'Will Take Time': Manawanui's Fate Still To Be Decided
Lydia Lewis, RNZ Pacific Presenter/Bulletin Editor
Samoa's Ministry of Works, Transport, and Infrastructure chief executive says the final fate of the sunken Manawanui is still to be decided.
The New Zealand Navy vessel sank off the coast of Upolu in October last year, with a report into the grounding finding the crew were undertrained and the boat was not up to the task it was doing.
Fui Tupa'i Simanu said in a statement that the International Tanker Owners Pollution Federation is conducting an independent report on the wreck.
"Once that report is tabled, further decisions will be made," he said, adding "that includes the final decision on the wreck."
A report on the incident released last month found that the crew and commanding officer were undertrained, the boat was not up to the task it was doing, and the person in charge of the ship was distracted.
A local surf guide, Manu Percival, who operates near the shipwreck, told RNZ Pacific that he was shocked and disappointed at the findings.
Percival said it was simply not good enough.
"That is absolutely shocking that they had inadequately trained crew members and they went on a boat. I cannot believe how stupid that is," he said.
"New Zealand has had so many disasters throughout history, and learned from it, and then to come over here [Samoa] and not practice what they practice in New Zealand is just stupid.
"What were they doing? Showing off? Looks like they just show off."
Percival suggested the New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) give him a call about compensation for the impact on Samoans.
However, Fui said there are ongoing discussions on compensation.
Read more:
The NZDF said earlier this week that it has completed work to retrieve important equipment, weapons, ammunition and some debris from in and around the shipwreck.
In a statement on Monday, Commodore Andrew Brown said it is an important milestone which follows the successful removal of diesel fuel, oil and other pollutants from the ship.
He said all the equipment, weapons and the ammunition have now been returned to New Zealand and much of the scrap metal debris has gone to be repurposed locally.
The rest of the debris, along with tanktainers of unusable diesel fuel, pollutants, and oil mix, will return to New Zealand on the salvors' barge for safe disposal.
"Every effort has been taken to leave the Manawanui as safe and secure as possible, until a decision is reached on next steps for the ship and the work required for that," Brown said.
"With our focus on the next steps for Manawanui, reef and environmental studies are progressing to inform and sit alongside the independent wreck assessment.
"These will take time, but will provide essential expert advice, to inform government decisions."
A core group of NZDF personnel remains in Samoa for support, and the Samoan government's prohibited area of two kilometres around the Manawanui remains.
Dive site idea is 'bullshit'
Meanwhile, Percival is completely against turning the Manawanui wreck into a dive site.
There were three options Samoa's Cabinet was set to consider, including potentially leaving the wreck on the reef.
Percival wanted that option ruled out.
"It is a wild ocean," he said. "Diving does not work, but nah, it is just like it should not be there. Should get rid of it.
"Keeping it there as a shipwreck? That is bullshit."
He added that not only would dive operations not be a viable business due to cost, New Zealand had a responsibility to fully remove the ship.
RNZ Pacific has spoken with two other locals who shared similar views, but said they were too scared to go on record out of fear of repercussions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Jan Taouma: Tributes flow for pioneer of Samoan language
By Khalia Strong , PMN Janice 'Jan' Taouma is remembered as a pioneer of bilingual Pacific early childhood education. Photo: RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly Leading educators are honouring the late Janice 'Jan' Margaret Cockburn Taouma as a powerful advocate for the Samoan language. Taouma passed away on Saturday in Auckland, surrounded by her family, after battling lung disease. She was 77. For more than four decades, Taouma championed Pacific language and culture, establishing A'oga Fa'a Samoa, the country's first licensed Samoan-language immersion early childhood centre. Pauline Winter, the chief executive of the Auckland Kindergarten Association, describes Taouma as a pioneer who was friendly, supportive, and deeply committed. "Jan was a powerhouse, but also a gentle woman with sparkly eyes and a smile that always welcomed an opportunity to have a chat. "She had a vision, a very strong one, grounded in Samoan values…just a wonderful, wonderful legacy she has left." Taouma established A'oga Fa'a Samoa in the 1980s, on the grounds of Richmond Road School in Grey Lynn, at a time when culturally responsive, Pacific-led early childhood education was virtually unheard of. Dr Tafili Utumapu-McBride, a senior lecturer at AUT's School of Education, describes Taouma as a role model who truly embodied her beliefs. "She was a palagi, a Pākehā, and comfortable speaking our language. That stood out. People took their children there because of the love, the values, and the solid foundation Jan built. "Jan's love for our children and for maintaining our language and culture was visible. She set the standard." Utumapu-McBride first encountered Taouma in the early 1990s while researching Sāmoan language nests. She recalls the centre as one of the most well-managed and widely respected in the country. "I know quite a few people who've taken their children there over the years because of its reputation and the intergenerational aspect. "The grandmothers learning language alongside their children and grandchildren - that was highly evident. The dedication, and the fact that it's still going strong after 40 years, really speaks volumes. Not all centres last that long." Fa'alogo Dr Jacoba Matapo, pro vice-chancellor Pacific at AUT, says Taouma nurtured not just tamariki (children), but an entire movement. "As a visiting lecturer, I witnessed firsthand her generosity of spirit, her openness to serve the community, and her commitment to nurturing the professional journey of emerging teachers through mentorship. "Her mentorship was deeply relational - shaped by fa'aaloalo (respect), alofa (love), and tautua (service). I witnessed her gentle yet resolute leadership, her belief in growing Pacific leadership from within, and her remarkable ability to hold space for others to rise and lead," she says. "I know that Jan's legacy lives on in every Pacific child who learns through their language, in every teacher she mentored, and in the enduring strength of A'oga Fa'a Samoa as a beacon of Pacific excellence. She leaves a profound imprint on the hearts of many, and a reach that will continue to guide Pacific early childhood education for generations to come." In an earlier interview with Early Childhood New Zealand, Taouma reflected on returning from Samoa with her husband, Pita, and her desire to provide a space for their five children to maintain their cultural heritage. "I had a baby who was about 18 months old, so I was keen that this child had the same language opportunities as my other children in Samoa. I got involved and I've been here ever since. I never thought it was going to be my vocation in life!" In 2014, Taouma received a Queen's Service Medal for her commitment to Pacific children. Starting as a grassroots initiative, A'oga Fa'a Samoa has grown into a nationally-recognised centre of Pacific excellence. Its continued success, more than 40 years later, is a testament to Taouma's enduring vision. Despite ongoing challenges in the sector, including persistent funding gaps for culturally-grounded services, Winter says Taouma's unwavering commitment remains a beacon for other bilingual programmes. "She showed us what's possible. Jan never gave up. That's a true lesson for all of us. "We've now got a Tongan kindergarten, and we work with other Pacific ECEs when they ask us to. It's about generosity from providers, working productively together to bridge resource gaps across different areas," she says. "The dream was to have children and their whānau taught in a different way, a way where they could achieve, feel comfortable, and feel supported. I think that's part of Jan's legacy too, people who were passionate about education put in blood, sweat and tears to establish these centres." As tributes flow from across Aotearoa, Taouma's influence resonates not only in educational circles but in every Pacific home touched by her legacy. "Manuia lau malaga, Jan," Fa'alogo says. "You will be deeply missed and forever remembered." Taouma's life will be celebrated on Friday, 1 August at PIPC Newton Church, 2 Edinburgh St, Newton, from 10.30am to 12.30pm, with a burial to follow at Waikumete Cemetery, Plot 21, Chapel View area at 2pm. The family invites everyone to wear bright colours and flowers in their hair, and to come "in the spirit of Taouma's last fiafia ." -This article was first published by PMN .
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
‘Most generous heart': Founder of New Zealand's first Samoan language early childcare centre dies
Jan Taouma co-founded the first Samoan early childhood centre in New Zealand, the A'oga Fa'a Samoa, in Auckland in the 1980s. RNZ Photo / Cole Eastham-Farrelly Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech. Jan Taouma co-founded the first Samoan early childhood centre in New Zealand, the A'oga Fa'a Samoa, in Auckland in the 1980s. RNZ Photo / Cole Eastham-Farrelly One of the Auckland Samoan community's biggest advocates for maintaining the Samoan language and culture in New Zealand has died. Jan Taouma, co-founder of the country's first Pacific Island language early childhood centre, is being remembered for her dedication and work in the ECE sector that spanned over 40 years. She died in Auckland over the weekend, surrounded by her seven children. She was in her 77. Known affectionately as 'Mama Jan,' Taouma helped to establish the Aoga Fa'a Samoa early childcare centre in Auckland in the early 1980s, after recognising the importance of keeping the language alive among New Zealand-born Samoans.
Scoop
3 days ago
- Scoop
Double Win For Tauranga Teen
Press Release – Blue Light Reflecting on his week at camp, Tatahau shared, The camp gave me confidence and understanding in myselfIt also gave me the confidence to work with others and lead a group while gaining life skills and knowledge on how routine, discipline and … 'Not only my peers but also the staff had acknowledged the person I am', says Tatahau Ronaki (18), who achieved an impressive double win at Blue Light's Life Skills Camp held at the Burnham Military Base from 14 – 18 July 2025. Tatahau, who lives in Tauranga, walked away with two of the three top awards – the Overall Excellence Award and the Peers' Choice Award – impressing both the New Zealand Defence Force and his fellow participants. Reflecting on his week at camp, Tatahau shared, 'The camp gave me confidence and understanding in myself…It also gave me the confidence to work with others and lead a group while gaining life skills and knowledge on how routine, discipline and teamwork can go a long way.' Tatahau encourages other teens to consider the Blue Light Life Skills Camp. 'Don't hold back and give it a go. This opportunity is a great experience and you get to work alongside great staff and meet amazing new people, and in that week, you can learn a lot about yourself,' he advises. Blue Light Mentor, Kawana Marsden, reflects on Tatahau's journey. 'Tatahau really stood out during camp, not because he was the loudest or the fastest, but because he gave everything a go, even when he was a bit nervous. He lifted his team with quiet confidence, always encouraging those around him. You could see his teammates naturally looking to him for leadership and wanting him to represent them. He soaked up every bit of advice from the NZDF staff and wasn't there to show off – he was there to grow. His attitude, leadership and commitment shone through, and it's no surprise he took home both the Overall Excellence and Peers' Choice Awards.' Looking ahead, Tatahau shared his next steps. 'I have my eyes on joining either the Army or the Police, but I'm still not sure. For now, I am looking for employment,' he shared. Blue Light's Life Skills Camp, run in partnership with the New Zealand Defence Force, provides young people with a unique opportunity to develop confidence, leadership, and resilience. Tatahau's story is just one of many where teens discover their strengths and set goals for a brighter future. This highly successful programme has been run by New Zealand Blue Light in partnership with the NZ Defence Force for the past 14 years and has adventure-based experiential learning as a key part of the programme. The programme provides 14-17-year-olds with critical life skills such as self-development, self-control, and teamwork that will enable young people to be successful at home, school, in communities, and in employment. Up to 12 courses are held each year in Auckland, Trentham, Waiouru, and Burnham locations. For more information about the Blue Light Life Skills camps, visit Blue Light is grateful for the support of the sponsorship of the Lion Foundation and community supporters. See or visit New Zealand Blue Light Blue Light is a not-for-profit charity that works in partnership with the Police to create positive connections between young people and the Police, helping young people find direction, fun, and a sense of belonging within their communities, enabling young people to develop life skills, leadership skills, and find employment opportunities. Blue Light believes that it is through the empowerment of disadvantaged youth to reach their full potential that their overall well-being can be improved, and in turn, the well-being of their communities. Blue Light achieves this through removing the barriers for disadvantaged youth to participate positively in the community, through both its national and locally-based programmes, activities, and events. Blue Light's work in the community is unique – it is not a one-size-fits-all approach. We have 70 local branches working with NZ Police to create meaningful experiences for young people in their regions, including cultural, sporting, and educational activities that are alcohol, drug, and violence-free. Although Blue Light is supported by the Police, the two operate independently. For many participants, the programmes decrease the risk of youth offending and becoming victims of crime through access to positive role models, time with other young people away and the opportunity to see the world outside their current environment. Blue Light originally began in Australia as a community policing initiative and remains strong in all states. As well as in New Zealand, it is now active in the Solomon Islands, Fiji, the Cook Islands, and Scotland.
