Lack of consultation means Ontario's Bill 5 oversteps treaty obligations, Oneida chief says
Oneida Nation of the Thames Chief Todd Cornelius had hoped that the days of Canadian governments passing laws that affect Indigenous communities without consulting them were in the past.
Then Ontario's Bill 5 happened.
Cornelius said the sweeping bill — which became law Thursday — violates signed treaty provisions that requires consultations with Indigenous groups, he wrote in a statement released Wednesday.
"This is not only a political failure, it is a betrayal of the relationship between the Crown and our Nation," said Cornelius.
Passing the bill without sufficient consultation amounts to the Ontario government breaking the series of agreements the Haudenosaunee (also known as the Six Nations and Iroquois League) signed with the Crown prior to Confederation, known as the Silver Covenant Chain, he said.
"At this moment, the chain has been deeply tarnished," he said.
Bill 5, also known as the Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act, includes major changes to the province's endangered species and environmental protection laws. The bill creates "special economic zones" which override provincial and municipal laws for certain projects.
Premier Doug Ford has said the Ring of Fire mineral deposit in northern Ontario and his proposed tunnel under Highway 401 would be given that special status under the proposed law.
Cornelius, however, said he's concerned that in an attempt to clear the way for economic development, Bill 5 negates environmental protections that are important to people in Oneida.
"Oneida will not participate in a processes that diminish its sovereignty," he said. "Oneida is a nation, not a municipality or a stakeholder under Ontario law."
Cornelius said he's ready to meet with representatives of the Crown — in this case the Governor General.
CBC News contacted the office of Governor General Mary Simon for comment Friday, but did not receive a response.
Oneida is not the first Indigenous community in Ontario to speak out against Bill 5. Among the outcry were protests at Queen's Park over the past week. Facing pressure, the government did add "duty to consult" provisions to the bill.
At Queen's Park Wednesday, Indigenous Affairs Minister Greg Rickford said the duty to consult provision is being put forward to provide "greater certainty" despite it referring to existing Constitution rights for First Nations.
Rosalind Antone, a member of Oneida's elected council, was one of more than 30 members from Oneida who travelled to Queen's Park this week to protest the bill. About 20 of those who came were youth members.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Over 200 candidates sign up for Poilievre's byelection — doubling previous record
Social Sharing More than 200 candidates, mostly associated with a group of electoral reform advocates, have signed up to run in an upcoming federal byelection next month. The number more than doubles the previous record on a single ballot. Former Alberta MP Damien Kurek vacated his seat in Battle River-Crowfoot to give Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre a chance to rejoin the House of Commons. Poilievre lost his longtime Carleton riding in April's general election. A group known as the Longest Ballot Committee has been organizing candidates to run in byelections in recent years in an effort to push for electoral reform. The committee's organizers want to put a citizens' assembly in charge of electoral reform and say political parties are too reluctant to make government more representative of the electorate. As of Sunday evening, 209 candidates had registered to run in Battle River-Crowfoot, exceeding than committee's goal of 200. That's more than double the previous record of 91 which has occurred twice in the past year: during a byelection in LaSalle-Emard-Verdun last September and Carleton during the last general election. That number of candidates resulted in a ballot roughly a metre long. The massive ballots have resulted in delays in vote counting and have confounded some voters. Elections Canada told CBC News on Wednesday that it will finalize ways to minimize disruptions from the long ballots. "We are looking at ways to [simplify] things based on recent experiences with elections involving a higher-than-usual number of candidates. We will finalize our plans after the deadline for candidate nominations," spokesperson Matthew McKenna said in an email. Elections Canada has already had to make changes to accommodate the mammoth-sized ballots — mostly through early counting and bringing in extra workers. Although the Longest Ballot Committee has organized in two elections where Poilievre is running, the group has also targeted Liberal strongholds such as Toronto-St. Paul's and LaSalle-Émard-Verdun in 2024. But the advocates' efforts to push the limits of a ballot have sparked calls for changes, most recently from Poilievre himself which he refers to as a "scam." The Conservative leader wrote a letter to government House leader Steven MacKinnon on Tuesday, calling for legislation to change Canada's election rules in an effort to curb the long ballot protests. A spokesperson for MacKinnon's office said the Liberals share those concerns and are open to changes. MPs were debating legislation last Parliamentary session that could have implemented some of Poilievre's proposed changes — specifically to limit electors to only signing one nomination form. The advocates have voters sign multiple forms. Elections Canada head Stéphane Perrault himself made the suggestion in front of a committee of MPs that was studying a bill to amend the Canada Elections Act before Parliament was prorogued. Perrault argued that "certain penalties" should be imposed on individuals who sign — or encourage others to sign — multiple nomination papers in an effort to get as many candidates on a ballot as possible, though he didn't say what those penalties should be. The deadline to register as a candidate in Battle River-Crowfoot is Monday. Voters head to the polls on Aug. 18.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Animal rescue fighting to save resident wild boar
An animal rescue in Yellowhead County is running up against a problematic law that bans residents from raising wild boars. Rosie's Rescue recently relocated to the area along with its wild boar Wilbur who was rescued from a meat farm. As Sarah Reid reports, a recent vote by council means he'll have to be either destroyed or removed.
CBC
5 hours ago
- CBC
Canadian targeted by Hong Kong arrest warrant decries Beijing's 'tyranny'
The Canadian government is condemning new arrest warrants issued by Hong Kong for activists based overseas, including in Canada. Canadian Victor Ho, who is among those named in the warrants, sees it as the latest example of 'transnational repression by the Communist government in China,' and says he's not afraid to be targeted.
