Cathy Dillon: A reporter remembers the Air India Disaster of June 23rd, 1985
The date was June 24th, 1985, the day after the Air India disaster, when a terrorist bomb blew up a 747 jumbo jet in Irish airspace off the coast of West Cork, killing all 329 people on board. A wannabe journalist, straight out of college and working in the shambolic newsroom of a local pirate radio station, I had been sent by the head of news to report from Cork airport for the six o'clock evening bulletin. When I arrived at the normally sleepy airport terminal, lugging my enormous and ungainly tape recorder, I could hardly believe my eyes. Teams of army and navy personnel, security men and ambulance staff jostled with large crowds of reporters from news channels and papers throughout the world.
Amid the throng, I spied Nell McCafferty, small in stature but definitely not in personality, instantly recognisable from the telly with her head of bushy grey hair. While the other reporters ran around in a tizzy, she stood and surveyed the scene coolly, her hands in the pockets of her jeans.
I was awe struck – I had grown up reading her brilliant series of court reports, In the Eyes of the Law, in
The Irish Times,
and in our house we regularly used her wry TV sign-off phrase: 'Goodnight, Sisters' among ourselves, with a roll of our eyes, in response to some particularly egregious instance of chauvinism that had been brought to our attention.
I somehow made myself walk over to her and introduce myself. Sensing I was slightly at a loss in this melee, Nell was kind enough to take the greenhorn under her wing. She had heard that some of the media were being taken out on helicopters to survey and photograph the crash scene.
READ MORE
'Hello there,' she greeted the security officer. 'How are ya?' The man in the high-vis vest instantly recognised the face. 'Ah, 'tis yourself, Nell.'
'Listen, I was wondering is there any chance you could get me and the wee girl here out on one of the choppers?' The man in the high-vis vest looked dubious. 'Oh,' he said, shaking his head, 'I don't know. I don't think so.'
Nell waited a few moments and then tried another tack. 'Did anyone ever tell you you're the image of Jack Nicholson?' she said flirtatiously. She turned to me, standing meekly beside her. 'Isn't he the head off Jack Nicholson?'
I couldn't see the resemblance myself, but I wasn't about to argue.
The crash site was 190km off the coast of Mizen, where Irish Naval Service crewmen, assisted by RAF and Royal Naval helicopters as well as merchant ships and fishing trawlers, were searching for bodies that could be returned to the victims' relatives. Nell was doing her best to get us right to the grim heart of the action.
On this rare occasion, even Nell's charm couldn't prevail and I, at least, never got out on the helicopter. In truth, though of course I didn't say this to Nell, I was partly relieved. I left and went about finding others to talk to and filed my report by phone from the airport. I never met Nell afterwards, either, or got a chance to thank her, though I was lucky enough to share one space – the list of contributors' in
Hot Press
magazine – with her (and many others) in the late 1980s and early 1990s.
The incident showed me that kindness and humour can survive in the bleakest of circumstances. Air India flight 182 was on its way from Toronto via Montreal to London and New Delhi, and the majority of the passengers were Canadians of Indian descent. The main suspects in the bombing were members of the Sikh militant group Babbar Khalsa. After a fraught investigation that lasted almost 20 years, in 2003 Inderjit Singh Reyat, a Canadian national, was sentenced to 15 years in prison for building the bomb that exploded aboard Flight 182 and another that went off prematurely at Narita airport in Tokyo and killed two baggage handlers. He was freed in February last year.
In 2010, a report by a commission of inquiry found the victims' families had been left in a limbo by the Canadian government, and had 'often been treated as adversaries, as if they had somehow brought this calamity upon themselves'. After 25 years, the prime minister of the day, Stephen Harper, issued an apology on behalf of the government.
The local people in West Cork, as is their wont, showed great compassion to the bereaved relatives who arrived immediately after the disaster and some struck up friendships with them that have lasted over the decades.
Some of the families, seeking to find the nearest land point to where the plane disintegrated at 31,000 feet, discovered a site at Ahakista where a shoreline memorial garden was created, with a sundial made by Cork sculptor Ken Thompson. Every year since, on June 24th, in the garden, locals join relatives of the victims in remembering. The families float white balloons into the sky, and walk in silence. They recite the names of those they lost. This year, it's the 40th anniversary. And, a little later this year, we will also remember Nell, who died on August 21st last year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Carlow gunman Evan Fitzgerald had other weapons, Garda investigation found
Evan Fitzgerald , the gunman who fired shots into the air in a Carlow shopping centre before taking his own life, had possession of more weapons than previously reported, it has emerged. On June 1st, Mr Fitzgerald (22) entered the busy Fairgreen Shopping Centre and using a pump action shotgun, stolen in a burglary from a neighbour, began firing shots in the air before turning the gun on himself. At the time, the former steelyard worker from Portrushen, Kiltegan, Co Wicklow, was facing charges for possession of a military grade assault rifle, a handgun and ammunition which he had allegedly attempted to buy on the dark web. Undercover gardaí sold him the guns, which they had decommissioned, after being tipped off that Mr Fitzgerald was attempting to source weapons on the internet. READ MORE Armed officers then forcibly stopped his car and arrested him a short time later. It has now emerged that following the shooting incident in Fairgreen Shopping Centre, gardaí located further weapons, which have been conclusively linked to Mr Fitzgerald. Gardaí carried out several searches following the incident to determine Mr Fitzgerald's motive that day. During these searches they found another shotgun and a replica firearm. A big concern for investigators is that they have been unable to determine the source of these items. They may have been taken in a burglary or sourced online, sources say. The Garda has faced significant criticism is recent weeks for its handling of the Fitzgerald case. Senator and former minister for justice Michael McDowell described the Garda operation to sell him the guns as 'entrapment' and claimed misleading evidence had been provided to the District Court judge in Mr Fitzgerald's case. Mr McDowell had raised court reports that suggested gardaí had told the judge they were 'investigating' how Mr Fitzgerald acquired the guns. The Garda has referred these comments to Fiosrú , the Garda Ombudsman. Labour TD Alan Kelly questioned the need for gardaí to deliver the weapons to Mr Fitzgerald, describing him as a 'poor, tragic, vulnerable individual'. Gardaí have defended their handling of the case and said they used internationally accepted tactics in the interests of public safety. Senior sources said they accepted Mr Fitzgerald was a vulnerable person with mental issues and that he did not have links to terrorism or organised crime. However, they could not rule out that he was planning a mass shooting of the type seen in the United States and other countries in recent years. They said investigations show the young man shared some characteristics of mass shooters, including a fascination with firearms and feelings of deep isolation. As part of the investigation, they have been examining Mr Fitzgerald's internet use to determine if he may have been under the influence of violent online figures. Investigators pointed to the fact that searches of Mr Fitzgerald's home led to the discovery of ammunition and material which could be used to make explosives. On Thursday, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris and his deputy Justin Kelly defended their handling of the case, with the commissioner raising the recent school shooting 'by a lone gunman' in Austria which left 11 people dead. 'This is sadly a more frequent occurrence,' Mr Harris told a meeting of the Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee. 'There is very insidious material on the internet which seeks to radicalise young people. We have to look at the individual and the threat to the general public and deal with that appropriately. 'I have to say, this was a very successful operation in that we made sure a threat to the public did not arise from the circumstances we were dealing with.' There was 'no other way of doing it', Mr Harris said. The suicide of Mr Fitzgerald was 'obviously very tragic' but did not arise from the Garda operation, he added. Since his death, the firearms case against Mr Fitzgerald has been withdrawn. Two other young men who were allegedly in the car when gardaí stopped Mr Fitzgerald with the firearms remain before the court. Daniel Quinn Burke, of Allendale Lawns, Baltinglass, Co Wicklow has entered a guilty plea to the charges while his co-accused Shane Kinsella, of Tynock, Kiltegan, Co Wicklow has yet to enter a plea.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Jón Jónsson answers are in Iceland, not Ireland, his brother says
The brother of missing Icelandic man Jón Jónsson agrees with Garda detectives that the answers to his brother's disappearance six years ago lie in Iceland . The poker player had been in Ireland less than 24 hours when he disappeared after leaving the Bonnington Hotel in February 2019 during the Dublin Poker Festival. 'You would think the answers are in Iceland,' said Jón's brother, Davíð Karl Wiium. 'Probably something prior to his disappearance has something to do with his disappearance.' Five gardaí have come to Reykjavik for the first time this week to work on the case, a development that is welcomed by Wiium and his family. Gardaí are working closely with members of the Icelandic police. 'We are very happy that they're here. It's a huge milestone in the case. It's been six years,' Wiium said. READ MORE He hopes that in Iceland, gardaí will get answers that will point them in the right direction. 'I hope, by coming here, the Irish police can get a better understanding of what he was doing before he came to Ireland. Look into his closest surroundings, talk with people of interest, the family, friends,' Wiium said. 'You get to know the person. You get to know what he was doing, and where he was before, and what he was involved in.' [ 'I'm almost certain something happened': Family fear missing Jón Jónsson was killed by hitman in case of mistaken identity Opens in new window ] Wiium met gardaí in Reykjavik this week as they began to take statements in Iceland. He has felt momentum pick up in the case again with recent media appearances such as The Late Late Show, which the family appeared on in March. A podcast series on Jónsson's disappearance also came out in January. 'We really felt the snowball rolling,' Wiium said, adding that the podcast has given the family extra strength. 'It has probably been the most positive impact from the beginning. It was like an extra push that we needed after a long, long time.' Where is Jón?/Hvar er Jón? is a co-production between RTÉ and Icelandic broadcaster RÚV. It delves into Jón's background over seven episodes, through interviews with his family and friends. Jón's family welcomed the podcast's focus on Jón's case and hoped it would bring them answers. Wiium said it was important also that the podcast 'portrayed Jón as who he is. He was a really good man, a great person and father that coincidentally started playing poker a couple of years before he disappeared.' Wiium said his brother had been looking forward to the tournament and remembers him speaking about it for weeks beforehand. 'I know he really wanted to be a poker player. He was not a sports guy. He was into board games, poker, video games, that kind of stuff. And he wanted to be really good at poker.' He speaks of a man who was always there for everyone. 'A 'family comes first' kind of man. So it's very much out of character.' The toll it has taken on Jón's family has been immense. 'It's hard for everyone. It's a big family, and emotionally it's hard. When you have someone disappearing very close to you, it starts to tear you up inside. It always creeps back. It's always there.' 'We just really want to find him, and hopefully figure out what happened.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘It was not really human at all': policing the worst of Dublin's rental market, with its bed bugs, overcrowding and no leases
Julia Langneck was full of hope and excitement when she moved from Brazil to Dublin to learn English at 18 years of age. Within months of arriving in the country she would find herself living in a bedbug-infested bedsit, sharing a room with four other people and paying almost €400 a month for the privilege. There were eight people sharing one bathroom on the ground floor of the three-storey building on Bolton Street in Dublin's north inner city. They were allocated one shelf each in a shared fridge, one cupboard each in the kitchen and slept in bunk beds in two separate rooms. 'It was not really human at all; it was really terrible,' says Langneck. READ MORE She recalls watching a bedbug crawl across her phone one night, and sleeping in the livingroom for fear of being bitten. 'My two housemates had bruises and bites all over their body, and we had to pay for it to be cleaned,' she says. There were eight people sharing one kitchen on the ground floor of the three-storey building on Bolton Street in Dublin 1. Photograph: Julia Langneck When the situation became unbearable, Langneck decided to move out, but her landlord, Renato Passos, withheld her deposit. She brought a case against him to the Residential Tenancies Board, the rental market regulator and arbiter of landlord-tenant disputes. The board ordered him to pay the deposit and damages. It would not be the last time he would have dealings with the regulator. [ Dublin landlord hit with largest-ever RTB fine over failure to register tenancies Opens in new window ] Sources within the RTB this week gave The Irish Times an insight into how they investigate rogue landlords and what they have seen vulnerable tenants go through. Inside the RTB, a team of investigators work like a detective unit to turn tip-offs into tangible prosecutions under powers afforded to it in 2019. They report a pattern in their findings: landlords with multiple properties, the subdividing of dwellings, overcrowded units and the absence of lease agreements. They regularly find vulnerable tenants, who have often just arrived in Ireland with no real understanding of their tenancy rights, paying high rents in substandard accommodation and being threatened with eviction or being moved around to different locations with no notice and seemingly no other option. Part 7A of the Residential Tenancies Act was enacted in 2019 and gives powers to the RTB to investigate improper conduct by landlords. Under the Act the RTB can appoint 'authorised officers' to investigate complaints and gives them extensive powers of entry and search, as well as power to compel people to provide information. The outcome of the investigation is sent to a 'decision maker' within the RTB, who decides if improper conduct has occurred. A financial sanction can then be imposed on the landlord, and must be confirmed by the Circuit Court. Details of the sanctions – and the landlord who received them – are then published on the RTB website. Tenants were sleeping on beds on the floor of the bar area of what was once Buck Whaley's nightclub on Leeson Street While Langneck's case was taken through its disputes process, the RTB subsequently began its own independent investigation into Passos when media reports detailed serious overcrowding and unstable tenancies in properties he was leasing on Leeson Street in Dublin 2. In November 2024 this resulted in the RTB's largest ever sanction, with the company run by Passos, Sweet Home Accommodation Ltd, being fined €22,000 for a breach of rental laws at six city-centre properties under his control. Investigators established that he had failed to register 20 tenancies in properties on Leeson Street, Middle Abbey Street and Upper Abbey Street. During its investigation the RTB discovered Brazilian students were being targeted through language schools and on social media about properties Passos did not actually own but was subletting. The tenancies were very short term, only a few months in duration, and rents were on average €500 per month. Tenants were sleeping on beds on the floor of the bar area of what was once Buck Whaley's nightclub on Leeson Street. There was extensive overcrowding at this property and at multiple other properties run by Passos, with bunk beds crammed into makeshift apartments, mattresses laid on floors and livingrooms converted into bedrooms. In one property there were 15 people sharing one kitchen. Investigating this case proved particularly difficult for the RTB because almost all of the tenants had moved out, often back to Brazil, by the time the case started. Significant time was spent by investigators tracing down these tenants, calling, emailing and chasing them by any means possible to try to get their evidence on the record. Eventually they gathered enough responses to ground a case, noting the most striking thing about their evidence was that these people did not know they were tenants, nor that the landlord couldn't move them out in the morning, nor that they were entitled to privacy and space in their own home. Sweet Home Accommodation Ltd is now in liquidation and the RTB is not aware of any outstanding cases against Passos. Asked to comment on the investigations, Passos responded to say the company was no longer operating. While Passos engaged with the RTB investigators and was co-operative in their investigation, other landlords have proven much more difficult to track down. Serving the notice of investigation on Marc Godart proved particularly difficult Controversial Luxembourg landlord Marc Godart and his company Green Label Ltd has been issued several sanctions by the RTB, following the conclusion of multiple investigations into his conduct. The Irish Times has investigated his rental property interests over several years, finding repeated instances of overcrowded accommodation and unlawful evictions in his sprawling Irish rental portfolio. However, sources within the RTB say that serving the actual notice of investigation on him proved particularly difficult. An investigation cannot continue unless the board can prove this notice was received by the landlord, and so landlords often do their best to evade receiving it. The first line of defence is often hiding behind multiple different company names, requiring the regulator to trawl through company records to establish the person behind the front. In Godart's case, investigators found letters were returned to them because the letterbox of his registered address had been blocked up. When investigators called to hand over the letter in person, they found the office was on an upper floor of a multi-unit block that they could not access. In the end, they waited outside the office on five occasions in order to gain trust with those coming and going, who eventually let them in and allowed them to push a letter under the door of the registered address. The RTB is keen to emphasise its persistence in investigating improper conduct in the rental market, and latest figures show the number of sanctions it is securing is growing at a steady rate. In 2024 it published 75 sanctions, with a value of just over €238,000. This is almost four times higher than what it gathered in 2023, at €64,360. Julia Langneck: 'I really love Ireland, but accommodation is such a big issue' Julia Langneck says she is grateful for the investigations into Passos, who she feels made her time in a foreign land far more difficult than it needed to be. 'You feel that someone from your country is going to help you, because you just arrived and everything is hard, but it was totally the opposite,' she says. 'He just kind of used us to get money. 'It's really upsetting, because you think you just crossed the ocean to another country to try a better life, and then you meet someone from your own country, and you think that person is going to help you, but definitely not.' After six years in Ireland, she returned to Brazil this summer to be with her boyfriend, Deliveroo driver João Ferreira. Ferreira lost part of his right leg after being seriously injured when he was hit by a Garda vehicle on the M50 in 2023. He is awaiting more surgeries in his home city of São Paulo. As the couple adapts to the realities of this new life, Langneck reflects on her time in Ireland. 'When people ask me, I say I really love Ireland, but accommodation is such a big issue there. In the end I got a nice apartment, a nice job – after years of worry, I felt like it was worth it in the end.'
