BD120,000 claim on fake property sale dismissed
She had also demanded BD7,000 in rent for the time he held onto the property, claiming he used a power of attorney she had signed to sell it behind her back.
The High Civil Court dismissed the case after hearing from witnesses, sifting through documents and reviewing rulings from the Sharia court.
Among those who gave evidence was their own mother, who had been listed as the buyer.
Authority
The row began when the woman granted her brother sweeping authority to manage a property she had received as a gift from their mother.
The document gave him the right to sell it to himself or someone else.
He chose the latter and sold it to their mother, the same person who had owned it to begin with. She then gifted it back to him.
Arrangement
The woman argued that her brother used the arrangement to walk away with the money. He said it was just a paper transaction. The court took his side.
His lawyer, AbdulAtheem Hubail, said the sale was purely procedural, a way to transfer ownership without any money changing hands.
Payment
He presented Sharia court rulings backing the claim that the power of attorney had been issued to pass the property back to their mother without payment.
The mother confirmed this in court. She said she had not paid a dinar and the sale was just for show. The real trouble, she said, came from family disputes over who should get what.
Gift
The civil court also noted that the sister had already tried and failed to undo the mother's later gift to her brother in religious court.
That challenge was rejected after the Sharia court confirmed the gift was valid.
With no evidence the brother had received any money, the civil court found there was no case to answer.
The claim was dismissed and the woman was ordered to cover the costs.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Tribune
2 days ago
- Daily Tribune
Mediator to repay BD2,000 in friends' dispute
A mediator trusted to resolve a money row between two mates has been ordered by the Civil Court to return BD2,000 he kept for himself. The dispute began when one friend owed BD4,000 to another. He attempted to pay half, but the creditor insisted on full repayment, and the pair disagreed about the deadline. To settle the matter, the debtor handed BD2,000 to a third friend, expecting this intermediary to deliver the money and put an end to the quarrel. Requests Instead, the trusted middleman kept the sum and refused to return it, despite repeated requests. With the situation at a standstill, the claimant and debtor confronted the mediator directly. The debtor stated clearly he wanted the funds passed on. The mediator agreed, promising to withdraw and deliver the money the next Sunday
Daily Tribune
2 days ago
- Daily Tribune
Woman jailed for forcing maid into unpaid labour and seizing passport
A woman has been jailed for three years and fined BD3,000 after forcing a young Asian domestic worker into unpaid labour and confiscating her passport. The court also ordered her to pay for the victim's return to her home country. The High Criminal Court of Appeal upheld the earlier ruling, which found the woman guilty of running an unlicensed labour arrangement and exploiting the worker for a full year. Visit visa The 25-year-old victim had arrived in Bahrain on a visit visa with the hope of securing work as a housemaid for BD120 a month. She was taken in by the accused, made to sleep on the kitchen floor and passed from one household to another. She worked for nine families in total without receiving her wages after the first two months. Problem The accused withheld BD800 and kept the victim's passport, claiming there was a problem with the document whenever it was requested. The woman told the court she was moved between homes while the accused collected her wages. She was only paid BD200 in total. When one of the families offered to sponsor her legally, the accused refused to hand over the passport. Instead, she continued to send the woman elsewhere and pocketed the income. An Interior Ministry officer testified that his enquiries pointed to forced labour. The victim had worked for several families without a proper licence.
Daily Tribune
2 days ago
- Daily Tribune
Hotel to repay BD4,140 after failing to deliver paid services
TDT | Manama After paying BD25,000 for paperwork that never arrived, two clients have won just BD4,140 from one of Bahrain's best-known hotels in a ruling by the High Court of Appeal. The hotel had agreed to arrange guarantor permits and temporary residency documentation. While the full fee was paid upfront, the services were not fully delivered. Represented by lawyer Essam Al Tayyib, the clients took legal action to recover the value of what was left undone. A lower court threw out their claim but the Appeal Court reversed that decision after Al Tayyib submitted a letter signed by the hotel's own representative admitting the debt and proposing a partial settlement. Judges treated this as an implied acknowledgement of both the contract and the amount owed. Al Tayyib argued the initial ruling failed to take key evidence into account. He referred to the letter dated 11 August 2024 which the hotel had never denied. Under Bahraini law, silence on such a document adds weight to its content.
