California families of girl athletes speak out as state changes championship amid rules transgender drama
Amid a national controversy involving a trans athlete competing in the girls' category, the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) announced a series of sweeping rule changes in the days leading up to the event to accommodate female competitors.
But now multiple families of girls who have already been displaced by a trans athlete at previous meets have spoken out against the federation, expressing dissatisfaction with the changes.
On Tuesday, the CIF announced it would expand the size of the championship competition pool and inviting "biological female" athletes who missed out on making the title meet by one spot due to a trans athlete finishing ahead of them in last week's qualifying round.
Then on Wednesday, the federation announced it would also recognize female athletes on the medal podium if a girl who misses out on a medal finish does so because they came behind a trans athlete.
Crean Lutheran track and field star Reese Hogan finished in second place to trans athlete AB Hernandez of Jurupa Valley High School in the triple jump at the Southern Sectional final on May 17. Then, on the medal podium, after Hernandez stepped off, Hogan stepped up to the first-place spot for a photo-op to a roaring applause. The stunt went viral as Hogan was praised by women's sports rights activists as a heroine.
But CIF's latest rule changes won't be giving Hogan the first-place medal for that event.
Hogan's family provided a statement from her to Fox News Digital that read, "The recent CIF rule changes clearly acknowledge a misstep on their part. However, what they've proposed falls short of what we truly need for all girls across all sports. I placed second in CIF, and I know that if I hadn't been competing against a boy, I would have claimed the top spot on the podium."
"Unfortunately, we can't revisit that moment to rectify this injustice. This issue transcends a single meet, sport, or individual; it's fundamentally about the rights of all females to compete fairly among themselves. We deserve that opportunity, and we will continue to advocate for it."
Hogan has previously told Fox News Digital she finds the situation involving Hernandez "sad."
"It's just kind of sad just watching. He's obviously a really talented athlete, we've all seen him jump and stuff, and I wish him the best of luck, but in a boys' division," Hogan previously told Fox News Digital about competing against the athlete. "It's pretty obvious the certain advantages that he has, and it's obviously just sad as a woman to watch that."
Meanwhile, the family of Hogan's Crean Lutheran teammate, Olivia Viola, also isn't satisfied with the rule changes.
"While we are grateful that a few female athletes will regain their ability to compete at states and females will earn their rightful titles at this weekends competition, unfortunately CIFs trial program doesn't actually fix anything. Women are still being forced to compete against biological males. The title IX civil rights of our daughters, sisters, friends and teammates are still being violated," Viola's family said in a statement to Fox News Digital.
"Unfortunately, with each step our state leaders take, comes the realization that California really has no intention of protecting our girls in the ways that are necessary. The pilot program essentially admits that allowing biological males to compete in the female category was a mistake. Now it's time for full course correction. There is a fundamental truth here that must be upheld. Separating competitive athletics into two XX-XY gender categories must be a non-negotiable."
President Donald Trump weighed in on the situation when he sent a Truth Social post on Tuesday morning, warning the state and Gov. Gavin Newsom of potential funding cuts and orders to local authorities to prevent a trans athlete from competing in the girls' category on Saturday. The first rule change came just hours after Trump's post.
The Department of Justice announced it would launch an investigation into the CIF and California Attorney General Rob Bonta over the state's law that allows biologically male trans athletes to compete with girls and women on Wednesday. The second rule change took place shortly after that announcement.
On Tuesday, the family of another girls' track star who has been displaced by Hernandez in the track and field postseason, Katie McGuinness of La Canada High School, told Fox News Digital they are grateful for Trump's intervention.
"We are grateful that President Trump is fighting for female athletes and giving them a fair shot to compete on a level playing field. CIF's 'solution' to this situation, which allows additional girls to compete at the state championship who otherwise didn't qualify because the transgender athlete took their spot, isn't good enough – it's still an unfair competition and an injustice to the girls competing," the family said in a statement.
"Allowing biological males to compete in women's sports is unfair, unjust and defies common sense," the family added.
Katie previously spoke out against CIF for allowing the situation to get this far in an interview on Fox News' "America Reports" last week.
"I have nothing against this athlete as a person, and I have nothing against the trans community," McGuinness said. "My message today is really specifically to CIF and for them to act quickly and in a timely manner because this is a really time-sensitive issue."
Follow Fox News Digital's sports coverage on X, and subscribe to the Fox News Sports Huddle newsletter.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
3 minutes ago
- New York Times
A poignant reminder in Trinity Rodman's return. Plus: Blockbuster NWSL transfer
Full Time Newsletter ⚽| This is The Athletic's weekly women's soccer newsletter. Sign up here to receive Full Time directly in your inbox. Just when we thought things would slow down, women's soccer continued to deliver. Today: 😮 A blockbuster NWSL transfer 🥹 Rodman's emotional return 🤯 A scoreline you have to see to believe Welcome to Full Time! Let's rewind to Friday first: Blockbuster in Kansas City Even beyond the transfer funds exchanged, which set a new NWSL record, Ally Sentnor's move to the Kansas City Current from Utah is a bona fide blockbuster. The 21-year-old is among the brightest rising stars on the USWNT, able to score audacious goals and help teams move upfield with determination. Sentnor's move also serves as an incidental referendum on the former NWSL Draft. The league abolished its rookie draft ahead of the 2025 season, with Sentnor being the final No. 1 pick. Eighteen months later, she's already on to another club. This past offseason, college players had an open market to assess their fit and how quickly they'd get first-team minutes rather than having their club careers kick off without control over their destination. Advertisement While Sentnor became the instant face of the Royals, a player with her ambition may have preferred to end up with a more stable club situation and an immediate path to annual contention — a team like Kansas City. — Jeff Rueter Two key returns to the pitch I promise the back to school metaphor won't overstay its welcome in describing the NWSL's return to play after the long summer break. But between the slew of drowsy ties — four to be exact, between Chicago and Gotham, North Carolina and San Diego, Bay and Houston, and Orlando and Utah — and joyful returns of players we haven't seen on the pitch in a while, the parallels were too strong to ignore. Let's start with Trinity Rodman's epic and emotional first minutes in almost four months, which happened while the Washington Spirit were hunting for a vibe-restoring home dub against the Portland Thorns yesterday. brb watching this trinity rodman goal on repeat 🔁 — National Women's Soccer League (@NWSL) August 3, 2025 Farther down the East Coast was another happy-cry moment: The return of Orlando Pride's Simone Charley, who hasn't played in two years after injuring her Achilles tendon on both legs, one in 2023 and one in 2024. She and Brazilian international Luana were removed from the Season-Ending Injury list over the weekend, and Charley immediately went into Impact Player Beast Mode when she subbed on in the 79th minute vs. Utah yesterday, nearly scoring a game winner. — Tamerra Griffin Rodman's return was the story of the NWSL this weekend, and it's crucial for a lot of reasons. Most importantly, of course, is Rodman herself. The 23-year-old clearly went through a very emotional journey over the past few months, getting her body and mind right, grappling not just with recovering from this lingering back injury but understanding how to approach the game as a different player. Her quotes before the match and her reaction after scoring all showed the depth of the situation. It wasn't a new side to Rodman, as we all knew how seriously she takes this sport and the joy she finds in it, but those emotions were bigger than just her. Advertisement She didn't shy away from them either, not on the field or on national TV. We should celebrate Rodman for being willing to be that vulnerable upon her return. We shouldn't have to remind people that these players are human, but a moment like this carries its own power. From the NWSL point of view, Rodman's return and goal must have earned at least a handful of sighs of relief around the front office. Even as she works to regain full fitness, it's a narrative that has already broken out of the NWSL sphere. Rodman single-handedly guaranteed more coverage coming out of the summer break, even with all the storylines around the international players featured at the Euros, WAFCON and Copa America. Rodman's star power is currently the North Star for the NWSL, driving eyeballs, ratings, ticket sales, merchandise sales … you name it. Ahead of the Spirit's win over Portland, Rodman promised: 'I'm still gonna be Trin.' She might have made some adjustments to her game, but Sunday's goal proved that even with those changes, she's still the exact same force on the field. Unbelievable Copa final delivers Rodman's return may have been the NWSL story of the weekend, but Saturday's Copa América Femenina championship was the match of the summer — an iconic display of the best of South American women's football. After a relentless 120 minutes and seven rounds of penalty kicks, Brazil overcame Colombia to lift its ninth Copa América title, sealing their place once again as the best team on the continent. The final score: Colombia 4 (4) – Brazil. 4 (5). Yes, you read that right. The most iconic moments came from 39-year-old Pride star Marta, with the Brazilian legend saving her team in the final minute of stoppage time with a beautiful goal that sent the final into extra time: MARTA EQUALIZES IN STOPPAGE TIME 🤯 THE LEGEND HERSELF KEEPS BRAZIL ALIVE IN THE 2025 COPA AMÉRICA FEMENINA FINAL!!!! 🇧🇷 — FOX Soccer (@FOXSoccer) August 2, 2025 Then, another Marta goal in extra time upped the stakes, only for Colombia and Spirit midfielder Leicy Santos to respond by scoring off a free kick in the 115th minute, pushing the game into a tense round of penalties. No matter if they played for Colombia or Brazil, the nine NWSL players who contributed to this historic finale will soon return to the league as heroes. There was Marta, Santos and Orlando's Angelina, but also Kansas City's Lorena, Gotham's Gabi Portilho, Louisville's Ary Borges and Angela Baron, San Diego's Daniela Arias and Utah's Ana Maria Guzman. They'll be offered time off, but it's possible we'll see them sooner than we'd expect (just ask Euros winner and Gotham defender Jess Carter). Advertisement This tournament has us begging for more South American women's football magic. Sure, there were some valuable lessons learned. But we now have some exciting things on the horizon, like Conmebol's inaugural Nations League competition in October. This will serve as the qualifying route for South America's first World Cup, coming to Brazil in 2027. — Melanie Anzidei 🎧 More on this game on the latest episode of the 'Full Time' podcast. NWSL pressing to get fans in seats As the NWSL returns from a midseason break that coincided with a summer packed with international women's tournaments, clubs across the league are rolling out aggressive strategies to win fans back and restore momentum heading into the fall. With nearly 40 NWSL players starring in global competitions, teams are using that star power to fuel renewed interest at home. Washington is hitting the market with free ticket giveaways for first-time attendees. Gotham is capitalizing on Euro buzz by opening its upper bowl, offering player-themed promos, and piloting a NYC-area bus to its stadium. On the West Coast, Bay FC is chasing attendance records by relocating their game against the Spirit on Aug. 23 to an iconic MLB venue, Oracle Park, while North Carolina leans into summer heat with cooling stations and in-stadium credits. The playbook is clear: marquee matchups, theme nights, creative promotions and community engagement are the most effective ways to reignite fan enthusiasm post-break. — Asli Pelit The NWSL is going with the rivalry weekend theme, though there are truly only three real rivalry games going on this weekend. All three should be a) fun to watch as a neutral, b) important for the standings and c) hopefully full of NWSL Chaos. Try streaming these games for free on Fubo. How did she do that?!: Yeah, we're still not over Lucy Bronze playing through the Euros with a broken tibia. Sarah Shephard considers how it was done, and the risks of playing with a major injury. Good news for Boston: There's no deal in place yet, but there's potential for the Connecticut Sun to make a move up to Boston if the WNBA approves Steve Pagliuca's offer for the team. Pro women's soccer, basketball and hockey (and more) all in Boston within a couple of years? Stay tuned. 📫 Love Full Time? These stories can also be found on Yahoo's women's sports hub, in partnership with The Athletic. Also, check out our other newsletters. Streaming links in this article are provided by partners of The Athletic. Restrictions may apply. The Athletic maintains full editorial independence. Partners have no control over or input into the reporting or editing process and do not review stories before publication.
New York Times
3 minutes ago
- New York Times
Yankees continue recent slide, get walked off by Rangers in extra innings
ARLINGTON, Texas — The New York Yankees landed in Texas, fired up the grill and started BBQ-ing their own playoff hopes. After closer Devin Williams blew the save in the ninth inning, the Rangers walked the Yankees off in the 10th inning on Josh Jung's three-run, two-out blast to left-center field for a 8-5 defeat. Advertisement It happened right after pitching coach Matt Blake visited the mound and reliever Jake Bird intentionally walked Wyatt Langford. Jung blasted a 1-1 sinker from Bird that was middle-in. The homer was a no-doubter. It also came after an embarrassing weekend in which the Miami Marlins swept the Yankees as New York made awful mistakes in each loss. The Yankees are 0-4 since Thursday's trade deadline, when they were just about universally praised for the flurry of deals they made. WALK-OFF BOMB FROM THE JUNGSTER! #AllForTX — Texas Rangers (@Rangers) August 5, 2025 On Monday, the drama for the Yankees started when pinch hitter Joc Pederson crushed a solo homer off Williams to tie it 5-5 with two outs in the ninth. Pederson hammered a hanging changeup well into the seats in right field, sending the crowd at Globe Life Field into a frenzy. It was Williams' second blown save in as many chances. He hadn't pitched since Wednesday. In the top of the 10th, the Yankees squandered a chance to bring home the extra-innings runner when Austin Wells hit into an inning-ending double play. They started the day in third place in the American League East and 4 1/2 games back of the first-place Toronto Blue Jays. They had been holding on to the second wild-card position by just a half-game.
New York Times
3 minutes ago
- New York Times
For one night, Jesús Sánchez is the face of the Astros' trade deadline
MIAMI — Caught within Carlos Correa mania and a franchise's reunion with one of its icons is Jesús Sánchez. The acquisition of the ex-Marlins outfielder came together within minutes of Correa agreeing to waive his no-trade clause, rendering the 27-year-old outfielder a footnote of the Houston Astros' frenzied trade deadline. Advertisement Before it began, Sánchez served as an archetype for what the Astros desired. He hits left-handed, ravages right-handed pitching and can play all three outfield positions, ideal for an imbalanced roster that's missing its starting center fielder and witnessing a regression from the rookie playing right. Sánchez fixes all of those flaws. If he and utility infielder Ramón Urías were the extent of Houston's offensive acquisitions, few would've fretted. Correa's availability changed the calculus and cemented him as the obvious face of Houston's deadline. At loanDepot Park, that title belongs to Sánchez. Hovering around .500 prevented Marlins president of baseball operations Peter Bendix from orchestrating a total selloff. Edward Cabrera and Kyle Stowers are still around. So is Sandy Alcantara, despite serious interest from a slew of teams, including the Astros. Sánchez is the lone exception. Fate brought him back to the ballpark four days after he departed. A sparse crowd of 10,827 showered him with a nice ovation before his first at-bat and during a video tribute between the first and second inning. Sánchez flashed the smile that's already become contagious inside the Astros' clubhouse. 'Such a great guy. Not a bad bone in his body,' shortstop Jeremy Peña said after Houston's 8-2 win. 'He's so happy. Always great energy. I admire that about him.' Houston surrendered two prospects and a major-league starter with six years of control for Sánchez's services, signaling how high he sat on the Astros' priority list. On the first day of Sánchez's tenure, manager Joe Espada promised to 'hit him in the middle of the lineup.' He has hit second or third in each of the four games since. 'He's asking a ton of questions,' Espada said. 'He wants to know how we've done it here for so many years. You want to be part of something special, a winning culture, and we've been able to do that for a long time.' On Monday, the roles reversed. Houston's advance scouting meeting began at 4 p.m. Sánchez stood before his new teammates and offered insights into the Marlins' tendencies. Among the topics: how best to attack Alcantara, a portrait of inconsistency in his first season back from Tommy John surgery, but still armed with some of the sport's nastiest stuff. Advertisement 'Seeing Alcantara made me really happy, very happy to see him,' Sánchez said through an interpreter. 'Very excited to see him. Facing him is a lot of fun.' Just a select few can make such a claim. Now, count Sánchez among them. His ringing double during the fourth inning catalyzed a five-run frame from a lineup that sorely needed it. Houston scored six runs and had nine hits against Alcantara. None were struck harder than the 112.2 mph missile Sánchez delivered against Alcantara's first-pitch curveball. If not for a diving play from center fielder Jakob Marsee in the fifth, Sánchez would've had his second multi-hit game in an Astros uniform. 'Honestly, it feels great to be here,' Sánchez said. 'With this group, it's really easy to feel at home. There's a lot of Hispanic players here and we understand each other real well. It just feels good to be here.' Such is the standard for so many that enter Houston's clubhouse. The culture inside of it is unquantifiable, but this season has supplied the closest thing to tangible proof of its existence. New faces have shuttled in and out amid a rash of injuries. All of them have, in some form, contributed to a club that is 13 games over .500. Sánchez is here to offer stability. He will play against almost all right-handed starting pitchers and afford balance that's been missing since Yordan Alvarez fractured his hand. Sánchez does not strike out, nor does he get cheated on many of the swings he takes. His average bat speed of 75.7 mph is in the 93rd percentile of all major-league hitters. His 92.2 mph average exit velocity is in the 88th. Sánchez's defensive metrics are above-average, even if the first four games of his Astros tenure may not reflect it. He has started thrice in left field — the spot in which he is least experienced — and had some adventurous results. Advertisement Overrunning a fly ball in the cramped left-field corner of Fenway Park, forgetting to hit the cutoff man or taking circuitous outfield routes aren't absolute causes for alarm. Aggressive mistakes are always preferred over being afraid of failure. Trying to impress a new team can cause some overcompensation, though Espada sought to squash that upon Sánchez's arrival. When the two men first met, Espada encouraged him to 'play without pressure.' Too many stars are on this team for Sánchez to feel he must be something superhuman. 'With this team, the confidence that this team has is very key, super important,' Sánchez said. 'Confidence is everything you need with this team.'
