‘Borderlands 4' Goes Back To Series Roots, Even As Gearbox Software Expands Core Concepts

Geek Culture

18-06-2025

In the crowded first-person shooter (FPS) genre filled with overly serious military simulators, hectic multiplayer PvP experiences, and nostalgic boomer shooters, one franchise stands out and above because of the absolute nonsense it brings to the battlefield – Gearbox Software's Borderlands .
While many IPs struggle to find that balance between providing an engaging narrative alongside solid gameplay fundamentals, while not being too reliant on a multiplayer aspect to keep a player engaged in the long run, Borderlands' three mainline entries and two spin-offs have provided an addictive gameplay loop alongside an engaging narrative to boot, balancing equal parts humour and drama.
Granted, some changes have sat better with fans since its 2009 debut, especially with the last mainline entry, 2019's Borderlands 3 , drawing criticism for its writing, in part due to the game's influencer-like main villain duo, the Calypso Twins leading the game's overall tone which tried to cater to a target audience that didn't exist.
Well, fans would be glad to know that the criticisms did not go unnoticed by the studio, because with its upcoming sequel, Borderlands 4 , the studio is going all out to ensure that the highly anticipated outing not only makes an effort to ground the series to a level that fans can appreciate.
' Borderlands has always been in the borderland between drama and comedy, there's its centre line that has always been serious, and on the fringes it was ridiculous,' explains Gearbox CEO Randy Pitchford during an exclusive interview with Geek Culture alongside an accompanying preview session. Gearbox CEO Randy Pitchford (far left), Gearbox Global Creative Executive Officer Andrew Reiner (far right)
'But it's neither, it's never been either a drama or a comedy, but it's both of that. It's this weird thing in between, and that's what Borderlands is, it's always the in-between space of things that don't belong together.'
As a series, Borderlands has always leveraged its humour as a selling point, constantly ramping up the ridiculousness with every entry, and while this growth has seen its share of hits and misses, the team has taken it all as a learning experience.
'I think Borderlands 1 was probably the most serious version of Borderlands , and Borderlands 3 was probably the most ridiculous.' Pitchford adds, 'The more we've done, the more experience we have, and I think we now know the right place to dial in Borderlands 4 for where we are at this time and place, and that's where we're at now.'
At the core of the Borderlands experience lies its jokes, an area where the third entry unfortunately fell flat due to its focus on quantity over quality. To this end, the game's narrative director, Sam Winkler, previously teased that the game would feature 'more situational' humour this time around, a point that we asked Pitchford to elaborate on.
'In the past, there was a moment when we felt like we would do a lot of jokes at once, because different jokes would hit for different people, and because not everyone has the same taste and humour, so we thought we'd just machine gun it,' Pitchford explains.
'And that kind of works, because if you tell 20 jokes, one of them will hit, but there's also something to be said for the experience of feeling the 19 that didn't.'
'So I think in this context, we've been a lot more surgical and measured this time around,' he adds.
'I think what Sam was speaking to is a better coordination between narrative storytelling and writing with natural elements like the environment, the situation and gameplay construction. And I think that's a really cool thing.'
To put this into context, an example of the Bloodwing fight in Borderlands 2 was brought up. For the uninitiated, Bloodwing was the loyal companion of Mordecai, one of the four main characters in the first game, who was unfortunately captured and mutated by the second game's villain, Handsome Jack, forcing both Mordecai and the player character to fight and kill the corrupted beast, a moment that served as a significant emotional moment in the game.
As messed up as the situation may seem, there was something innately humorous about the whole situation, infusing the series with a special kind of dark comedy that makes a player question why they were forced to fight such a well-known character, building on equal parts astonishment and disbelief in the moment to make players crack a regretful smile.
According to Pitchford, it's this natural (and sometimes unintentional) integration of humour into moment-to-moment gameplay that will drive Borderlands 4's comedy forward.
'Every experience adds up,' says Pitchford, who admits that even though the development of Borderlands 4 was not affected by the rather poor reception of the third title, both its criticism and praise and their effect on the team were impossible to deny, who used these learning lessons to craft a much more formidable, and less annoying, villain this time around: The Timekeeper.
Borderlands 4 takes place on Kairos, a once-hidden planet ruled with an iron fist by the mysterious Timekeeper, a being of immense power in command of a vast army of synthetic enforcers known as The Order. According to Pitchford, the Timekeeper marks the franchise's most serious antagonist to date, which is certainly an interesting twist in tone.
'I don't think he has ever told a joke. If this is a smile, the Timekeeper probably hasn't even done this.' Pitchford explains, as he cracks the most forced smile he could muster as a reference.
'He is intelligent, calculated, in your face right out of the gates, and a serious threat. He's no joke. Darth Vader? That guy cracks more jokes.'
It will be interesting to see how a shift to a completely serious main antagonist will affect the game's overall comedic element, although chances are, it will be delegated to the four new Vault Hunters (Vex, Rafa, Amon, and Harlowe) and their interactions with their various allies and foes.
It's this return to the traditional four pre-set characters that marks yet another way Borderlands 4 is doubling down on series roots, even as the team also expands upon this sequel's scale, story, and comedic elements. Alas, this means that the franchise's updated character customisation, introduced in 2022's Tiny Tina's Wonderlands spin-off , which allowed the tailoring of a character's looks, along with a player's ability to mix and match classes to suit every playstyle, won't be seen here.
While it marked a refreshing and well-received switch by the fanbase, due to the added gameplay flexibility and personalisation it provided, the team decided to return to the traditional method of only allowing the choice between four pre-set characters.
Why? For Pitchford, allowing players the freedom to create an original character diminished one important aspect of its story – the element of playing out a superhero fantasy.
'With Wonderlands , the strategy was leaning into what we fantasise about when we think about playing fantasy role-playing games, how part of the joy is crafting your character,' he explains.
'In Borderlands , we don't have that same wish. The thing we are offering instead is the ability to become one of the characters that are integral to the storyline, to be a superhero. If we could all create our own superheroes, then all of the superheroes would be diminished.'
And while some fans might be disappointed that they won't be able to create their own Vault Hunter in the game, the logic is sound, considering the game's lore. Pandora was always a dangerous place, and Kairos looks to be even more so, making the four new Vault Hunters the proverbial cream of the crop, the only ones badass enough to survive and thrive in the harsh world where so many other would-be treasure hunter enthusiasts have failed.
Having a choice of pre-set characters ensures that each possesses a unique personality, something that's difficult to pull off when opting for a creation system seen in Wonderlands . Furthermore, the team has also made steps to properly establish the player character's presence in the game's storyline this time around.
And while Borderlands 3 faced criticism for leaving the player character on the sidelines, with its story playing out like it was independent of the main protagonist rather than them actively being a part of it, Borderlands 4 is set to focus heavily on the player character, and rightfully so. For the first time in the series' history, the player will not only physically appear in cutscenes, but also accurately reflect a chosen outfit, which will probably lead to hilarious interactions considering how wacky some of the game's costumes can get.
With the improvements and reworks of its story, characters and humour, that leaves one other major aspect of the game that has been developed from scratch – its world. Instead of exploring the vast and diverse landscapes of Pandora, or in Promethea, Athenas or Eden-6, Borderlands 4 is shifting gears and dropping players on the brand-new planet of Kairos.
And despite focusing on a single planet this time around, the game promises the most diverse and expansive environments to date.
'In terms of square footage, Borderlands 4 has more than all of the previous games added together – it's massive,' states Pitchford when asked about how the game's scale compares to Borderlands 3 , which back then was the franchise's most environmentally diverse title with its inclusion of multiple planets to explore.
'In terms of diversity of environment, well, again, Borderlands 4 is at the top of the game. Yes, each planet in Borderlands 3 had some different, distinct set pieces and environments, but that was integral to the game's story. Borderlands 4 is about this legendary planet of Kairos that's been locked away for thousands of years, which has more vaults than any other planet in the universe. So it's a whole different story conceit, everything happens on this planet, with the struggle between the dictators controlling the planet and everyone's desire for freedom being the backdrop.'
So, how does this translate to more meaningful exploration and discovery? For Gearbox Global Creative Executive Officer Andrew Reiner, it's all about creating player agency within the game's sandbox.
'Another big distinction in Borderlands 4 is that we're not just creating vistas and backdrops,' he adds, 'You can physically get everywhere in this world. You see a crashed ship on a hillside? It's not just there as something to look at and say 'Oh, that's cool'. You can get up there if you want, everything is free to explore and experience.'
Even from early impressions, it's clear that Borderlands 4 is doubling down on the franchise's madness. We've already seen this in effect via our extended gameplay preview, but this looks to be the case for its narrative elements as well, with all signs pointing to a title that will put the series back on track while making meaningful adjustments. Let's just hope that most of its jokes will hit this time around, and that Claptrap will remain just as annoying as ever.
Never change, Claptrap.
Borderlands 4 will launch on 12 September 2025 for the PS5, Xbox Series X|S and PC, with a release on the Nintendo Switch 2 arriving later in the year.
Kevin is a reformed PC Master Race gamer with a penchant for franchise 'duds' like Darksiders III and Dead Space 3 . He has made it his life-long mission to play every single major game release – lest his wallet dies trying. 2K Games Borderlands Borderlands 4 Gearbox Software Geek Interview