UK's Palestine Action loses bid to pause ban as terrorist group
Huda Ammori, who helped found Palestine Action in 2020, asked London's High Court to stop the proscription of Palestine Action as a terrorist organisation, before a full hearing of her case that banning the group is unlawful later this month.
British lawmakers this week decided to ban Palestine Action after its activists broke into a Royal Air Force base and damaged two planes in protest against what the group says is Britain's support for Israel.
Proscription would make it a crime to be a member of Palestine Action that carries a maximum sentence of 14 years in prison.
Palestine Action has increasingly targeted Israel-linked companies in Britain, often spraying red paint, blocking entrances or damaging equipment. The group accuses the British government of complicity in what it says are Israeli war crimes in its ongoing bombardment of Gaza.
Israel has repeatedly denied committing abuses in its war in Gaza, which began after Palestinian militant group Hamas attacked Israel on Oct 7, 2023.
Ammori's lawyer Raza Husain said the proscription marked the first time Britain had sought to ban a group carrying out such direct action, describing it as "an ill-considered, discriminatory, authoritarian abuse of statutory power".
Critics of the government's decision, including some United Nations experts and civil liberties groups, have also argued that damaging property does not amount to terrorism.
DEFENCE FIRMS TARGETED
The group has particularly focused on Israeli defence firm Elbit Systems and Britain's government cited a raid at an Elbit site last year when it decided to proscribe the group.
The decision to ban the group came as four members were charged over the incident at the RAF Brize Norton air base, in which military planes were sprayed with red paint.
Husain said that was the only example of action targeting a government or military facility and all previous incidents were against private companies to support his argument against designating Palestine Action as terrorist.
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, Britain's interior minister, has said that violence and criminal damage have no place in legitimate protest and that Palestine Action's activities pass the threshold for proscription.
Judge Martin Chamberlain ruled against Ammori's bid to pause the ban, meaning the proscription of Palestine Action will come into force at midnight.
Husain asked for a temporary pause until Monday pending an appeal but Chamberlain refused, saying: "You are going to have to trouble the Court of Appeal tonight."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Trump welcomes Edan Alexander, former Hamas hostage, to White House
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Mr Edan Alexander (right) with Mr Trump at the White House. WASHINGTON - US President Donald Trump said on July 4 that he had met in the Oval Office with Mr Edan Alexander, a dual American and Israeli citizen who was held hostage in the Gaza Strip for nearly 600 days. Mr Alexander, who was released in May , was accompanied by his parents, Mr Adi and Mrs Yael Alexander, of Tenafly, New Jersey. He was welcomed at the White House by Mr Trump on July 3, Israeli news media reported. Mr Trump posted a video on his Truth Social site showing Mr Alexander, 21, being greeted in the Oval Office by officials including Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth. In a video posted on the social platform X by one of Mr Trump's aides, the president, standing beside the first lady, Mrs Melania Trump, tells Mr Alexander and his parents that it was 'very important' to the first lady that Mr Alexander returned home safely and the fact that Mr Alexander was an American citizen 'had a big impact.' Mr Alexander was abducted during the Oct 7, 2023, Hamas-led attack on Israel that touched off the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza. He had been serving in the infantry of the Israeli military when Hamas took him from a military outpost near the border with Gaza. Mr Alexander's family sobbed as they held him after his release in May. His parents had advocated relentlessly for his freedom and had travelled from the United States to Israel with Mr Trump administration officials to bring him home. 'We never lost hope,' Mr Alexander's father told The New York Times in May after his son's release. 'I could not allow myself to think any other way.' Mr Alexander, who grew up in Tenafly, was a star swimmer in high school. He was handcuffed, beaten and interrogated during his time in captivity, his father said, and he listened as Israeli bombs shook the tunnels where he was held. He became gaunt, without much access to food. 'His whole body has bedbug bites,' his father said in May. 'His skin is in terrible condition.' The year and a half in captivity has left its mark, but Mr Alexander is recovering, his father said. 'He was this goofy, funny guy' when he joined the army, his father said. 'He's still funny. I don't think he's a different person. He is simply tired.' Mr Trump's meeting with Mr Alexander came after the president said on July 1 that Israel had agreed to 'conditions to finalise' a 60-day ceasefire with Hamas. He is scheduled to meet with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu next week in the United States. NYTIMES
CNA
4 hours ago
- CNA
Commentary: A new Gaza ceasefire deal is on the table. Will this time be different?
LONDON: US President Donald Trump says that Israel has agreed to terms for a 60-day ceasefire in Gaza. If that sounds familiar, it is. The idea of a two-month truce has been discussed since the collapse of the last short-lived ceasefire in March. A similar proposal was floated in May, but Hamas viewed it as an enabling mechanism for Israel to continue the war after a brief pause, rather than reaching a permanent peace deal. As the devastation in Gaza worsens by the day, will this time be any different? The proposal, put forward by Qatari mediators, reportedly involves Hamas releasing 10 living hostages and the bodies of 18 deceased hostages over the 60-day period, in exchange for the release of a number of Palestinian prisoners. The remaining 22 hostages would be released if a long-term deal is reached. The 60-day ceasefire period would also involve negotiations for a permanent end to hostilities and a roadmap for post-war governance in Gaza. But the plan is similar to the eight-week, three-phase ceasefire from January to March of this year, which collapsed after the first phase of hostage exchanges. Since then, peace talks have hit a recurrent impasse. THIS TIME MIGHT BE DIFFERENT For Hamas, a long-term ceasefire means the permanent end to the war and the withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza. Israel, meanwhile, wants to see the complete removal of Hamas from power, the dismantling and disarming of its military wing and the exile of remaining senior Hamas leaders. But despite the persistent challenges, there are several reasons that this attempt for a ceasefire might be different. First and foremost is the recent so-called ' 12-day war ' between Israel and Iran, which Israel has trumpeted as a major success for degrading Iran's nuclear capabilities (although the reality is more nuanced). The perceived win gives Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu political manoeuvrability to pursue a ceasefire over the objections of far-right hardliners in his coalition who have threatened to bring down the government in previous rounds. The Iran-Israel war, in which the US controversially carried out strikes on Iran's nuclear sites, also revived Trump's interest in the Middle East. Trump entered office just as the phased Gaza ceasefire deal was being agreed. But Trump put little diplomatic pressure on Israel to engage in serious talks to get from the first phase of the agreement to phase two, allowing the war to resume in March. Now however, after assisting Israel militarily in Iran, Trump has significant leverage he can use with Netanyahu. He will have the chance to use it (if he chooses) when Netanyahu visits Washington next week. Both men also view Iran's weakened position as an opportunity for expanding the Abraham accords. This was the set of agreements normalising relations between Israel and several Arab states, including the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Sudan and Morocco, which Trump brokered at the end of his first term. Netanyahu has long eyed a US-backed deal with Saudi Arabia, and a smaller-scale declaration with Syria is reportedly now under discussion as well. But those deals can't move forward while the war in Gaza is going. ADDITIONAL OBSTACLES However, the recurrent obstacles to a deal remain – and it's unclear if the proposed terms will include guarantees to prevent Israel resuming the war after the 60-day period. New issues have also arisen since the last round of talks that could create further challenges. Hamas is demanding a return to traditional humanitarian aid distribution in Gaza – or at least the replacement of the controversial US and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). The GHF's four distribution sites, located in militarised zones, replaced over 400 previously operating aid points, and more than 400 people have been killed while seeking aid near the sites since May 26. More than 170 international non-governmental organisations and charities have called for the GHF to be shut down. Israel's military control over Gaza has also become further entrenched since the last ceasefire. More than 80 per cent is thought to be covered by evacuation orders – and new orders for north Gaza and Gaza City were issued on Jun 29 and Jul 2 respectively. Israeli officials have described the renewed operations as military pressure on Hamas to accept a ceasefire. But Netanyahu has also spoken openly about long-term military occupation of Gaza. He recently stated that Israel would remain in 'full security control of Gaza' even after the war. Even if a temporary ceasefire is agreed, the road ahead is strewn with difficulties in moving towards a long-lasting ceasefire or reaching an acceptable 'day-after' agreement. Still, the current moment offers an opportunity for a breakthrough. Trump has a renewed interest in getting to a ceasefire and Netanyahu has a rare political window to enter an agreement and get hostages home. Hamas, meanwhile, has been weakened, not only by Israel's relentless military pounding, but by increasing disillusionment from the people of Gaza, who are desperate for an end to the war. There is no shortage of reasons to end the war in Gaza. The only question is if Israel and Hamas have the will to do so.
CNA
6 hours ago
- CNA
Hamas says it responds to Gaza ceasefire proposal in 'a positive spirit'
CAIRO/TEL AVIV: Hamas said it had responded on Friday (Jul 4) in "a positive spirit" to a US-brokered Gaza ceasefire proposal and was prepared to enter into talks on implementing the deal which envisages a release of hostages and negotiations on ending the conflict. US President Donald Trump earlier announced a "final proposal" for a 60-day ceasefire in the nearly 21-month-old war between Israel and Hamas, stating he anticipated a reply from the parties in coming hours. Hamas wrote on its official website: "The Hamas movement has completed its internal consultations as well as discussions with Palestinian factions and forces regarding the latest proposal by the mediators to halt the aggression against our people in Gaza. "The movement has delivered its response to the brotherly mediators, which was characterized by a positive spirit. Hamas is fully prepared, with all seriousness, to immediately enter a new round of negotiations on the mechanism for implementing this framework," the statement said. In a sign of potential challenges still facing the sides, a Palestinian official of a militant group allied with Hamas said concerns remain over humanitarian aid, passage through the Rafah crossing to Egypt and clarity over a timetable of Israeli troop withdrawals. Trump said on Tuesday that Israel had agreed "to the necessary conditions to finalise" a 60-day ceasefire, during which efforts would be made to end the US ally's war in the Palestinian enclave. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has yet to comment on Trump's announcement and in their public statements, the two sides remain far apart. Netanyahu has repeatedly said Hamas must be disarmed, a position the militant group, which is thought to be holding 20 living hostages, has so far refused to discuss. Netanyahu is due to meet Trump in Washington on Monday. Trump has said he would be "very firm" with Netanyahu on the need for a speedy Gaza ceasefire while noting that the Israeli leader wants one as well. "We hope it's going to happen. And we're looking forward to it happening sometime next week," he told reporters earlier this week. "We want to get the hostages out." 'STOP THIS WAR' Israeli attacks have killed at least 138 Palestinians in Gaza over the past 24 hours, local health officials said. Health officials at the Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, southern Gaza, said the Israeli military had carried out an airstrike on a tent encampment west of the city around 2am (7am, Singapore time), killing 15 Palestinians displaced by nearly two years of war. The Israeli military said troops operating in the Khan Younis area had eliminated militants, confiscated weapons and dismantled Hamas outposts in the last 24 hours, while striking 100 targets across Gaza, including military structures, weapons storage facilities and launchers. Later on Friday, Palestinians gathered to perform funeral prayers before burying those killed overnight. "There should have been a ceasefire long ago before I lost my brother," said 13-year-old Mayar Al Farr as she wept. Her brother, Mahmoud, was shot dead in another incident, she said. "He went to get aid, so he can get a bag of flour for us to eat. He got a bullet in his neck. It killed him on the spot," she said. Adlar Mouamar said her nephew, Ashraf, was also killed in Gaza. "Our hearts are broken. We ask the world, we don't want want them to end the bloodshed. We want them to stop this war." 'MAKE THE DEAL' In Tel Aviv, families and friends of hostages held in Gaza were among demonstrators who gathered outside a US Embassy building on US Independence Day, calling on Trump to secure a deal for all of the captives. Demonstrators set up a symbolic Sabbath dinner table, placing 50 empty chairs to represent those who are still held in Gaza. Banners hung nearby displaying a post by Trump from his Truth Social platform that read, "MAKE THE DEAL IN GAZA. GET THE HOSTAGES BACK!!!" The Sabbath, or Shabbat, observed from Friday evening to Saturday nightfall, is often marked by Jewish families with a traditional Friday night dinner. "Only you can make the deal. We want one beautiful deal. One beautiful hostage deal," said Gideon Rosenberg, 48, from Tel Aviv. Rosenberg was wearing a shirt with the image of hostage Avinatan Or, one of his employees who was abducted by Palestinian militants from the Nova musical festival on Oct 7, 2023. He is among the 20 hostages who are believed to be alive after more than 600 days of captivity. Ruby Chen, 55, the father of 19-year-old American-Israeli Itay, who is believed to have been killed after being taken captive, urged Netanyahu to return from meeting with Trump in Washington on Monday with a deal that brings back all hostages. "Let this United States Independence Day mark the beginning of a lasting peace... one that secures the sacred value of human life and one that bestows dignity to the deceased hostages by ensuring their return to proper burial," he said, also appealing to Trump. Itay Chen, also a German national, was serving as an Israeli soldier when Hamas carried out its surprise attack on Oct 7, 2023, killing around 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and taking another 251 hostage. Israel's retaliatory war against Hamas has devastated Gaza, which the militant group has ruled for almost two decades but now only controls in parts, displacing most of the population of more than 2 million and triggering widespread hunger. More than 57,000 Palestinians have been killed in nearly two years of fighting, most of them civilians, according to local health officials.
