Department objected to Government's ‘housing tsar' amid concerns over pay and recruitment
Department of Public Expenditure
sought to block the approval by
Cabinet
of the so-called '
housing tsar
' in April, new internal records show.
The Government department responsible for State spending cited concerns about the lack of a business case for the role, the implications for wider public pay policy and concerns about the process for the selection of the preferred candidate,
Brendan McDonagh
, the chief executive of Nama.
Mr McDonagh withdrew from consideration for the role after political concerns were raised about the possibility that he might retain his €430,000 salary at Nama in the new job, and public disagreements between Coalition partners Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael over the issue.
The Government intends to proceed with establishing the role to head a new 'Housing Activation Office', which is being created in a bid to speed up the building of homes to ease the housing crisis.
READ MORE
But it is understood objections from the Department of Public Expenditure over the role have not yet been addressed.
[
Nama's Brendan McDonagh says he could have added 'value' to new housing delivery agency
Opens in new window
]
The proposal is not yet ready to be signed off at a meeting of the Cabinet housing committee scheduled for today, though senior sources expect that possible names for the post will be discussed by the leaders of the Government parties soon, possibly next week.
Newly released emails between senior officials in the Department of Public Expenditure ('DPer') and the Department of Housing – issued under the Freedom of Information Act – reveals concerns about the role.
DPer officials told their counterparts in housing on Friday, April 25th that the memo relating to the role was 'not in position to go to Government' the following week.
'We have only got sight of the draft today and we need time to properly consider a number of elements, particularly around the organisation structure,' the spending department told them.
DPer complained that its pay policy division had not received a request to sanction the post describe this as 'the usual process'.
'There seems to have been no engagement with them on this and the wider pay policy implications,' the officials said.
There was, the department said, no business case made; the pay rate was not disclosed; there were 'unclear' references to 'contracted expertise' for staff; and no background material was supplied on the recruitment process 'that appears to have been undertaken for the selection of the appointee'.
Earlier, Eoin Dorgan, an assistant secretary at the Department of Public Expenditure, had written to the Department of Housing warning that several issues would have to be considered before the memo could go to Government.
They included the functions and objectives of the HAO, its Exchequer implications, pay and conditions for the chief executive and wider staff and the precedents established by them and how the new office would interact with 'wider infrastructure projects and the National Development Plan'.
Sources with knowledge of the issues raised said DPer's objections have not fully been addressed yet, though it is expected that the office, with a new chief executive, will be established in the coming weeks.
In response to questions, the Department of Public Expenditure said it was continuing to engage with the Department of Housing 'to finalise the establishment of the new office and its operations and also in relation to the arrangements for the CEO of the HAO as appropriate'.
Last week, the most senior civil servant in the Department of Housing Graham Doyle
told a property conference he did not think a 'housing tsar'
was necessary. The department later said in a statement that his remarks reflected his opposition to the term 'tsar' rather than the role.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
China Sichuan to Go takeaway review: The aromatic duck alone is worth the trip
What's on offer? China Sichuan originally did takeaway more than 25 years ago, back when it was run by Kevin Hui's parents on Kilmacud Road in Stillorgan , Co Dublin. During Covid, Kevin briefly revived a collection service out of Whelehan's Wines in Loughlinstown, but that ended when the main restaurant reopened. Still, demand for top-tier Chinese takeaway never went away. China Sichuan to Go is the response: a spin-off focused on lunch and early evening orders, serving a tight menu of dishes from the mothership – same technique, less formality. It opens from 8am on weekdays with coffee and pastries, and has a small retail section selling house-made sauces, dried noodles and a few well-chosen wines. What did we order? Wonton dumpling soup, crispy vegetarian dumplings, Sichuan aromatic duck, steamed rice, Chongqing chicken and Mapo tofu. How was the service? You order online, choose a collection time and show up. Ours was ready on the dot, piping hot and packed properly – no leaks, no waiting. READ MORE China Sichuan to Go has a small retail section within the takeaway Was the food nice? The wonton dumpling soup is a strong start: a clear broth with bok choi, spring onions, and dumplings stuffed with seasoned chicken and pork – light but satisfying. The crispy vegetarian dumplings are even better: golden, delicately spiced and filled with chopped cabbage and carrot. The Sichuan aromatic duck is the star of the show. Two generous Silverhill duck breasts are served sliced, with a crunchy outside coating while staying juicy inside. It comes in a compartmentalised container, with cucumber, spring onion, a mellow plum sauce and two packs of pancakes to wrap it all up. The duck alone could feed two. Chongqing chicken is spicy, salty and crunchy, a pile of deep-fried chicken pieces tossed with dried chillies, spring onions, cabbage and a scattering of cashew nuts. It's like a Sichuan version of popcorn chicken. The Mapo tofu is also good. Cubes of soft tofu in a punchy, oily sauce of fermented bean paste, dried chilli and Sichuan peppercorns. It's fiery but not overwhelming, and great with steamed rice. What about the packaging? Everything is packed into a large paper bag. Plastic containers – recyclable but not ideal – are used for the main dishes, and the rice is in a cardboard container. What did it cost? €84.40 for dinner for three people: Wonton dumpling soup, €8.95; crispy vegetarian dumplings, €10.95; Sichuan aromatic duck, €27; Chong Qing chicken with steamed rice, €22; Mapo tofu, with steamed rice, €15.50. Where does it deliver? Takeaway only, open Mon-Fri, 8am-9pm; Sat-Sun, 3pm-9.30pm. Delivery is planned for September. Would I order it again? Yes. The duck alone is worth the trip. Everything else was well made and full of flavour.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Matt Cooper glugging wine and playing cards on air: who'd have thought?
For all his strengths as a current-affairs broadcaster , whooping it up isn't a characteristic one normally associates with Matt Cooper . Yet there he is, glugging wine and playing cards during Tuesday's edition of The Last Word (Today FM, weekdays). Fans of Cooper's steady style need not fret, however: he hasn't gone full gonzo. In fact, his items on wine tasting and tarot reading only underline his sensibly inquisitive instincts, even if he comes across as slightly more unbuttoned than usual. Cooper certainly sounds as if he's enjoying himself when the sommelier (and regular guest) Brigid O'Hora arrives with a selection of organic and biodynamic wines to taste. 'For me anyway,' the host clarifies, a tad too smugly. While asking about these winemaking methods, Cooper reveals himself to be something of an oenophile, talking confidently about the pepper flavours of an Austrian bottle. 'Look at you, you are a natural,' O'Hora replies, clearly impressed. The presenter sounds less comfortable as the novelist Noëlle Harrison outlines the background to her latest book, The Tarot Reader of Versailles, written under the pen name Anya Bergman. Harrison explains how the cards, which seemingly originated as a storytelling game in Renaissance Italy, act as 'tools of support and self-awareness', adding that reading Cooper's tarot cards would be 'a blueprint of your subconscious'. The inherently sceptical host occasionally sounds facetious – 'Is it the summoning of spirits beyond the grave?' – but for the most part is curious about his guest's esoteric interests, to the listener's benefit. READ MORE Although Cooper may not possess the temperament of a fortune teller, he's happy to read the runes on the future of the Coalition. Following the suggestion by Minister for Higher Education James Lawless , of Fianna Fáil, that third-level registration fees could go back up to €3,000 a year, the host is gleeful as he discusses the resultant tensions between the Government parties. 'This shouldn't have come as a surprise to Fine Gael,' Cooper crows. 'James Lawless said as much to us months ago on this programme.' His interview with Fine Gael's education spokesperson, Maeve O'Connell, does little to cool the simmering row as she restates her party's commitment to reducing student fees. 'The reality is if the fees go up,' the deputy reiterates, 'that is not what anyone would have expected from a commitment in the programme for government.' As this is the same programme promising an increase in homebuilding, it mightn't be that big a surprise, a point the host makes in roundabout fashion: 'What I'm hearing from a lot of people is that a much bigger issue is the cost of student accommodation, which is a multiple of their fees each year.' O'Connell sidesteps addressing this inconvenient observation, but as Cooper's quietly lethal approach indicates, the omens for Government harmony don't look promising. It all depends where the cards fall. Elsewhere, Today with Claire Byrne (RTÉ Radio 1, weekdays) covers the news that the former swimming coach George Gibney has been arrested in the United States on foot of a Garda extradition request for alleged historical child sex-abuse offences. This move has largely been prompted by fresh allegations made against the ex-Olympic coach on the BBC podcast Where Is George Gibney? , as Byrne notes when she talks to Mark Horgan, the podcast's presenter and producer. Horgan calls the news 'hugely significant' and commends the resilience of those survivors who spoke of the abuse they suffered, while choosing his words carefully, conscious of the legal proceedings afoot. But aside from the vile acts Gibney is accused of, the interview is interesting in its insights on the way podcasts have not only changed how audio content is consumed but also enabled it to yield real-world effects. 'This is something that's really remarkable about the medium,' says Horgan. The open-ended format of the series meant that survivors affected by early episodes could contact both the producers and the police. 'It wasn't something we were trying to turn around quickly, with short soundbites,' Horgan says, 'Obviously with journalism it's really difficult to get the opportunity to do that, but we were afforded that time.' As changes wrought by online platforms are often presented as harbingers of doom, it's an encouraging aspect, even if the podcast's contents are harrowing. Crimes of unimaginable horror are the focus of another series aimed at the podcast market, but this time also aired on radio. Stolen Sister (RTÉ Radio 1, Friday), produced by the Documentary on One team, tells the story of the abduction, rape and murder of two young women, Elizabeth Plunkett and Mary Duffy, at the hands of two serial killers, Geoffrey Evans and John Shaw , in 1976. Those are the basic, sickening facts. But the series, narrated by Roz Purcell, not only traces the sequence of events that saw two English ex-convicts embark on an unspeakable crime spree but also, more pertinently, puts the focus on the women they brutally killed. Accordingly, much of the tale is told through the lens of the Plunkett siblings in particular, who recall their growing dread after Elizabeth went missing in Co Wicklow. But, equally, they remind us that their sister was a real person of independent spirit, not some preordained victim: 'She read Cosmo and she had notions.' Similarly, Purcell's plainly delivered narration underscores that these were ordinary women with hopes and dreams, their lives mercilessly ended by Evans and Shaw, whose murderous lack of empathy makes the term psychopathic seem far too kind. There is a bitter sting in the tale. 'Unbelievably, no one has ever been found guilty of Elizabeth's murder, despite both Shaw and Evans confessing to everything,' Purcell says. Such moments make for contemporary resonance – Shaw is still alive and in prison – while emphasising how the Documentary on One strand has become RTÉ's most adept podcast creator. The team also produced the series Where Is Jón? , which reinvigorated the ongoing investigation into the disappearance of an Icelandic poker player, Jón Jónsson, in 2019. [ Jón Jónsson disappearance: Gardaí interview almost 60 people in Iceland Opens in new window ] Whether these podcasts can yield justice remains to be seen. But whether the embattled national broadcaster can replicate such mastery of the online medium across the network will surely have a bearing on its fortunes. Moment of the week As the post- Joe Duffy era of Liveline (RTÉ Radio 1) begins on Monday, Philip Boucher-Hayes requests that listeners 'be kind' as he assumes the role of guest host. However, as callers complain about the mooted increases in college fees , the presenter – previously a regular Liveline stand-in – maintains an unflappable mien. But as the show draws to a close, he suddenly sounds alarmed. 'God, I'm very badly over time,' Boucher-Hayes laments. 'I'm very bad on this first day of the job.' [ Joe Duffy's last Liveline: A rare acerbic shot at the Taoiseach, then the fabled phone-in show goes full end-of-pier Opens in new window ] He then takes an ad break, which further gobbles up airtime belonging to his Radio 1 colleague Ray D'Arcy. 'I am in such trouble,' Boucher-Hayes ruefully remarks. Should he be a contender in the race to replace Duffy, he's not off to an auspicious start.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Two refreshing summer drinks in innovative packaging from Aldi
Aldi is not afraid to innovate when it comes to wine packaging or the wine itself. Last year, it introduced two wines housed in flat bottles made from recycled PET plastic. Flat bottles take up a lot less space and are therefore more carbon friendly. Plastic is lighter, also saving carbon emissions. This year, Aldi has introduced an Italian Pinot Grigio in an innovative aluminium bottle that weighs more than 70 per cent less than standard glass bottles, again saving CO2 emissions. It is also fully recyclable. As well as this, Aldi now has a Sangria in a one-litre PET. Anybody who visits Spain will know that this mix of wine, chopped fruits, a sweetener and sparkling water is the perfect low-alcohol refresher on a sunny day. Castellore Pinot Grigio delle Venezie Castellore Pinot Grigio delle Venezie 2024 11% abv, €8.99 Light and refreshing with crisp citrus and pear fruits finishing dry. A good summer sipper or try it with light seafood dishes. From Aldi READ MORE Sangria from Aldi Aldi Sangria, Spain 5% abv, €4.99 one litre Fresh sweet red fruits with citrus and spices. Serve well chilled the next time we have a hot, sunny day. From Aldi
