Khandallah murder trial: Blood spatter found around the kitchen sink
Helen Gregory, 79, was killed at home in January last year, and her daughter Julia DeLuney is on trial for her murder at the High Court in Wellington.
The Crown says DeLuney attacked her mother before staging it to look like she had fallen from the attic, but the defence says someone else caused those injuries in the 90 minutes in which she had gone to get help.
Glenys Knight from ESR told the court today that in her opinion, it appeared someone had washed blood-stained hands or an object in the kitchen sink.
There was some visible blood on the bench around the sink when the scene was examined, and a Luminol test revealed extensive blood spattering.
ADVERTISEMENT
Knight told the court she had attended more than 150 scenes, many of which were homicides, including several multiple homicides and high profile cases, and she carried out the scene examination at Gregory's home at 8 Baroda St.
Pieces of detached hair and flesh were preserved, along with a broken nail, which had small blood stains on it.
She said visible blood was found on a number of items and doorways in multiple rooms, and its presence was confirmed with different tests, including the Kastle-Meyer test, the Combur test and Luminol testing, in which a chemical reagent reacts with blood and glows blue in low light.
The court heard in earlier evidence the street lights in the area were turned off to allow for Luminol testing.
Areas in and around the sink lit up strongly during testing.
"In my opinion, these were most likely created by diluted blood being flicked or splashed and then left to dry," Knight said.
"From the position of these stains around the sink, it would appear likely that someone has washed blood-stained hands or a blood-stained item in the kitchen sink."
ADVERTISEMENT
Julia DeLuney is on trial for her mother's murder at the High Court in Wellington. (Source: rnz.co.nz)
Next to the sink, in a Wild Bean Cafe paper bag, sat an uneaten pastry.
Blood was also found on the doorframe and door handle of the patio door, the tap in the laundry, the handle of the fridge, a mug on the kitchen table and on the kitchen floor – in Knight's opinion, all were transfer stains from another object – along with the extensive blood in the bedroom Gregory was found in, and the hallway.
It was also found on her personal alarm, normally worn on the wrist but instead found sitting on the television cabinet in the sitting room.
"Some blood stains, which in my opinion appeared dilute were detected on the front and back of the face and strap of the NevaAlone personal alarm," Knight said, reading from her report.
That alarm was also sampled for trace DNA, but Knight did not speak about the results of that test.
No blood was found on cleaning products in the cleaning cupboard, or its handles.
ADVERTISEMENT
There were also two circles of "probable" blood on the white tile next to the stove – only classed as probably as they reacted with luminol but the other, less sensitive tests did not confirm its presence.
Those circles matched a number of items in the house, including some crockery, lamps, candle holders and a metal bucket under the sink, but there were no traces of blood found on any of those items.
Knight said the bloody footprints on the kitchen floor were unusual, in that the soles did not have a detailed pattern on the bottom, indicating they might be from slippers or dress shoes which usually had featureless sole patterns.
Neighbour says blinds remained open
In separate evidence, a neighbour told the court that on the night of Gregory's death, the lights in her home were off and the blinds left open.
The neighbour said she went to bed about 10pm, and at that point, the house was in darkness and nobody had closed the blinds.
But she said she woke up around 2am to see lights on in Gregory's house, which were shining into her own bedroom.
She said she did worry something had happened, and the next day, a police officer knocked on her door to take her statement.
rnz.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Khandallah murder trial: Blood 'wiped' onto walls to stage scene
Julia DeLuney is on trial for the murder of her mother Helen Gregory. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii A forensic scientist has told the jury in the Khandallah murder trial that, in her opinion, the blood on the hallway walls was staged. Julia DeLuney is accused of murdering her 79-year-old mother, Helen Gregory, who was killed at her Wellington home in January last year. The jury has already seen photos of blood smeared on the walls in the hallway, in and around the utility cupboard which houses the entrance to the attic. DeLuney's defence is that her mother was injured falling from the attic, and she put her in the bedroom on the floor while she drove to get help. In that time, the defence said, someone else caused those fatal injuries. But Knight gave evidence that the blood smears on the hallway walls looked like it had been applied to the wall with fabric. Defence lawyer Quentin Duff asked whether it could have been applied by someone staggering around the house - to which she replied that she doubted it. "I've never seen it in my experience." Knight said in her opinion, the most likely scenario was that blood was wiped onto the walls. She explained that the horizontal bloodstains along the wall curved upward and downward, making it unlikely they were made by the leaning shoulder of either an injured person - or an attacker covered in blood. She told the court an orange fake nail, broken off beside Gregory's body, was found sitting on a pool of blood, and was also covered in tiny blood spatters. Knight said it was possible it had been kicked onto the area of pooled blood, but in her opinion, it had been present and lying face up on the carpet while blood was flying around. DNA testing had shown there was "extremely strong scientific support" for at least some of the DNA on the nail coming from DeLuney. But the defence has argued throughout that the investigation suffered from tunnel vision from the very beginning. Duff pointed to an online exchange between Knight and her peer reviewer. He challenged her on her likely scenario, asking her to present an alternative explanation, and instead Knight doubled down, offering information she gained from police about what they think happened that night by way of explanation. She pointed out a number of things she understood DeLuney had done that night, which she said she was told by the police, to lend weight to her likely scenario. For example, she told her reviewer that DeLuney supposedly changed her clothes, took a shower, and chased a rubbish truck down the street to dispose of some clothing. It is not yet clear from the proceedings of the trial so far whether all of those things did happen. The defence said it caused the reviewer to change his own conclusion - but Knight said she thought of it more as a lightbulb coming on for him during the course of the conversation, and by the end of it, he came around to her way of thinking. Friday would mark the final day of the trial's second week, and it was set down for at least a further two weeks after that. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Khandallah murder trial: 'Blood looked staged'
science crime 29 minutes ago A forensic scientist has told the jury in the Khandallah murder trial that, in her opinion, the blood in the hallway looked staged. Julia DeLuney is accused of murdering her 79-year-old mother, Helen Gregory, who was killed at her Wellington home in January 2024. Kate Green reports.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Khandallah murder trial: Victim was bludgeoned, forensic pathologist tells jury
Helen Gregory died at her Khandallah home in January last year. Photo: RNZ / Soumya Bhamidipati The elderly woman found dead in her home in Wellington's suburb of Khandallah last year was bludgeoned, a forensic pathologist has told a jury. Helen Gregory, 79, was killed in January 2024 - her daughter Julia DeLuney is on trial for murder in the High Court at Wellington. She has pleaded not guilty. The Crown says DeLuney attacked her mother, possibly with a vase that has never been found, before staging it to look like she had fallen from the attic. But the defence says someone else caused those injuries in the 90 minutes in which DeLuney went to get help. Julia DeLuney in the High Court. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii On Wednesday, the court heard from forensic pathologist Dr Judy Melinek, who peer-reviewed Gregory's post-mortem. Melinek said she agreed with the post-mortem, which found the 79-year-old had died from complications of blunt force trauma - primarily to the head. She said death would not have been instantaneous, as the swelling of the brain that results from such trauma typically takes several hours. Melinek took pains to describe to the jury the different types of injuries that can result from blunt force trauma - abrasions, contusions, and lacerations - before using the bust of a mannequin to point out the type and location of Gregory's wounds. She said Gregory had a total of "11 planes of injury on the head alone," meaning she had sustained at least 11 separate impacts. She said the impacts were caused by "significant force". "You know, someone taking a heavy object, like a cricket bat or something, or a large hefty object and hitting it with a good amount of force over the head." In response to questions from the prosecution, Melinek said the injuries could have been caused by a vase. "An object like that vase would be a blunt force object and it's hefty and heavy, so it could easily cause the lacerations such as we see on Ms Gregory." Under cross-examination, Melinek said a fall could also cause blunt force injuries, but the pattern tended to be different from being struck by an object. She said a fall from a height of a metre or two could cause one of the smaller head wounds, but a fall couldn't explain a large injury on the back of her head. "I've never seen an injury of that magnitude caused by a fall in someone's residence, even if we're talking from stairs. It's too big and there are too many planes of impact. "You need a bludgeoning to get this many planes of injury." Melinek said it was plausible that multiple and repeated strikes against an entertainment unit could have caused the head wounds, but maintained it was unlikely they were the result of being kicked. She said in total, Gregory had about 75 discrete injuries, including lacerations, contusions, abrasions and fractures. She also said bruising on the soft tissue of her arms was consistent with "grab marks" and defensive injuries on her wrists. She said injuries from a fall tended to be located on boney parts of the body. The defence suggested that the injuries could have been sustained at a different point in time. The trial continues. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
