Trump's Big Law executive orders go 0-4 after judge slaps down order against Susman Godfrey
President Donald Trump faced another legal loss on Friday after a District Court judge slapped down his executive order against the Big Law firm Susman Godfrey.
In her ruling, Judge Loren AliKhan wrote that the order against Susman Godfrey "was one in a series attacking firms that had taken positions with which President Trump disagreed."
"In the ensuing months, every court to have considered a challenge to one of these orders has found grave constitutional violations and permanently enjoined enforcement of the order in full," AliKhan wrote. "Today, this court follows suit, concluding that the order targeting Susman violates the US Constitution and must be permanently enjoined."
Three other federal judges have already found similar executive orders against Perkins Coie, Jenner & Block, and WilmerHale unconstitutional. AliKhan's ruling in the Susman Godfrey case marks a 0-4 record for the Trump administration in legal challenges regarding his executive orders targeting Big Law firms.
Susman Godfrey said in a statement that the court's ruling "is a resounding victory for the rule of law and the right of every American to be represented by legal counsel without fear of retaliation."
"We applaud the Court for declaring the administration's order unconstitutional," the firm's statement continued. "Our firm is committed to the rule of law and to protecting the rights of our clients without regard to their political or other beliefs. Susman Godfrey's lawyers and staff live these values every day."
Harrison Fields, principal White House deputy press secretary, told Business Insider in a statement that the White House opposes Judge AliKhan's ruling.
"The decision to grant any individual access to this nation's secrets is a sensitive judgment call entrusted to the President," Fields said. "Weighing these factors and implementing such decisions are core executive powers, and reviewing the President's clearance decisions falls well outside the judiciary's authority."
The federal government can appeal AliKhan's ruling, in which case the proceedings will be heard in the court of appeals. Any subsequent appeal would be heard by the Supreme Court.
Fields did not immediately respond to Business Insider when asked if the government would appeal Judge AliKhan's decision.
Judge AliKhan's ruling represents a major legal victory for the firms that have challenged the president's executive orders in court.
While some other Big Law firms chose instead to strike deals with the administration to avoid or reverse punitive executive actions against them — drawing sharp criticism from industry insiders and a spate of resignations among associates and some partners — Business Insider previously reported that Susman Godfrey's decision to fight back in court took just two hours.
In the original April 9 executive order against Susman Godfrey, the Trump administration accused the firm of "efforts to weaponize the American legal system and degrade the quality of American elections."
Judge AliKahn had granted the firm a temporary restraining order on April 15, preventing enforcement of the order against Susman Godfrey pending further proceedings.
In issuing her order granting the TRO, the judge said she believed "the framers of our constitution would see this as a shocking abuse of power," according to The American Lawyer.
Susman Godfrey represented Dominion Voting Systems in its suit against Fox News after the 2020 election, which resulted in a $787.5 million settlement, and The New York Times in the publication's copyright suit against OpenAI and Microsoft, which has not yet reached a conclusion.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
11 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Here are the 4 home trends that are hot in 2025
The NAHB asked 3,000 recent and prospective buyers what they want most in newly built homes. Newly built homes may be shrinking, but buyers aren't sacrificing comfort and quality. Buyers said that a great outdoor living space and smart technology are must-haves. Americans buying newly built homes are working with a lot less space, but that doesn't mean their expectations are any lower. In fact, it means they're looking to maximize every square foot. At the 2025 National Association of Real Estate Editors conference held earlier this month in New Orleans, Rose Quint, assistant vice president for survey research at the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), shared during a panel discussion what today's homebuyers value most. Drawing from NAHB's 2024 What Home Buyers Really Want report, a national survey of more than 3,000 recent and prospective homebuyers, Quint revealed that buyers are prioritizing spacious kitchens, ample outdoor space, and smart technology. "High home prices and elevated mortgage rates have made homebuyers keenly aware of what features add the most value to their daily lives," Quint said. "Buyers have determined that investing in the kitchen, in a patio, and home security features enhances the livability of a home." According to NAHB's survey, here are four trends shaping homebuying — from a bigger kitchen that focuses on efficiency to smart thermostats that allow homeowners to control their home's temperature remotely. 1. Buyers want a bigger kitchen. The American home may be shrinking, but one space buyers aren't willing to give up is the kitchen. "For those buying a smaller house, if that's what it takes to make the math work, we ask: What part of the home will you shrink? And they say, take the square footage from the home office, the dining room, even the living room, but for God's sake, stay away from the kitchen," Quint said. Homebuyers don't just want a large kitchen; they're looking for efficiency and a space that brings the family together. This means they're asking for bigger island spaces, walk-in pantries to store food and appliances, and even special-use storage for wine and spices. NAHB data shows that a central kitchen island is a top desired feature among buyers. In some luxury homes, Quint said buyers are even requesting two islands to accommodate cooking, dining, and entertaining needs. 2. Porches and patios are making a comeback. Outdoor living areas have become more important than ever, especially as homes get smaller and offer fewer gathering spaces. Survey data from the NAHB shows that 86% of respondents said they want a patio, and 81% said they'd like a back porch — a sign that porches are making a comeback. The numbers tell the story. In 2008, just 47% of newly built single-family homes had patios; by 2023, that figure had climbed to 64%. Likewise, the share of homes with porches rose from 60% to 68% over the same period. "Buyers want a patio. They want a front porch," Quint added. "They want exterior lighting to enhance the outdoor appeal of their home, landscaping, and a deck. If the home's shrinking, at least that space allows them to have more living space." 3. The modern McMansion can't beat a classic home. For a while, it felt like you couldn't drive through a neighborhood without seeing rows of boxy, modern homes. You know the look — white or gray stone exteriors, oversized rectangular windows, and often a flat roof. They may be trendy, but those minimalist builds may not be dominating the market after all. Today's buyers are leaning more toward traditionally designed homes inspired by classic styles like the kind of house you'd see on "Full House." While there's no clear majority when it comes to architectural preference, NAHB's survey found that 34% of respondents prefer traditional homes. Meanwhile, 26% favor contemporary designs, 17% lean toward bold modern styles, and just 12% prefer transitional homes, which blend modern aesthetics with traditional elements. 4. Homebuyers are tech-obsessed. From smartphones to smart cars, Americans crave cutting-edge tech, so of course, we want it in our homes, too. The NAHB found that the tech features homebuyers want most in their homes include wireless security systems, security cameras, video doorbells, smart thermostats that let them automate their home's temperature, and multi-zone HVAC systems so they can control the temperature in each room separately. "The reason these five features top the list is because homeowners are relying on technology to do two things: increase the safety of their home and improve temperature control," Quint said. "They want technology that works for them."
Miami Herald
12 minutes ago
- Miami Herald
County leaders mostly silent after arrest of woman objecting to ICE deal in Miami-Dade
A day after a 36-year-old real estate agent was dragged out of the Miami-Dade County Commission chambers by plain-clothed officers during a public meeting, the elected officials who watched it happen are mostly keeping mum on what they saw. The Miami Herald requested statements from the county's 13 commissioners and Mayor Daniella Levine Cava, who until January oversaw a county police force that's now under the control of an elected sheriff. No commissioner offices provided statements. Levine Cava did, but the message did not directly address the police response that landed Camila Ramos in jail overnight on felony charges after a brief and tense exchange with the sheriff's deputies that serve as plain-clothed sergeants-at-arms during commission meetings. VIDEO: Officers drag woman out of Miami-Dade meeting during ICE discussion Ramos had intended to speak on a modified agreement between the county's jails system and Immigration and Customs Enforcement during the allotted public comment portion of the meeting but was removed while attempting to ask a question about the rules after an officer had warned her not to speak. 'It was unfortunate that yesterday's meeting escalated the way it did when people were there simply to make their voices heard,' Levine Cava said. 'Public input is an essential part of an accessible, accountable local government and as elected officials we should encourage all residents to exercise their right to participate.' The Herald also requested a statement from Sheriff Rosie Cordero-Stutz, the veteran county police administrator who in November won the county's first sheriff election since the 1950s under a change mandated by Florida's Constitution. The Sheriff's Office has not released a statement but did provide arrest reports alleging a deputy saw Ramos punch an officer while being dragged to the chamber doors. Ramos was heard denying to an officer that she had punched her — or that if she had, it was inadvertent. Video of the ejection showed officers with hands on both of Ramos' arms and, at one point, also on her hair and foot. Less than two minutes passed between when a sergeant-at-arms first took hold of Ramos' arm near the microphone that members of the public use to address commissioners to when she was dragged out of the chamber doors by officers, her hand briefly grasping the arm of her husband, who was there to speak as well. 'I'm trying to understand the process,' Ramos said as the two sergeants took hold of her arms and started pulling her toward the exits. 'You're ejecting me?' Video shows Ramos dragging her feet and then falling to the ground while the sergeants still held her arms. They then began dragging her while her body remained in contact with the floor. 'I deserve to know the process,' she said. 'Let me go of me.' While commissioners have kept quiet on the incident, some politicians are sharing their views. Ken Russell, a former Miami commissioner running for city mayor, said on social media: 'Being silent is a message in itself…ANY elected [official] can speak up to allow someone to be heard or to stop an ejection.' Surfside Mayor Charles Burkett sent an email Friday morning to town administrators urging them to make sure Surfside could avoid that kind of incident. 'This is really bad. I can't think of any good reason why a situation like this ought to evolve with a woman on the floor with two very strong police around her,' Burkett wrote. 'We must never allow something like this to happen under our watch.' Ramos was released from the Turner Guilford Knight jail on Friday after posting bond for two felony charges, including battery against an officer. The arrest report shows uniformed deputies who helped take her out of the chambers were wearing body cameras, but that footage hasn't yet been released. It could prove crucial in her criminal case because a uniformed deputy wrote in the report that he witnessed Ramos strike a sergeant-at-arms in the face. While Ramos hasn't spoken publicly, supporters on Friday held a press conference outside of County Hall to denounce what happened to her. 'Her flailing may have mistakenly grazed an officer,' Juan Cuba, director of Sheriff Accountability Action, an advocacy group. 'I don't see in any video evidence it was battery.' He urged the county's elected officials to denounce what happened in the chambers Thursday. Cuba, a longtime Miami activist, is married to one of Levine Cava's top aides, Deputy Chief of Staff Rachel Johnson. Video of the meeting showed the confrontation began during a confusing moment in the session. While commissioners were scheduled to vote on a modification of the county's existing ICE agreement, there was a last-minute move to delay that vote indefinitely. As Chair Anthony Rodriguez explained the plan to the audience, he also outlined speaking rules that seemed to contradict guidelines from the county's top lawyer. Rodriguez told the audience they had a right to speak on the ICE item. At that point, Ramos was standing in an area near the lecterns where members of the public typically wait their turn for their allotted time at the microphones. While the audience members could still speak on the item about to be deferred, Rodriguez said, doing so would mean the public wouldn't have the chance to address commissioners if the item ever came up for an actual vote at a future meeting. 'Even if just one person speaks,' he said, 'then public hearing has been had on this item. And if it resurfaces, there will be no opportunity to speak on this item again.' Those instructions appeared more restrictive than guidance provided by County Attorney Geri Bonzon-Keenan a couple of minutes earlier. Asked by Rodriguez how to handle the list of people signed up to speak about the ICE item at Thursday's meeting, the top lawyer outlined a procedure where people wanting to speak Thursday could line up for the microphones and those who chose to stay seated could address commissioners if the item came up at a future meeting. 'I would just start calling the names,' Bonzon-Keenan said. 'And those that wish to speak can stand up. And those that don't stand up, they can come back and speak at the appropriate time when the matter is under consideration.' Those conflicting rules were what faced Ramos as she waited for her allotted 60 seconds before commissioners, with a paper of prepared remarks in her hand. Video showed she was approached by sergeant-at-arms and a disagreement followed, with Ramos pointed toward the dais. Soon, two sergeants had her by the arms and pulled her away as the audience chanted 'Let her go!' and 'Let her speak!'
Business Insider
19 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Luxury gym memberships can be a splurge. 3 people share how they find discounts and make the most of amenities.
Every day after work, Alex Meyers picks up her two kids from day care and drives straight to her gym, one of the Bay Club locations in California. There, she drops them off at her gym's complimentary childcare center for two hours while she works out. When they're done, the family eats the dinner Meyers packed before heading home, doing it all over again the next day. Like other luxury gym-goers, Meyers pays a few hundred dollars a month (around $500, to be exact) for her membership. She also feels it's completely worth the price tag. "On the weekends, you could go spend $100 going to the zoo or a museum or some other local kid attraction places," Meyers, a 32-year-old civil engineer project manager, told Business Insider. Instead, she takes her children, ages three and four, swimming or to the gym's basketball court. "We save that money by just going to our gym." Luxury gyms have become a third space for many people. Popular athletic club franchises like Equinox and Life Time offer amenities beyond sparkling new equipment and specialty classes, such as childcare services, tidy workspaces, and, in some cases, poolside bars. Younger generations even see gyms as the new social clubs. It's why people are willing to shell out for shiny memberships, even if they have to budget or sacrifice other luxuries to afford them. An all-inclusive third space At the very least, a luxury gym will run you over $200 a month, or at least $2,400 annually. Rob Moal, a personal trainer in Vancouver, spends $260 a month for his Equinox membership. "With the higher price, I try to use the place as much as I can," Moal, 43, said. He goes there six to seven times a week, sometimes even a few times a day, even though he doesn't actually train his clients there. He likes taking yoga and boxing classes in addition to his solo workouts. If he's not exercising, he's catching up on some work at the gym, unwinding in the sauna, or chatting up other gymgoers. Given Moal's work experience, he's seen a lot of gyms. He said he likes how clean and organized Equinox is, and who it attracts in turn: often ambitious, full-time workers who he said are also "very respectful" of the space. "It's almost like a social influence," he said. "If I go there in the morning, everyone's very busy and they're doing their thing, and they get out. So it kind of encourages me to keep up the pace." For some, it's not necessarily a place to work out Some members use their gym's other amenities almost more than the gym itself. Hannah Le, 27, the inventor of the Buckle Scrunchie, spends her days pitching her product to retailers. Instead of trekking back home or hunkering down in cafes between meetings, she finds the closest Life Time. There, she can do some work, charge her phone, or freshen up before a date or party. "I don't see it as just a gym," Le, who signed up at a discount with her roommate and pays $224.16 a month, said. "They really cover a lot of the other bases for me." Le touches upon another factor drawing people to luxury athletic clubs: you don't need to exercise to get a lot out of them. Meyers takes her kids to the Bay Club even when she feels too exhausted to work out. On those days, she sits in the meditation chair or just reads by the pool. "It gives me a minute to breathe," Meyers, whose husband is on the road on weekdays, said. No-brainer budgeting For those working remotely or hybrid, venturing outside the home can cost a pretty penny. Co-working spaces like WeWork and Industrious cost at least $100 a month — cheaper than a gym membership, but without the core perk of having workout equipment and specialty classes. Fancier options like Soho House have gyms baked in, but run you a few thousand annually. Coffee shops, meanwhile, add up and aren't always convenient in big cities: in New York, you still have to hunt for a seat and worry about leaving your laptop unattended. If it takes a little extra saving to swing a membership, luxury gym members say they are willing to do it. Moal packs his lunches instead of buying Equinox's and budgets for his membership. In months when money is tighter, he'll skip a night out drinking. Others make up for the gym cost on what they don't spend. Meyers said after-school activities, which sometimes last only 45 minutes for kids as young as hers, can also be expensive and time-consuming to coordinate. Instead, she puts that money toward her gym and its childcare services, which she said include all the toys, crafts, and activities a typical daycare has. "I can get something out of it, and they get something out of it that they love as well," she said. For some, paying a few hundred extra dollars a month on rent still wouldn't afford them their own place, or even a much bigger room. It can, however, grant them access to multiple spacious facilities almost whenever they want. Le, who shares the "tiniest studio apartment with no direct sunlight" with her roommate, sees Life Time as a slice of luxury she can enjoy every day. "I use this gym probably more than 95% of the rest of the city does," she said. When she first moved to New York and dropped her stuff off at home, it was the first place she went.
