Patient had to wait 169 days for ‘urgent' appointment at Mater Hospital breast cancer clinic
On Wednesday, the
Irish Cancer Society
published new data showing delays in access to testing and treatment of
cancer
in the State.
The urgent symptomatic breast disease clinics aim to see 95 per cent of patients within 10 working days. However, between March 2024 and February 2025, only 76.3 per cent of patients received their appointment within this recommended timeframe.
There was also significant variation between hospitals. The lowest compliance was found at the Mater Hospital in
Dublin
, with just 28.9 per cent of patients seen in this time, followed by St James's Hospital at 54.5 per cent and Letterkenny University Hospital,
Co Donegal
, at 59.8 per cent.
READ MORE
Some hospitals had very high compliance, with University Hospital Waterford seeing 100 per cent of patients within the target timeframe, followed by Beaumont Hospital in Dublin, at 99.7 per cent, and University Hospital Limerick at 97.7 per cent.
According to the data, the longest waiting time in the 11 months up to February 2025 was found in the Mater Hospital, where one patient waited for 169 days.
A spokeswoman for the Mater Hospital said its mammography service is facing 'significant capacity constraints due to high demand and a lack of funding'.
'The hospital has submitted a comprehensive business case requesting additional staffing and resources to support the demands on the service and to reduce any delays, including in surveillance mammography,' the spokeswoman said.
The Irish Cancer Society data also provided insights into Rapid Access Prostate Clinics, which have a target timeframe of seeing 90 per cent of patients within 20 working days.
Nationally, between March 2024 and February 2025, only 74.2 per cent of patients received their appointment within this recommended timeframe.
Prostate cancer is the most common cancer diagnosed in men. If it is diagnosed at stage one, almost all men will survive. If diagnosed at stage four, only half survive.
The lowest target timeframe compliance was found at Galway University Hospital where 12.7 per cent of patients received their appointment within the timeframe, followed by St Vincent's Hospital at 74.4 per cent and Cork University Hospital at 82.8 per cent.
The highest compliance was found at Beaumont Hospital (100 per cent), followed by the Mater Hospital (99.4 per cent) and St James's Hospital (95.9 per cent).
Timely access to the Rapid Access Lung Clinic was better, with 93.7 per cent of patients accessing their first appointment within the target time of 10 working days.
Averil Power, chief executive of the Irish Cancer Society, said early treatment 'dramatically reduces your risk of dying from cancer'. The figures highlight 'alarming failures' to meet the targets in many cancer centres due to shortages of 'staff, physical space and equipment'.
She added that the society increasingly hears that, while appointments are being provided within the timeline, in some cases all diagnostic testing is not conducted that day, meaning there can be delays to diagnosis.
[
Irish Cancer Society calls for breast cancer screening to be lowered to 45
Opens in new window
]
Dr Michael McCarthy, president of the Irish Society of Medical Oncology, and consultant medical oncologist at University Hospital Galway, said he sees the 'human cost of the postcode lottery in Irish cancer care every day'.
'Once chemotherapy is prescribed, the National Cancer Strategy states that it should start within 15 working days. The reality in Galway is that patients are now typically waiting seven to eight weeks for their first session,' he said.
'With every week that passes, the risk increases that their cancer will grow, or worse that it will spread to other parts of their body.'
A HSE spokeswoman said cancer survival is improving.
Rising referrals and increasing complexity of care 'are placing significant demand on existing services, as evidenced by performance data of some cancer services'.
She said €20 million has been allocated for new cancer services in 2025 and 2026.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Leaving Certificate student died after blood clotting formed in lungs, inquest hears
A Leaving Certificate student developed blood clots in her lungs which led to her death shortly after being prescribed the contraceptive pill, an inquest has heard. Dublin District Coroner's Court heard on Friday how Sarah-Kate O'Meara went into cardiac arrest on the morning she was due to sit a mathematics exam last year – three days after starting to take the oral contraceptive pill and three days before her 18th birthday. Genetic testing following her death revealed she had a mutation called Factor V Leiden, unknown at the time of being prescribed the contraceptive pill, which placed her at a greater risk for blood clotting. The inquest heard how the Mount Mercy pupil became ill at her home in Cork before she was due to go to a Leaving Cert exam on June 10th, 2024. She experienced chest tightness and disorientation and lost consciousness. READ MORE She was taken by ambulance to Cork University Hospital and later transferred to the Mater Hospital in Dublin. Her mother Dianne O'Meara, who was with Sarah-Kate when she started to feel unwell, told the inquest she was a very sporty and a 'health-conscious' teenager. Sarah-Kate was an avid camogie player. Ms O'Meara described how her daughter's illness first presented with tightness 'as if she had something stuck in her chest' and what appeared to be a fainting episode around 8.25am. Her condition quickly deteriorated and she appeared clammy and slightly disorientated, and vomited. Minutes later she collapsed again and started convulsing, at which point an ambulance was called. The inquest heard how Tony O'Meara tried to resuscitate his unresponsive daughter as the family waited on the ambulance to arrive. Ms O'Meara sought help from a local pharmacist. She said her daughter had recently been prescribed the combined oral contraceptive pill, which she had started taking three days earlier, and that she had a history of migraines. Sarah-Kate's GP, Dr Caroline Burke, described their last consultation in which she prescribed the pill on May 13th, 2024. She had outlined the contraception options available and their associated risks. She said she had questioned Sarah-Kate about her history of migraines and asked whether she had ever experienced 'aura migraines', which she had not. These are a specific type of migraine that would make put her at too high risk of blood clotting to be prescribed the combined oral contraceptive pill. The hearing was told Sarah-Kate arrived to the Mater at about 1.20am on June 11th. She was pronounced dead on June 17th at 9.14pm. Dr Katie Murphy, cardiology consultant at the Mater who assessed Sarah Kate, told the inquest that 'multifactorial' respiratory pulmonary embolism, or clotting, was identified as the primary issue, pointing to the increased risk of clots posed by the pill and the 'sedentary period' surrounding exams. Dr Murphy said the results of genetic testing at the hospital showed Sarah-Kate had a previously unknown mutation called Factor V Leiden, which increased risk of clotting. The inquest heard how echocardiograms and CAT scans were performed throughout the duration of Sarah-Kate's care. In her closing statement, Coroner Clare Keane notedthe 'increased risk of blood clots with the use of [the] combined hormonal contraceptive pill' and increased risk of blood clot formation due to the 'significant condition' Factor V Leiden. Dr Keane said the case 'isn't straightforward' and, given the complexity of Miss O'Meara's death, a narrative verdict was most appropriate to reflect the evidence. A letter received from Organ Donation Transplant Ireland said 'Sarah-Kate has given new life to two patients through the donation of her kidneys', the inquest heard.
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Toddler died of Fentanyl toxicity from uncle's pain medication, inquest hears
A 20-month old child found unresponsive on the floor of his bedroom died of toxicity from Fentanyl, a powerful opioid used for pain relief, a coroner has found. The death of Christopher McDonagh-Marhsall, an otherwise healthy child, is believed to be the first of its kind from Fentanyl toxicity here. Lawyers for his mother, Leanne Marshall, said that with appropriate instructions and warnings, 'it could so easily have been avoided'. An inquest at Portlaoise coroner's court on Friday was told Ms Marshall and her extended family believe Christopher's sudden death on November 22nd 2023 arose from exposure to Fentanyl patches worn for pain relief purposes by his then terminally ill uncle Joe Marshall. A postmortem found toxicology results from the child's blood samples showed the presence of Fentanyl at what consultant histopathologist Dr John O'Neill said was a 'very high' level, ten times above the therapeutic level for adults, and 'which would certainly be associated with toxicity and death in adults and children'. READ MORE In a narrative verdict, which describes the circumstances of a death, Laois County Coroner Eugene O'Connor found the cause of the child's death was Fentanyl toxicity and said he will issue specific recommendations in due course for appropriate warnings to be issued concerning use, storage and disposal of Fentanyl patches. The inquest heard Joe Marshall, along with Leanne and Christopher and other family members, was living at the time in their mother Kelly Marshall's home at Ashbury View, Roscrea, Co Tipperary. A distraught Leanne Marshall, who held a framed photo of her son throughout the inquest, attended by many of her family and extended family, said the day of his death was 'the day my world fell apart'. Ms Marshall, who was estranged from Christopher's birth father Richard McDonagh, from Tullamore, said Joe was 'like a father' to her son and the two were very close. Christopher would often fall asleep on Joe's chest, they watched TV and played together, the inquest heard. In submissions for Ms Marshall, barrister John Sweetman, instructed by solicitor Mark Tiernan, said the child's death was 'a tragedy of extreme circumstances', compounded by Joe Marshall's death, aged 33, in January 2024, followed by the death by suicide of the child's birth father in August 2024. Christopher McDonagh-Marshall, whose inquest was held today in Portlaoise. The family's wish was that no other family will experience such a tragedy, they hoped there would be learning from Christopher's death and the coroner would make recommendations to help avoid any similar tragedy, he said. It seemed clear Christopher's death was a result of exposure to Fentanyl patches and what was 'so extremely sad about it is that it could so easily have been avoided', counsel said. Had there been any sort of warning or instructions to any of those involved, especially to family, 'it would not have happened'. In this case, there was a 'massive systems failure', he said, nobody was aware of the seriousness and dangers of this medication, it was 'an accident waiting to happen' and it could happen again. In his ruling, the coroner said the cause of death was Fentanyl toxicity and it was beyond doubt that was from the patch, 'whether it fell on the ground or whatever occurred', he said. Mother Leanne Marshall (right) holding a photograph of her late son Christopher McDonagh-Marshall, accompanied by her mother Kelly, the boy's grandmother outside Portaloise coroner's court at his inquest. Photograph: Mary Carolan Fentanyl patches are very useful slow release pain relieving medication that enables a person with terminal illness to remain at home and that facility should be there, he said. He would recommend verbal instructions and a 'simple' document understandable by non-medical people to convey the risk should be given to every family and patient dealing with such medication. The material should note a patch can and will fall off, set out what to do about that, how to dispose of it and the fact the patch is a particular danger to small children who would have no awareness of danger involved and likely to pick up everything and examine it. Earlier, the inquest heard that, on November 22nd 2023, the extended family were preparing for an early Christmas because they feared Mr Marshall might not survive until then. When Christopher was found unconscious that evening, and pronounced dead, the early Christmas was cancelled and the child's presents and Christmas pyjamas remained untouched. His grandmother Kelly said his room remains today as it was.
RTÉ News
14 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Four public parks in Cork to offer free sunscreen
Four public parks in Co Cork will be offering free sunscreen from Monday. Labour Councillor John Maher said the cost of sunscreen is a factor in preventing people from using it. It comes as the Irish Cancer Society says that there is an increased risk of skin cancer amid high temperatures. It said that according to a survey, seven in ten people find that sunscreen is too expensive. The charity also says that one in ten people surveyed do not wear sunscreen because they cannot afford it. Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, Mr Maher said providing sunscreen dispensers was something "that was achievable" and could be delivered at a low cost. "This is a partnership with the HSE and we're going to share the costs initially and it's going to run to the end of the summer. "As with all pilots, we're going to see how it goes, we're going to see the usage," he said. Mr Maher said that because the sunscreen dispensers will be in public parks owned by Cork city, they expect to have good control over the initiative and to be able to manage it well. He said the sun in Ireland is "still dangerous" and this will provide people with protection. The sunscreen on offer will be factor 50, he added. "There's a mirror there so that if you are putting it on yourself, you can get all the spots behind your ears and neck and you don't go around with a lot of cream on you," he said. The sunscreen dispensers will be available at Marina Park, Fitzgerald Park, Clashduv Park and Meelick Park from Monday. A Status Yellow high temperature warning is in effect for 14 counties, and will be extended countrywide from midday tomorrow.
