How to Be More Charismatic, but Not Too Much More
Want to stay current with Arthur's writing? Sign up to get an email every time a new column comes out.
A special quality sets some people apart from the crowd. They are magnetic to be around, attractive to watch, hypnotic to listen to. They have, in a word, charisma. It seems like a divine grace—indeed, the word derives from the ancient Greek χάρισμα, meaning 'God's gift.' The word appeared in third-century B.C.E. Greek translations of the Hebrew Bible, and early Christians referred to charismata as blessings bestowed on believers such as prophecy, healing, and speaking in tongues.
Our modern usage of charisma comes from the early-20th-century sociologist Max Weber, who called it a 'certain quality of an individual personality, by virtue of which he is set apart from ordinary men and treated as endowed with supernatural, superhuman, or at least specifically exceptional powers or qualities.' And today, the concept of charisma is having a moment in the abbreviated slang term rizz, which, in Generation Z vernacular, describes one's ability to charismatically court a romantic partner. It involves a notable power to impress others with smooth talk, confidence, or style—a skill we'd probably all like to have, beyond the domain of romance.
Do you have charisma? Would your life be better if you had more? Or is it, like fame, a blessing that hides a curse? The idea of being more charismatic certainly seems appealing, but here's what science can tell you about whether this elusive rizz is a divine gift or a false friend.
[From the September 2016 issue: The charisma effect]
A number of psychologists have looked for charisma's seemingly magic ingredients. One of the most cited studies on the topic, from the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2018, argues that charisma is actually a combination of two traits: influence (the ability to guide others with confidence and competence) and affability (the ability to make other people feel comfortable and at ease). Influence is judged based on qualities such as one's presence in a room, magnetism, and leadership ability. People see affability in, among other traits, frequency of smiling, approachability, and projection of positive energy.
Leaders use their charisma to influence others in very specific ways. By analyzing speeches given by charismatic individuals, one helpful model shows a distinct, three-stage use of emotion. First, the speakers model and amplify the mood prevailing among their audience ('We are angry because those people over there are bad!'). Then they introduce a dissonant emotion that actually confuses people ('But you know what? I don't really care about that.'). Finally, they use that confusion to reframe the emotional environment and win over the audience to their view ('Because we should be happy that we are better people than they are!').
You will not be surprised to learn that charisma and professional success are strongly associated. Researchers following people's careers find that charisma early in life predicts a higher income 15 years later, as well as the managerial level a person achieves and the number of subordinates they have. However, this relationship appears to be curvilinear. Scholars in 2018 showed that people with a more charismatic personality are judged to be a more effective leader, but only up to about the 60th percentile. Beyond that point, perceived leadership effectiveness associated with charisma starts to decline. The authors of that study believed this was because extremely charismatic leaders tend to be strong on imparting a vision but weak on implementing it.
Another possible reason why a very high level of charisma may lower the perceived effectiveness of a leader is the possible connection with narcissism. High charisma is specifically associated with people whom psychologists label 'agentic narcissists'; these people are extremely self-assured (whereas 'antagonistic narcissists' are mean and aggressive, and not perceived as charismatic at all). You can probably think of individuals whose charismatic qualities make them an effective leader up to a point, but tip over into being off-putting and arousing suspicion.
[Tom F. Wright: The origin of vibes]
In short, charisma might be a trait you'd want to increase—within reasonable limits. Of course, if charismatic individuals are simply born with the gift, this is a moot point. Some charisma, no doubt, is innate. We know, say, that attractive people are perceived as more charismatic than unattractive people; the same is true of more intelligent people. Charisma is also strongly correlated with personality traits, which are 40 to 60 percent heritable. Here, extroverts have the advantage because they tend to be high in influence and affability, while introverts score low on both.
Yet ample evidence exists that charisma can be cultivated. Last year, three Israeli researchers created a virtual-reality device called the 'Charismulator' to help people develop a more appealing communication style, both verbal and nonverbal. Subjects who trained for only a few minutes with the device were judged by others to have 17 percent more 'general charisma' than they'd had before the intervention.
The nonverbal-communication training exposed the participants to emphatic body gestures that conveyed a message, warm facial expressions, and powerful voice inflections—all demonstrated by charismatic speakers. You can re-create this input easily by reading the words of famous orators (think Abraham Lincoln and Martin Luther King Jr.), and studying videos of great speakers on YouTube. I stumbled on my own version of this method of the Charismulator intervention early in my public-speaking career, by listening to audio recordings of great communicators. I took copious notes on the speakers I admired, and accepted every invitation to talk in order to practice what I was learning. (Your nephew's bar mitzvah in February in Fairbanks, Alaska? I'll be there!)
Anyone can improve their charismatic presence by being conscious of using these physical gestures, but it takes practice to make learned charisma stick. The early feedback I got on my public speaking did not include the phrase incredible charisma. The first notes were more like 'paces like a caged animal' and 'terrifying amount of eye contact.' With time, I did get better at it—fortunately.
[Read: The perils of charisma]
One question I haven't answered yet—and given this column's remit, you might be thinking that was a strange oversight: Does possessing charisma make you happier? I have found no evidence that addresses this topic head-on. Although you might assume that charisma would deliver happiness, one line of research gives me pause. One human capacity that strongly predicts charisma but is most definitely not correlated with higher happiness is self-consciousness—that is, thinking frequently about yourself. Charismatic people do think about themselves a lot—and that characteristic, as I have previously discussed, usually brings unhappiness.
When it comes to happiness, much can be said for accepting who you are, rather than constantly worrying about what impression you're making on others. So yes: You probably can get more rizz, but you might want to skip it and have more peace of mind instead.
Article originally published at The Atlantic
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Woman Wants to Skip Mother-in-Law's Birthday After Feeling 'Emotionally Depleted' Trying to Maintain Their Relationship
After enduring years of subtle jabs and backhanded compliments, one woman decides it may be time to skip her mother-in-law's birthday celebration A woman seeks advice from the Reddit community following a decision that has sparked tension in her family: she doesn't want to attend her mother-in-law's birthday dinner this year. While she admits it's just one evening, she's emotionally drained from years of uncomfortable encounters and thinly veiled criticism. 'My in-laws present themselves as easygoing, religious Christians,' she writes in her post, 'but in reality they can be quite judgmental and snobbish.' She adds that both she and her husband are aware of this dynamic, having dealt with numerous situations where they were made to feel like the problem, even when her in-laws were the ones bending the truth. Her mother-in-law, she says, has always made her feel uneasy. 'She often talks about her career peak from 30 years ago and seems to evaluate other women through that lens,' she shares, adding that the compliments she does receive feel less than sincere. What makes matters worse is how fixated her mother-in-law seems to be on her sister, someone she's only met once. 'We suspect it's because my sister happens to live and work in a city my mother-in-law used to visit for business,' the woman explains. 'It feels like some strange competitiveness or projection.' This strange dynamic has even been noticed by others, including the woman's own mother. 'My mom has noticed how fake-nice my mother-in-law acts when my sister is mentioned,' she writes, which has led her and her husband to start 'gatekeeping info about her to avoid the tension.' The emotional distance was clear from day one, even on the woman's wedding day. 'The only thing she said to me was 'Your dress is nice,' ' she recalls. 'No congratulations, no meaningful words — just that.' Now, with another birthday approaching, the woman is torn between keeping the peace and protecting her own mental well-being. 'I know it's just one dinner, but I always leave feeling emotionally depleted,' she writes. Her husband, she says, understands her feelings, but both are aware that skipping the event might stir up even more drama. Her mother-in-law 'treats her birthday like a major life event,' she explains, adding that while she respects that, she personally doesn't care much for birthdays. In previous years, she has gone out of her way to be thoughtful and generous. 'I've given her thoughtful gifts — a Kindle, a very luxurious hand cream,' she shares, but notes with disappointment that she's never seen her mother-in-law use them or even acknowledge them afterward. 'It's not about the gifts,' she realizes. 'She just wants people physically present for the performance of it.' She points to last year as an example, when her mother-in-law had three separate groups bring her cakes. The woman and her husband took her out to a nice dinner that evening, deliberately skipping dessert, believing it would align with her focus on healthy eating. 'She still seemed disappointed as if we were supposed to bring a fourth cake,' she writes. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. The invitation this year was similarly off-putting. 'Just yesterday, while we were at her house, she suddenly said to me: 'Let's eat on 5th September, I think you'll be free,' ' she shares, noting how it wasn't even framed as a question or discussed like a typical invitation. That moment hit a nerve for her, as her mother-in-law rarely speaks to her directly about other family gatherings. 'But when it's her birthday, she always corners me like this,' she adds. It's not just about one dinner or one awkward exchange. 'I'm struggling to celebrate someone who never connects with me emotionally, never appreciates the gifts I give,' she writes, 'and seems happiest when she's comparing me or my family unfavorably to hers.' Now she's left wondering if she's in the wrong for not wanting to go. 'AITA for wanting to sit this one out?' she asks, openly looking for guidance. 'If yes, what should I do?' Read the original article on People Solve the daily Crossword


Atlantic
11 hours ago
- Atlantic
The Psychological Secret to Longevity
Your subjective sense of things going slowly, and then speeding up, is real. But you can also control it. Illustration by Jan Buchczik Want to stay current with Arthur's writing? Sign up to get an email every time a new column comes out. W hen I was 9 years old , Thursday was my favorite day of the week, for one very special reason: I had my beloved weekly French-horn lesson. I remember thinking that Thursdays felt as though they came only about once a month. Some five decades later, Thursdays still have a special significance for me—as the day my Atlantic column comes out. But unlike the way I felt so many years ago, I now feel as though Thursdays occur about every three or four days. The weekly thing seems to come around much sooner than every week. What gives? This phenomenon of time seeming to speed up with age—or, for that matter, slow down under the influence of boredom or frustration—attracts a good deal of wonderment. The jarring juxtaposition of clock and calendar time with the subjective experience of time's passing can make life feel like a poorly dubbed movie. You may simply have assumed that your sense of time was unreliable, but the truth is more complicated—and interesting. An entire science and philosophy of perception explains this warping of time. Whether time speeds by or crawls along, a grasp of this concept can help you make the most of your life. Read: Being powerful distorts people's perception of time W e tend to think of time as a dimension of physics, but philosophers have much to say about its mysteries. A principal target of their skeptical scrutiny is whether time manifests objective linearity. The French philosopher Henri Bergson, for example, introduced the idea of time as a truly subjective unit of experience. A minute is not 60 ticks of a hand on the clock but rather a quantum of your individual existence. The size of that quantum depends on what you are doing: It is very small when you are sleeping; it is very large when you are waiting in line at Starbucks. We need artificial, objective measures of time—clocks and calendars—to manage many aspects of a functioning society, but clock time is no more 'real' than the map on your phone is the actual road you are driving on. Bergson's 19th-century compatriot Paul Janet argued that the size of a unit of time is primarily a function of age, because a person's perception of time depends on how much time they have themselves experienced. In other words, time truly does speed up as you get older. In 2017, a group of psychologists working from estimates that people gave of how they perceived the passage of time at different ages showed that most of us do experience this sense of acceleration. Many researchers believe that time perception shifts in a logarithmic way, and some social scientists have found evidence supporting this idea: In one 2009 experiment, study participants reported that the next three months seemed to them in that moment like three months, whereas when they were asked to contemplate a period of 36 months in the future, that felt like less than six months in today's terms. I have created my own equation that provides similar modeling of 'experienced life' (EL) at different ages. You need to specify your current age (a) and your expected age at death (n). Then the subjective years of life you have left is 1 minus EL multiplied by n. The numbers it generates are a bit discouraging, I'll admit. According to actuarial tables, given the good health I still enjoy at 61, I have even odds of making it to 95. That seems overly optimistic, given my family history, but I would certainly take an extra 34 years on the planet. Unfortunately, according to my formula inspired by our French philosopher friends, most of those 35 years are 'fake' because I have already experienced 91 percent of my life, which implies that I have only about eight subjective years left. If I live not to 95 but to 80, I have just five and a half years to go. No more waiting in the Starbucks line for me! (Or so you might think; more on this below.) Age is not the only reason that experienced time might be compressed. Another is your circadian rhythms. In 1972, a French explorer named Michel Siffre spent six months in an underground cave in Texas, living with a complete absence of natural light, clock, and calendar. Gradually, his 'days'—periods of being awake and asleep—began to stretch, sometimes to as long as 48 hours. When he emerged, he believed that he had been in the cave for only two or three months. If you struggle to get to sleep at night, your time perception might be a less extreme version of Siffre's. Researchers have found that some people have a natural circadian rhythm of more than 24 hours, meaning that days feel a bit too short and that these people are chronically not sleepy at night. If you lived in a cave, your life would have fewer days than those measured out in standard 24-hour chunks. Perception of time accelerates not just with age and circadian rhythms; it can also speed up—or slow down—depending on what you are experiencing at any given moment. This phenomenon is called tachypsychia. Neuroscientists have shown through experiments with mice that when levels of dopamine are elevated because of excitement and engagement, time passes more quickly in the brain; when dopamine is depressed because of boredom or anxiety, time goes by more slowly. In other words, time really does fly when you're having fun. An extreme form of tachypsychia involves time seeming to freeze—when a few moments seem like minutes or hours, and you remember them clearly for years afterward. This can be a positive experience, such as a 10-second roller-coaster ride, or negative, such as a car accident that your brain processes in ultra-slow motion. One hypothesis for this tachypsychic phenomenon is that during these extremely intense moments, you lay down memories very densely in the brain, which makes a moment's experience seem to endure an unusually long time. Read: Why a healthy person's perception of time is inaccurate A ll of the philosophy and research of experienced time yields this bitter irony: The more you enjoy yourself, especially in the second half of life, the faster time passes. So how can you alter this effect and live, subjectively speaking, longer? One answer is to spend more time tapping your foot impatiently in the Starbucks line, especially the older you get. Also, be sure to get into a lot of car accidents. ('Officer, I ran all those red lights because I am trying to live longer. I read it in The Atlantic.') If the boredom or trauma strategies don't suit you—and I don't recommend them—here are some better ways to get greater value from your scarce time. 1. Meaning is greater than fun. An important principle of time maximization is memory, as the accident example suggests: The denser your memories from an experience, the longer it seems to go on in the moment and the better you recall it later, in all its rich, imprinted detail. You don't have to leave this to chance—and especially not to an accident. Research suggests that your memory is enhanced by significant, emotionally evocative activities, which implies that a truly long life favors the pursuit of deep meaning over simple fun. I find this true when I recall a spiritual experience such as walking the Camino de Santiago with my wife in a way I can savor—whereas a beach vacation that lasted the same number of days on the calendar went by very pleasantly, but without leaving much trace of its significance. I think of one as lasting, in every sense; the other, as fleeting. 2. Savor the moments. Part of seeking meaning is to be strategic in your choice of activities and partners. But another part of the task requires you to be purposeful and present in your life. I have written before about the art of savoring life, which psychologists define as the 'capacity to attend to, appreciate, and enhance the positive experiences.' This means paying full attention to whatever you are doing now, instead of thinking about whatever might come next. To expand my perception of time while savoring, I try to include not just the positive experiences but also negative ones—rather than trying to eliminate them as quickly as possible. Although that practice can be hard at first, it ends up making me feel more fully alive. 3. Avoid routine. I have moved home a lot in my adult life—about 20 times in the past 40 years. (No, I am not in a witness-protection program.) I also travel almost every week. One reason for this is that I'm allergic to routine. Some people like a predictable commute to work and seeing the same people and things every day, but I am not one of them. This restless bias of mine does create some transaction costs, but the constant novelty has the benefit of giving me denser memories and thus the sensation of a longer life. Researchers have run experiments that show that when people pursue familiar activities, time goes by more quickly, whereas unfamiliar experiences slow time down. Routines put you on autopilot, and that makes savoring difficult and its rewards elusive. You might not want to go so far as to move house, which is certainly stressful, but you can do a lot to change up your environment, your daily habits, and the people you see. Arthur C. Brooks: How to be your best despite the passing years O ne more point in closing: The most important principle in managing your time well is not how much of it you have, or how long you can extend it, but how you use each moment of it. We tend to act as though our lives will go on forever, so we waste time on trivial activities (scrolling) or participate in unproductive ones (meetings). This is not a new problem. The Stoic philosophers of antiquity recognized it well, which is why they used the adage memento mori ('remember you will die') to guide their meditations. By focusing on nonbeing, they argued, you will appreciate being more fully. That consciousness, whether your life goes by quickly or slowly, will help you use your time well. On that note, I am pondering the fact that one Thursday will be my last column. But this is not it, which makes me happy. Arthur C. Brooks is a contributing writer at The Atlantic and the host of the How to Build a Happy Life podcast. To receive his weekly column 'How to Build a Life' in your inbox, sign up here.

Miami Herald
2 days ago
- Miami Herald
Popular pizza chain makes drastic store expansion move
When you think of some of the hottest destinations for pizza around the world, a few cities probably come to mind. Naples, which is purportedly the birthplace of pizza, is known for its fresh, garden-style Neapolitan pizza. Related: Home Depot is quietly beating out Lowe's in urgent customer race The pies tend to have thin crust and feature tomatoes, medallions of mozzarella, and fresh basil. The crust is often airy and puffy, since the pizza is baked at high temperatures in a wood fired oven. Sometimes they're even drizzled in olive oil for a fresh twist. You might also associate New York with pizza. New York slices tend to differ from Neapolitan ones. These pizzas are often large and foldable, with doughy, hand tossed crust that tends to be chewier, thanks to its higher gluten content. If you're sticking around the states, there are plenty more types of pizza to test out. Detroit style (which is square or rectangular with very thick crust) and deep dish Chicago style pizza (which often features the tomato sauce on top of the pie) are popular in the Midwest. There's also Sicilian, Greek, Californian, St. Louis, and New Haven style pizzas. And, depending on where you live, you probably have very strong opinions on which kind is best. Many purists will probably tell you that pizzas are supposed to be hand made, hand tossed, and topped with freshly grown ingredients from your family's backyard garden. Unfortunately for most of the world, that's not really a possibility. Most of us are far too busy to tend a personal pizza garden, and the cost and time commitment associated with hand-preparing a pizza whenever we're in the mood for one are simply too high. MORE RETAIL: Popular Mexican chain closing all restaurants, no bankruptcyHome Depot local rival closing permanently after 120 yearsAmazon makes a harsh decision amid concerning customer trendHuge bankrupt retail chain closing down all stores after 80 years So we turn to the next best thing. If you're lucky enough to live near a regional sensation, like Sally's in New Haven or Giordano's in Chicago, getting a quality slice isn't too hard. But bringing affordable pizza to the masses or remote parts of the population is no easy task. And that's where franchises come in. Franchises like Domino's, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesar's are some of the most popular shops in the U.S. And since the U.S. exports most of our culture to the rest of the world, some top franchises have spread and gained popularity in recent years. And now, Little Caesar's has agreed to partner with North Sun Energy to bring the largest franchise to Canada. North Sun Energy is a gas and convenience store chain popular along the Atlantic part of Canada with over 100 locations. It will install 18 Little Caesar's pizza outlets alongside the convenience store stations, offering easy access for hungry travelers. Each store will be small format, about 450 square feet, and have just a couple of employees. The new pizza shops will be across: Newfoundland and LabradorNova ScotiaPrince Edward Island This partnership makes Little Caesar's the third largest pizza chain in the world, and it means Canada now has a Little Caesar's in every province. The Arena Media Brands, LLC THESTREET is a registered trademark of TheStreet, Inc.