharks washing up along the metropolitan coastline – including North Haven between the river mouth and marina breakwater, Tennyson Beach, north of Grange jetty, and south of Christies Beach Surf Life Saving Club. Several mussel farming sites around the Port Lincoln area have also been shut after shellfish toxins were detected in the area. Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young has called on the Prime Minister to respond to the growing algae bloom 'disaster' in South Australia. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia Greens senator Sarah Hanson Young has says the bloom is a 'national disaster' and therefore required a 'national response'. She called on the Prime Minister and federal Environment Minister Murray Watt to visit Adelaide and 'take some action'. 'If this was happening in Bondi, or on the North Shore in Sydney, the Prime Minister would have already been on the beach, talking to concerned locals and the affected industries,' Senator Hanson-Young said on Wednesday. Reports have emerged of dead marine life washing up along areas of SA's metropolitan coastline. Stefan Andrews / Great Southern Reef Foundation Credit: Supplied More than 200 marine species have been recorded as dead due to a toxic algae bloom in South Australia. Supplied Credit: News Corp Australia 'But today, we've had virtually nothing from the federal government.' South Australia's flagship fisheries patrol vessel Southern Ranger has been deployed to inspect the bloom and help authorities understand its impact. Senator Hanson-Young, the Greens' environment and water spokeswoman, said this should have been happening 'weeks and weeks ago' – pointing out SA's fishing and tourism industries were being 'smashed'. 'Our environment is dying, and our community is alarmed,' she said. The algae bloom was first detected in March. Supplied / Great Southern Reef Credit: Supplied 'This is the climate crisis unfolding before our very eyes, and South Australia can't handle it on our own.' Senator Hanson-Young said she would be moving for a federal inquiry into the crisis when parliament resumes. In their latest update on Wednesday, the SA Department of Environment and Water said the algae – known as Karenia mikimotoi – had been detected in the Port River. Elevated levels were found by authorities along the metropolitan coastline, while 'very high' levels were at the Garden Island and Outer Harbor boat ramps. It was first detected on the Fleurieu Peninsula in March. The bloom quickly spread to other waterways after it was detected in the Fleurieu Peninsula four months ago. Stefan Andrews / Great Southern Reef Foundation Credit: Supplied 'State government agencies are taking weekly water samples at 17 sites across West Lakes, the Port River, the Patawalonga River and the end of four jetties at Largs Bay, Grange, Glenelg and Port Noarlunga,' the department said in their update. The South Australian opposition has already called for a royal commission to explore the origin and consequences of the algae and what could have been done to manage the situation, the ABC reports. Authorities believe a marine heatwave in September last year could have contributed to the bloom. Flooding in the Murray River over 2022 and 2023 washing extra nutrients into the sea, or an unprecedented cold-water upwelling over the summer of 2023-24, may also have contributed. The last large event of this type of algae recorded in SA was at Coffin Bay in 2014. Karenia mikimotoi is not known to cause long-term harmful effects in humans but exposure to discoloured or foamy water can cause short-term skin or eye irritation and respiratory symptoms.
Perth Now
5 hours ago
- Perth Now
Figures make a mockery of Treasurer's claim
Australia is falling further behind its ambitious 1.2 million new home target, as the number of dwellings started, completed or under construction has slipped. According to Australian Bureau of Statistics figures, 27,663 new houses were built in the March quarter, down 1.3 per cent, while new private sector housing came in at 15,190, a drop of 9.3 per cent. When combined, 43,517 homes were built in the March quarter, down by 4 per cent on the December quarter. Last year, the federal government set an ambitious 1.2 million new-home target in five years under the National Housing Accord. In order to achieve this, Australia needs to build 60,000 homes a quarter. Australia is building less than the 60,000 homes a quarter it needs. NewsWire/ Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia In brighter news, there was a 14 per cent lift in new houses started in March to 47,645. Property Council group executive policy and advocacy Matthew Kandelaars said Wednesday's data was further proof Australia needed to be building more homes. 'Progress against our housing targets was never going to be linear, but we've reached the point where we need to hit housing delivery in top gear just to keep pace, let alone get ahead,' Mr Kandelaars said. 'Official data on completions for the March 2025 quarter, nine months into the National Housing Accord, show we're running 18,147 homes behind target. Housing construction has slowed in recent years. NewsWire / Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia 'It takes more than a year to build a home and more than three years to build an apartment project. Yet another quarter of poor numbers means more disappointment for future homebuyers and renters.' The data comes days after partially unredacted files were released to the ABC through a freedom of information request showing that Australia's National Housing Accord would 'not be met'. While Labor has committed to building 1.2 million well-located homes in the five years to June 30, 2029, the target is already 55,300 homes behind following its first year of operation. Despite the slow start, Treasurer Jim Chalmers backed Labor's ability to reach the target, adding that he was 'pretty relaxed' about the accidental FOI slip. Treasurer Jim Chalmers says it's an ambitious target. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia 'Under current trajectories, we would fall short, but that doesn't mean that between now and over the course of the next four years that we can't consider ways and work with the states and territories and others, local governments and others, on ways to build more homes,' he told reporters on Monday. 'It's not the worst thing from time to time for it to be understood in the broader community that this will be a difficult target to meet. 'But if we all do our bit, we all play our part, as the Commonwealth has been willing to play, then we can build the homes that people desperately need.' Acting Coalition housing spokesman James Paterson said the advice from Treasury 'confirmed what Australians already know'. 'Labor will fail to build the 1.2 million new homes they promised,' he said. 'Under the former Coalition government, Australia built an average of 190,000 new homes per year. Under Labor, that figure has dropped to barely 170,000. To meet their own housing target, Labor needs to build 250,000 new homes annually. 'Instead of building housing, Labor are obsessed with building housing bureaucracies.' Mr Kandelaars said the nation's property industry remained ready to deliver but was being held back by settings that deter investment, slow approvals, high development costs and post-approval roadblocks. 'We're building homes half as fast as we were 30 years ago. That's not just a housing issue but a productivity problem,' Mr Kandelaars said. 'Next month's Economic Reform Roundtable hosted by the Treasurer is a chance to put housing delivery at the heart of the national productivity agenda, which means getting investment settings right and focusing on better, smarter and more efficient planning and environmental approvals.'
ABC News
5 hours ago
- ABC News
'Scary' child safety system in spotlight ahead of Queensland inquiry
As Queensland's inquiry into the child safety system announces its first public hearing will begin next week, Dakota McSpadden hopes the process will overhaul the "inadequate'' system she experienced as a child. "It never felt like care; it felt like punishment." Ms McSpadden, now aged 20, came to the attention of child safety at the age of nine, was homeless by 13 and entered residential care at 15. Residential care or "resi", as it is known by some, provides a environment where children as young as 12 live together under the watch of a social worker. Ms McSpadden said it was meant to be supportive, "but it was chaos". "People [in resi] turned a blind eye to what I was doing — I needed help … I never got consequences," she said. "I would act out in anger because I was so scared, and I think that's what a lot of kids do." The Sunshine Coast woman is one of many Queenslanders making a submission to the state government's review into what Premier David Crisafulli has called a "broken" child safety system. Led by former Federal Court judge Paul Anastassiou KC, the LNP's 18-month inquiry is examining how the state supports vulnerable children, including its growing reliance on residential care. As of July 2025, more than 2,000 children were in residential care in Queensland, up from 435 in 2015, according to government records. Residential care becomes an option when foster or kinship placements are not available or suitable. Typically, it is for children over 12, but the government's Residential Care Policy provides for children under 12 to be placed into residential care in "specific circumstances". Rebecca Scott has been a foster carer for 15 years in Queensland and Victoria, and spent a year as a residential care support worker on the Sunshine Coast. She described residential care as "confronting" and "unsafe". In one incident, a 10-year-old held a screwdriver to her throat. "These kids were just trying to out-tough each other." Ms Scott said the children often perceived residential care as a rule-free option. "They sabotage their foster homes to get into resi, then they realise it's scary, volatile," she said. Ms Scott said upon leaving resi to start adult life, many young people were ageing out of the system without any support systems in place. "They're turning 18, and they've got no relationship with foster carers or biological family — no one to turn to except kids they met in residential care," she said. The experience has left her convinced that the system is failing both children and carers. "These kids don't need more workers — they need parents," Ms Scott said. The commission's formal opening and first public hearing is set for next Wednesday, July 23, at Brisbane Magistrates Court. A spokesperson for the commission said it was committed to hearing from people with lived experience. Submissions can be made online and public hearings will be held throughout regional Queensland, with those details to be released this month. The commissioner has also had his first regional visit. He recently met with stakeholders during a two-day visit to Townsville, "where there is a significant demand for child safety services", according to the commission's spokesperson. It is not the first time there has been an inquiry into the state's child protection system. Millions of dollars have been spent over the last 25 years on multiple inquiries, resulting in hundreds of recommendations being handed down. The Create Foundation — Australia's peak body representing the 12,500 children and young people in the state's care system — hopes this process will finally result in meaningful change. But in order for that to happen, chief executive officer Imogen Edeson said it must hear the voices of those with firsthand experience. "They talk about coercive practices, constant staff changes, and not feeling at home. Some are left to navigate the system alone." State Minister for Child Safety Amanda Camm also urged those with lived experience to come forward, but warned Queenslanders would be "shocked by the stories" that emerged from the inquiry. Ms Scott, who has had 72 children in her care since 2000, intends to share her firsthand experience. She is calling for more permanent care options, better support for foster carers, and a limit to residential care settings that lack support for young people. Ms Scott said residential care — where there was "no consequences, no consistency" — needed more structure. Ms Scott argued more support for foster carers "when we set rules" could reduce the number of children heading to resi. "Let us make the mistakes … and then let us repair from them, just like a biological parent would," she said. Reflecting on her years in residential care, 20-year-old Dakota McSpadden said having access to support workers with lived experience would make a huge difference to young people in the system. Ms McSpadden will also be advocating for accessible and ongoing mental health support, safe spaces outside hospital, and greater peer connection and emotional support. "If kids knew there's others going through the same thing, they could help each other," she said. The inquiry is due to provide its final report to the state government by November 30, 2026.
