TDs and senators question if €7m Dáil broadcasting contract is value for money
Oireachtas
proceedings, with questions around its value for money.
In a letter to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission, which runs Leinster House, the public representatives, including Minister of State
Jerry Buttimer
, said there is a 'compelling case' for the commission to directly employ the 10 full-time and 20 part-time professional broadcast workers providing the coverage, 'given the extremely concerning working conditions and pay issues'.
They allege 'precarious and uncertain working hours, withdrawal of pay during Oireachtas recess periods – including Christmas – lack of pension entitlements, pay that is significantly below the industry norm, lack of any retainer payment and a culture of criticism from management'.
'These workers are left to rely on social welfare for periods when the Oireachtas is not in session.'
READ MORE
The letter also says 'it is difficult to see what a contract with a private company adds to the services they provide given that all the skilled work is carried out by these workers and their equipment is provided by the Oireachtas itself'.
The first five-year contract was issued in 2011 for €7 million. TDs and senators are attempting to establish the current value of the contract 'and how this money is spent'.
Pi Communications, the current contractor, which provides a similar service to the
Northern Ireland Assembly
, has said the contract operates on a 'pay per public minute model'. Based on the 2011 contract, this meant €250 an hour for each hour of broadcast, as well as an overall contract fee.
The employees broadcast the live feeds of the Dáil, Seanad and committees. They also oversee the archiving of all feeds.
The company said the workers have a guaranteed fixed amount of work 'each full sitting week', with 'certainty of income for their contracted work'.
However, one employee, who did not want to be named, said most of the employees are on 'casual part-time contracts' with 'only one day a week guaranteed, which is very precarious'. Some workers have no guaranteed days and are only brought in occasionally, the employee said.
In response, Pi Communications said: 'We are surprised and disappointed that some who have commented on our operations did not first fact-check the accuracy and veracity of ill-founded claims.'
The company said the employees earn substantially more than the national living wage, with attractive bonus arrangements and receive paid leave and sick leave.
Employees 'are free to work on other projects or for other employers, as is the norm in our industry'. It said salaries are regularly benchmarked and commensurate with roles, skills, experience and responsibilities.
Social Democrats TD Liam Quaide, who co-ordinated the TDs. and senators' letter, said public representatives question 'the value for money' the contract provides. They believe it would be cheaper for the Oireachtas to pay the workers directly. He said the 'only overheads in the contract would seem to be the employees' pay', as the equipment is supplied by the Oireachtas.
The issue has been referred to the Public Accounts Committee and to the Oireachtas Media Committee.
The letter says the contract is due for renewal this year. It adds that any review should include an in-depth investigation into the issues raised by the broadcast workers, which they have previously attempted to resolve through industrial relations mechanisms.
Included in the group of 125 calling for the review is Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald, Labour leader Ivana Bacik, Social Democrats acting leader Cian O'Callaghan, and former journalists Evanne Ní Chuilinn (Fine Gael) and Alison Comyn (Fianna Fáil), both of whom are senators.
The Houses of the Oireachtas Commission has said the workers and Pi Communications are in dialogue at the Workplace Relations Commission and it would not be appropriate 'to undermine the industrial relations process'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
33 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Simon Harris tells US ambassador ‘landing zone' can be found to avert trade war
Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris discussed trade issues on Monday with the new US ambassador to Dublin, Ed Walsh, following President Donald Trump 's threat at the weekend to impose 30 per cent tariffs on EU exports to the US. At the scheduled meeting, Mr Harris told the ambassador that he believed there was a 'landing zone' for an agreement between the two sides that would avoid the threatened tariffs on August 1st. Mr Harris also outlined Ireland's concerns for the pharmaceutical sector, which is the subject of an investigation by the US authorities that could lead to further trade measures by Washington. Mr Harris explained how this was a 'significant concern for Ireland', officials said. The two men also discussed the situation in the Middle East and the need for a ceasefire. When the Occupied Territories Bill was raised by the ambassador, the Tánaiste explained the process that the Bill is going through, officials said. READ MORE The Bill, and the Irish Government's wider response to the situation in Gaza, has been the subject of significant criticism in Washington. The previous US ambassador, Claire Cronin, made representations to Dublin about the Bill, which would ban – as currently drafted – the import of goods produced in the occupied Palestinian territories. Pro-Israeli organisations have been lobbying against the Bill in Washington, with an analysis supplied by one group to the Irish Government claiming it would affect US companies operating in Ireland. Commenting on the Bill recently, the US senator Jim Risch, who is chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said it showed Ireland was on a 'hateful, anti-Semitic path that will only lead to self-inflicted economic suffering'. Mr Harris and Mr Walsh also discussed in Ukraine, Northern Ireland, Ireland's J1 visa programme and the upcoming college (American) football and NFL games taking place in Ireland later this year, officials said.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
State `well positioned' despite uncertain markets, NTMA says
The State is 'well positioned against the backdrop of uncertain markets' even though the Ireland still has debt of more than €200 billion and there is no place for complacency, National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) chief executive Frank O'Connor said as the agency published its latest annual report. 'There is a strong market awareness of the buffers we have in place through our funding and debt management strategy,' said Mr O'Connor. 'The strength of our public finances coupled with the long weighted average maturity of our debt, means we expect to have relatively low borrowing requirements in the short to medium term.' Mr O'Connor said that at the end of 2024 general Government debt was at €218 billion – almost €20 billion below the post pandemic peak. The agency has raised €5.25 billion so far this year in the bond market, close to the bottom end of its €6 billion-€10 billion fundraising target. It had over €30 billion in cash and liquid assets at the half year point, reducing the requirement for borrowing in the coming year, amid heightened global economic uncertainty as a result of the Trump administration trade policies and heightened geopolitical tension in the Middle East. READ MORE US President Donald Trump announced on Friday that he planned to introduce a 30 per cent tariff on goods coming from the EU at the beginning of August. However, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said at the NTMA briefing that it is still possible for Brussels and Washington to reach an agreement on trade by that time. 'We are now entering into a crucial final phase of this engagement', he said. [ Opens in new window ] The State's ratio of debt to modified gross national income-star (GNI*) stood at just below 70 per cent at the end of last year – down from about 160 per cent in 2012 and approximately 100 per cent in 2021. Mr O'Connor said Ireland was also benefiting from locking in low interest rates in previous years. He said debt interest cost €3.2 billion in 2024 which was almost 60 per cent lower than its peak over a decade ago. 'Sentiment towards Ireland is positive, as demonstrated by robust ongoing demand for our debt and a positive trend of upgrades from ratings agencies', he said. The State's creditworthiness is rated AA by Moody's, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch, the world's three main debt ratings agencies. The Juggle: the issues facing women with young children when balancing childcare and their careers Listen | 44:30 Two new sovereign wealth funds set up last year to capture and invest windfall tax revenues are set to have about €16 billion on their books between them by the end of the year, according to Mr O'Connor. Mr O'Connor said that NTMA will have to 'look hard' at its systems and protocols after it was discovered in recent days a €5 million fraud had been perpetrated against it . The payment was made to a third party at a time when there was a financial drawdown or capital call anticipated, involving one investee company of the NTMA-managed Ireland Strategic Investment Fund (Isif) There had previously been a legitimate payment to the company. The €5 million fraud was 'an extremely serious matter' for the agency, he said, adding that once the issue was discovered last week, the NTMA immediately made a report to the Garda, the Department of Finance and other relevant authorities. He said there was no suggestion that there had been an IT breach or any threat to the IT systems in the NTMA.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
NTMA ‘will look hard' at its systems and protocols after €5m fraud
The National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) has said it will have to 'look hard' at its systems and protocols after it was discovered in recent days a €5 million fraud had been perpetrated against it . NTMA chief executive Frank O'Connor on Monday said the payment was made to a third party at a time when there was a financial drawdown or capital call anticipated, involving one investee company of the Ireland Strategic Investment Fund. There had previously been a legitimate payment to the company. Speaking at the unveiling of the NTMA's annual report for 2024, he said the €5 million fraud was 'an extremely serious matter' for the agency. READ MORE He said there was no suggestion that there had been an IT breach or any threat to the IT systems in the NTMA. Mr O'Connor said when the issue was discovered, the NTMA immediately made a report to the Garda, the Department of Finance and other relevant authorities. 'It won't surprise you that our immediate focus is on recovery and investigating the matter fully', he said. Mr O'Connor said that having approved an investment, there could be several capital calls or drawdowns of money. 'We will have to look hard at our systems and our own protocols to ensure was there anything we could have spotted (or) any shortcomings and the investigation will (look) at that,' he said. Mr O'Connor said a capital call was not just a phone call. He said it involved a process that would have to be engaged in and that would lead to the withdrawal of funds. He said there was no suggestion that the fraud could have been perpetrated on the basis of inside information. 'Obviously a fraudulent actor may have gathered enough (information) outside of the NTMA that may have led to it. I can't really get into any more detail at this stage and obviously we will investigate the matter fully.' Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe backed management at the NTMA. He said the €5 million fraud was 'regrettable, but extremely rare'. 'In my many years of engagement with the National Treasury Management Agency, I have seen at the first hand how seriously they take all matters with regard to security, and the ongoing and huge efforts that are made to protect the money of the taxpayer of Ireland,' he said. 'I have seen at first hand the investments and care they make to protect their systems and to protect the money of our country. I know that every effort will be made to investigate, to review and to follow up on all of the circumstances around this incident.'
