logo
Mica Miller's story continues to inspire change, engage activists on first anniversary of her death

Mica Miller's story continues to inspire change, engage activists on first anniversary of her death

Yahoo27-04-2025
MYRTLE BEACH, S.C. (WBTW) — In the year Mica Miller died at Lumber River State Park in Robeson County in what authorities have ruled a suicide, much has changed.
Solid Rock Church, a Market Common ministry the 30-year-old loved deeply is no more, while her estranged husband has been investigated by the FBI and sued multiple times over sexual assault allegations.
Mica was active at Solid Rock, running its women's ministry, helping with its graphic design and heading up worship sessions.
Documented incidents of emotional and psychological abuse by Miller's former partner, Myrtle Beach-area pastor John-Paul, have emerged through police reports and court records — prompting a grassroots movement to strengthen South Carolina's domestic violence laws.
Just days before the anniversary of her death, state Sen. Stephen Goldfinch, (R-Murrells Inlet), introduced legislation that would criminalize coercive control.
In other ways, much has remained the same. South Carolina still ranks near the top in reported domestic violence cases, and demands for justice on behalf of Mica and others continue to draw attention.
Sunday's Walk to Remember at The Market Common is the latest reminder that Mica Miller's legacy continues to inspire and engage activists pressing for more comprehensive domestic violence prevention and protection laws.
Here's a look back at News13's coverage of Mica Miller and her life:
The earliest indication of just how deeply Mica's death would resonate in her community came on May 5, when hundreds of people gathered outside of Solid Rock Church in a display of solidarity, laying a foundation for what would become known as the 'Justice for Mica' movement.
'I came out today to support her, to support her family, to support her story,' said Melissa Snyder. 'Because her story is important, and it needs to be told.'
Don Sites, who also attended the morning event, recalled Miller for her warmth.
'I remember one time, just passing by saying 'hi,' and she had the biggest smile on her face saying 'hi' back,' he said.
As Mica's story unfolded publicly, her strained relationship with John-Paul was at the center of it all. Two days before her death, she served him with divorce papers. Horry County police reports obtained by News13 in early May 2024 revealed that a GPS tracker was placed on her vehicle.
MIller made two complaints on March 11 — the first coming after her vehicle's tire was found slashed near Springmaid Pier, the report said. The second complaint, filed hours later, came after Miller took her vehicle to East Coast Honda on Highway 17 Bypass to have the tire repaired.
The police reports indicate that the suspect in both incidents was a male.
According to the police reports, Miller first contacted officers at about 1:20 a.m. on March 11 to report one of her tires had been slashed. Officers met her at a Margarita Drive address.
Miller told officers that 'this is the second time a razor has deflated her tire in the last week,' the report states. Miller said she was leaving Springmaid Pier when she 'heard a pop and noticed that a piece of metal was protruding from her tire.'
Probate court documents filed by two of Mica's siblings showed that their sister feared for her life amid divorce proceedings, at one point confiding that, 'if I end up with a bullet in my head, it was JP,'' Mica's sister, Sierra Francis, said in an affidavit asking to be named the special administrator of Mica's estate.
The May 2 affidavits filed by Sierra and Nathaniel Francis allege a pattern of abuse and harassment toward Mica by her husband.
'I know my sister to have expressed the abuse and violence against her by her husband to others, including family members and members of the church congregation,' Sierra Francis' affidavit said.
Sierra Francis said her sister told her that people were following her and indicated that her husband had hired people to follow her. The affidavit also alleges that John-Paul transferred assets, including the deed to their home, to one of his sons and moved his wife's personal belongings from their home while she was undergoing treatment at a mental-health facility.
Over 10 days in March, Mica Miller used her Facebook page to deliver words of affirmation and messages of strength — ending each one with a smile.
Five videos posted between March 18 and March 28 — totaling just over nine minutes — pulled in more than 5,000 positive reactions.
'My Bible says He took all the abuse you could think of for you so that you didn't have to live that life of slavery and bondage and pain', she said on March 22.
'You don't have to stay in an abusive relationship, whether that's sexual, whether that's somebody forcing you to take illegal drugs or alcohol abuse or physical abuse, psychological abuse, making you think this is all your fault, or you're a bad mom, or you're a bad wife or you're a bad husband, or you're not giving it your all when you know you are,' she said.
Mica Miller called 911 on April 27 and told authorities she was about to kill herself — purchasing a gun that same day, Robeson County authorities said.
'I'm about to kill myself and I just want my family to know where to find me,' Miller said in the call, according to authorities.
That was at 2:54 p.m., and by 3:03 p.m., deputies were sent to Lumber River State Park where her body was found. Mica's relatives were given the information during a May 7 meeting with Sheriff Burnis Wilkins and other investigators.
Mica-MillerDownload
After that, authorities revealed how Miller spent the final hours of her life — releasing a meticulous timeline and other pieces of evidence to substantiate the medical examiner's conclusion that Miller committed suicide.
Authorities confirmed John-Paul spent the night in Charleston at the time of his wife's death. He was seen traveling on Highway 17 Bypass in Horry County at 2:22 p.m. on April 27.
'Unfortunately, rumors and conspiracy theories were spreading quickly, and assumptions were being made. However, in the end, we must make decisions based on the facts, and evidence that has been gathered,' Wilkins said in a news release at the time.
John-Paul began 'grooming' Mica before the couple wed in 2017, according to a Myrtle Beach police report obtained by News13.
Miller made the allegation in a Feb. 21 complaint about a stolen vehicle after being discharged from an involuntary hospital stay.
Court documents show that John-Paul had power of attorney over Mica's healthcare, and he told officers Miller was prone to 'episodes on an annual basis' around Christmas.
John-Paul said his wife 'spends large amounts of money when she stops taking her prescribed medication,' and acknowledged having the car to prevent it from being sold.
John-Paul Miller told police 'the vehicle was martial property and that he was unwilling to give back to his wife for a month, which he stated was usually the timeframe of these reckless episodes.
John-Paul's attorney Russell Long denied Mica's allegations in a lengthy statement.
'Following the untimely death of Mica Miller, unfounded rumors and false accusations began circulating on social media and in various media outlets, suggesting Pastor Miller's involvement in her demise,' he said in a news release. 'This created a buzz, causing local and national media outlets to be proliferating these falsehoods, on a mammoth proportion. Our client refutes any report that suggests he ever abused his wife.'
A man who was fishing nearby when authorities said Mica Miller shot and killed herself at a state park near Lumberton says he heard the gunshot and then found some of her personal items on the riverbank when he went to investigate.
In an exclusive interview with News13, Johnnie Jacobs, who asked not to be shown on camera, said he has been harassed on social media since the April 27 incident in which authorities said Miller bought a gun in Horry County and then went to the park and took her own life.
On the day of the shooting, Jacobs said he remembers hearing cries from that area and a single gunshot. After that, he said the cries stopped.
'As I decided that I was going to stop fishing, I came back through, stopped where they call it a slew or a lake off of the river,' he said. 'So, I pulled in there with my little boat and, maybe five minutes after, and maybe five minutes into the slew, I heard a cry. I heard it for about two or three minutes. Then I stopped, heard a gunshot. Then, the crying stopped.'
Jacobs said he could not see Miller but that if he could have seen her he would have tried to help.
'If it had been a person that was crying in the open, I would have checked on them all day long,' he said. 'I just wish I would have gone in there and checked on her.'
Jacobs was killed in a March 14 car wreck when authorities say his car was t boned.
Mica filed multiple police reports more than month before she died, complaining of GPS trackers tacked to her vehicles.
They don't give any indication from police about who placed the trackers on the vehicles, but the documents say Mica's brother Nathaniel forwarded him an email from John-Paul in which he apologized for the 'tires and causing damage to her vehicle.'
In November 2023, Sierra Francis called 911 after receiving threatening texts from John-Paul, according to the phone call obtained by NewsNation.
The call was made by Mica's sister when Mica was staying with her. She made the call after receiving threatening texts from John-Paul, quoting him in it as saying 'you better drive down the road now or there is going to be hell to pay.'
In the call, Mica's sister told the dispatcher that John-Paul was threatening suicide and that he texted 'blood is going to be on your hands.' The sister asked for a police officer to check the roads to ensure John-Paul did not show up.
'Call the cops, I don't care,' John-Paul allegedly told Mica's sister. 'I'm armed and ready.'
According to Horry County and Myrtle Beach police records, Mica reported four instances of GPS trackers being placed on vehicles she was driving.
News13 began looking to domestic violence laws in South Carolina for victims of stalking and harassing as Mica's story continued to grab attention.
According to state law, for someone to be convicted of stalking, victims must be able to show a pattern of two or more acts within a 90-day period.
Mica Miller made five police reports related to harassment and stalking in that 90-day period. However, no arrests were ever made.
'Stalking and harassment are just beginning, and they lead to much bigger things that unfortunately, in this case, Mica lost her life because of it,' said Allicia Young, a former Solid Rock Church member and friend of Mica.
Young launched an online petition urging lawmakers to adopt 'Mica's Law,' which as of April 26 had garnered more than 40,000 signatures with hundreds of comments from people who said they or a loved one have experienced some type of domestic violence.
Some of Mica Miller's personal belongings were turned over to an attorney after lawyers for her family and her husband John-Paul Miller reached an agreement on June 5.
'One of the primary issues we were seeking a court order from the judge is possession of Mica's personal property that's being held in the possession of the Robeson County Sheriff's Department,' Conway attorney Regina Ward said at an hourlong news conference outside the Horry County government building.
The deal came shortly before a scheduled hearing in Horry County Family Court to discuss Mica's estate. That session was canceled.
Ward said the car Mica drove to Lumber River was titled to her godmother, who will retain possession of it under the terms of the agreement.
'His lawyer would be able to ask us about having access to it to, but right now we are very satisfied and happy that he has been advised by his attorney to allow us to get that property in our possession,' Ward said.
The agreement also contained several restraining orders.
Despite the prior week's agreement, John-Paul pushed back against Mica's relatives in a series of court filings that included asking a judge to bar a posthumous name change.
Four days after, Sierra Francis filed her petition to become special administrator of Mica's estate on May 3, it was amended to include allegations of 'collusion' between John-Paul Miller and his Solid Rock church to undervalue a Coldwater Circle home.
The property was transferred solely to John-Paul on Nov. 17, 2020, records show. The next day, he took out a purchase money mortgage of $199,500 — paying it off by Dec. 12, 2023. In July 2021, court documents allege that John-Paul took out a second mortgage against the home, valued at $208,587, both being paid through 'joint marital funds,' court documents say.
The Millers then put an additional $90,000 worth of improvements into the home. Mica filed for divorce on Oct. 9, 2023, but that was later dismissed. However, While it was pending, John-Paul sold the home to Solid Rock Ministries for $169,331.
'Defendant Miller's supposed sale of the marital home to Defendant Church is believed to have been his attempt to defraud and deprive his wife … from her fair share of the marital asset,' the amended complaint says. 'Church (Solid Rock) is in collusion with the Defendant Husband in an attempt to deprive Wife from the fair share of the marital estate.'
Mica's body was discovered 'prone' and 'submerged' 100 feet from several shell casings found along a Robeson County riverbank where the 30-year-old killed herself in late April, a medical examiner's report revealed.
And two days before Mica fatally shot herself at Lumber River State Park on April 27, she had been prescribed anti-anxiety medication — the latest in a series of treatments to combat mental health problems that included suicidal ideations and bipolar disorder, according to a preliminary summary conducted by the North Carolina Office of the Chief Medical Examiner.
Three casings from a Sig Sauer 9 mm were recovered along the riverbank: Two live and one spent, the medical examiner's office said. The gun itself was pulled from the water by magnet about five feet from the shore.
The report, which is not based on an autopsy, said a post-mortem blood test performed the day after her death did not show any drugs or alcohol in her system. There were also no signs of a 'physical struggle' near where authorities said the wife of Myrtle Beach pastor John-Paul Miller took her life.
The Robeson County Sheriff's Office declined to comment that Monday. When contacted by News13 the next day, John-Paul acknowledged the report but did not comment.
Entry and exit wounds were marked just above her ears — 4 1/2 inches from the middle of her head.
Mica also had seven tattoos — including the name 'John Paul Miller' on the right side of her lower chest.
On the day she died, Miller's relatives were unable to contact her via photo calls or text messages. She was last seen alive at 1:33 p.m. in Mullins. A kayaker reported to authorities exactly three hours later that he found a body in the river that was determined to be Mica.
The report also said medical records showed that Mica was hospitalized twice between 2022 and 2024 — the first from Nov. 29 through Dec. 5, 2022, on 'suicidal precautions for bipolar 1' and 'recurrent manic episode' along with THC dependency and a 'dependent personality disorder.'
Mica was admitted again from Feb. 7-12 of this year by a therapist. Mica also was using Delta 8 gummies at the time, the report said.
John-Paul and Mica's relatives on July 29 agreed to end all legal disputes and called on protesters to drop demonstrations in front of his Market Common church.
Instead, all sides said they want to press state lawmakers into adopting a coercive control law in her memory. Attorneys announced the deal following an Horry County Probate Court hearing.
The unified front ended all pending lawsuits between Mica's family, John-Paul and his Solid Rock Ministries have been addressed through a global settlement whose terms are confidential — including control of Mica's estate.
'This is over. This global agreement is Mica's justice. The next step is the legislative goal. We only ask that you remember Mica as the wonderful, beautiful person that she was,' said Russell Long, an attorney for John-Paul Miller.
The deal also bars John-Paul from any civil wrongful death claims tied to Mica's suicide.
In life, Mica loved music, her community and her faith.
All three were on display Nov. 17 as part of a daylong event honoring the life of a woman whose April suicide sparked a national conversation about domestic violence awareness and prevention.
'I know that she would be so very excited to be here for all of this, so we are here standing for Mica and honoring her and everything that she did for his community,' said her sister, Abigail Francis. 'For so many people to be out here is just incredible.'
The Socastee High School band, where Mica attended, were among those that performed, and pictures of her lined the road leading into the park.
'She believed that God is the one and only waymaker, so we are out here showing that God makes a way for everything,' Francis said.
Inspired by Mica's story and those of dozens more who called his office, Republican state Sen. Stephen Goldfinch of Murrells Inlet on Tuesday introduced a measure that would amend South Carolina's domestic violence law to add coercive control as a criminal offense.
Four years ago, lawmakers filed a bill that would criminalize 'coercive control,' with punishments of up to 10 years in prison and a $10,000 fine. Since that time, efforts to get such a law on the books have stalled in both chambers of the General Assembly.
Several states including California, Connecticut and Hawaii have adopted 'coercive control' laws, while similar efforts are pending in Florida, Maryland, New York and Washington, according to the group Americas Conference to End Coercive Control.
* * *
Adam Benson joined the News13 digital team in January 2024. He is a veteran South Carolina reporter with previous stops at the Greenwood Index-Journal, Post & Courier and The Sun News in Myrtle Beach. Adam is a Boston native and University of Utah graduate. Follow Adam on X, formerly Twitter, at @AdamNewshound12. See more of his work here.
* * *
Adrianna Lawrence is a multimedia journalist at News13. Adrianna is originally from Virginia Beach, Virginia, and joined the News13 team in June 2023 after graduating from Virginia Commonwealth University in May 2023. Keep up with Adrianna on Instagram, Facebook, and X, formerly Twitter. You can also read more of her work here.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

FBI arrests Dixon man on 6 charges of disseminating child sex abuse images: Illinois attorney general
FBI arrests Dixon man on 6 charges of disseminating child sex abuse images: Illinois attorney general

Yahoo

time11 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

FBI arrests Dixon man on 6 charges of disseminating child sex abuse images: Illinois attorney general

Jul. 4—DIXON — A Dixon man was charged with disseminating images of child sexual abuse after federal and state law enforcement agencies searched his home. Heath A. Knipple, 46, was charged Wednesday, July 2, in Lee County Circuit Court with six counts of Class X felony dissemination of child pornography, with each listing the victim as younger than 13. The charges are all alleged to have occurred on June 27, 2024, according to Lee County court documents. Each charge is punishable by up to 30 years in prison if Knipple is convicted. The charges were filed the same day that state and FBI investigators, along with Illinois State Police officers, searched Knipple's residence in the 1200 block of Fourth Avenue in Dixon, according to a news release from Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul. The release stated Knipple was taken into custody after investigators discovered evidence of child sexual abuse material. He is being held in the Whiteside County Jail in Morrison, with a detention hearing set for 1:30 p.m. Tuesday, July 7, in Lee County Circuit Court. He is being represented by Sterling Attorney James Mertes. According to the news release, the case is part of Raoul's ongoing work, in collaboration with federal law enforcement agencies and local law enforcement officials throughout Illinois, to apprehend offenders who download and trade child sexual abuse material online. "Child exploitation is a horrific crime that is made even more reprehensible when the alleged offender is an active and trusted member of the community," Raoul said. "My office's Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force will continue to partner with law enforcement agencies at the federal, state and local levels to locate and bring to justice individuals who engage in the exploitation of minors." Raoul's office, with a grant from the U.S. Department of Justice, runs the Illinois Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force that investigates child exploitation crimes and trains law enforcement agencies. The task force receives online reports of child sexual abuse material from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. Over the past several years, CyberTipline reports have steadily increased. In 2024, reports to the ICAC increased by 11% over 2023, according to the release. Illinois' ICAC Task Force is one of 61 ICAC task forces throughout the country and is composed of a network of more than 200 local, county, state and federal law enforcement agencies. Since 2019, the Attorney General's ICAC Task Force has received more than 60,000 CyberTips and has been involved in more than 1,000 arrests of sexual predators. In 2024, the task force was involved in rescuing more than 45 child victims from ongoing abuse. The task force has also provided internet safety training and education to tens of thousands of parents, teachers, students and law enforcement professionals. Raoul is reminding the public that child sexual exploitation can be reported online at and child abuse at Local child advocacy centers can be found at Deputy Bureau Chief Shannon O'Brien is prosecuting the case for Raoul's High Tech Crimes Bureau.

NYPD steps up security for NYC 4th of July festivities amid heightened threat level
NYPD steps up security for NYC 4th of July festivities amid heightened threat level

CNN

time2 hours ago

  • CNN

NYPD steps up security for NYC 4th of July festivities amid heightened threat level

Thousands of spectators are expected to flock to Manhattan and Brooklyn to watch fireworks burst through the air from the East River at the Macy's 4th of July Fireworks show, one of the country's largest fireworks displays. Law enforcement in New York is staying vigilant and the New York Police Department's security response will also be bigger than in previous years, the NYPD's counterterrorism chief told CNN, because the mix of large crowds at the high-profile event could make the evening a target for an attack. But conflicts overseas and incidents sparked by domestic extremists, along with a threat assessment from the Department of Homeland Security, the FBI and other law enforcement agencies warning about lone wolf attacks, have raised the threat level. Despite this, there are no known or credible threats to New York City, even though there are more potential threats to monitor than in years prior, Rebecca Weiner, deputy commissioner of the NYPD's intelligence and counterterrorism unit, told CNN in an interview on one of the counterterrorism boats the police department has deployed to the East River. 'We describe this as the 'everything everywhere all at once' threat environment,' Weiner said. Recent high-profile attacks – like the truck driver who rammed his vehicle into a crowd of revelers in New Orleans on New Year's, as well as several violent, antisemitic attacks linked to tensions over the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza – could spur lone wolf, small group or copycat attacks, authorities warn. The NYPD has been on high alert with extra enforcement at religious institutions since the Israel-Hamas war's start nearly two years ago. Now, emerging issues abroad such as the Israel-Iran conflict and at home, like the attacks on politicians and ongoing civil unrest over immigration enforcement actions, have all caused ripple effects in New York City. 'These are all individually threats that we've contended with for years but what's new is having them at the same time, requiring us to pivot from one to the other with our resources,' Weiner said. CNN goes aboard an NYPD patrol boat tasked with keeping New Yorkers safe during July 4th celebrations. In late June, the FBI, the Department of Homeland Security and other law enforcement agencies issued a joint bulletin saying the 'the most significant terrorism threat facing the Macy's 4th of July Fireworks stems from lone offenders and small groups of individuals seeking to commit acts of violence.' As 80,000 firework shells dazzle in the sky, thousands of NYPD officers, including plainclothes officers mixed in with crowds, will patrol the streets and drone and aviation units will surveil the skies. NYPD's marine units will be monitoring from the East River, each counterterrorism boat a high-tech vessel equipped with radiation detection and underwater surveillance capabilities designed to relay information and respond to incidents in real time. The massive police presence is bolstered with advanced technology, intelligence strategies and specialized units that are all designed to snuff out problems before they arise. The NYPD's Joint Operations Center, a massive intelligence hub where police can access over 50,000 cameras in the city and keep a watchful eye on possible threats emanating from crowds, will be active with other state and federal law enforcement agencies also sharing information. Strategic street closures around the viewing areas are all designed to insulate the festivities from incidents like the truck-ramming attack in New Orleans that killed 14 people and injured nearly 60 others, while officers on the ground check bags for weapons. This response is all part of what makes the massive July 4 deployment second only to New Year's Eve, according to Weiner. 'Our job is to have a combination of resources that you see, our heavy weapons teams, our explosive trace detection, our canines, our physical deployments, bomb squad, to protect an event like July 4th as well as many resources that you don't see,' Weiner said. 'The intelligence capabilities, monitoring those online and, of course, off-line threats, tips and leads. That isn't new. There's just a lot more of it.' The intelligence component is a significant part of the counterterrorism response, according to Weiner. The intelligence and partnerships with other state and federal agencies is what helps them identify, detect and disrupt bad actors and plots before they hatch, Weiner said. 'This is an incredibly challenging threat environment, and it has been since October 7th and, of course, that didn't start the terrorism threat environment at all for New York City, or across the country, but that did provide a real inflection point,' Weiner said. 'All of us have to be on top of our game because again, we're not just dealing with Iran. We're not just dealing with a lone actor inspired by ISIS. We're not dealing with just civil disobedience and unrest. (It's) all of them at the same time.' CNN's John Miller and Holly Yan contributed to this report.

Patel and Ratcliffe try to bolster claims that FBI and CIA conspired against Trump
Patel and Ratcliffe try to bolster claims that FBI and CIA conspired against Trump

Yahoo

time4 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Patel and Ratcliffe try to bolster claims that FBI and CIA conspired against Trump

The release of formerly classified FBI and CIA documents this week illustrates how President Donald Trump's appointees at both agencies are trying to use the levers of government to prop up his long-standing assertions that intelligence agencies conspired against him. The FBI released emails on Tuesday that purport to show an effort by the bureau's leaders in 2020 to cover up a source's claim that there was a Chinese plot to throw the presidential election to Joe Biden. In a statement to the Daily Mail, Trump's FBI director, Kash Patel, said the emails reveal that bureau leaders 'chose to play politics and withhold key information from the American people.' And CIA Director John Ratcliffe released an internal agency analysis related to the 2020 election that he argued showed that Democratic appointees 'manipulated intelligence and silenced career professionals — all to get Trump.' Patel's and Ratcliffe's claims went beyond the information contained in the released documents. The documents do not describe definitive evidence that any official acted out of political motive or engaged in anything beyond the good-faith debate that is typical of the intelligence verification and analysis process. The emails do show that at least one FBI official raised the concern that the report conflicted with congressional testimony at the time by Director Christopher Wray, who said the FBI was not aware of any Chinese attempt to interfere in the presidential election. A former FBI official told NBC News that Wray does not recall being made aware of the report. A former senior FBI official said he was not aware of the report either. The former official, who requested anonymity, noted that the bureau produces hundreds of reports every day based on such tips, which do not always pan out. Patel also promoted an article by the right-wing journalist John Solomon than mentioned that U.S. Customs and Border Protection had seized fake licenses that were arriving mostly from China and Hong Kong around the time the FBI received the tip. According to a 2020 news release from CBP, 20,000 fake licenses were seized in Chicago between that January and June. It said 'most were for college-age students,' a population that has historically sought licenses with fake birthdays so underage students can purchase alcohol. The FBI did not respond to a request for comment from Patel regarding the fake licenses. Dozens of judges, including Trump appointees, have found no evidence of widespread or systemic voter fraud affecting the 2020 election, despite allegations promoted by Trump and his allies since he lost that year's presidential race. The day after Patel released the emails, though, Trump appeared to mention them during a press conference where he talked about 'China and the license plates' and claimed that 'tens of thousands of cards' were used to vote in the 2020 election. The emails released by Patel offer a window into the deep concern among senior career FBI analysts about an intelligence report from an agent in the Albany field office based on a single, unvetted source making a historic allegation: that the Chinese government sent thousands of fake IDs to help people fraudulently vote for Biden. The report was ultimately withdrawn over concerns about its veracity. Two FBI officials familiar with the matter told NBC News that the tip was not credible intelligence and never should have been sent out in an intelligence report. The CIA analysis cited by Ratcliffe found procedural faults with how the agency crafted its assessment that Russia tried to denigrate Hillary Clinton and help Trump get elected in 2016. But it didn't question that broad conclusion — one echoed by two exhaustive congressional investigations. Yet Trump appointees and allies quickly argued the documents vindicated Trump's long-running claims that he had been wronged by intelligence agencies investigating foreign election interference. The CIA review found that 'Obama's Trump-Russia collusion report was corrupt from start,' read the headline of a New York Post piece by conservative columnist Miranda Devine. A press release from the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Chuck Grassley of Iowa, said the 'bombshell' FBI emails showed 'FBI headquarters interfered with [an] alleged Chinese election interference probe' to shield then-Director Christopher Wray 'from political blowback.' The FBI emails show that senior career public servants at the bureau had concerns about the reliability of information from a confidential human source who claimed that the Chinese Communist Party planned to use fake IDs to cast ballots for Biden in the 2020 election. The information came from a source that an FBI agent based in Albany, New York, had just met, who in turn got it from a separate unnamed source. The emails say the source in Albany also repeated a claim made on social media that the Chinese government was intentionally spreading Covid in the U.S. — an allegation that has never been corroborated. One email released by the FBI said the information had not been verified through other intelligence-gathering methods. The emails say top bureau intelligence analysts Nikki Floris and Tonya Ugoretz ordered the intelligence report recalled because it lacked corroboration. Floris was forced out of the FBI earlier this year, and Ugoretz — who was promoted to become the FBI's top intelligence official — was recently placed on leave. The FBI has not said why. Floris and Ugoretz did not respond to requests for comment. The emails lay out an internal debate over the reliability of the intelligence, which former FBI agents say is typical. The Albany office, backing its agent, sought to prevent the report from being recalled. Senior FBI officials, meanwhile, pushed for corroboration of the source's allegations. In a Sept. 25, 2020, email, an assistant section chief in the Criminal Intelligence Branch said the claim about Chinese election interference was 'getting a lot of attention from all HQ divisions.' The assistant section chief added, 'We know that the source is first contact and hasn't been re-interviewed. Are you considering recalling the [intelligence report] until you can track the source down and re-interview? Everything election is getting scrutiny, and we just want to be sure we have reliable sourcing.' In a Sept. 28 email, another official noted that the allegation that China was trying to influence the election in favor of Biden, as well as previous seizures of fake driver's licenses imported from China, 'were all documented in some fashion on open sources.' The official added that 'Given the lack of specifics we received in the initial reporting, my first opinion was that the [confidential human source] wants to help and is probably supplementing his reporting via open sources.' Ultimately, the emails show, an FBI official who specializes in Chinese foreign interference instructed the Albany office that 'we have not approved a re-issue' of the report 'specifically because of our concerns that the reporting is not authoritative.' The new head of the FBI's Office of Congressional Affairs is Marshall Yates. A former Republican aide on Capitol Hill, Yates has ties to figures that have long backed Trump's false claim that the 2020 election was stolen. Yates was chief of staff to former Rep. Mo Brooks, R-Ala., on Jan. 6, 2021, when Brooks spoke at Trump's rally in support of efforts to overturn his election loss. Yates then went on to work for the Election Integrity Network, a project headed by Republican lawyer Cleta Mitchell, a key figure in the efforts to overturn the 2020 election. In a 2022 speech in New Mexico, Yates said the 'election objection did not go as we wanted in 2020, on Jan. 6,' but that 'luckily' it had 'sparked a grassroots movement across the country for election integrity.' The FBI did not reply to a request for comment about Yates' involvement. The internal review released by Ratcliffe last week examined how the CIA put together a 2017 intelligence assessment that concluded that Russia interfered in the 2016 election to help Trump defeat Hillary Clinton. The review found some deviance from standard procedures, but it defended the assessment's overall findings. The report disclosed that two senior leaders of a CIA mission center focusing on Russia objected to the conclusion that Russia's goal was to help secure Trump's victory but agreed that Putin hoped to denigrate Clinton and undermine the U.S. democratic process. The review also cited complaints by some CIA officers that they felt rushed by a tight deadline to produce the assessment. The CIA director at the time, John Brennan, was a Democratic political appointee who has since become an ardent Trump critic. In a second post on X, Ratcliffe argued that the complaints about the process were evidence the 'assessment was conducted through an atypical & corrupt process under the politically charged environments' of Brennan and then-FBI Director James Comey. The CIA declined to comment when asked to explain the basis for Ratcliffe's accusation. A special counsel appointed during the first Trump administration looked extensively into how the CIA crafted its assessment but filed no criminal charges and reported no clear evidence that political bias tainted the process. A bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee investigation in 2020 concurred with the 2017 intelligence assessment and found no reason to dispute its conclusions. This article was originally published on

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store