Competing Otago Port proposals 'frustrating', Minister says
The Associate Regional Development Minister says local leaders should have created a coordinated regional plan.
Photo:
123RF
Clutha's mayor says newly announced
funding for an inland port
proposal came out of the blue, despite his efforts to be transparent about a similar project just down the road.
Calder Stewart debuted plans to develop a privately-funded inland port in Milburn just days before the
government announced a multi-million dollar loan
to develop a rail connection between Port Chalmers and a proposed Southern Link Logistics Park in Mosgiel last week.
The Associate Regional Development Minister said local leaders should have created a coordinated regional plan instead of having two nearby competing inland port proposals - Mosgiel and Milburn are less than 50 kilometres away from each other.
Dunedin mayor Jules Radich said he had repeatedly discussed the Mosgiel plan when Clutha's mayor was present.
But Clutha district mayor Bryan Cadogan said he was caught off guard by Friday's Port Otago funding announcement, which was frustrating as his district had been upfront and transparent about the Milburn proposal.
Photo:
Supplied by Calder Stewart
The Calder Stewart proposal was the district's "once in a lifetime project" and had been in the pipeline for at least a decade.
Local leaders including Dunedin's mayor had discussed the project last year, he said.
The Regional Development Minister hadn't been briefed about the Milburn proposal which could have impacted the government's funding decision as it didn't have the whole picture for the region, he said.
Cadogan didn't have any issue with the Port Otago project and didn't believe Calder Stewart intended to seek government funding, instead he was concerned that those local leaders didn't disclose a competing proposal despite his efforts to keep them informed.
He wanted the South to start working in unison.
"If there is a conflict like this, just be transparent. If I put my cards on the table, could you put cards on the table the same way," Cadogan said
Dunedin mayor Jules Radich agreed that it was important for regions to work together, but said he had talked about the Port Otago-Mosgiel plan repeatedly in the Clutha mayor's presence including at the Otago mayoral forum in Queenstown last year.
"I asked for government support of a heavy traffic bypass for Mosgiel to complement the project," Radich said.
"I also think the Mosgiel logistics hub would be a great asset to the meatworks in Balclutha and Ōamaru."
The up to $8.2 million loan for the Port Otago rail connection was earmarked from the Regional Infrastructure Fund, which is run by the government's Regional Economic Development and Investment Unit, Kānoa.
Associate Regional Development Minister and local List MP Mark Patterson said only one project was formally proposed to the government in the end.
It was frustrating there were two competing proposals when they could have worked together to create a cohesive proposal, he said.
He described collaboration in the regions as "absolutely critical", and said the government was expecting that regions would coalesce around an agreed set of projects and priorities.
The Port Otago option also had backing from Fonterra, Silver Fern Farms and KiwiRail so they were confident in their processes and in making the investment, he said.
He believed they could be complementary projects, and said last week's funding announcement wouldn't prevent Calder Stewart from making a funding application in the future if it chose to.
The Regional Development Minister has been contacted for comment.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
30 minutes ago
- RNZ News
NZDF receives hundreds of gifts from commercial suppliers
The NZDF has accepted gifts and hospitality worth more than $418,000 since 2016. File photo. Photo: New Zealand Defence Force The New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) needs to be careful when accepting gifts or hospitality from commercial suppliers, says the Auditor-General, after an inquiry found it accepted more than 2500 gifts in recent years. The inquiry found that between 2016 and 2025 the NZDF accepted gifts and hospitality valued at more than $418,000 including food and drinks at functions, gift vouchers and smart watches, as well as tickets to concerts by international artists, the World of Wearable Arts and sporting events. In a media release, Auditor-General John Ryan said spending public money through contracts with suppliers must be, and be seen to be, made for the right reasons without inappropriate influence. The Office of the Auditor-General (OAG) became aware of NZDF accepting gifts and hospitality from a commercial supplier in 2024 and staff carried out inquiry work to understand NZDF's policies. The NZDF introduced a new policy in 2023 which saw a reduction in the number of gifts and hospitality being accepted and clearer expectations are also being by senior leadership. Auditor General John Ryan. Photo: Controller and Auditor General Ryan said while there had been some positive change, the NZDF continued to accept gifts and hospitality. "NZDF needs to carefully consider the inherent risks associated with continuing to accept offer of gifts or hospitality from its suppliers. The practices we have seen in this case risk the public and Parliament losing confidence in the decisions made to contract with those suppliers." Ryan said. The inquiry found 78 percent of gifts and hospitality were recorded as accepted to build "business relationships" and most of them (84 percent) were in the period before November 2023, when NZDF introduced their new policy. In a statement, a spokesperson for the New Zealand Defence Force said they welcomed the inquiry and the NZDF accepted it must maintain high standards to maintain trust. "The defence force will continue to ensure standards are maintained and improvements are made where required. No evidence was found of inappropriate influence of NZDF officials or decisions in relation to commercial contracts." Many of the concerns raised were historical and addressed by improvements made proactively by the NZDF and since the inquiry more work had been to improve "organisational awareness " the statement said. "The NZDF accepts it needs to continue work to ensure expectations are maintained. "The NZDF's policy on accepting gifts and hospitality reflects that the organisation must maintain constructive working relationships with commercial suppliers in the defence industry, particularly in the context of future procurement and the need to rapidly advance defence capabilities." The statement said the NZDF reports to the Foreign Affairs Defence & Trade Select Committee every year with a list of gifts and hospitality, which was available online. OAG inquiries manager David Lemmon told RNZ his office had seem some improvement in recent years, but the NZDF still had to keep steady. "We also note that the defence force needs to carefully consider these risks as it continues to do its business, and if it's going to accept or consider accepting any of these gifts, it needs to carefully consider the risk with doing that." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Community support workers among NZ's lowest paid
They are among New Zealand's lowest paid employees. The wages of home and community support workers, who look after the country's elderly, typically max out about $29 an hour. They also use their own vehicles to travel between jobs and, while they're reimbursed for that, it's at an amount significantly less than IRD recommends for personal vehicle use. The issue was part of a pay equity claim by the female dominated workforce, who consider themselves underpaid in comparison to those dominated by men. That's now off the table after the government changed the law last month. Jimmy Ellingham reports. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Supermarket prices up highest amount since 2023
business food 28 minutes ago Whether it's a block of butter or cheese, a kilo of mince, a dozen eggs or a cooked chook, food prices have gone up rapidly. The latest Stats NZ figures show in the past 12 months food prices have gone up 4.4% - the highest increase since December 2023. Over the last three years Checkpoint has been tracking a weekly shop from the same suburb at a Countdown and Pak'n SAVE supermarket to see just how much things have gone up at the checkout. Louise Ternouth reports.
