Doctors need to work with the NHS, not against it
But to demand a 29 per cent increase, and to rush into a strike ballot to support it, is a counterproductive and damaging tactic.
Last year, they secured a better deal than most public-sector workers, and there were no strings attached requiring more efficient working practices. They should believe Wes Streeting when he tells them: 'You will not find another health and social care secretary as sympathetic to resident [formerly junior] doctors as me.'
Mr Streeting secured a funding settlement for the NHS over the next four years that is generous compared with other departments. But a real-terms increase of 3 per cent a year is only around the long-run historical average. It is half the rate achieved in the New Labour years. So there is no scope for utopian pay settlements (such as the excessively generous GP contracts negotiated in Tony Blair's time).
If the British Medical Association, the doctors' trade union, really wanted to promote the interest of its members, it would work with Mr Streeting to plot a gradual real increase in doctors' pay over the next few years allied to a plan to modernise the NHS and increase health service productivity.
Instead, it is seeking to repel public opinion with the threat of another round of strikes in pursuit of a pay claim that most reasonable people regard as pie in the sky.
Already public opinion is narrowly opposed to doctors being allowed to go on strike at all (opposed by 49 per cent to 44 per cent, according to YouGov), but the one thing that will ensure that the doctors lack public support is the demand for such an unrealistic increase.
Of course, it is only the opening bid in a negotiation – but this is a negotiation with public opinion as much as it is with Mr Streeting.
The BMA is pleased, as militant trade unions usually are, with the 'resounding majority' in favour of strike action in its ballot: 90 per cent certainly looks like an impressive mandate. But the turnout for that ballot was only 55 per cent, which means that just fewer than half of those eligible to vote supported strikes – a less than 'resounding' margin.
This is not how the allocation of resources in a public health service should be decided. The idea that one NHS interest group should use its old-fashioned, Seventies-style industrial muscle to secure a larger share of a limited budget is one that belongs in the past.
The very idea of the NHS is in danger. Years of Conservative underfunding have weakened it to the point that many younger people have become used to paying for private GPs and minor procedures. If the waiting lists left over from the coronavirus cannot be cleared, support for the idea of social insurance systems such as those formerly advocated by Nigel Farage will grow.
Perhaps they should. Continental Europe seems to do well enough without a universal tax-funded model such as the NHS. But that is not what the BMA purports to believe. It believes in an NHS free at the point of need. And if its members believe that too, they should drop the threat of strikes and work with Mr Streeting to modernise the NHS and make it work.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
10 minutes ago
- BBC News
Five stories in Peterborough you might have missed this week
An epic walk between Peterborough United's football stadium and the nation's capital helped raise money for an 11-year-old with cancer, while a box of abandoned kittens were discovered by the city's volunteer litter pickers. Here are five stories from Peterborough you might have missed this week. Call for 'Benedict's Law' to protect children with allergies The family of a five-year-old boy who died from a severe allergic reaction at school are calling for a new law to help keep children Blythe died after accidental exposure to an allergen - cow's milk protein - at Barnack Primary School in December inquest jury found the school did not follow all the measures in place to prevent the fatal anaphylactic reaction - and there were risks of contamination with other milk and delays in administering an adrenalin pen. Police walk between football grounds for Millie, 11 A group of police officers have covered a 95-mile (150km) route between football stadiums to raise money for an 11-year-old girl diagnosed with was diagnosed with a form of bone cancer last year and had to have her left leg amputated above the knee. Her parents are trying to buy a new artificial leg for her.A group of 60 people walked from Peterborough United's ground on London Road to the home of Millie's favourite team Chelsea FC, at Stamford Bridge, west London. Kitten litter found by city litter pickers Volunteer litter pickers got more than they bargained for when they found a box with six kittens tiny creatures were discovered abandoned and alone on a path near Peterborough's Embankment area on Thursday by Peterborough Litter group immediately called a local cat rescue charity which came along to collect them. 'We have many bus stops, but zero buses' People have voiced concerns that recently installed bus stops around their village will become redundant when a bus service ends next near Ramsey, currently has three bus stops for the 31 bus route, operated by Stagecoach, which connects the village with Ramsey, Whittlesey and full service will stop running in Bury on 31 August, but the 31 route will continue to serve Whittlesey and Peterborough, Stagecoach said."Bury will be the place with so many bus stops, but zero buses servicing it," said 16-year-old student Harriet Copley, who will be attending college in Peterborough from September. Community space to open in football club's old shop Plans to open a new community space in Peterborough United's former club shop have been would lead to meetings, social events, and activities including yoga, being held next to the Weston Homes Stadium entrance. The week in politics Plans for a £15m city regeneration project to refurbish a library and build a food hall and business incubator have moved a step City Council has been asked to approve the award of construction contracts for a project known as The council originally wanted to use the former TK Maxx building in Bridge Street before deciding this was unviable. Separately, that building is being put out to market. Meanwhile, a report revealed that safety measures to protect people at Peterborough Town Hall could cost £900,000. It comes after reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (Raac) was found on the second floor of the civic building last year. Finally, Peterborough City Council's leader Dennis Jones said the authority would be reviewing all organisations and companies benefitting from rent and rate relief. It came after it was revealed a community radio station set up by former council leader Wayne Fitzgerald had been benefitting from the relief for nine years. He said the arrangement was reviewed annually by the council and that the station provided community value. Follow Peterborough news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
BBC News
25 minutes ago
- BBC News
What would a regional mayor mean for Norfolk and Suffolk?
Big changes in how Norfolk and Suffolk are run are on the government wants to carry out a major shake-up of local authorities – existing councils will be scrapped and replaced by new ones - and the counties will share a will be given extra powers over areas including transport and housing, with elections for the mayoral role due to take place in May next successful politician will then oversee councils running two counties that have traditionally been known to have a friendly rivalry. Why is this happening? Last December ministers revealed devolution plans which would see a huge reorganisation of local government, with the pledge of moving more power away from London and also cutting prime minister Angela Rayner told the BBC that giving regional mayors more control over housing, transport, education and employment would help drive economic plan will also see numerous existing councils Norfolk that means eight existing councils will be scrapped, although there is debate as to how they should be reformedThe existing county council favours one authority covering the entire county while six of the district councils favour three. South Norfolk Council has said two would be Suffolk, six current councils will county council has said it should be replaced by one authority, but the five districts are backing the idea of three. What would the mayor do? The mayor would be in charge of what is called a combined county authority – which would be made up of Norfolk and Suffolk's government has said they would have "greater local control" over transport, adult education and skills, and housing – and it would expect them to deliver improvements including economic may also take on the responsibilities of the police and crime powers will ultimately be determined by the Devolution Bill - launched on Thursday - if that passes through parliament and becomes mayor would also represent Norfolk and Suffolk on the Council of Nations and Regions – which includes the Prime Minister, leaders of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland – as well other regional mayors. What other parts of the country have mayors like this? There are already 14 regional mayors in England covering the likes of Greater Manchester, Greater Lincolnshire and Cambridge and powers and responsibilities vary, with the Mayor of London role being quite different as it was setup under a different model of devolution. Who could the next mayor be? With the election not due to take place until next year, the major parties have yet to select their as a high-profile, new role, competition to be nominated would likely be could also see independent candidates put themselves forward. Don't we already have mayors? Yes, we do – but they are different from the one we have been talking about selects a new Lord Mayor every year from its existing councillors, while West Suffolk, Great Yarmouth and King's Lynn and West Norfolk Borough councillors do the same for their each case, it is a ceremonial role that sees them chairing full council meetings, attending civic events and councils like Bury St Edmunds, Cromer, Thetford and Felixstowe also have mayors who are, again, existing councillors serving as figureheads and chairing meetings. How would they be chosen? An election is scheduled for 7 May 2026, with everyone registered to vote in Norfolk and Suffolk able to take mayor would then serve for a fixed term of four years, before another election takes place. Will these changes definitely happen? Devolution deals have been on the table for both Norfolk and Suffolk in the past, but ultimately came to time around, the majority of players involved want to move forward with a deal, even though they may not currently agree on what the final deal should sorting out such a major reorganisation is not simple, and there is still a lot of work to be done in a relatively short period of time. Follow East of England news on X, Instagram and Facebook: BBC Norfolk or BBC Suffolk.
Telegraph
26 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Unite's doing an astounding PR job for Reform
Unite's shock decision to suspend Angela Rayner's membership and re-examine its relationship with Labour on Friday left the trade union community aghast. As senior union officials messaged each other in shock, political rivals were left salivating. This is just the kind of shake-it-up drama they were hankering for. 'This is an odd hill to die on,' one bemused union insider says of Unite chief Sharon Graham's decision. 'It's bonkers – what's their endgame here? Your average union member doesn't give a f--- about political affiliations, but this is damaging for Labour and now is not a good time to damage them.' Unite, Labour's biggest union backer, should be very careful what it wishes for. When it ran a private poll of its members before last year's general election, insiders were alarmed to discover growing support for Nigel Farage's Reform. Clearly concerned about the shift in political tone among its membership, a Unite insider told me earlier this year that Reform was simply an example of 'very wealthy people plugging into the zeitgeist of workers. Is Reform a friend to workers? No'. So it seems odd that the very same union is now doing some pretty astounding PR for Reform, knowing from their own membership base exactly how effective ex-City trader Farage's efforts have been (the union never revealed the results of the poll). If the gameplan here is to shift funds to Jeremy Corbyn's new Left-wing party, it's unlikely to work – those union members who have been caught up by Farage's razzle dazzle won't suddenly become Corbynites just because Sharon Graham says so. While it's younger voters who are more likely to vote for the Corbyn-led party, it's older workers who are more likely to join a union. According to official data, 40pc of union members are over 50 years old while just 3.7pc are under the age of 24. Gen Z might have a reputation for demanding change, but very few are actually unionised. Meanwhile older, unionised workers who have lost faith in mainstream politics have been listening to Farage for months. From Reform's local election launch rally at JCB where Farage declared that he was 'on the side of working people' to his message in a working men's club in Durham, when he said Reform was parking its 'tanks' on Labour's lawn in Red Wall areas, Farage's charm offensive has paid off. Union chiefs have been working hard to convince any won-over members to rethink. Tackling Reform's rise was a major focus at a lunch hosted by the Public and Commercial Services (PCS) union, which represents almost 200,000 civil servants, earlier this year while the Trades Union Congress (TUC) has been promoting clips on social media of workers asking why Farage wants them to lose their jobs. When I asked a union boss about all of this recently, he acknowledged that members were frustrated and angry, living in a country that feels 'broken and beaten'. Reform has tapped into this feeling. But unions have a job to do, he continued – 'remind our members that the reason we have a historic relationship with Labour is that working people need a voice. We still feel that is best served by Labour'. Maybe so, but Unite just bulldozed that message. Despite vowing to spend less of members' time and money on Westminster politics, Sharon Graham has been attacking government policies for months. Going 10 steps further with a formal split from the party and a withdrawal of funding would mark a landmark political moment – one which as well as damaging Labour could serve as a boost for corporate Britain and the wealthy, instead of the workers unions are fighting for. If Labour falls out with its union paymasters, ministers might be more likely to listen to the needs of the executive class. The government may reconsider its tax raids on the rich amid accusations that it is driving the wealthy away, or it might soften the looming Employment Rights Bill - which is set to give unions far more power – in order to appease UK plc. Both issues are at a crunch point. As the Bill makes its way to the final stages of the parliamentary process, bosses will be raising the volume on their long-running concerns. Meanwhile billionaires who swung behind Labour in the lead-up to the election are losing patience. Sir Keir refused to rule out introducing a new wealth tax, a move which unions back, earlier this week after former Labour leader Lord Kinnock suggested the party was 'willing to explore' a tax on assets worth more than £10m. One of Labour's richest supporters, Phones4U founder and former Tory John Caudwell, has said he is growing 'increasingly nervous' about the Government's direction and argued that a wealth tax would be 'very destructive' to growth. Labour knows it can't ignore these concerns. Sir Keir's pro-business party looked beyond the unions who traditionally bankroll it in the run-up to the election, accepting nearly £13m in private donations in 2023 versus £5.8m from unions. It is clear that divisions on the Left will not only benefit Reform but also drive Labour into the arms of billionaires and big business. Unite, which has donated £19m to Labour since 2019, is not as in control as it might think.
