Legal cases of former Bankstown, Sydney nurses charged over antisemitic video return to court
Ahmad Rashad Nadir, 27, and Sarah Abu Lebdeh, 26, were stood down from their jobs at Bankstown Hospital on February 12 after a video emerged of the pair allegedly making threats against Israeli patients.
The pair, who are both on conditional bail, are excused from appearing in person when their cases are briefly mentioned in Sydney's Downing Centre Local Court from 9.30am.
The video, which went viral in February, showed Mr Nadir and Ms Lebdeh wearing nursing uniforms as they spoke to Jewish content creator Max Veifer through an online chat room called Chatruletka, which randomly connects users.
In the clip, Ms Lebedh allegedly bragged about refusing to treat Israeli patients at the hospital and threatened to kill them.
Mr Nadir allegedly said he had sent Israeli patients to 'Jahannam', which means hell in Arabic.
The video was widely circulated online after it was shared to social media by Mr Veifer, sparking an investigation by health authorities and police.
On February 25, Ms Lebdeh was arrested and charged with three Commonwealth offences including threatening violence to a group, using a carriage service to threaten to kill, and using a carriage service to menace, harass or offend.
Mr Nadir was arrested on March 4 and charged with a Commonwealth offence of using a carriage service to menace, harass, offend or threaten.
He was also charged with possessing a prohibited drug, which was allegedly found inside his locker at Bankstown Hospital.
Dramatic scenes unfolded outside Sydney's Downing Centre in March when the two former nurses appeared in court for the first time since their arrests.
Mr Nadir's lawyer Zemarai Khatiz said his client will challenge the charges against him on the grounds of the video being taken without his consent.
"My client will be pleading not guilty to the charges. He will be defending the matter on legal and technical grounds," Mr Khatiz told reporters.
"The video that was captured and recorded, was done without the consent of my client, without his knowledge. And we'll argue for that to be excluded."
Meanwhile, Ms Lebdeh was rushed out of the courthouse while being shielded by an entourage of men in black hoodies before she was whisked away in a waiting black car.
Mr Nadir has previously apologised for his remarks in the video through a legal representative who said the former nurse does not 'protect what he has done or hide from it'.
A family member of Ms Lebdeh, who identified himself as her uncle, previously told the media she was sorry for her comments.
"She will come out and make a statement when she's ready, but you can't talk to her now because she's having a panic attack, an anxiety attack," he told The Australian at the time.
On February 13, Federal Health Minister Mark Butler confirmed the Nursing and Midwifery Council of New South Wales had suspended Mr Nadir and Ms Lebdeh's nursing registrations.
This means they are currently banned from practising nursing anywhere in Australia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
16 hours ago
- The Age
We can have a good childcare system, or a cheap one. When protecting children, that choice should be easy
Once it became clear that a string of child abuse offences may have taken place across Melbourne for years undetected, and parents of 1200 children were contacted, it was obvious that there would be wider public consternation. Parents across the nation would have experienced a pang of doubt. But childcare is not simply childcare. It is, as the federal government knows, a vital building block in the way modern Australian families live, and it underpins our economy. Put simply, parents cannot work productively unless they can outsource this care for part of the day. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese made widened access to childcare a key part of his re-election pitch, and has introduced legislation to guarantee three days of subsidised early education and care universally, with talk of a flat-fee system as part of his second-term vision. His government has also pushed higher wages for those working in childcare. But this week's revelations of police investigations bring us back to fundamental questions about a sector that the Commonwealth and states are anxious to build out rapidly. In March, reporting by the ABC's Four Corners showed that childcare centres were allowed to continue operating despite falling short of regulatory standards, and that regulation was infrequent and staff sometimes unqualified. At the time, Albanese insisted that a royal commission into these allegations was unnecessary because states would be able to investigate such clear wrongdoing. Loading At a hastily convened press conference on Wednesday, Premier Jacinta Allan and Minister for Children Lizzie Blandthorn implied that Victoria was moving quickly on reforming the sector, only to find itself frustrated by the pace of progress at the national level. They pledged to have a state register of workers in the sector by the end of August, which they hoped would then slot into a national register. The uproar surrounding the case of Joshua Dale Brown understandably has parents demanding immediate action, while politicians are left explaining the constraints they work under. But it is nearly three years since Deborah Glass, in her role as Victorian ombudsman, issued a report pointing to holes in the state's system of working with children checks. It was only this April that Allan launched a 'rapid review' of the system. Why such a delay? Robert Fitzgerald, a commissioner for the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, told The Age federal and state governments have had the opportunity to act on the recommendation for a nationally coordinated working with children scheme since 2015. In the ten years since, they have failed to do so. He says it is time to 'get the job done.' Yesterday, the premier spoke about an 'urgent review' into the incident. For parents waiting to discover whether their children have been abused, talk of urgency and pledges of reform will wear thin if not followed by palpable action.
Sky News AU
a day ago
- Sky News AU
Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan announces review into childcare sector safety after daycare worker charged with sex offences
Victoria has announced an urgent review into childcare safety after a former Melbourne daycare worker was charged with more than 70 child sex offences. Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan on Wednesday confirmed the government will fast-track a state register of childcare workers, noting work is already under way on a national level. The state will also bring forward a ban of personal devices at childcare centres, effective from September 26. Childcare facilities caught breaking the ban could be slapped with a hefty fine of up to $50,000. The reform follows allegations of sexual assault against 26-year-old former childcare worker Joshua Dale Brown being made public by police on Tuesday. Mr Brown faces staggering list of charges, including sexual penetration of a child under 12, and producing child abuse material for use through a carriage service. The offences allegedly occurred at Creative Gardens Early Learning Centre in Point Cook, where Mr Brown was employed from October 2021 until February 2024. "Every Victorian was just so completed horrified by those sickening allegations that were made public," Ms Allan told reporters on Wednesday. Ms Allan said she would not comment further on the case, noting there is an active police investigation. "What we do know ... is that families must be able to trust that their children are safe when they are placed in the care in childcare centres," Ms Allan said. "I will do everything in my power to make sure that parents can trust the system." Ms Allan acknowledged work was being done with the Commonwealth and state and territories governments to strengthen safety in the childcare sector, but stressed urgent reform is needed. "Here in Victoria, though, I will not wait. Families cannot wait," the Premier said. "More needs to happen now and that is why, in acknowledging that there is work to create a national register of childcare workers, more needs to happen now. "We will start building the Victorian register to give families an extra layer of checks and balances as soon as possible." Ms Allan said all Victorian childcare centres will be put "on notice" that they will need to adhere to the personal devices ban from September 26. The Premier will ask for the review into the state's childcare sector to be provided to the government by August 15. Ms Allan said the review will be will be a "short sharp piece of work that will focus on the immediate actions" the state can take to strengthen childcare safety. "I want this Victorian review to examine options, for example, of installing CCTV in childcare centres," she said. "We'll also too look at the national framework for childcare to see if we can go even further and act faster on any of the measures that are currently being considered at a national level. "I'll be clear too, that we will be adopting the recommendations of the review and looking at how we can implement them as quickly as possible." The person tasked with spearheading the review is expected to be announced by the end of the week.
7NEWS
2 days ago
- 7NEWS
Clare O'Neil fights tears as she speaks of her own ‘panic' on news of allegations at Melbourne childcare centre
Federal Housing Minister Clare O'Neil fought back tears as she spoke of her own 'panicked' response to the alleged child sexual abuse that occurred at a daycare centre in Melbourne. Childcare worker Joshua Brown, 26, was arrested over charges related to eight victims who attended a Point Cook childcare centre between April 2022 and January 2023. Melbourne-based O'Neil, whose young children attend childcare centres in Victoria, said she was left 'panicked' herself as she scanned list of childcare centres involved in the incidents. 'Can I first say I am a parent of a child in childcare in Victoria, and this has been enormously upsetting news for all of us here,' she told Sunrise on Wednesday. 'We take so much care of our children and then to place your trust in an institution and have it betrayed in this way, it is just awful.' The alleged victims are aged between five months and two-years-old, and the charges include sexual penetration of a child under 12, sexual assault of a child under 16, producing child abuse material and possessing child abuse material. Due to the nature of the alleged offending, around 1200 children have been recommended for screening for infectious diseases. 'I just want to say to Victorian parents, we stand with you as you are trying to process this.' As the news broke, O'Neil spoke of her own distress. 'I was so panicked yesterday, looking on that list to see if any of my kids have been affected in any of these centres. '(I know) thousands of parents around Victoria having to go through these discussions with their children, that we would never want a parent to have to talk to a child about, so I just say from a human perspective, this is absolutely awful.' O'Neil explained there would be a 'very fierce' and 'appropriate discussion' about what needs to be done to ensure this never happens again. A national watchdog for childcare centres has been suggested. 'You won't find this being politicised,' O'Neil said. 'Every politician, every leader, every regulator in a country will be poring over this case to see how things could have been done differently. '(Federal) minister Jason Clare has made a statement yesterday pointing some things that have been happening across the Commonwealth and the state. 'But please, for the public to understand that we are desperately concerned about what has happened here and will be looking at every step that we can to try to address the situation.' Parents need reassurance Senator Bridget McKenzie was equally upset. 'I was reading those stories, and I am just so thankful my kids are through childcare, and I can imagine what it would be like,' McKenzie said. 'Childhood needs to be innocent, needs to be enjoyed, and to have those conversations, I just can't imagine it. 'It is horrific, these monsters need to be identified, they need to be locked up. 'Parents need to have confidence in our childcare system that their children will be safe from these types of predators. 'So, absolutely back the calls for a review of the safeguards, and I know that as Clare said, everyone on all sides of politics will want to be getting measures in place to absolutely get this sort of behaviour out of our childcare centres and society, more generally.'
