Parents of children with undescended testes not told of cancer risks
Lucy Nugent, the chief executive of Children's Health Ireland (CHI), told the Oireachtas Committee on Health that the parents did not meet the threshold for open disclosure.
Advertisement
Executive and senior clinicians from CHI appeared before the committee on Thursday to update politicians on spinal surgeries, a review of hip surgeries and other governance issues at CHI.
The committee was told that concerns about orchidopexy – a surgical procedure to correct undescended testes – were raised in an unpublished report.
Executive and senior clinicians from CHI appeared before the committee on Thursday to update politicians on spinal surgeries, a review on hip surgeries and other governance issues at CHI (Anthony Devlin/PA)
Sinn Féin TD David Cullinane said that despite young patients being put at a real risk of fertility issues and cancer later in life due to delayed treatment, parents and families were not told about the risks, nor a report into the concerns.
Mr Cullinane said: '(The report) says, despite an existing alternative options being available for quicker treatment, patients with undescended testes who require this procedure are waiting far in excess of the recommended time frame for treatment, placing those patients at real and known risk for fertility issues and or cancer in later life.
Advertisement
'I mean, that's shocking that that can happen.'
Asked why the report was not published, Ms Nugent said the anonymised report made no sense.
Mr Cullinane said 'the patients were placed at real and known risk for cancer' but parents were not told about the report.
It was also confirmed that families were not made aware of a report about concerns relating to the care of children under CHI, and other parents were not told about a separate report about concerns raised regarding oncology, which was completed in August 2021.
Advertisement
Mr Cullinane said that was 'profoundly shocking'.
Mr Cullinane said that the full breadth of crises and scandals that have hit the CHI has left it 'almost impossible' to give any justice to the families.
'We had the Boston review, we had the HIQA review into the use of non-medical grade springs. We have a waiting list still for children with spina bifida and scoliosis. We had an audit into hip dysplasia, potentially hundreds of procedures that were carried out unnecessarily.
'We have this unpublished report, which cites concerns in relation to oncology, urology, orthopaedics, a lot of different issues. It's frightening what was happening in CHI and families, I have to say, feel very let down.'
Advertisement
The committee was also told that the CHI does not accept that a report on waiting list irregularities and a 'toxic' work culture at a hospital run by the CHI met the threshold to be referred to gardaí.
The report, which has not been published, has been reported in some media outlets.
Kate Killeen White, the regional executive officer for the Dublin and Midlands health region, confirmed that the HSE referred the report to gardaí.
She told the committee that CHI has since verbalised an opinion that it doesn't believe it meets the threshold for referring it to gardaí.
Advertisement
Mr Cullinane said he found that 'extraordinary'.
He added that he could not accept that there has been a cultural shift within the CHI following the revelations.
Earlier, Ms Nugent apologised to children and families affected by practices and governance issues at CHI.
Ms Nugent, who joined as chief five months ago, said she was sorry on behalf of the management of CHI and 'I am sorry on behalf of the entire organisation'.
A clinical audit of surgeries for dysplasia of the hips in children found that a lower threshold for operations was used at CHI Temple Street hospital and the National Orthopaedic Hospital Cappagh (NOHC) than the threshold used at CHI Crumlin.
The review discovered that in the period 2021 to 2023, almost 80 per cent of children operated on at the NOHC, and 60 per cent of those at Temple Street, did not meet the threshold for surgery.
Around 2,200 families whose children had surgery since 2010 have been written to and told they will be offered a medical review.
Dr Martin Daly, a Fianna Fáil TD and health spokesman for the party, said there is 'zero confidence' in the board of the CHI.
Dr Daly, who has been a doctor for 40 years, said the 'sense of gravity' of what happened to the children was not reflected in Ms Nugent's statement to the committee.
He added that what happened to the children was 'scandalous'.
'This is about the whole system failure, and when you talk about moving into CHI, the new hospital, 2.5 billion, it's like having top-of-the-range hardware for your computer and the software is rotten,' he said.
'There's no other way to put it, and I don't think you imparted the sense of realisation of the anger.
'There is a whole generation of children who have been operated on who shouldn't have been operated on, on spurious evidence without proper audit and without proper governance.'
He said that it all happened under the watch of Eilish Hardiman, the former chief executive of the CHI, who attended the committee hearing.
Ms Hardiman is now CHI's strategic programme director.
'Miss Hardiman, you were there, it looks like under your regime, you were rewarded for substandard management of the hospital, and I am saying that strongly, because all of this happened under your watch,' Dr Daly added.
'I have to say there is absolutely zero confidence in the CHI board, zero confidence in the management, notwithstanding the changes you've outlined Ms Nugent, but there is zero confidence.'
Becoming emotional, Ms Nugent said it keeps her awake at night.
'If I in any way did not convey the gravity of the situation, I apologise. It keeps me awake,' she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
The genetic factor that could impact a child's future weight, according to experts
A mother's genes could play a role in determining a child's future weight – more so than a father's. Researchers at University College London (UCL) investigated how a parent's weight and genes influence their children's weight and diet from birth to age 17. To make the comparison, researchers used genetic and health data of 2,621 UK families in the Millennium Cohort Study, a UK birth cohort study of individuals born in 2001-2002. The study, published in the journal PLOS Genetics, looked at the BMI of parents and the birthweight of their children. They also looked at the child's diet at ages three, five, seven, 11, 14, and 17. Children's diets were assessed through self-reported records of how often and how much they consumed different food groups, including fruit, vegetables, fast food, and sugary drinks. Researchers then separated the direct effects of inherited genes from the indirect effects of genes that were not inherited. Study authors explained that non-inherited genes can still influence children's outcomes by influencing the development environment, such as conditions in the womb and parenting practices, as these are shaped by parents' genetics. Analysis revealed that while both parents' genetics influence a child's BMI, a mother's BMI continued to affect the child's weight beyond direct genetic inheritance. Researchers suggest this means genetic nurture, where a parent's genes shape the environment they create for their child, might be a big factor in a child's weight. This could be the case if a mother's genes influence her own weight, eating habits, or behaviours during pregnancy, which in turn can affect the child's development and long-term health. Dr Liam Wright, the study's lead author, said: ' Mothers ' genetics appear to play an important role in influencing their child's weight over and above the child's genetics. 'In addition to the genes mums directly pass on, our findings suggest that maternal genetics are instrumental in shaping the environment in which the child develops, therefore indirectly influencing the child's BMI too.' Almost a third of children aged two to 15 were considered to be obese or overweight in 2024, according to NHS data. However, researchers acknowledge BMI is not the most accurate way of measuring body fat, particularly among children, and so supplemented their analysis with several other adiposity-related measures, including fat mass. Dr Wright added: 'This isn't about blaming mothers, rather, supporting families to make a meaningful difference to children's long-term health. Targeted interventions to reduce maternal BMI, particularly during pregnancy, could reduce the intergenerational impacts of obesity."
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Family horror as suicide clinic ‘sends them WhatsApp saying their mum, 58, is dead and her ashes are in the post'
AN IRISH family was left devastated after allegedly receiving a text from a Swiss assisted dying clinic that their mum was dead and her ashes would be sent by post. Maureen Slough, a 58-year-old from Cavan, travelled to the Pegasos clinic on July 8 to seek an assisted death - without her family's knowledge - according to the Irish Independent. 2 Maureen reportedly told her family that she and a friend were going to Lithuania. "I was actually talking to her that morning and she was full of life," Maureen's partner Mick Lynch told the newspaper, speaking about the morning of her death. "She said after having her breakfast... she was going out to sit in the sun. Maybe she was heading off to that place. I still thought she was coming home." Her daughter, Megan Royal, then received a heartbreaking WhatsApp message, which allegedly said her mum had died listening to gospel music sung by Elvis Presley. The family is shocked that the clinic would accept an application for assisted dying from Maureen, who they say had long struggled with mental illness. She had also attempted suicide a year prior, after the deaths of her two sisters. Adding to their dismay, the family claims the clinic never informed them of her plans. Friends are reportedly horrified by the clinic's method of returning the ashes via parcel post. Her friend, Stephanie Daly, told the newspaper: "You get letters in the post, not people." Desperate for answers, the family found out Maureen had paid a reported £13,000 to the Pegasos Swiss Association to assist her death. Car bursts into flames in busy Glasgow street sparking rush hour chaos The Pegasos group is a non-profit voluntary assisted dying organisation. According to its website, the clinic believes it's "the human right of every rational adult of sound mind, regardless of state of health, to choose the manner and timing of their death". The group allegedly said it received a letter from Megan, stating she was aware of and accepted her mum's decision to die. The clinic also claims it verified the letter's authenticity through an email response from Megan, using an email address her mum provided. But Megan insists she never wrote the letter or verified any contact from the clinic, the report said. The family claims Maureen may have forged the letter and created a fake email address to verify it. Her brother Philip, a UK solicitor, claims Maureen provided the clinic with "letters of complaint to medical authorities in Éire in respect of bogus medical conditions" - which Pegasos then used as supporting documents for her application. Megan reportedly argues her mum's decision to go to the clinic was made in a state of grief, as a result of her sisters' deaths. She also cites her mum's difficult upbringing as a child. It is understood that in the past few weeks, the family has received handwritten goodbye letters from Maureen. The Pegasos group maintains that it carried out an extensive assessment of Maureen's mental health - including an independent psychiatric evaluation. They added that Maureen told the clinic she was in unbearable and unrelievable chronic pain and that they received supporting medical documentation from her pain-management consultant. Regarding the letter, the clinic claims Megan confirmed its authenticity via email and apologised for not being able to accompany her mum to Switzerland. The clinic claims the letter expressed that while Megan was unhappy with her mum's decision, she accepted it. Maureen's brother wants the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, along with Swiss authorities, to conduct an investigation. "I am working on the assumption that my sister created this email and the clinic's procedures were woefully inadequate in verification," he wrote. "The Pegasos clinic has faced numerous criticisms in the UK for their practices with British nationals, and the circumstances in which my sister took her life are highly questionable." When approached for comment by the Daily Mail, the Pegasos Swiss Association said it could not "share, confirm, nor deny the identities of our patients in public". It added: "When talking about voluntary assisted death in Switzerland, it is important to understand that all organisations are legally bound to do careful prior assessment. "Pegasos has always respected the applicable Swiss law without exception and continues to do so." Maureen's family's story is not unique. Other families have also slammed Pegasos, claiming they had no knowledge that their loved ones would undergo assisted deaths. In 2023, Pegasos reportedly vowed to contact a person's relatives beforehand after 47-year-old teacher Alistair Hamilton - who had no diagnosed illness - died, leaving his family shocked. However, in 2025, the organisation appeared to break this promise. Anne Canning, a 51-year-old British mum, who was battling depression after the sudden death of her son 19 months prior, ended her life at the clinic, ITV first reported. Her family were allegedly not informed of her decision - only finding out after they received goodbye letters she had written shortly before her death.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Obesity runs in the family – but one parent's genes have more influence on a child's weight, study finds
OBESITY does get passed down through families, but one parent's genes may play a bigger role in children's weight, scientists say. UCL researchers looked at the body mass index (BMI), diet and genetic data of over 2,500 families. They found that kids whose parents were obese were more likely to be obese themselves. But children's weight was more heavily impacted by the genes of a specific parent. A mum's genetics may play a bigger role in determining whether a child becomes overweight than a dad's - even if those genes aren't passed down. Lead author Dr Liam Wright, from the UCL Social Research Institute, said: 'Mothers' genetics appear to play an important role in influencing her child's weight over and above the child's genetics. 'In addition to the genes mums directly pass on, our findings suggest that maternal genetics are instrumental in shaping the environment in which the child develops, therefore indirectly influencing the child's BMI too.' Published in PLOS Genetics, the study analysed genetic and health data from 2,621 UK families. Researchers investigated how parents' BMI and related genes influenced their children's weight and diet from birth to age 17. To do this, the team looked at the kids' weight, BMI, and diet at six key points during childhood and adolescence, at the ages of three, five, seven, 11, 14, and 17. They focused on how these were linked to the parents' BMIs. Children's diets were assessed through self-reported records of how often and how much they consumed different food groups, including fruit, vegetables, fast food, and sugary drinks. The 7 ways you're making your kids fat without knowing it - and why it might be time to bin your By measuring both children's and their parents' genes, the researchers were able to separate how inherited genes affected the kids, versus the indirect effect of genes that were not inherited. Non-inherited genes can still influence children's outcomes by influencing their development environment, researchers explained. For example, conditions that babies are exposed to in the womb and parenting techniques can all be shaped by parents' genes. Researchers found that both parents' BMI was linked to their child's BMI. But a dad's influence could mostly be attributed to direct genetic inheritance. Meanwhile, a child didn't need to inherit their mum's genes for their weight to be influenced by hers. For example, a mum's genes might influence her own weight, eating habits, or behaviours during pregnancy, which in turn affect her child's development and long-term health. This suggests, that genetic nurture - where a parent's genes shape the environment they create for their child - is a big factor in children's weight, researchers said. Dr Wright stressed: 'This isn't about blaming mothers, rather, supporting families to make a meaningful difference to children's long-term health. 'Targeted interventions to reduce maternal BMI, particularly during pregnancy, could reduce the intergenerational impacts of obesity." Childhood obesity is a continuing problem in the UK - as well as other countries - with NHS data from 2024 showing 27 per cent of children aged between two and 15 were either obese or overweight.
