Ash Regan faces questions over 'ludicrous' costs of prostitution bill
In a financial memorandum submitted to the Scottish Parliament for her Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill, the Alba MSP claimed that it would cost as little as 50p to train 17,000 police officers in the new laws if the bill was passed.
The memo said: 'There will also be one-off training costs for Police Scotland to prepare for the introduction of the new offence.
READ MORE: 'Multiple serving MSPs have paid me for sex', former sex worker tells Ash Regan
'The estimated cost of delivering a two-hour training session to all approximately 17,000 Police Scotland officers, assuming the training is conducted in-house during normal working hours, is approximately £17,000 to £85,000.'
At the higher end of the scale, Regan estimates that it would cost £2.50 to train every officer per hour.
But the same document states that Police Scotland estimates the hourly rate of officers at £79.50.
The total cost of enforcing the new laws would be £2.6 million, falling to £2.2m annually thereafter.
Regan estimates that securing charges in a case would take 'on average an additional six hours of police work' and that this would amount to each case costing £477.
NUM said her figures were 'laughably false'.
READ MORE: Former sex worker supports Ash Regan bid to criminalise buying sex
Lynsey Walton, chief executive of NUM, said: 'As the UK's national sex worker safety charity, NUM works with police forces across the country to support sex workers during investigations. This means we know that Regan's estimates of police time needed to enforce her proposed legislation are laughably false, just like her ludicrous claims that it costs just 50p an hour to train officers.
'Sex worker groups, alongside NGOs like Amnesty and the World Health Organisation, oppose the new law on the grounds that it will make life more difficult and dangerous for sex workers, while costing taxpayers millions of pounds a year to enforce.'
Regan was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Graziadaily
17 minutes ago
- Graziadaily
Karen Pirie Season 2: Meet The Cast
Get ready, armchair detectives - Karen Pirie has returned to ITV for a second season. Expect unsolved crimes, brooding Scottish landscapes, and a strong female lead... Karen Pirie was a hit when it initially premiered in 2022, featuring Lauren Lyle as Scottish detective Karen. Drawing inspiration from Val McDermid's second Inspector Karen Pirie novel, A Darker Domain, the series will focus on the 1984 abduction of wealthy oil heiress Catriona Grant and her two-year-old son Adam, who vanished outside a Fife chip shop after being snatched at gunpoint. When the first breakthrough arrives in decades, Karen and her colleagues find themselves facing their most daunting investigation yet. A synopsis reads, 'After her bittersweet success in series one, Karen has been promoted to Detective Inspector and seemingly given the authority she has long been fighting for. Just as she's getting into the swing of her powerful new role, she is assigned an infamous unsolved case that will put her under intense scrutiny; from her boss, from the media, and ultimately, from sinister forces that would rather the past stayed in the past.' 'As Karen delves deeper into what happened in the autumn of 1984, political grudges and painful secrets reveal themselves - and it soon becomes clear the past is far from dead.' Plenty of familiar faces will be returning, along with some new ones. Here's everything to know about the cast of Karen Pirie season 2. ©Opening up about returning for series 2, Lauren said, 'I'm thrilled that we will continue the life of our fearless young detective Karen Pirie, and of course, her bumbag.' Outside of Karen Pirie , Lauren is best known for playing the character of Marsali MacKimmie Fraser in Outlander. ©Euan Cherry/BAFTA/Getty Images for BAFTA Chris will return as DC Jason 'Mint' Murray, a member of Karen's team. He is best known for playing Steve Morley in Sex Education , as well as Callum Barker in Vigil. Zach - who is best known for his roles in Timestalker and The Witcher: Blood Origin - stars as DS Parhatka, a driven detective who shares a secret connection with Karen. Best known for playing Michael Moon in EastEnders , Steve has revived his role as DCS Lees - Karen's boss, who struggles to trust her. Adapting the series from Val McDermid's novels, Emer will appear in the series as River Wilde - Karen's best friend, and a professor of forensic anthropology and archeology. Emer is best known for her roles as Zsa Zsa Carter in EastEnders , and Penelope 'Bunty' Windermere in Father Brown. Rakhee appears in series 2 of Karen Pirie as Bel, a former podcast turned documentarian who first met Karen during season one. Rakhee has previously appeared as Shabnam Masood in EastEnders and Emily Sands in Sex Education . Newcomer Saskia will join the cast as Isla, an 'ambitious newcomer' who is planted by DCS Lees to spy on Karen. She has previously starred in series including Trust Me, Six Four , and The Rig. You may recognise James for his roles as Angus MacLeod in Highlander, Campbell in Braveheart, and as Father Christmas in The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe. He will join the cast of Karen Pirie as Sir Broderick 'Brodie' Grant, the billionaire oil tycoon father of missing woman Catriona. A younger version of Lord Brodie is also played by Jamie Michie ( Skins, Game of Thrones, Baby Reindeer ) Frances will star in Karen Pirie as Lady Mary Grant - the mother of Catriona and the ex-wife of Sir Brodie. The Belfast-born actress has starred in several TV shows, including Inspector Morse , Cracker , and Silent Witness. Lady Mary is also played by Madeleine, who has starred in shows such as Call the Midwife and We Were the Lucky Ones , as well as films including Paddington and The Legend of Tarzan. ©Fergus Sinclair, the father of Catriona's missing son Adam, will be played by Scottish actor John. His TV credits include Taggart as DI Robbie Ross, Coronation Street as Karl Munro, and appearances in both Casualty and Holby City. Jack will appear as a young Fergus Sinclair. His previous acting roles including Outlander , Payback , and A Scottish Love Scheme. Julia will appear as Catriona 'Cat' Grant, the woman at the centre of this season's cold-case. Fans may recognise Julia from starring as Lois Bennett in BBC's World on Fire , as well as appearing in crime drama Shetland and CBBC's M.I High. Mark will star as Mick, a man who had a secret relationship with Cat before her kidnap. You my recognise him from his role in The Last Kingdom , as well as appearances in Luther , SAS Rogue Heroes , and The Spanish Princess. Kat ( Casualty, Dinosaur ) stars in Karen Pirie as Bonnie - Cat's best friend, who witnessed her kidnap. Conor ( Schemers, Dept. Q ) appears as Andy, who is a friend of Mick's. The first episode of Karen Pirie season 2 aired on Sunday July 20th, premiering at 8pm on ITV1. All episodes are available on ITVX. Charlotte Roberts is a news and entertainment writer at Grazia UK. She spends her days covering everything celebrity, culture, and entertainment.
South Wales Argus
31 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Officers considering legal action against Police Scotland over Trump visit plans
The Scottish Police Federation (SPF), which represents 98% of all police officers in Scotland, said the force has already breached health and safety standards in the run up to the visit by the US president. Thousands of officers are expected to be involved in what Police Scotland has described as a 'significant policing operation'. The White House confirmed Mr Trump will visit his golf courses in Aberdeenshire and Ayrshire between July 25 and 29. Thousands of officers are expected to be impacted by Donald Trump's five-day visit to Scotland (Andrew Milligan/PA) He will meet the Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and the First Minister John Swinney during his private trip. The visit is likely to result in widespread protests, following similar demonstrations during his last visit to Scotland. David Kennedy, general secretary of the SPF, suggested planning for the visit has already put officers at risk. He said: 'We currently have workforce agreements in place to protect police officers and provide minimum standards of Health and Safety at work. 'Sadly, we have seen these agreements breached in the days leading to the arrival of Potus (President of the United States) and as such we are seeking legal advice regarding potential legal action against the service.' Speaking to STV News, Mr Kennedy said he had 'major concerns' about the plans to police Mr Trump's trip. He told the broadcaster: 'We do not have enough police officers in Scotland. 'Anyone that says we do, I don't know where they get those figures from. 'We know what police officers have to do day in, day out and we need more officers in Scotland. 'When these events come along that puts those officers that are here under so much pressure.' David Kennedy said the Scottish Police Federation is looking at legal action against Police Scotland (Andrew Milligan/PA) Police Scotland said earlier this month it would seek help from the Scottish and UK Governments over the 'considerable' cost of policing the visit. It has also asked for support from Northern Ireland's police force, the PSNI. There had been speculation the King would host the American leader in Scotland after a meeting was suggested at Balmoral or Dumfries House, in a letter he wrote to Mr Trump in February inviting him to make the state visit. But it is understood that both sides will wait until the president's official state visit later this year. Police Scotland's Assistant Chief Constable Emma Bond said: 'We are working closely with the Scottish Police Federation to address any concerns they may have.' A spokesperson for the PSNI said: 'There are well established processes for any UK-based police services to request support from other services at times of peak demand. 'These requests are managed via the National Police Co-ordination Centre (NPoCC) and we can confirm that PSNI have received a request to provide mutual aid to Police Scotland which we are currently assessing. 'The decision to provide officers under the mutual aid process will be considered against our own demands, ensuring that we retain the capacity to respond effectively to local issues and maintain our own operational competence.'
South Wales Guardian
31 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Officers considering legal action against Police Scotland over Trump visit plans
The Scottish Police Federation (SPF), which represents 98% of all police officers in Scotland, said the force has already breached health and safety standards in the run up to the visit by the US president. Thousands of officers are expected to be involved in what Police Scotland has described as a 'significant policing operation'. The White House confirmed Mr Trump will visit his golf courses in Aberdeenshire and Ayrshire between July 25 and 29. He will meet the Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and the First Minister John Swinney during his private trip. The visit is likely to result in widespread protests, following similar demonstrations during his last visit to Scotland. David Kennedy, general secretary of the SPF, suggested planning for the visit has already put officers at risk. He said: 'We currently have workforce agreements in place to protect police officers and provide minimum standards of Health and Safety at work. 'Sadly, we have seen these agreements breached in the days leading to the arrival of Potus (President of the United States) and as such we are seeking legal advice regarding potential legal action against the service.' Speaking to STV News, Mr Kennedy said he had 'major concerns' about the plans to police Mr Trump's trip. He told the broadcaster: 'We do not have enough police officers in Scotland. 'Anyone that says we do, I don't know where they get those figures from. 'We know what police officers have to do day in, day out and we need more officers in Scotland. 'When these events come along that puts those officers that are here under so much pressure.' Police Scotland said earlier this month it would seek help from the Scottish and UK Governments over the 'considerable' cost of policing the visit. It has also asked for support from Northern Ireland's police force, the PSNI. There had been speculation the King would host the American leader in Scotland after a meeting was suggested at Balmoral or Dumfries House, in a letter he wrote to Mr Trump in February inviting him to make the state visit. But it is understood that both sides will wait until the president's official state visit later this year. Police Scotland's Assistant Chief Constable Emma Bond said: 'We are working closely with the Scottish Police Federation to address any concerns they may have.' A spokesperson for the PSNI said: 'There are well established processes for any UK-based police services to request support from other services at times of peak demand. 'These requests are managed via the National Police Co-ordination Centre (NPoCC) and we can confirm that PSNI have received a request to provide mutual aid to Police Scotland which we are currently assessing. 'The decision to provide officers under the mutual aid process will be considered against our own demands, ensuring that we retain the capacity to respond effectively to local issues and maintain our own operational competence.'
