$500K estate of woman under care of public guardian will go to Winnipeg Foundation, judge rules
A note written by a Winnipeg woman who was under the care of the public guardian and wished to leave the bulk of her estate to charity — and only $1 to any family or friends — has been accepted by a judge as her final will.
In a Manitoba Court of King's Bench ruling delivered May 2, Justice Shawn Greenberg found there was "good reason" Minnie Blustein wanted her assets to go to charity, and ruled her estate, valued at about $500,000, will be used to create an endowment at the Winnipeg Foundation to fund scholarships in her family's name.
Such rulings are "very rare," a lawyer for the Winnipeg Foundation said.
It has been about 20 years since the last time the endowment-based charity inherited the estate of a person who was under the care of the public guardian and trustee through the court system, said Jennifer Litchfield. She's aware of only one similar case.
More commonly, such gifts come from a living family member, and "they look to have that estate go out into the community as some way to do good with what is left behind," said Litchfield.
In 2007, Blustein's personal and financial decisions fell under the control of the public trustee, after she was deemed mentally incompetent by a doctor and had no one else to look after her.
The Public Guardian and Trustee of Manitoba is an arm's-length government agency that makes the personal and financial decisions for people deemed medically incompetent by a doctor.
Blustein, who died in October 2017 at age 88, spent the last decade of her life at a personal care home.
"There is no evidence that anyone ever visited her there," Greenberg wrote.
"This is not a case where suspicions are raised because a family member has been inexplicably excluded from the will."
Greenberg's decision centred on a handwritten November 1994 note, where Blustein indicated she wanted her estate to go to Manitoba's public trustee so it could be invested in Canada Savings Bonds, with 50 per cent of its interest going toward "scholarships for the needy."
The note also said, "to any relations or friends who feel that they are entitled to my estate, I leave the sum of $1, which is more than they ever gave me," according to Greenberg's 18-page decision.
'Lived a solitary life'
The public trustee found the document while cleaning up Blustein's home, after she became a ward of the trustee in 2007.
The trustee also found another handwritten note among Blustein's belongings, dated February 1972, which said in the event of her death, she wanted to leave everything she owned to an orphanage in Israel.
After Blustein's death, the public trustee made an application with Manitoba's Court of King's Bench to determine whether either note could be probated as the will for her estate, or if she died intestate, meaning without a valid will. In such cases, the estate goes to "intestacy beneficiaries" — the closest relatives.
Greenberg ruled both notes complied with the requirements of a valid holographic will — one that is handwritten by a person, and is signed and dated — and accepted the 1994 note as Blustein's will, given it was written last.
"The object of the bequest in the 1994 will is clear," Greenberg wrote in her decision. "As Ms. Blustein had no close family and lived a solitary life, it is not surprising she left her estate to charity."
She had no spouse, children or siblings, the court decision said. Her mother and father died decades before her, and the public trustee was not aware of any friends or close relatives Blustein had, other than a distant maternal cousin in Ontario.
An heir-tracing company found Blustein had seven paternal cousins, none of whom lived in Canada.
If it was determined she died intestate, the estate would have gone to those cousins, Greenberg's decision says.
However, "none of the cousins provided any evidence" to the court, and "there is no indication that the paternal cousins knew Ms. Blustein or that they wish to make a claim to her estate," Greenberg wrote.
"I also note that no one has come forward in the eight years since Ms. Blustein died to claim any interest in the estate," which "might explain why Ms. Blustein did not make any provision for a family in either of the two notes," wrote Greenberg.
The court also found Blustein had the capacity to make her will. While she suffered from mental health issues when the public trustee committed to her care in 2007, that was long after the notes were written, Greenberg said.
The lawyer appointed to represent any intestacy beneficiaries had argued the 1994 note "seems emotional," suggesting it was "the result of an impulsive act and not a considered plan," Greenberg wrote.
The judge disagreed.
Blustein "had good reason for not including relatives or friends" in her will, the decision said. "The document shows a deliberate and final intent that people who never had anything to do with her should not benefit from her estate" because of intestacy laws, it said.
'A huge impact'
The judge said Blustein's intention to use her estate for scholarships through an endowment fund was clear.
But since the public trustee is not capable of doing so, the lawyer appointed to represent her charitable interests gave the court a list of four Winnipeg charities that could manage such an endowment.
Greenberg chose the Winnipeg Foundation, writing Blustein's "intent would be best implemented by setting up the trust with an institution that would reach the broadest part of the community."
When contacted by CBC last Thursday, the Winnipeg Foundation had not officially been made aware of the court decision yet, but its legal counsel wasn't entirely surprised.
"There are a number of steps that have to happen before any payments are made out of an estate," Litchfield said.
A spokesperson for the province, which oversees the public trustee, said the court has yet to issue a written order to carry out the decision. Then, the trustee has to wait for an appeal period to expire.
But an endowment fund from an estate as large as Blustein's "can have a huge impact," said Litchfield.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
How Canada could boost disease surveillance to make up for U.S. health cuts
Canada should do more to strengthen its health surveillance systems as cuts to U.S. health institutions threaten access to crucial monitoring data, experts say in an editorial published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) this week. The editorial says cuts within the U.S. Centers for Disease Control (CDC), the National Institutes of Health and the federal Department of Health and Human Services could strip Canada and other countries of valuable health data. "We've had a decades-long relationship with the Centers for Disease Control and other organizations in the States," said co-author Dr. Shannon Charlebois, a family physician and CMAJ's medical editor. "As those are dismantled, we're not going to have our early warning systems." For example, when the mpox virus broke out in the U.S., Charlebois said the CDC formally notified the Public Health Agency of Canada. This comes, the authors say, as a "crisis of communicable diseases is unfolding in North America," pointing to increasing rates of syphilis and HIV in Canada, along with measles outbreaks and livestock culls due to avian influenza. "We can't obviously control everything that happens in the U.S., but we can improve our own systems," said co-author Dr. Jasmine Pawa, public health and preventive medicine physician at the Dalla Lana School of Public Health at the University of Toronto. U.S. cuts should 'light a fire' to act on surveillance There have long been calls for Canada to improve surveillance of infectious diseases. "This should really light a fire under policymakers to take very seriously this question of public health surveillance," said Dr. Lorian Hardcastle, associate professor in the Faculty of Law and Cumming School of Medicine at the University of Calgary who specialises in health law and policy. What the U.S. does in public health has a ripple effect, she said. "When you have this major world player pull back out of public health surveillance and is no longer resourcing public health in the manner that they've historically done, then there's a call to others to step up their game." Beyond formal warnings, Charlebois said there are also informal links between the two countries that can help in planning. But with layoffs and budget cuts, now "we don't know who to call to get that informal information," she in an interview with CBC Radio's All in a Day. WATCH | Yukon doctors say territory is vulnerable after U.S. health cuts: Yukon doctors say U.S. CDC and FDA cuts leave territory vulnerable 3 months ago Duration 1:27 Earlier this month, U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced thousands of job cuts at the CDC, FDA and National Institutes of Health. Yukon doctors are now saying these cuts leave the territory vulnerable. What can be done here In Canada, one of the major hurdles to increasing surveillance is getting provinces and territories to collaborate and share data in a timely, uniform way, said Hardcastle. "A lot of it is just needing the political will to make it happen, which is a huge challenge," she said. But she said there are also tools Canada could implement, including electronic medical records, and better waste water surveillance for antimicrobial resistance. Hardcastle said that kind of surveillance was done during the COVID-19 pandemic and stepping it up could be beneficial not only for infectious disease monitoring, but for public health in general. That would give policymakers an early alert of problems, she said, "rather than waiting for things to really snowball." Others, like Charlebois, are calling for a national vaccine registry, so patients and medical professionals can keep track of immunizations and pinpoint who is protected and who is at risk. "We don't have a national vaccine registry and we are not meeting our obligation to the World Health Organization on that," said Charlebois. Misinformation crosses borders too The CMAJ editorial said all of this is compounded by another concern: misinformation. "People living in Canada are vulnerable to a cross-border bleed of not only microorganisms, but also of attitudes, health misinformation and exposure to biased U.S. media," the authors wrote. Misinformation can further challenge the health system, said infectious disease physician Dr. Michael Gardam, who has watched as the issue has undermined efforts to control the spread of illnesses, like measles. "People have stopped following what were highly effective control measures. Why have they stopped? Because people are telling them through social media not to follow them anymore," said Gardam. With the changes to health institutions in the U.S., Gardam said Canada and other countries will have a void to fill, but it will take time and effort. "We didn't build up our surveillance because the U.S. had our back," he said. "If they don't have your back anymore, you have to create it yourself or you have to create new partnerships with other countries to do it."
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Quebec tightened the rules for e-scooters. So why aren't they safer?
As of early July, the Montreal Children's Hospital says it has seen close to 30 scooter-related injuries. That's four times the number of patients compared to the same time last year.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Could your beach reads actually be therapeutic? Bibliotherapy suggests they might
The novels Book Boyfriend, Atmosphere and Can't Get Enough might be in your stack of beach reads, but are they good for your mental health? While reading a novel and escaping into a fictional world can be enjoyable, those who study and practice bibliotherapy, the use of written materials as a form of treatment for mental health conditions, suggest there are aspects of reading that can measurably improve our well-being. It's not a new concept. Though the term bibliotherapy was coined in a 1916 article by American essayist and minister Samuel McChord Crothers, American psychiatrists and other physicians as far back as the early 1800s argued that reading benefited their patients and pushed for hospitals to include libraries. In more recent times, bibliotherapy refers to things like self-help books and workbooks that clinical therapists can direct patients to read or complete to improve their mental health. Researchers are now exploring how creative bibliotherapy can use novels, poetry, plays or even picture books to achieve the same result. Hoi Cheu, a trained marriage and family therapist and professor at the School of Liberal Arts at Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ont., uses bibliotherapy to help patients cope with challenges such as loneliness. He says for bibliotherapy to work, the therapist needs to learn what he called "the story of the patient." Many who practice clinical bibliotherapy ask patients to find readings that interest them, then observe how they respond to the literature, he said in an email. Cheu, whose PhD thesis was titled Zen and the Art of James Joyce, likened the use of creative bibliotherapy to the practice of Chinese herbal medicine. "In short, reading literature is a process, and the readings are tools, not drugs." Benefits of talking about books Cheu says literary bibliotherapy works because it allows readers to use stories to figure out how to repair their own dysfunctional narratives. But simply reading a book may not be enough to improve our well-being, according to James Carney, an associate professor at the London Interdisciplinary School in the U.K. Carney, who has used a series of small experiments and questionnaires to study what makes creative bibliotherapy helpful, says he's found that the discussion of the reading material is more beneficial than the act of reading itself. For example, he says it helps if patients can reflect on the material they've just read with a therapist or group to tease out how it may be relevant to their situation. "What happens is a book gains its impact in conversation," Carney said. "You discuss what you've read. You reflect upon what you've read in a way that is socially activated. That typically has the main impact." Books can allow patients to see themselves Dr. Judith Laposa, a psychologist at Toronto's Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, says self-help books, a common form of bibliotherapy, can help those with mild to moderate depression understand their thoughts, feelings and behaviours. "It can be a really helpful starting point, and for some people, in and of itself, it's sufficient," Laposa said. "But for other people, that may be the first step of a broader mental health journey that also may involve mental health professionals." In Ontario, Laposa says the provincially funded structured psychotherapy program to treat anxiety and mood-related conditions served about 23,000 individuals last year. The program includes guided bibliotherapy, where a clinician assists in recommending self-help exercises as part of the treatment. Laposa says she's found the self-help form of bibliotherapy useful as she looks for ways to supplement sessions with her patients, because she says the literature often includes different characters describing challenges they face. "Many people … can see themselves in a lot of those descriptions and that can help them feel less alone," she said. Safely exploring issues through fiction Carney says creative bibliotherapy, which uses fiction rather than self-help, can be helpful because it allows people to indirectly examine difficult topics in a safe, fictional space. He suggests that fiction gives us "a way of engaging with troubling scenarios in such a manner that we are not directly strategically involved in them." Carney gave an example of having somebody going through marital difficulties reading a novel about a troubled marriage. He says this could allow the reader to see the unpleasant experience in a different perspective by experiencing it in a fictional setting where it's not directly threatening. "We can play in the sandbox, but we're not stuck there," Carney said. "We get to kind of do dress rehearsals, if you like, for bad things that can happen to us." WATCH | Does listening to an audio book count as reading? If you listened to an audiobook, can you say you've read the book? 6 months ago Duration 4:12 Carney is open to the idea that creative bibliotherapy promotes mental well-being. But as a data-driven researcher, he says much depends on the person, the book and how they engage with it. That might take the form of one-on-one therapy, traditional in-person book clubs, or discussion on social media sites like Reddit, which has threads devoted to books, or TikTok, with its literature-focused community known as BookTok. Both Laposa and Carney cautioned about possible harms that could result from the therapy, such as books containing material that could be triggering for those with eating disorders or addiction issues. But Cheu, the Sudbury therapist and professor who prescribes bibliotherapy, says any tool can be misused.
