Pupils punished for incorrect uniform due to cost pressures, charity warns
A poll of 3,000 parents of school-aged children in the UK found some pupils have received detention, been placed in isolation or been excluded for not having the correct uniform.
Nearly two in five (38%) parents said they struggle to pay for the school uniform their child needs, according to the poll for The Children's Society.
The survey, carried out by Censuswide in June, found 42% of parents said school uniform was not more affordable this year (2024/25) compared to the previous academic year (2023/24).
It comes as the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill, which is currently being considered in the House of Lords, includes a proposal to cap the number of branded uniform items schools in England can require.
The survey found 44% of parents said their children have faced negative outcomes for wearing the incorrect uniform, or for not having a required item, as the uniform is unaffordable.
Around one in eight (12%) said their child had received a detention for uniform breaches, while 9% had been placed in isolation, and 8% had been excluded.
The poll found 15% of parents said their child had not been able to participate in lessons and 12% were not able to participate in extracurricular activities due to incorrect uniform.
Mark Russell, chief executive at The Children's Society, said: 'Punishing children for circumstances outside their control is deeply unjust.
'Every child should be able to attend school without fear of detention, isolation, or exclusion because of uniform costs their families cannot afford.'
Nearly four in five (78%) parents believe there should be a specific limit on the number of branded uniform items that schools can require, the survey found.
The charity is calling on the Government to implement proposals set out in the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill to introduce a limit of three branded items of school uniform to help families.
Mr Russell added: 'At a time when many families are already struggling to afford the basics, we can't let the cost of school uniforms make life even harder for children.'
Pepe Di'Iasio, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, said: 'The experiences reflected in this survey are worrying, and demonstrate just how tough the financial position is for some families who face having to make impossible decisions.
'Most schools – in our experience – are acutely conscious of cost pressures on families and work hard to support the many children in our country who live in difficult financial circumstances.
'We support the Government's intention of limiting the cost of uniforms – though we think this would be better achieved with a monetary cap rather than specifying the number of branded items that are allowed.'
Ahead of the committee stage debate on the Bill in the House of Lords on Thursday, schoolwear retailers have repeated warnings that the proposed cap of three branded school uniform items could increase costs for families.
Matthew Easter, chairman of the Schoolwear Association, said: 'We have repeatedly tried to engage with ministers in a constructive way to warn of the risks of this policy backfiring – harming the very families it's meant to help, and putting small community businesses and local jobs at risk.
'A blunt, one-size-fits-all cap will only drive-up costs and reduce access to essential support.'
Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson said: 'School uniforms can create a sense of community and belonging for children but they shouldn't cost the earth.
'Through our Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill we are capping the number of costly branded uniform items – putting money back into the pockets of working families as part of our Plan for Change.
'Whilst it might upset those who profit from branded items, it's clear from the Children's Society research that we have the backing of parents. It means schools can continue to benefit from a cohesive uniform, while parents can shop where suits their budget.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
17 minutes ago
- Times
The 15 biggest kitchen myths
I love the idea of treasured recipes and kitchen wisdom being passed down through the generations — the handwritten notes in the margins of old cookbooks, the whispered tip from grandma about the 'right' way to make pastry, the family belief that gravy must always be stirred clockwise. These traditions give cooking its soul. But the truth is, times change. A better recipe comes along, a quicker technique makes life easier, or science quietly debunks what we always thought was gospel. And yet some of these so-called golden rules just won't die. They are passed on reverently, like folklore — repeated at dinner parties, printed in cookbooks, even taught at cookery schools. The trouble is, a lot of them are just plain wrong. Having spent my entire working life in the kitchen, as a food writer, editor, recipe developer and chef, I've had endless opportunities to test these beliefs for myself. And in many cases, I'm astonished they still hold sway. It's time to separate fact from fiction, tradition from truth, and do a little culinary myth-busting. It's true that 99 per cent of the time you don't need to. Most things — roasts, cakes, bread, cookies, pastry, casseroles and ready meals — can successfully (and safely) be cooked from cold. Put the dish in a cold oven and as it heats up, so does the food. It starts gently, then quickly catches up. Depending on your oven, just add 6-8 minutes to the cooking time and as ever, check food is properly cooked before serving. The sourdough guru and bestselling author Elaine Boddy has been on about this for years. 'Preheating is madness — so wasteful and pointless. I receive so many messages from people who don't believe it'll work, then try it, bake perfect loaves and swear they'll never preheat again.' So why do recipes and pack instructions tell us to preheat? Because cooks have come to expect exact timings, and the only way to achieve this is to start with a level playing field: a preheated oven. You can also save yourself even more energy by switching the oven off five minutes before the end. • Read restaurant reviews and recipes from our food experts This is a ceremonial habit in many kitchens, but mostly unnecessary. Modern flour is uniform, finely milled and bug-free. Experiments by the science food writer Harold McGee show that sifting has little to no effect on texture. You'll save yourself mess and washing up by giving it a quick whisk instead. Don't throw away your sieve just yet, though: cocoa powder and icing sugar clump and genuinely do need sifting. Obviously, if you keep opening and slamming your oven door, it will struggle to maintain temperature. But soufflés, cakes and even Yorkshire puddings are more robust than we give them credit for. It's absolutely fine to rotate the tray at half-time or test things by prodding towards the end. The one exception I've encountered is gougères; delicate choux pastry puffs that featured on the menu when I cooked in France. A few years ago I demonstrated the recipe at a large food festival. The celebrity chef with whom I was sharing the stage opened the oven door as a joke, and my point was proved. It sank. It's fine to put stainless steel serrated knives, such as paring or vegetable knives with plastic handles, in the dishwasher. Resin-handled or ceramic knives are another matter, however. It's not that you'll blunt them, but they are not designed to withstand the dishwasher's rapid heating and cooling cycles or harsh detergent. Wash by hand — it takes seconds. As Axel Steenbergs of Steenbergs Organic (the UK's leading organic herb supplier) explains, this isn't necessarily the case; it depends on the herb. 'The woodier the original plant, the more likely it is to retain its flavour — think bay, thyme, rosemary and lavender. Leafy herbs like basil, chives, chervil and parsley are better fresh, especially if they are from your own garden rather than the supermarket.' There are some exceptions — dried dill is one of Steenberg's favourites. As for oregano, dried is infinitely more flavourful. Steenberg also advises using fresh herbs for bright summer dishes and salads and switching to dried in winter. There is a myth that extra virgin olive oil is automatically better than other oils, in all contexts. It isn't — not for flavour (except when you want an olive flavour), and not for cooking. It is perhaps the best all-round oil from a health point of view, although rapeseed gives it a run for its money. Because it's unrefined, Evo (as it's known in the trade) retains far more of the olive's natural flavour — grassy, peppery, often with a bitter tang. That's desirable in dressings and drizzles, but often too assertive if you're making something like mayonnaise, where a milder or neutral oil is more suitable. Then there's the warning that Evo is bad for non-stick pans. Some manufacturers do advise against it (the low smoke point can cause the oil to carbonise and build up residue) so check care instructions when buying. My pan is a Scanpan (and is the best I've ever had) and I use Evo for all Italian recipes; the scent of the oil as it warms is una goduria — pure pleasure in a pan. • Seven olive oil recipes — this summer's favourite ingredient One of many myths surrounding pasta. About 250g dried pasta actually cooks perfectly in as little as 1 litre of water (add 1 teaspoon salt), or 500g in 1.2 litres (add 1½ teaspoons salt). You just need to watch that it doesn't boil over. Even more radical, you can start dried pasta in cold water then bring it to the boil; simply add 2-3 minutes to the time it says on the pack. Best of all, here's the way I do it. Add the pasta to boiling water, bring it back to the boil, pop on the lid, turn off the heat and leave it for the time it says on the pack. And don't add oil to pasta cooking water — it's messy and a waste of oil. Instead, stir the pasta often until the water comes back to the boil, after which there's no need because the bubbling water will stop it sticking. Finally, fresh pasta is not superior (or inferior) to dried, it just cooks quicker and has a slightly softer texture. And I find cream-based sauces (such as alfredo) stick to it better than dried. That might have been true once, but not any more. There are good reasons to choose unsalted: you might prefer the taste (especially with artisanal or cultured varieties) or wish to reduce salt intake. If a recipe specifies unsalted butter, then tells you to add a measured amount of salt, it's because the writer is aiming to control the salt level precisely or they persist in the old-fashioned belief that unsalted is inherently better. Smaller eggs tend to be laid by younger birds, at the peak of health, and are excellent quality. The yolks are proportionately larger than the yolks in bigger eggs, and the whites tend to be less watery. Yet because recipes often specify large eggs, people often turn up their noses at small and medium. The result? Hens are put under increasing pressure to lay larger and larger eggs through multiple husbandry techniques. Pressure is the word: large eggs can be painful and exhausting for the hens. Jane Howorth, the founder of the British Hen Welfare Trust, urges shoppers to buy mixed-weight boxes instead. 'The farmers and hens will thank you, and you'll get more yolk for your buck.' Plus, if you're following a recipe, switching egg size is unlikely to throw it off. As for the 'should I store eggs in the fridge?' debate — yes, they keep better. Ideally remove half an hour before using, or float them in a bowl of warm water for a few minutes. This is not the case — however, it does make the meat much tastier. The process doesn't seal anything in — in fact, some moisture is lost — but this doesn't mean the meat ends up dry. Juiciness comes from not overcooking and letting the meat rest. Just be sure to keep the heat high, so the surface browns quickly without stewing in its own juices. As the food writer and broadcaster Tim Hayward explains in his book Steak: The Whole Story, searing causes meat fibres to release amino acids and sugars. When exposed to high heat, these compounds trigger the Maillard reaction, creating that rich, savoury crust we associate with sizzling steaks, chops and barbecue favourites. Keep going and sugars begin to caramelise, adding depth and sweetness. Recently, disenchanted by a run of garlic that was mouldy or sprouted before its time, I tried prepared garlic cloves, the kind that are peeled for you and come chilled in tubs. They are a bit more expensive, but the cloves are large, fresh and juicy. I used them to make a batch of hummus, which my husband tells me I never make garlicky enough, and it was deemed the 'best ever'. I won't be going back to fresh. Who came up with this? Salting early, either in the soaking or cooking water, improves texture and flavour and allows the seasoning to penetrate the bean, not just coat the surface. If your beans are too hard, they are out of date, or you live in a very hard water area, or you've added acidic ingredients (tomatoes, vinegar, lemon juice) too early. • The perfect prawn cocktail and seafood recipes for summer It reduces it, but doesn't eliminate it. In a long-simmered boeuf bourguignon, about 5 per cent of the alcohol remains. In quick-flamed dishes such as crêpes suzette, as much as 75 per cent remains. The quantities of wine or cognac used are unlikely to get anyone drunk, but it's worth knowing if someone has an allergy or avoids alcohol for other reasons. Overheating will ruin chocolate, but by far the commonest cause of seizing — when chocolate turns lumpy and grainy — is water getting in while it's melting. Even the smallest amount (like from a damp wooden spoon) can make the sugar clump up and break the emulsification, ruining the smooth texture. The fix, which may seem counterintuitive, is to beat in more water (teaspoon by teaspoon, hot or cold) until it becomes smooth again. You may need to fiddle with your recipe to take account of this, but at least the chocolate is saved. As a guide, you'll need to add up to 1 tbsp water per 100g chocolate. Melting chocolate in the microwave rather than over a pan of hot water also minimises the risk. If you've seen the guck left in the water after washing mushrooms, you wouldn't want to eat it. Furthermore, McGee's experiments showed that they absorb very little water from washing, and if they are fried correctly over high heat you'll never know the difference. 'Never crowd the pan' is also nonsense. Mushrooms reduce enormously in volume when cooking, so pile them in and keep stirring and tossing to get them brown all Murrin is a former editor of BBC Good Food and the founder of Olive magazine. His latest novel, Murder Below Deck, is published by Bantam. He has a lifetime achievement award from the Guild of Food Writers. @orlandomurrinauthor;
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
More than 100m of hedgerow in Ilminster may be removed for houses
More than 100m of hedgerow could be removed to provide access to a new housing Homes South West secured outline planning permission in January 2024 to construct up to 360 homes on Canal Way in Ilminster, Somerset, on land adjacent to the Meadows Exeter-based developer has now submitted detailed plans for the access arrangements, which involve removing 120m of hedges and changing the current layout of the surgery's car Council is expected to make a decision on the plans by the autumn. The development site lies between Canal Way and Herne Hill, which was designated as a local nature reserve by South Somerset District Council in July 2018, according to the Local Democracy Reporting Coles, director of planning at Carney Sweeney, representing the developer, said approving the plans would prevent delays in building the new site is one of more than 50 development sites within the former South Somerset area whose delivery has been delayed by the ongoing phosphates crisis, with developers having to secure additional mitigation to prevent any net increase in phosphates on the Somerset Levels and Moors.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Elizabeth Emblem awarded to Manx firefighter killed on duty 1965
An Isle of Man firefighter who died in the line of duty in 1965 has been posthumously honoured for his "extraordinary courage and selfless service".Henry Bertram Kenna has been awarded the Elizabeth Emblem, which is named after the late Queen and recognises public servants who died in the line of Officer Kenna collapsed and died after attending a commercial building fire in Douglas on 22 November is among 100 people being posthumously recognised across the British Isles and is the first person on the Isle of Man to receive it. Mr Kenna attended the blaze on Athol Street on foot as emergency teams were already attending a separate entered the building alone to search of people inside, but collapse after emerging from the of Man Lieutenant Governor Sir John Lorimer said the award, which will be formally presented to Mr Kenna's family, honours his "selfless actions and ultimate sacrifice" that day. 'Immensely proud' Sir John said: "This long-overdue recognition honours not only his bravery, but the enduring contribution of our island's emergency services."Chief Fire Officer Mark Christian said: "The actions of station officer Kenna on that fateful day were nothing short of heroic."He said he firefighter, who was known to his friends as Bert, "showed no hesitation in entering the building to try and help others and, tragically, made the ultimate sacrifice"."We are immensely proud to see station officer Kenna and his family recognised for his bravery and selflessness," he Elizabeth Emblem was extended to the Crown Dependencies and devolved administrations last year. Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
