Our Médecins Sans Frontières staff are being killed in Gaza. Why are UK ministers enabling that?
This is part of the genocide that is being committed in Gaza. And the UK government is complicit.
At the beginning of April, we at MSF UK wrote to the foreign secretary, David Lammy, detailing our first-hand observations in Gaza. We described the massive influxes of wounded patients and dead bodies being received by MSF teams in medical facilities across Gaza on 18 March, as Israeli forces unleashed attacks of unprecedented intensity, shattering the short-lived ceasefire. We explained that MSF medical staff and their patients had already had to evacuate 17 health facilities and had endured a massive number of violent incidents, including airstrikes damaging and destroying hospitals and health facilities, tanks opening fire on humanitarian shelters, ground offensives being conducted in medical facilities, and humanitarian convoys and ambulances being fired upon by the Israeli military. We noted that not a single hospital in Gaza was currently fully functional, and that about half of them were no longer functioning at all. And we described the complete siege imposed by the Israeli authorities on Gaza.
We noted that this evidence was consistent with the description of ethnic cleansing and genocide provided by legal experts and human rights organisations. We requested a meeting to brief the foreign secretary further and to hear what concrete actions the UK planned, to hold Israel to account for its atrocities against the Palestinian people.
We did not receive a response.
So on 7 May, MSF wrote an open letter to the prime minister describing the use of starvation and collective punishment as weapons of war by the Israeli government against an entire population. We implored the UK government to uphold its obligations as a permanent member of the UN security council to act under international humanitarian law to protect all civilians in Gaza. We also called on the UK government to publicly condemn the Israeli government for the atrocities it is inflicting on the people of Gaza. We warned that failure to take immediate action and to adopt a clear position on these extensively documented and flagrant war crimes and breaches of international law would leave the UK government at high risk of charges of complicity.
We did not receive a response.
In fact, since 1 November 2023 we have repeatedly contacted the government to provide evidence of atrocities directly witnessed and experienced by our hundreds of colleagues in Gaza, to remind the UK of its power and its obligation to act, and to request an urgent high-level meeting.
We never received clear acknowledgment of the evidence that we have provided, nor have we ever been offered that meeting.
We can only conclude that the UK government just does not want to admit what everybody else can see: that genocide is being committed in Gaza, and it is being committed with the military, diplomatic and material support of the UK.
Eventually, on 23 June, we did receive a letter from the parliamentary under-secretary of state for the Middle East, Hamish Falconer. It was woefully inadequate and did not address any of our points. It said only: 'We need further action from the Israeli government now to lift all restrictions on aid, to enable the UN and aid partners to do their work, and to ensure that food and other critical supplies can reach people safely.'
But aid will not stop a genocide. We also need the Israeli government to stop the ethnic cleansing, the war crimes and the crimes against humanity, and to abide by international law and the advice of the international court of justice (ICJ).
Since October 2023, the entire population of the Gaza Strip has been subjected to relentless bombardment by the Israeli armed forces. Gaza's healthcare system has been destroyed, and medical workers, including our MSF colleagues, are systematically targeted by the Israeli military.
Due to the siege imposed by Israel and the obstruction of humanitarian aid, more than 2 million people are currently on the brink of starvation as part of a calculated strategy aimed at eradicating Palestinian society.
The UK government must acknowledge and respect the rulings of the ICJ, and abide by international law and the advisory of the ICJ regarding the plausibility of genocide. MSF has a responsibility to act with moral clarity and humanitarian consistency in the face of mass atrocities.
The same should apply to the UK government.
Dr Natalie Roberts is the executive director of Médecins Sans Frontières UK
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Trump promised to be a ‘peacemaker' president. He launched nearly as many airstrikes in five months as Biden did in four years
In his inaugural address, Donald Trump said his 'proudest legacy' as president will be that of a 'peacemaker.' 'Our power will stop all wars and bring a new spirit of unity to a world that has been angry, violent and totally unpredictable,' the president said in his remarks on January 20. But six months later, Trump has already launched nearly as many airstrikes on foreign nations as Joe Biden did within four years, with analysts asking whether the president's plan to end so-called 'forever wars' involves overwhelming firepower to stop them from happening in the first place. Since Trump returned to the White House, the United States has carried out at least 529 bombings in more than 240 locations in Africa, the Middle East and Central Asia, according to Armed Conflict Location & Event Data (ACLED), an international data collection nonprofit. His predecessor's administration launched 555. 'Trump's preference for engagement begs the question: Does this contradict his promise to end America's wars — or are the foreign strikes how he wishes to keep that promise?' ACLED president Clionadh Raleigh said in a statement. 'The recent airstrikes on Iran's nuclear sites have been framed as a major turning point in U.S. foreign policy. But if you take a step back, they don't stand out — they fit.' 'All of President Trump's decisive actions have been overwhelmingly popular and resulted in greater peace,' White House deputy press secretary Anna Kelly said in a statement to The Independent. ' Operation Midnight Hammer successfully obliterated Iran's nuclear capabilities, and [the Department of Defense's] successful strikes against ISIS and other malign groups killed terrorists want to do harm to Americans,' she added. 'Anyone who sympathizes with evil terrorists and wants them to live should look inward,' she said. A majority of the U.S. military's airstrikes thus far have targeted Iran-backed Houthis in Yemen in an effort to stop their attacks on merchant ships in the Red Sea launched in retaliation for Israel's war in Gaza. The administration struck Yemen at least 474 times within three months, ACLED found. The Biden administration launched 294 attacks in Yemen within roughly 12 months. Trump's airstrikes in Yemen have reportedly killed as many civilians within the eight-week bombing campaign as in the previous two decades of U.S. attacks targeting militants in the country, according to nonprofit watchdog Airwars. At least 224 civilians were killed during the campaign between March and May, compared to 258 deaths between 2002 and 2024, that report found. The administration also launched 44 airstrikes in Somalia to target Islamic State operatives, according to ACLED. Trump first ordered the airstrikes in February, marking the first attacks in the African nation in his second term. 'The U.S. military is moving faster, hitting harder, and doing so with fewer constraints,' according to Raleigh. 'Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, Yemen, Somalia, and now Iran are all familiar terrain, but this isn't about geography — it's about frequency.' Targeted airstrikes don't appear to be a last-resort measure under the Trump administration but 'the first move,' Raleigh added. 'While Trump has repeatedly promised to end America's 'forever wars,' he has rarely elaborated on how,' Raleigh said. 'These early months suggest the plan may be to use overwhelming firepower to end fights before they begin, or before they drag on.' Throughout his campaign, the president accused Biden and, later, his Democratic rival Kamala Harris of leading the United States into World War III. 'These are wars that will never end with him,' Trump said of Biden during a presidential debate in June 2024. 'We're closer to World War III than anybody can imagine.' Receiving the endorsement of now-intelligence director Tulsi Gabbard last year, Trump said the pair was 'uniting forces to end the endless foreign wars.' 'I am confident that his first task will be to do the work to walk us back from the brink of war,' Gabbard said at the time. 'We cannot be prosperous unless we are at peace.' Trump — vocal about his desire for a Nobel Peace Prize, and nominated for the honor by at least four of his allies — also promised his administration would bring an end to Russia's war in Ukraine and Israel's war in Gaza. On Monday, the president laid out prospective steps to pressure Russia to end its war, including sending more weapons to Ukraine and threatening economic sanctions in Moscow if there is no peace agreement within 50 days. 'I felt we had a deal about four times,' Trump said. 'But it just kept going on and on.' His administration has also failed to broker a ceasefire in Gaza as Palestinians face threats of famine and Israeli airstrikes continue to bombard the strip. A tentative Trump-backed plan to force hundreds of thousands of Palestinian civilians into an area controlled by Israel's military close to the Gaza-Egypt border has also threatened to derail ceasefire talks. The Independent
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Mike Waltz defends his use of Signal app during Senate hearing
National security adviser Mike Waltz faced questioning regarding his use of the encrypted app Signal for sensitive military discussions, a matter dubbed the 'Signalgate' scandal. During a Senate hearing, Waltz was questioned about adding The Atlantic editor Jeffrey Goldberg to a Signal group chat discussing a military operation in Yemen. Waltz defended his actions by asserting that the use of Signal was authorized under Biden -era Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) guidance. Conversely, Department of Defense policy explicitly prohibited the use of commercial encrypted messaging applications, including Signal, for transmitting non-public DoD information. Signal group chat.
Times
3 hours ago
- Times
Israel hits Syrian troops in Druze city of Sweida after violent clashes
Israel has carried out strikes on Syrian soldiers as they deployed in the southern Druze city of Sweida on Tuesday to impose a curfew after clashes are said to have left over 100 dead. Damascus had been warned by Israel against sending troops and armour to the south, closer to its border, which Israel wants to turn into a demilitarised zone. It has also said it would not allow any harm to the Druze, a minority with a sizeable population in Israel, alongside Syria and Lebanon. Binyamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, said in a statement he had instructed the military to intervene to 'prevent harm to the Druze in Syria' and to police the demilitarisation zone, which Damascus had not agreed to. The Israeli military said it had targeted several tanks and armoured vehicles in the airstrikes. Syria's foreign ministry said that it held Israel fully responsible for the latest attacks and any consequences. In a statement, the ministry said that it would protect all Syrian citizens without exception, including the Druze. Syrian government forces had begun deploying in the city on Tuesday after an agreement with Druze religious leaders to end some of the deadliest fighting in Syria since March, when the new government put down an insurrection by another minority, the Alawis that ended in massacres of civilians. But as they started to enter the city, a leading Druze leader recanted a statement welcoming them, saying he had been forced to issue it under duress, and called for 'resistance'. The government later agreed to withdraw its soldiers and replace them with a police force. The latest violence began with clashes between the Druze and Bedouin tribes, which involved government forces. Syria's interior ministry said at least 30 people were killed but a Syrian monitoring group put the toll at 116. On Sunday Bedouin gunmen abducted a Druze vegetable vendor on the highway to Damascus, prompting retaliatory kidnappings and escalating unrest. In Israel, dozens of Druze held protests in various locations demanding the government do more to intervene and support their brethren, blocking roads and torching car tires in some instances. Some protesters were believed to have crossed the border with Syria. Israel's military posted on X that their 'troops are currently working to safely return the civilians' home. Please enable cookies and other technologies to view this content. You can update your cookies preferences any time using privacy manager. The Druze make up about 1 per cent of Israel's population, but many hold senior positions in the military and police. Israel had taken a hardline stance on the new government, which is led by Ahmed al-Sharaa, a former al-Qaeda commander who led rebels into overthrowing the Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad in December. It had warned Sharaa against sending forces to the south, nearer to its border, and conducted several airstrikes against his troops, saying it wanted to protect the Druze in the south. However, it has also held talks with his government on security arrangements after its troops took over a buffer zone and more territory in Syria after Assad's overthrow. Amichai Chikli, Israel's diaspora affairs minister, called for Sharaa to be 'eliminated without delay', accusing the Syrian leader on both his English and Hebrew X accounts of being a 'terrorist, a barbaric murderer'. Sharaa has struggled to impose the central government's authority on the country, which was riven by a decade-long and increasingly sectarian civil war under Assad, who hailed from the Alawi minority. In March, Syrian troops and allied militia were accused of massacring hundreds of Alawis after insurrectionists killed several dozen soldiers, raising concerns among the Druze, who have refused to come under the new government's authority. Sharaa, however, received a boost from President Trump two months later, after Trump agreed to meet in the Saudi capital, Riyadh, and lift all sanctions on the country. Trump also rescinded a US terrorism designation against Sharaa and his former rebel group, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham. In northern Lebanon, Israeli airstrikes killed at least 12 people, including seven Syrians who were in a displaced people's camp, the Lebanese news agency reported. The Israeli military said it had struck Hezbollah targets in the area as it tries to prevent the militia from rearming and regrouping after a war last year.
