Geldof's threat to quit Blair's Africa Commission
But official papers released to the National Archives in Kew, west London, show he was outraged when – after just one meeting – the commissioners were sent a document setting its 'emerging conclusions'.
In an angry letter to the commission's director of policy, the economist Sir Nick Stern, dated August 9 2004, he said it was impossible to have come to any conclusions it such a short period of time.
The former rock star warned that he was not prepared to serve on a body which was simply there to push 'pre-determined government policy'.
'To be clear, policy must be determined by the commission independently sitting and independently deliberating and concluding of its own volition. This distinction is vital. If I have got this wrong please inform me so I may tender my resignation,' he wrote.
'More broadly, the whole notion of emerging solutions is laughable. If the solution to the misery of Africa can be 'concluded' within a mere six week time span, it is a truly remarkable feat.
'How blind we must all have been these past years. The fact is that there are not and cannot as yet be any emerging conclusions.
'The commission will lose all credibility if it is not clearly seen to be an independent entity. If it seems to advance pre-determined government policy it will be correctly viewed as a laughable grotesque.'
Geldof went on to complain that the involvement of some of the commissioners – including some of those from Africa – appeared to have been 'minimal'.
'Is it not the secretariat's function, on behalf of the chair, to ensure that this is not the case? Or is this all some farcical political game played out at the expense of the wretchedly poor? If so, I ain't playing.'
Sir Nicholas wrote back hurriedly to assure him the that the document was not an attempt pre-empt the commission's findings, and that the input from British politicians had been 'comparatively minor'.
'Far from being an attempt to rush conclusions the paper is intended to to be a tool to help promote discussion and ensure a real interchange between commissioners at the second meeting in October,' he wrote.
'I would be very keen to sit down and discuss these questions with you; perhaps we could meet for a drink as soon as we are both around?'
Geldof's reply is not recorded in the files, but he was sufficiently placated to carry on.
After the Gleneagles summit the following year agreed to double aid to Africa and extend debt relief, he hailed it as 'mission accomplished'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
24 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Adams: It's a regret that end to armed campaign took decades to bring about
The former Sinn Fein president also voiced regret that it took so long to come, suggesting the UK Government was focused on 'defeating republicanism'. He also said he regretted the number of lives lost during the Troubles as he reflected on the upcoming 20th anniversary of the IRA statement. The IRA formally ended its 35-year paramilitary campaign on July 28 2005 when former republican prisoner Seanna Walsh read a statement. While a number of ceasefires had been announced and collapsed since 1994, the 2005 statement saw the start of the decommissioning of weapons. The statement said that members had been instructed to use exclusively peaceful means, and not to engage in any other activities whatsoever. Mr Adams described the move as seismic, and an 'indication of confidence' by 'all the IRA' and not just its leadership. 'The statement came after there had been some sort of internal process, a huge vote of confidence in people,' he said. 'It took decades for it to be put together. 'You have to go back to Father Alec Reid, Father Des Wilson, myself, John Hume and the endeavour to put together an alternative to armed struggle. 'It took all that time to do that, but that's what the IRA said in its statement, that they believed there was now a peaceful way to pursue republican and democratic objectives, and ordered its volunteers to not be engaged in any other activity whatsoever, and authorised contact with the International Commission on Decommissioning. 'It took decades and one of my regrets is that it took so long. In my humble opinion it took so long because the two governments, particularly the British government, only sought peace on its terms, which meant defeat the IRA, it meant defeat republicanism and that doesn't work, our people are resolute.' He added: 'The proof of it is that 20 years later the IRA isn't a feature. Some may want to make it a feature, invent, fabricate and so on, but that's the proof of it.' Asked whether he felt the IRA should issue an apology for all the lives lost by their actions, Mr Adam pointed to a statement in 2002 on the anniversary of Bloody Friday, a series of bombs across Belfast which claimed nine lives. It included an offer of 'sincere apologies and condolences' to the families of all 'non combatants' killed or injured by IRA actions. 'I think in fairness that the record will show that the IRA leadership have apologised on a number of occasions about specific incidents or operations which it was involved in, particularly around the issue of civilian casualties or fatalities,' he said. 'One of the big regrets that I have is that so many people were killed, and particularly people who weren't involved and particularly children, that's a real concern. 'I say that from a community and a family which lost loved ones in the course of all of this.' However, Mr Adams added that while he thinks it is important to look back over the last 20 years, it is also important to look forward to the next 20 years and a referendum on a united Ireland. 'One thing we can say with certainty is there is going to be a referendum on the future, the Irish Government doesn't want it, the British Government doesn't want it, unionists don't want it but there is going to be the day when people will vote for the future,' he said. 'Our responsibility, and for everyone who is concerned about the future, need to be part of the conversation well in advance of that vote. Whether it is about public services, health services, the economy, flags, emblems, taking all of those issues and trying to find solutions to them that allows everyone to be comfortable in the new Ireland. 'You rarely get the opportunity to write the future, and we now have that opportunity and its contained in the Good Friday Agreement.' 'I do know that there will be a united Ireland so whether it happens the day after I die or a couple of years before then. 'It is not inevitable, the forces against it are quite strong but if we work at it. 'If we continue to do the sensible, intelligent things that we have been trying to do, then – although I would love to live in a united Ireland – it matters little to me whether it happens after I die or before it. To be able to say in my own heart to say, 'I played a part in bringing that about', that'll do me.' Mr Adams was speaking ahead of an Feile An Phobail arts event this weekend to mark the anniversary. He will take part in a discussion alongside Mr Walsh, chaired by Sinn Fein Galway TD Mairead Farrell, at the Balmoral Hotel in Belfast on Saturday.
The Guardian
41 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Racing's D-day looms as proposed chief Lord Allen faces ‘sliding doors' moment
Around 80,000 people in Britain are employed in the horse racing industry. At least 1m adults are estimated to have a bet on the horses in any given month of the year. And it is a very fair bet that on the morning of 13 November last year, no more than one in every 1,000 of them had even heard of Lord Allen of Kensington CBE, who was about to be unveiled as the new chair of the British Horseracing Authority, the ruling body of Britain's second-biggest spectator sport. Lord Allen had, after all, had very little recorded contact with the sport of kings over the course of either a glittering business career in broadcasting, his time as a Labour party insider under Ed Milliband's leadership, or a dozen years in the House of Lords. But his lack of a racing background seemed less important than Lord Allen's well-connected position in what had recently become the ruling political party, and his track record with events including London's successful bid for the 2012 Olympics and, more recently, the Invictus Games. Beyond that, he could always learn on the job after assuming his new role on 1 June this year. Lord Allen has had plenty of contact with racing in the eight months' since his appointment was announced, however, which is the main reason why, nearly two months after his scheduled start date, his feet are still not under the BHA chairman's desk. The former chair of several multi-nationals took a long look at the BHA's governance structure, and in particular in the presence of members nominated by racing's various special-interest groups on the Authority's board, and did not like what he saw. He then went away and came back with an alternative vision. As a result, the 68-year-old will be cast in something akin to the Gwyneth Paltrow role on Monday as a sliding-doors drama with significant implications for a billion-pound industry unfolds at the BHA's offices in London. In one version of the story, Lord Allen will finally take over as the most powerful individual in British racing, having persuaded the vested interests and power blocs that currently hold sway on the BHA's board to, in effect, vote themselves into extinction. In the other, it will be a case of he came, he saw, he thought better of it. The first sign that Lord Allen was having second thoughts about his new role came just a few days before his intended start date, when the BHA somewhat sheepishly announced that, seven months after announcing his appointment, the new chair wanted more time to speak to stakeholders, 'to better inform his vision for the sport'. Lord Allen himself has been tight-lipped throughout, in public at least, but his vision, according to well-sourced reports in the Racing Post, includes the removal of stakeholder-nominated members from the BHA board and the division of the Authority into two parts, one entirely commercial in its outlook and the other in charge of rules and regulation. Lord Allen is hardly the first individual to ponder the twisted knot of factional self-interests that pervades every level of the British racing industry and suggest that something needs to be done. Most rational observers, either inside or outside the racing bubble, would probably reach the same conclusion after 10 minutes of consideration. But he is arguably the first to do so before being sucked into racing's political quicksand, where time stands still and a little foot-dragging here or there is more than enough to ensure that meaningful progress is always another a year or two away. A ruling body with a board focused entirely on the long-term health and interests of horse racing as a whole would be a first for British racing. Whether Lord Allen can get it across the line, however, is still far from certain. Special-interest groups proliferate in racing for a reason: it is not one sport, one business or even, as racehorse breeders will confirm, a single industry. It is a collection of many different businesses, from five-horse jumping stables to the uber-strings in Newmarket, from glittering venues like Ascot, the stage for Saturday's King George, to small independent tracks like Pontefract and Newton Abbot. Owners, breeders and even jockeys (within reason) can also come in all shapes and sizes. The two biggest racecourse groups – Jockey Club Racecourses and Arena Racing Company (ARC) – also operate with very different business models. JCR's tracks, along with big independents like Ascot, Newbury and Goodwood, have high levels of raceday revenue from attendance. Many of ARC's meetings, by contrast, are staged in front of empty stands to keep off-course betting turnover rolling. ARC's biggest asset is the ownership of its fixtures. It will need a cast-iron guarantee that Lord Allen's 'commercial' ambitions for a body that does not, of itself, have a great deal to sell, will not impinge on that situation. Whether or not Lord Allen's ambitious restructuring might actually come to pass or instead fade swiftly into obscurity may become apparent shortly after the BHA's board meets on Monday. Similar aspirations for a less factional future have come to nothing in the past, but this could be the moment when Gwyneth finally gets onto the train. Four of the five runners in Saturday's King George VI & Queen Elizabeth Stakes at Ascot are closely matched on both ratings and recent form, and the outsider of that quartet, the ultra-dependable Rebel's Romance (4.10), has a better chance to record his first Group One win in Britain than a price of around 5-1 might suggest. Charlie Appleby's gelding has seven top-level wins to his name abroad including two victories in the Breeders' Cup Turf, but finished only third, behind Goliath and the subsequent Arc winner, Bluestocking, in last year's King George. Rebel's Romance was better than the bare result, however, having raced much closer to an unrelenting pace than either of the horses that came past him a furlong out. In a smaller field and a more conventionally-run race, the seven-year-old's class and willingness to battle all the way to the line could be too much for his younger opponents. Ascot 1.40 A wide-open renewal of this Group Three for juvenile fillies, with Fitzella perhaps the pick of the prices at around 5-1 to build on her three-length fourth at Royal Ascot last time. York 2.00 Normal improvement from his first run for 149 days would see Jubilee Walk go close in an ultra-competitive sprint. Ascot 2.20 Royal Dress won with plenty to spare last time and could be a stern opponent for the improving Chantilly Lace. York 2.40 The exciting Almaqam has ground conditions to suit and should follow up his last-time out defeat of the subsequent Prince Of Wales's Stakes winner, Ombudsman. Ascot 3.00 Billyjoh had little chance from his draw over track and trip at the Royal meeting but has a better pitch here and plenty of pace among the high numbers to carry him into the race. Ascot 1.10 Dark Shore 1.40 Fitzella 2.20 Royal Dress 3.00 Billyjoh (nap) 3.35 Bopedro 4.10 Rebel's Romance (nb) 4.45 Kuredu King 5.15 Aramram York 1.25 Golden Palace 2.00 Jubilee Walk 2.40 Almaqam 3.20 Copper Knight 3.50 Chillingham 4.25 Tele Red 5.00 Kisskodi Chester 1.30 Kokinelli 2.10 Oratorical 2.45 Vince Le Prince 3.15 Arabian Cobra 3.45 Aces Wild 4.20 Stash The Cash 4.55 Kodiac Thriller 5.30 Ey Up Its The Boss Newcastle 1.52 Crownthorpe 2.30 Fast Fred 3.08 Beny Nahar 3.40 Sheriff's Court 4.15 Newyorkstateofmind 4.50 Greenlightforgo 5.25 Elettaria 5.55 Poet Windsor 5.45 Desert Treasure 6.15 Startled Lady 6.45 Offiah's Boy 7.15 Lady In Havana 7.45 Lahina Bay 8.15 Rage Of Thunder 8.45 Fancy Dancer Salisbury 6.00 Lost Signal 6.30 Addison Grey 7.00 The Bitter Moose 7.30 Patsy Snugfit 8.00 Twilight Moon 8.30 Alice's Impact York 3.20 The evergreen Copper Knight looks the safest option in this annual sprint for jump jockeys, at a track where he already has seven wins to his name. Ascot 3.35 David O'Meara's Bopedro is in the form of his life at nine years of age and looks big at around 10-1 to register a first win since the summer of 2023.
JAMnews
an hour ago
- JAMnews
British Embassy: "Georgian Dream has distanced itself from Euro-Atlantic cooperation"
UK regrets Georgian Dream's actions The British Embassy in Georgia has published a statement on sanctions against 21 Russian military intelligence agents and four Russian organizations 'in response to Russia's hostile actions.' The statement also mentions a cyberattack carried out by Russian military intelligence against Georgia in 2019. The Embassy reaffirms its strong support for Georgia's sovereignty and territorial integrity and expresses regret over the ruling Georgian Dream party's drift away from Euro-Atlantic cooperation. The text of the statement: 'In concert with the EU, NATO and a large coalition of states, the UK has called out Russia's irresponsible, destructive and destabilising hybrid activity targeting the UK, Ukraine, NATO allies and partners across the world. In response to Russia's persistent hostile activity, the UK has sanctioned 4 entities and 21 operatives of Russian military intelligence for irresponsible and destructive hybrid activity targeting the UK, Ukraine, and the wider world. This includes one of the units of the GRU – Russian military intelligence agency – which, in 2022, conducted online reconnaissance to help target missile strikes against Mariupol – including the strike that destroyed the Mariupol Theatre where hundreds of civilians, including children, were murdered. We have also sanctioned three leaders of Russia's 'Africa Initiative', a Foreign Information Manipulation and Influence (FIMI) outlet established and funded by Russia, employing Russian intelligence officers to conduct information operations in West Africa. Africa Initiative attempted to undermine lifesaving global health initiatives in the region by pushing baseless conspiracy theories to further the Kremlin's political agenda. The activity exposed is another demonstration of how hybrid activity – including through cyberspace and disinformation – are a tool in Russia's ongoing campaign to destabilise Europe, and in Russia's brutal and unprovoked war of aggression against Ukraine. In October 2019, Georgia was also the subject of a damaging cyber-attack by the Russian military intelligence. In February 2020, the UK Government and its partners exposed these cyber-attacks against Georgia as part of Russia's long-running campaign of hostile and destabilising activity. We have been clear that the GRU conducted these cyber-attacks in an attempt to undermine Georgia's sovereignty, to sow discord and disrupt the lives of ordinary Georgian people. The UK remains unwavering in its support for Georgia's sovereignty and territorial integrity. The UK and Georgia worked together to build cyber resilience and to publicly attribute that attack, unfortunately Georgian Dream has moved away from Euro-Atlantic co-operation, but the threat from Russia remains, including in the cyber sphere.' News in Georgia
