"The grievances about Hardeep Singh Nijjar and the Khalistan movement were not real": Former Pentagon official slams Trudeau for amplifying exaggerated claims
'The grievances about Hardeep Singh Nijjar and the Khalistan movement were not real': Rubin said, accusing Trudeau of appeasing radical Sikh extremists in Canada and shifting blame to India rather than acknowledging domestic issues.
Rubin further elaborated on Prime Minister Modi's leadership, saying, 'Even Prime Minister Narendra Modi's critics will acknowledge that he has grown tremendously in office and he's now one of the most influential statesmen not only in Asia but in the world. The fact of the matter is that this magnanimity is strategic and it also forces the Canadians to recognise that the problem all along was in Canada and not with India. So, kudos to Prime Minister Modi for this strategy and for rejoining and agreeing to go to Alberta and the fact of the matter is that a strong relationship between India and all of North America is within everybody's interests, especially given the rise of China.'
Touching upon the issue of Khalistani extremism, Rubin stressed the importance of decisive measures from Canada. He said, 'It is so essential that India continued to press Canada to address the Khalistan movement head-on to designate the Khalistan movement and extremists as terrorists, to uproot terror finance and to stigmatize forever these groups that really have no popular legitimacy back home in Punjab or for that matter, among the larger peaceful Sikh community in Canada. It's time to stop allowing the loud, extreme voices to win and instead recognise that those same loud, extreme voices oftentimes deserve to be in prison for their involvement in terror, tax fraud and organised crime in Canada, in San Francisco and elsewhere.'
Reiterating his criticism of Trudeau, Rubin again dismissed the narrative around Nijjar and the Khalistan movement. He said, 'The grievances about Hardeep Singh Nijjar and the Khalistan movement were not real. They were exaggerations that Justin Trudeau amplified...Justin Trudeau may have wanted so much to appease radical Sikh extremists in various constituencies that he was willing to take an organised crime hit between various Sikh groups and mafias and blame an outside power for it, rather than acknowledge the problem and the fault was Canada's alone. That is Justin Trudeau's problem. But now that Justin Trudeau is gone and likely will never return to power, Prime Minister Carney is taking a sober approach and recognising that he is not going to be tied to Justin Trudeau's fictions...'
In this context, Rubin has come out swinging against Khalistanis while praising Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's decision to accept Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney's invitation to the G7 Summit (from June 15 to 17) in Canada.
He believes PM Modi's magnanimity in attending the summit shows 'India has nothing to hide.'
Speaking to ANI on Wednesday, Rubin contrasted former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's approach with that of Carney's, saying Carney 'understands the importance of India' and wants to 'restore maturity to the relationship.'
'Canadian PM Mark Carney originally is a banker. He understands the importance of India. Justin Trudeau was a politician who peddled in image and imagination, and therefore it makes sense that Carney wants to restore maturity to the relationship,' Rubin told ANI.
'It actually makes sense for Prime Minister Modi to show that the problem was not Canada itself, but the immaturity and unprofessionalism of Justin Trudeau,' he added.
Further, the American security expert highlighted that the Indian government is 'willing to have a serious dialogue, much like they had with the United States.'
Rubin added that the problem with 'Justin Trudeau is that for his own domestic, political reasons and to assuage radical constituencies, he was basically shooting from the hip without any factual basis to support his accusations against India.'
'What Prime Minister Modi is showing is that India has nothing to hide. If you're going to have a serious law enforcement dialogue, it's got to be two-way. We've got to talk about illegal immigration into Canada, terror finance in Canada, radical Sikh mafias and how the Khalistan movement is tied to organised crime and terrorism,' he added.
Rubin also raised concerns about the Khalistanis' movements, stating, 'when you give safe haven to any terror group. Ultimately, your own interests are going to be subverted.'
'Justin Trudeau and frankly Pierre Trudeau before him, by embracing and tolerating the Khalistan movement in the face of some of the worst terrorist attacks in the 20th century, what they did is ultimately undermine Canada's moral authority and its strategic importance,' he added. (ANI)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Canada, America — compare and contrast
Opinion Three days and 90 years. That's the difference in age between Canada and America. But the differences between Canadians and Americans have never been on starker display than this, our joint birthday week. It is truly a tale of two countries, a revolutionary society versus an evolutionary community. The United States today is undergoing a second American revolution, one that will determine whether it remains a republican democracy or becomes a presidential autocracy. The signs are ominous. Canada, meanwhile, is engaged in a debate about economic progress and regional and civil accommodation. The signs are hopeful. The Canadian Press files The Peace Tower is pictured on Parliament Hill in Ottawa. The Peace, Order and Good Government clause has shaped the character of Canada, David McLaughlin writes. Two bills tell the tale. Parliament passed Bill C-5 last month, the 'Build Canada Act' meant to eliminate internal trade barriers and accelerate infrastructure projects, with strong majority support from the governing and opposition parties. This past week, Congress passed the 'One Big Beautiful Act,' the largest wealth transfer from the poor to the wealthy in American history, on strict partisan lines. More than differences of policy are on display. Differences of values, culture, and the very role of government are coming to the fore. The U.S. today is asserting 'nationalist sovereignty,' projecting an America-first mindset to protect a perceived superior and threatened cultural way of life. Canada is asserting 'sovereign nationalism,' projecting a distinct and stronger political and cultural identity buttressed by greater domestic economic wherewithal. Consider less than half-a-year of America under Trump. Executive power has exploded at the expense of due legal process to deport migrants and immigrants, using the National Guard and masked, unidentifiable ICE agents to swoop and detain. Law firms have been forced to do free legal work for MAGA-type causes to protect their regular government work, a form of racketeering. Media companies have paid the president or his surrogates tens of millions of dollars to avoid government-sponsored lawsuits against them, threatening freedom of the press. Science and evidence have been shut down in favour of extremist, crank views on vaccines and climate change. Between 12 million and 15 million Americans are about to lose their health insurance, making people sicker and poorer. None of this is being mirrored in Canada, leftist Liberal and rightist Conservative complaints notwithstanding. Even when there is some alignment in policy goals — investing in national defence, more secure borders, less immigration — there is a legitimate Canadian difference. A difference not just in degree but in form. Not just what we choose to do but how we choose to do it. Peace, order, and good government. This sums up the Canadian difference. It sets out our governing culture in constitutional clothing. When Canada was formed in 1867, Parliament was given authority 'to make Laws for the Peace, Order, and good Government of Canada.' This 'POGG clause' was the constitutional device in vogue in the 19th century as the British Empire 'decolonized' itself. Across Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, and South Africa, each of these countries incorporated the phrase into their self-governing constitutions. Uniquely here, though, this means of figuring out who does what jurisdictionally between the national and subnational governments, grew into a governance ethos for Canada. Our constitutional history has not been without contention over this phrase. Federal governments have justified controversial pan-Canadian interventionism with it such as carbon pricing. But these fights have occurred in the courts of law and public opinion with acceptably civil discourse. Blatant disobedience rarely rears itself. This is due to a political culture in Canada that has been historically shaped and influenced by expectations of, and satisfaction with, peace, order, and good government in our political life. Not the legality of the clause but its sentiment. Even as we've experienced a decades-long decline in deference for traditional public, religious, and social institutions, Canadians have opted for an evolutionary reordering of society in response. No national guard deployed here. Even the most revolutionary development in Canada since Confederation itself, the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Weekday Evenings Today's must-read stories and a roundup of the day's headlines, delivered every evening. This is to be celebrated. For it is during the difficult, fraught periods of political and societal tension that constitutional norms and behaviour become most important. In short, it is how you get through to the other side. Especially now as we contemplate how to forge a successful transition of 'sovereign nationalism' from today's unipolar economic vulnerability tied to the U.S. market to tomorrow's multi-polar economic wealth model of multiple markets, a transition that will challenge entrenched political and economic orthodoxies across the country through wrenching, uncomfortable change. Imagine if Trump's 'national sovereigntists' had access to this type of constitutional clause to assert unbridled executive power for their federal government. For what is occurring in America today is the greatest assertion of presidential authority at the expense of congress and the judiciary in that republic's history. This has been a year of resurgent Canadian patriotism. Waving the maple leaf flags, singing the national anthem, and posting 'elbows up' are all on the rise. In this, our birthday week, we should celebrate the true unsung hero of our Constitution — the Peace, Order, and Good Government clause. Over a century and a half, it has shaped the character of governing and the distinctiveness of Canada. It has made us — and keeps us — Canadian. David McLaughlin is a former clerk of the executive council and cabinet secretary in the Manitoba government.
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Authors aplenty in Order of Canada award recipients
Manitoba-born, Toronto-based novelist Miriam Toews wasn't the only Canadian author appointed to the Order of Canada in recent days. Toews was appointed on June 30 along with 82 other Canadians — a group that included a handful of other writers and illustrators. B.C. provincial health officer Bonnie Henry was among the appointees — she penned 2021's Be Kind, Be Calm, Be Safe, published by Allen Lane, in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Elbows Up! Buy on Ottawa lawyer Maureen McTeer was also appointed; her books include 2022's Fertility: 40 Years of Change and 2004's In My Own Name. Buy on Montreal appointee Marianne Dubuc is a French children's author whose books include the Mr. Postmouse series as well as Devant ma maison and the Governor General's Award-winning Le lion et l'oiseau. Buy on Fellow Montrealer Élise Gravel is a prolific children's author and illustrator in both French and English whose 50 picture books include Club Microbe, the Disgusting Critters series and It's My Brain! Buy on Ottawa's David Pelly has written extensively about Canada's North, including books such as 2017's The Old Way North: Following the Oberholtzer-Magee Expedition and Ukkusiksalik: The People's Story. Buy on For a complete list of the most recent appointees to the Order of Canada, see ● ● ● A collection of Canadian authors have come together in a collection being published on Oct. 14 in response to recent aggression shown by the U.S. Elbows Up!: Canadian Voices of Resilience and Resilience was edited by Elamin Abdulmahmoud and features essays by Manitoba writers David A. Robertson, Niigaan Sinclair, Jillian Horton, Peter Mansbridge and the late Margaret Laurence as well as Margaret Atwood, Dave Bidini, Omar El Akkad, Ann-Marie MacDonald, Carol Off, Jen Sookfong Lee, Canisia Lubrin and others. Buy on ● ● ● Montreal author Chanel Sutherland has been named the winner of the 2025 Commonwealth Short Story Prize, an award worth £5,000 (around $9,147). Neuromancer The prize is awarded to the author who has penned the best piece of unpublished short fiction between 2,000-5,000 words. One finalist from five different regions (Canada and Europe. Africa, Asia, Caribbean and Pacific) wins the top prizes, with each of the other finalists receiving £2,500 (just over $4,500). Sutherland has a debut story collection, Layaway Child, forthcoming from House of Anansi Press in spring 2026. ● ● ● South Carolina-born, Vancouver-based sci-fi author William Gibson's seminal debut novel, 1984's Neuromancer, has been announced as being in production for a streaming series coming to Apple TV+. In a very brief teaser trailer released July 1 online, little is revealed about the series, which is based on Gibson's novel that follows a computer hacker and which introduced the work 'cyberspace' into the vernacular. The series will star Callum Turner along with Briana Middleton, Joseph Lee, Peter Sarsgaard, Dane DeHaan and others, and will be created for TV by Graham Roland (Dark Winds, Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan). ● ● ● Every Second Friday The latest on food and drink in Winnipeg and beyond from arts writers Ben Sigurdson and Eva Wasney. Speaking of adaptations, a second version of Stephen King's The Running Man is heading for the big screen in the fall. The dystopian novel follows a character named Ben who must survive a reality TV show with all manner of dangerous, often-fatal challenges and deadly pursuers. The first version of The Running Man was released in 1987; it starred Arnold Schwarzenegger and was directed by Paul Michael Glaser. The new version stars Glen Powell (in Schwarzenegger's role), Colman Domingo, William H. Macy and others and was directed by Sean of the Dead's Edgar Wright. The film is slated to land in theatres in November 2025. books@ Ben SigurdsonLiterary editor, drinks writer Ben Sigurdson is the Free Press's literary editor and drinks writer. He graduated with a master of arts degree in English from the University of Manitoba in 2005, the same year he began writing Uncorked, the weekly Free Press drinks column. He joined the Free Press full time in 2013 as a copy editor before being appointed literary editor in 2014. Read more about Ben. In addition to providing opinions and analysis on wine and drinks, Ben oversees a team of freelance book reviewers and produces content for the arts and life section, all of which is reviewed by the Free Press's editing team before being posted online or published in print. It's part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Toronto Star
2 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Doug Ford heads west to meet with Danielle Smith and promote pipelines
Premier Doug Ford speaks during the northeast governors and Canadian premiers discussion on the impacts of President Donald Trump's tariffs at the Massachusetts State House Library in Boston, on June 16, 2025. JOSEPH PREZIOSO AFP via Getty Im
