Unexplained wealth orders: powerful but challenging tool, says TI-M
PETALING JAYA : An unexplained wealth order (UWO) could be a powerful tool in the fight against corruption—but enacting legislation for it could be fraught with challenges, says an anti-graft advocate.
Transparency International Malaysia (TI-M) president Raymon Ram said securing parliamentary approval for a UWO would be difficult, as the mechanism itself appears to undermine fundamental legal principles.
'MPs who might be subject to a UWO might vote against such a law,' he told FMT.
Raymon Ram.
Raymon explained that under the UWO, the burden of proof is shifted onto individuals to justify their wealth. This contradicts fundamental legal principles, including the presumption of innocence, he added.
Under established legal principles, the burden of proof typically rests with the claimant or prosecutor, and every individual is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Nevertheless, Raymon acknowledged that UWOs have 'remarkable potential' in the area of asset recovery and could complement laws such as the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission Act 2009 and the Anti-Money Laundering, Anti-Terrorism Financing and Proceeds of Unlawful Activities Act 2001.
He said any legislation enacted should frame the UWO as a civil mechanism — similar to the UK model — to avoid potential constitutional challenges, while still equipping enforcement agencies with meaningful powers.
He also said that there was need for judicial oversight to prevent abuse.
'A new UWO system must be built with checks and transparency so it isn't used or weaponised against political opponents,' said Raymon.
On Saturday, former Klang MP Charles Santiago urged the government to introduce legislation for the issuance of UWOs to tackle illicit wealth and systemic corruption among the elite.
He said the UK recovered £62.9 million (RM390 million) in a single year through the order and related civil actions.
Citing official estimates, Santiago said Malaysia lost RM277 billion to fraud, procurement abuse, and illicit flows between 2018 and 2023, or RM55 billion annually, that could have funded schools, hospitals, and food aid.
However, Center to Combat Corruption and Cronyism chief executive officer Pushpan Murugiah cautioned that the UWO was 'not a silver bullet that can solve all problems related to corruption'.
'UWOs do not curb corruption by preventing the commission of corrupt acts or addressing the root causes of corruption. It merely provides an easier and faster path towards asset recovery to an extent,' he said when contacted.
He also described the UWO as a form of civil forfeiture, characterising it primarily as an investigative tool designed to secure a civil recovery order by reversing the burden of proof.
Pushpan Murugiah.
Pushpan also pointed out that UWOs are used sparingly in the UK, with investigating agencies reluctant to invoke the law in cases involving complex asset structures. This was on account of the high legal costs they would become liable for if the UWO is overturned.
He also said the obscuring in Malaysia of assets through the use of layers of shell companies and proxies may become a major barrier to the adoption of UWOs locally.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Muhyiddin denies defending subsidies for foreigners
PN chairman Muhyiddin Yassin said the coalition's fundamental policy on subsidies has always been that they should be for Malaysians, not foreigners. PETALING JAYA : Perikatan Nasional chairman Muhyiddin Yassin has denied defending the distribution of government subsidies to foreigners, urging Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim to furnish proof he had ever made such a statement. In a video posted on Facebook, Muhyiddin said Anwar's claim that he had made such a remark was slanderous. 'I have never said such a thing. From the beginning, our fundamental policy on subsidies has been that they are meant for Malaysians, not foreigners. 'I want to ask where Anwar read or heard that (purported statement), because there's definitely none. 'What was the source, and was it genuine or fake?' asked the Bersatu president. Earlier today, Sinar Harian quoted Anwar as saying that Muhyiddin had questioned the government for burdening foreigners when they had also made significant contributions to the country. The prime minister said the government had decided on targeted subsidies for electricity and RON95 petrol so that they could continue helping Malaysians while reducing the nation's fiscal deficit.
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Sri Lankan parliament sacks disgraced police chief
Deshabandu Tennakoon was appointed Sri Lanka's police chief in November 2023. (EPA Images pic) COLOMBO : Sri Lanka's parliament voted overwhelmingly today to dismiss police chief Deshabandu Tennakoon for misconduct and criminal behaviour, making him the island's first inspector-general to be impeached. Tennakoon, 54, was removed less than two years after his controversial appointment, with a disciplinary committee finding him unfit to lead its 85,000-strong law enforcement body. Tennakoon was appointed in November 2023 by then-president Ranil Wickremesinghe, despite the Supreme Court having previously ruled that he had tortured a suspect in custody by rubbing menthol balm on his genitals. Public security minister Ananda Wijepala told parliament today that Tennakoon should never have been put in the top job, given that he faced 40 court cases for abuse of power. 'He is the most disgraced police chief in the history of our country,' Wijepala said. Parliament backed a resolution by speaker Jagath Wickramaratne to impeach Tennakoon, following a disciplinary hearing led by a Supreme Court judge and two others. 'I am pleased to inform that the motion to impeach Deshabandu Tennakoon has been approved with 177 votes in favour, and none against,' Wickramaratne said. Members of the main opposition SJB party also voted to remove the police chief. Shortly after his appointment to head the force, Tennakoon was accused of authorising a botched raid in December 2023 that led to a gun battle between rival police units in the coastal resort town of Weligama, resulting in the death of an officer. A disciplinary inquiry found that Tennakoon had 'spearheaded the questionable, illegal act of shooting'. The Supreme Court suspended him in July 2024 pending the outcome of a separate case. In March, the state prosecutor told a court that Tennakoon was operating a paramilitary hit squad to carry out illegal activities and was unfit to serve, even at the lowest rank in the police force. Opposition leader Sajith Premadasa said his party had objected to Tennakoon's appointment from the outset, and today's vote vindicated their position. There has been no response from Tennakoon since the impeachment process was initiated last month.
Free Malaysia Today
3 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
4-year-old boy dies in fall from 8th floor condo
Klang Selatan deputy police chief Kamal Ariffin Aman Shah said the boy died of head injuries while being treated in hospital. (Facebook pic) PETALING JAYA : A four-year-old boy died after falling from an eighth floor apartment in a condominium at Port Klang this morning. Police said the boy's father was at work while his mother had gone out to send another child to the babysitter's house. 'The boy is believed to have fallen out of the window of the family's apartment on the eighth floor,' Klang Selatan deputy police chief Kamal Ariffin Aman Shah said in a statement. The boy died of head injuries while receiving treatment at Tengku Ampuan Rahimah Hospital in Klang. Anyone with information can inform the nearest police station or call Klang Selatan police at 03-3376 2222.
