Doctors need to work with the NHS, not against it
But to demand a 29 per cent increase, and to rush into a strike ballot to support it, is a counterproductive and damaging tactic.
Last year, they secured a better deal than most public-sector workers, and there were no strings attached requiring more efficient working practices. They should believe Wes Streeting when he tells them: 'You will not find another health and social care secretary as sympathetic to resident [formerly junior] doctors as me.'
Mr Streeting secured a funding settlement for the NHS over the next four years that is generous compared with other departments. But a real-terms increase of 3 per cent a year is only around the long-run historical average. It is half the rate achieved in the New Labour years. So there is no scope for utopian pay settlements (such as the excessively generous GP contracts negotiated in Tony Blair's time).
If the British Medical Association, the doctors' trade union, really wanted to promote the interest of its members, it would work with Mr Streeting to plot a gradual real increase in doctors' pay over the next few years allied to a plan to modernise the NHS and increase health service productivity.
Instead, it is seeking to repel public opinion with the threat of another round of strikes in pursuit of a pay claim that most reasonable people regard as pie in the sky.
Already public opinion is narrowly opposed to doctors being allowed to go on strike at all (opposed by 49 per cent to 44 per cent, according to YouGov), but the one thing that will ensure that the doctors lack public support is the demand for such an unrealistic increase.
Of course, it is only the opening bid in a negotiation – but this is a negotiation with public opinion as much as it is with Mr Streeting.
The BMA is pleased, as militant trade unions usually are, with the 'resounding majority' in favour of strike action in its ballot: 90 per cent certainly looks like an impressive mandate. But the turnout for that ballot was only 55 per cent, which means that just fewer than half of those eligible to vote supported strikes – a less than 'resounding' margin.
This is not how the allocation of resources in a public health service should be decided. The idea that one NHS interest group should use its old-fashioned, Seventies-style industrial muscle to secure a larger share of a limited budget is one that belongs in the past.
The very idea of the NHS is in danger. Years of Conservative underfunding have weakened it to the point that many younger people have become used to paying for private GPs and minor procedures. If the waiting lists left over from the coronavirus cannot be cleared, support for the idea of social insurance systems such as those formerly advocated by Nigel Farage will grow.
Perhaps they should. Continental Europe seems to do well enough without a universal tax-funded model such as the NHS. But that is not what the BMA purports to believe. It believes in an NHS free at the point of need. And if its members believe that too, they should drop the threat of strikes and work with Mr Streeting to modernise the NHS and make it work.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
Macron says UK and France ‘share same will' amid crunch talks over migrant deal
Sir Keir Starmer said the UK would tackle illegal migration with 'new tactics' and a 'new level of intent' before crunch talks to hammer out a deal with Emmanuel Macron. The French president said the UK and France 'share the same will' to address the issue at the start of a Franco-British summit at Downing Street. It came after the pair said a 'new deterrent' was needed to stop small boats crossing the English Channel. The Prime Minister hopes the French president will sign up to a 'one in, one out' deal on Thursday, the last day of Mr Macron's state visit to the UK. Under the terms of the deal, Britain would accept migrants with links to the country in exchange for sending others back across the Channel. Sir Keir said the meeting was about working together on shared priorities. He said: 'For us, it's about delivering the changes that the British people want to see, and we will agree the situation in the Channel cannot go on as it is. 'So we're bringing new tactics into play and a new level of intent to tackle illegal migration and break the business model of the criminal gangs.' Speaking in French, Mr Macron said: 'We share the same will to tackle networks of illegal immigration through great co-ordination with other European countries. 'We have often mentioned France is the last destination before Great Britain for these men and women who often journey through paths of misery and are exploited by traffickers. 'We will work with countries of first entry in Europe (as) our intention is also to engage all countries who share a responsibility alongside us.' Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Energy Secretary Ed Miliband were also at the summit. Defence Secretary John Healey, who was also at the summit, told ITV's Good Morning Britain that footage of French authorities puncturing a migrant dinghy to stop it from setting off last week was a 'recognition' that France has agreed to change its rules to intervene in shallow waters. To reduce small boat crossings, he said those changes need to be 'fully implemented' alongside new legislation, building up the new border security command, and any steps to be announced by Sir Keir and Mr Macron after the summit. French newspaper Le Monde has reported that some 50 migrants a week would initially be returned to France under the terms of the proposed deal, which it described as largely symbolic. If such a deal were struck, it would only result in the return of a fraction of the 21,000 people who have made the Channel crossing so far in 2025, a record for this point in a year. But it would also represent a concession by the French that such returns are possible, after years of MPs on the right of British politics insisting France is a 'safe' country where migrants can be sent back to. The Times reported the scheme would be scaled up after an initial pilot had shown 'proof of concept', citing Government sources. In return, Mr Macron is said to be pushing for the UK to do more to address 'pull factors' which are attracting people to make the dangerous crossing to the English coast. When Mr Macron and Sir Keir met in Downing Street on Wednesday, the small boats crisis appeared to be the mainstay of their conversations. The pair agreed the crossings are a 'shared priority that requires shared solutions', a Downing Street spokesperson said. They also agreed on the need for a 'new deterrent to break the business model of these gangs' and are aiming for 'concrete progress' on the matter. Following the French-UK summit, the two leaders will host a call with coalition of the willing partners, the proposed peacekeeping mission to deter Russia from attacking Ukraine in future. In a sign of close alignment on defence, Britain and France have announced they will buy new supplies of Storm Shadow missiles, which both have loaned to Ukraine to strike targets deep inside Russia. The two nations will also work closely to develop a successor to the long-range missile, the Ministry of Defence said.
The Guardian
34 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Failure to tear down Belfast bonfire will be victory for mob rule, warns Sinn Féin
Police in Northern Ireland will be giving into 'mob rule' if they fail to assist with the dismantling of a loyalist bonfire that is believed to pose risks to public health and to energy supplies, Sinn Féin has said. Loyalist paramilitaries warned of disorder if authorities took down the towering pyre on Meridi Street off Donegall Road in Belfast, which is to be lit on Friday night as part of wider loyalist commemorations. On Wednesday a Belfast city council committee voted to send contractors to dismantle the bonfire, which is on a site that contains asbestos and is close to an electricity substation that powers two hospitals. The Police Service of Northern Ireland declared a 'major incident' over the bonfire site and is considering the council's request. A joint statement from south Belfast paramilitary groups warned of a backlash if the pyre was removed. 'PSNI have been advised of the risk of widespread disorder, with loyalists in other areas across NI staging interface riots to stretch the PSNI,' it said. The Sinn Féin assembly member Pat Sheehan urged the police on Thursday to take 'firm, immediate action' to protect public health and critical infrastructure. 'We can't allow mob rule to decide what happens to this bonfire,' he told BBC Radio Ulster. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Sheehan also urged unionist representatives to 'step up' and condemn the bonfire, which is one of about 300 that will be lit on Thursday and Friday as part of the annual celebration of the victory of King William III's Protestant forces over Catholics at the battle of the Boyne in 1690. Meanwhile, a senior cleric added his voice to condemnation of a separate bonfire, in the County Tyrone village of Moygashel, that features an effigy of a migrant vessel with a dozen mannequins in lifejackets and placards that say 'stop the boats' and 'veterans before refugees'. John McDowell, the Church of Ireland archbishop of Armagh and primate of all Ireland, called the effigy racist and threatening. 'It certainly has nothing whatsoever to do with Christianity or with Protestant culture and is in fact inhuman and deeply sub-Christian. I hope that the many people from other countries, who live in that area … can be reassured that it does not in any way represent the feeling of the vast majority of their neighbours.' An Irish national flag is also on the Moygashel pyre, which is to be lit on Thursday night.
Scottish Sun
35 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Moment Nigel Farage watches in fury as French Navy escorts 70 migrants to UK waters & hands them over to Britain
NIGEL Farage has witnessed first-hand SEVENTY migrants being escorted by France into British waters. The Reform UK leader looked on as a Border Force boat waited for the crammed dinghy to arrive for the handover. 6 Nigel Farage watches as French border force officials escort small boats into Dover Credit: GB News 6 Outraged Farage described it as a "classic" day in the English Channel Credit: GB News 6 Migrants smile and celebrate on a dinghy as it prepares to sail into the English Channel today in Gravelines, France Credit: Getty Video footage highlighted the moment the inflatable was monitored by British and French authorities in shocking footage. Illegal migrants waved and celebrated as they set sail for Britain. Mr Farage blasted successive UK governments who have handed £750 million to France to deal with the small boats issue - but the crisis continues. The incident happened as Sir Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron met in Downing Street to thrash out a deal to thwart the small boat journeys. Speaking from the Channel, Mr Farage said: "This is a classic day in the English Channel. Over the last five years, when the weather's on a red day, you've got a migrant boat. He told GB News: "And we've seen it through the binoculars, there's about 70 people on board being escorted all the way over by the French Navy. "And behind us we have Border Force sitting on a 12-mile line waiting for the handover. We've paid £800 million to the French, and this is the farce that goes on." Downing Street and France are currently trying to sign off on a "one in, one out" deal that could see fifty migrants sent back across the Channel each week. But Mr Farage says that as no one gets deported, Britain should hold up a sign in Dover saying "everyone welcome". He added: "You'd need 10,000 troops on the beach to stop any of these boats taking off. And we've got to be honest about this, we can be upset with the French, but it's our fault. It's our fault. Migrant camps brace for impact as UK-France deal fuels crossings "You might as well have a sign on the White Cliffs of Dover which says 'everyone welcome'. No one gets deported, and I think we have to go further than we've ever gone before." He adds that the nation is in "peril" as communities are destroyed with undocumented males able to roam the streets freely. He added: "I don't think these young, undocumented males that arrive today or any other day should be allowed to freely walk the streets of our country. "I think they've got to be detained in secure accommodation. Because, frankly, we are putting our nation and our people in peril." He added: "We cannot have people coming in and within a couple of days, walking our streets, working for Deliveroo or whatever else." Meanwhile, in Downing Street, Macron said that both the UK and France"share the same will" to address illegal immigration. Mr Macron said: "We share the same will to tackle networks of illegal immigration through great co-ordination with other European countries. "We have often mentioned France is the last destination before Great Britain for these men and women who often journey through paths of misery and are exploited by traffickers. "We will work with countries of first entry in Europe (as) our intention is also to engage all countries who share a responsibility alongside us." 6 A group of people thought to be migrants are brought in to Dover Credit: Darren Fletcher 6 This follows a small boat incident in the Channel Credit: PA
