Report highlights critical data gap on persons with disabilities in Indian justice system
Across police, prisons, judicial, and legal aid systems, disability-disaggregated data is missing or inconsistent, making accountability and reform difficult.
Poor implementation
Titled 'Access to Justice for Persons with Disabilities in India: A Data-Informed Report', the report notes how the justice system, despite some progressive mandates, remains largely inaccessible to persons with disabilities due to the absence of reliable data and poor institutional implementation.
'The United Nations Convention on Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD, 2008) provides a clear mandate for inclusion of persons with disabilities and maintaining disaggregated disability data. The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (RPwD Act 2016) also reflects the same to some extent,' it reads.
Fragmented and disparate
However, the implementation of national mandates at the level of States is fragmented and practices remain disparate, it notes.
According to the report, persons with disabilities are largely absent from justice sector jobs, with mandated employment quotas not being effectively implemented. The justice system also lacks the capacity to serve the needs of people with disabilities.
'For example, the NCRB Prisons Statistics Report of 2022 reveals a total of 69 sanctioned positions (58 for states and 11 for UTs) and 25 filled positions for psychologists/psychiatrists (21 for states and four for UTs) across State and UT prisons accounting for only 36.23% of the required strength,' it points out.
Inaccessible infra
The report also stresses on the inaccessible infrastructure, with many courts, police stations, and prisons remaining physically and digitally inaccessible, and even hostile for persons with disabilities despite legal mandates.
'Disability sensitisation in capacity building programmes for police, prison staff, judges and legal aid staff is lacking and insufficient. Efforts like Accessibility Committees exist in some High Courts, but the practise of appointing Accessibility Committees have not percolated to lower courts,' it finds out.
While persons with disabilities are entitled to free legal services, they face barriers due to limited outreach, accommodations, and staff training.
'In 2023-24, persons with disabilities who accessed legal aid services at various levels was a mere 0.29% of the overall number of persons who accessed it,' reads the study.
Call for action
Some of the action points suggested by the report include mandatory disability-disaggregated data in the justice system, public accessibility audits, transparent reporting of reasonable accommodations, and integration of disability rights into training curricula for police, judiciary, and legal aid actors.
'Over 26 million persons with disabilities in India continue to be excluded from the justice system. A relentless focus on disability inclusion through awareness, enforcement of reservation policies, infrastructure accessibility, and comprehensive data collection is needed to realise full inclusion of persons with disabilities in the justice system,' said Nivedita Krishna, founder, Pacta.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
13 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
₹34-cr assets attached in Ranya Rao gold smuggling case
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has attached properties worth ₹34.12 crore in its money laundering probe into gold smuggling syndicate involving Kannada actress Ranya Rao, agency said on Friday while adding that the accused had detailed coordination with foreign gold suppliers, hawala operators, and Dubai-based customs agents and public officials at airports in India are also under scrutiny. Ranya Rao 'ED, Headquarter Investigative Unit-II, New Delhi has provisionally attached immovable properties valued at ₹34.12 crore under the provisions of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) in a case involving transnational gold smuggling and laundering of its proceeds by Harshavardini Ranya alias Ranya Rao and her associates. The attached assets include immovable properties located in Bengaluru and Tumkur districts of Karnataka,' ED said in a statement. The financial crimes probe agency said it has identified proceeds of crime worth ₹55 crore in the smuggling so far. ED is among several central agencies - along with the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Directorate of Revenue and Intelligence (DRI) - that are looking into a larger conspiracy into the gold smuggling racket. Its probe is based on a CBI case filed in March 7 this year following a complaint by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI). DRI had intercepted Rao, stepdaughter of a director general of police rank officer, on March 3 at Kempegowda International Airport, Bengaluru, with 14.213 kg of concealed 24-carat foreign-origin gold, valued at ₹12.56 crore. A search of her residence led to the recovery of ₹2.67 crore in unaccounted Indian currency and gold jewellery worth ₹2.06 crore. The agency said on Friday its probe revealed that 'Ranya Rao, in active collusion with Tarun Konduru Raju and others, orchestrated a well-structured operation for smuggling gold into India'. 'Gold was procured from suppliers based in Dubai, Uganda, and other jurisdictions, and payments were made through hawala channels in cash, thereby circumventing legal financial systems. False customs declarations were filed in Dubai, fraudulently declaring the destination of gold shipments as Switzerland or the USA, while the actual travel of the gold smugglers was to India. Dual sets of travel documents were used i.e. one for the declared export destination and the other for their actual arrival in India, to evade scrutiny and facilitate smuggling through Indian airports,' ED said. Further, ED investigation has revealed that the smuggled gold was then sold within India in cash to jewellers and other local entities, and the proceeds were subsequently laundered through further hawala remittances abroad to finance repeat consignments for smuggling more gold into India. 'Evidence retrieved from the seized mobile phones and forensic extraction of digital devices, have revealed detailed coordination with foreign gold suppliers, hawala operators, and Dubai-based customs agents. Ranya Rao's involvement in generating, possessing, and circulating proceeds of crime was further corroborated by her digital footprint, which includes invoices, export declarations, foreign remittance records, and recorded chats establishing her active role in the smuggling syndicate,' agency said. Earlier, ED had in May raided 16 locations, including educational institutes linked to Karnataka home minister G Parameshwara and some hawala and forex dealers in this case. ED recorded Rao's statement during which she knowledge of the seized gold and other assets; however, her claims were demonstrably contradicted by seized physical evidence, including customs documents bearing her name, travel and purchase records, and digital conversations, agency statement said. 'Despite the seizure of 14.2 kg of smuggled gold and associated assets by DRI, the total proceeds of crime identified during ED's investigation have been quantified at ₹55.62 Crore. This includes approximately ₹38.32 Crore identified through analysis of the evidence gathered during the course of investigation by ED e.g. foreign invoices, customs declarations, and hawala-linked remittances,' ED added. 'It has also emerged during investigation that Ranya Rao was assisted at the airport upon her arrival in India, and the possible involvement of public servants in facilitating her illicit activities is under scrutiny,' it said. As a substantial portion of the proceeds of crime had been layered and reinvested into immovable assets to project them as untainted, ED said it has provisionally attached four properties of equivalent value belonging to Ranya Rao. These include a residential house in Victoria Layout, Bengaluru; a residential plot in Arkavathi Layout, Bengaluru; industrial land in Tumkur District; and agricultural land in Anekal Taluk, with a combined fair market value of ₹34.12 Crore. 'Further investigation is under progress to trace the remaining proceeds of crime and identify other individuals and entities involved in the syndicate,' it said.
Hindustan Times
13 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Delhi man held for ₹2 crore cyber fraud, links with Chinese-linked syndicate
Gurugram: Faridabad police arrested a 39-year-old Delhi resident, who runs a hotel and nightclub in Dubai, for allegedly orchestrating a ₹2.02 crore cyber fraud in collaboration with a Chinese-linked syndicate, officials said on Friday. Faridabad police arrested a 39-year-old Delhi resident, who runs a hotel and nightclub in Dubai, for a ₹ 2.02 crore cyber fraud. (Getty Images) Bhupesh Arora, originally from Karnal and currently residing in northwest Delhi's Rohini Sector 11, operates a four-star hotel and eight nightclubs in Dubai, police said, adding that he was taken into custody on Wednesday upon returning to India and is now on a four-day police remand. According to investigators, Arora and his business partner, also based in Dubai, ran a cyber fraud operation alongside their hospitality ventures. The duo facilitated illegal fund transfers from India to Dubai using payment gateways, later converting the funds into cryptocurrencies and handing them over to Chinese handlers after deducting a commission. Police said Arora was compelled to return to India 20 days back on the directions of the Punjab and Haryana high court. Faridabad police had got a lookout circular issued for him against which he had moved the high court. Though the court had quashed the circular, it had directed him to come to India and cooperate with the Faridabad police by joining the investigation of the case. Yashpal Yadav, Faridabad Police PRO, said investigators traced Arora through a payment gateway account linked to him, into which ₹2.8 lakh of the duped money was transferred. 'This payment gateway helped us identify Arora. The bank account holder couldn't be traced and may have been created fraudulently,' he said. Arora allegedly retained 30% of the proceeds, with the remaining 70% going to his Dubai-based partner, who liaised directly with the Chinese network, Yadav said. Arora is the 12th person arrested in this case. Police are now pursuing his business partner and three others. 'We will issue an LOC against his partner so he can be arrested on arrival in India,' said Yadav. The victim, whose name police have witheld, a 51-year-old man from Sector 88 in Faridabad, was duped in January 2024 after falling for a fake investment scheme promoted through social media ads. Believing he was investing in stock markets, he transferred ₹2.02 crore to 11 different bank accounts. A case was registered at the Cybercrime Police Station (Central), and police have so far recovered ₹60 lakh, which was returned to the victim. The remaining amount, officers said, had already been siphoned abroad.
Hindustan Times
13 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Ludhiana: Moga woman caught with 255-gm drugs
A Moga-based woman was arrested on the charges of drug smuggling after she was caught carrying 255-gm heroin on Thursday, police said. The accused has been identified as Amandeep Kaur alias Amne, a resident of Thathi Bhai village in Moga district. The accused has been identified as Amandeep Kaur alias Amne, a resident of Thathi Bhai village in Moga district. (HT Photo) According to Varinder Singh Khosa, deputy superintendent of police (DSP), Dakha, the arrest took place when a police team was heading towards Hissowal toll plaza for routine patrolling. They noticed a suspicious woman standing near the bridge on the main GT Road, close to the Budhel power grid. On spotting the police vehicle, the woman threw away a black envelope and tried to flee. She was apprehended after the cops checked the packet that had 255-gm heroin in it. A case has been registered under the relevant sections of the NDPS Act at the Sudhar police station. Police officials further noted that the accused was produced in court, after which police remand was obtained for further investigation.
