The Morrison government wanted to divert students from arts degrees. The result is all ancient Greek to me
I did end up choosing arts. But what I didn't realise was that the scheme would continue to push me away from studying areas I'm passionate about, through the bizarre cost discrepancies between different arts subjects.
Take my semester 1 subjects: literature and French were each $578. Creative writing and political theory were $2124 each.
I was shocked when I received that first fee statement. My choice of study area would determine whether I paid about $2000 for a single subject or an entire semester. My whole degree could cost anywhere between $14,000 and $50,000. And I couldn't understand the rationale behind these disparities. If, as it professed to do, the scheme's pricing system aimed to incentivise 'vocational' study areas, why were literature graduates considered four times more employable than politics students?
When I investigated further, I found the discrepancies between the cost of arts subjects even more perplexing. 'Indigenous Australian art histories' is twice as expensive as 'Art history: Australian art'. 'Aboriginal writing' is double the price of 'the Australian imaginary'. First Nations voices and history were long overlooked in university settings – why would these subjects be priced more prohibitively?
Whether there's an agenda there or not, the average arts student, in choosing between these two art history or literature subjects, would almost certainly be influenced by the significant price difference. I would be.
Likewise, gender studies sits within the highest price bracket, costing $2124 per subject. Amid a domestic violence epidemic and a rising wave of youth misogyny, students who attempt to understand the nature and history of gender-based discrimination are slapped with a financial penalty. And if the rationale behind this is employability, it's hard to argue that the high fees reflect the supposedly non-vocational nature of this study area, when Latin sits at the opposite end of the fee spectrum.
In fact, any argument that arts subject prices are determined by their vocational value seems void when you compare the prices of psychology and media with ancient Greek.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
13 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Day was accepted into a prestigious US art school. Then the social media rules changed
He said his accounts did not contain anything controversial: 'Just my art.' Dang, 19, is already a highly accomplished painter and drawer. At age 15 he was a finalist in the Lester Prize Youth Competition, and at 17 he made the shortlist for the Brisbane Portrait Prize Next Gen category. A watercolour painting of a white rabbit won him a prize from US Artist Magazine. His art often portrays family members and friends of different ethnic backgrounds that he met while a student at Brisbane State High School. With his four-year course in Providence commencing in August, Dang now faces the possibility of commencing late, or not at all. Associate Professor Anna Boucher, a University of Sydney expert in immigration policy, said any complexity added to the visa process, such as social media vetting, would slow down an already slow process. 'America has very high backlogs,' she said. Often with backlogs, it was 'simply not enough people in an immigration department compared to the pressures on the system. 'And it's also against the broader context of administrative cuts in the United States.' A spokesperson for the US Consulate General in Sydney said there were many potential students applying in the run-up to the start of the academic school year. 'In every case, consular officers will take the time necessary to ensure an applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and security of the United States and that he or she has credibly established his or her eligibility for the visa sought,' they said. The US State Department website has a guide to visa appointment wait times at all embassies. When this masthead checked, the next available appointment in Sydney for an F visa was in one month's time. Complicating matters for Tianzheng is the fact he is not yet an Australian citizen and had to apply for the F-1 on a Chinese passport. Tianzheng was born in Shanghai and moved to Brisbane with his family in 2018 at the age of 12. In May, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced the US was revoking student visas for Chinese students and would enhance its scrutiny of future applications. However, that directive appeared to be walked back two weeks later when President Trump announced a trade agreement with China. In April, Rhode Island School of Design president Crystal Williams announced in a public letter to the campus community that an international student already enrolled at RISD had had their visa terminated. However, Williams later advised this termination had been reversed. Its website advises: 'In recent weeks, the US federal administration has enacted a series of executive orders and policy changes that may impact the RISD community and our work.' '… We anticipate visa applicants may face more rigorous vetting, which could result in longer processing times including administrative processing delays by the US State Department.' Loading Boucher said it would be unclear if Chinese students hoping to study in the US were being disadvantaged until the data was available. 'For all the crackdown on international students, I think the Trump administration would realise that it would not be rational in terms of the profit losses from the international student market,' she said. In the meantime, Dang is awaiting a final decision on his visa application.
The Age
13 minutes ago
- The Age
Day was accepted into a prestigious US art school. Then the social media rules changed
He said his accounts did not contain anything controversial: 'Just my art.' Dang, 19, is already a highly accomplished painter and drawer. At age 15 he was a finalist in the Lester Prize Youth Competition, and at 17 he made the shortlist for the Brisbane Portrait Prize Next Gen category. A watercolour painting of a white rabbit won him a prize from US Artist Magazine. His art often portrays family members and friends of different ethnic backgrounds that he met while a student at Brisbane State High School. With his four-year course in Providence commencing in August, Dang now faces the possibility of commencing late, or not at all. Associate Professor Anna Boucher, a University of Sydney expert in immigration policy, said any complexity added to the visa process, such as social media vetting, would slow down an already slow process. 'America has very high backlogs,' she said. Often with backlogs, it was 'simply not enough people in an immigration department compared to the pressures on the system. 'And it's also against the broader context of administrative cuts in the United States.' A spokesperson for the US Consulate General in Sydney said there were many potential students applying in the run-up to the start of the academic school year. 'In every case, consular officers will take the time necessary to ensure an applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and security of the United States and that he or she has credibly established his or her eligibility for the visa sought,' they said. The US State Department website has a guide to visa appointment wait times at all embassies. When this masthead checked, the next available appointment in Sydney for an F visa was in one month's time. Complicating matters for Tianzheng is the fact he is not yet an Australian citizen and had to apply for the F-1 on a Chinese passport. Tianzheng was born in Shanghai and moved to Brisbane with his family in 2018 at the age of 12. In May, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced the US was revoking student visas for Chinese students and would enhance its scrutiny of future applications. However, that directive appeared to be walked back two weeks later when President Trump announced a trade agreement with China. In April, Rhode Island School of Design president Crystal Williams announced in a public letter to the campus community that an international student already enrolled at RISD had had their visa terminated. However, Williams later advised this termination had been reversed. Its website advises: 'In recent weeks, the US federal administration has enacted a series of executive orders and policy changes that may impact the RISD community and our work.' '… We anticipate visa applicants may face more rigorous vetting, which could result in longer processing times including administrative processing delays by the US State Department.' Loading Boucher said it would be unclear if Chinese students hoping to study in the US were being disadvantaged until the data was available. 'For all the crackdown on international students, I think the Trump administration would realise that it would not be rational in terms of the profit losses from the international student market,' she said. In the meantime, Dang is awaiting a final decision on his visa application.
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
Leading unions pressure government to bolster taxes and reform negative gearing in major blow to Anthony Albanese's productivity agenda
The Australian Council of Trade Unions has urged the government to make mammoth changes to numerous policies that would raise $25 billion per year in new taxes as Anthony Albanese's productivity agenda comes under threat. The government has come under fire in recent weeks for touting new taxes ahead of it's highly anticipated economic reform roundtable in late August, with the Coalition warning that fresh levies were not the right approach to lift the nations productivity slump. It was reported on Thursday that Treasurer Jim Chalmers was eyeing lifting the effective tax rate on Australia's 500 largest companies and reducing it for small businesses after the Productivity Commission proposed a new cashflow tax that would boost investment by up to $7.4 billion. The PC recommended the government cut the company tax rate for businesses with revenues under $1 billion while imposing a new 5 per cent net cashflow tax for all companies depending on how much they invest. It also called for a 20 per cent tax rate on profits for companies with annual revenues of up of to $1 billion. However, ACTU secretary Sally McManus urged the government to go a step further and make major reforms to negative gearing and capital gains tax and to further slap increased tax rates on family trusts and resources to alleviate the country's productivity woes. Ms McManus, who leads 38 unions, and 1.8 million workers said the government needed to pursue 'fair' redistribution of national wealth and that slashing regulation and red tape was not the answer. 'You can't address living standards without addressing housing affordability, so we are going to bring to the roundtable proposals that negative gearing and capital gains tax discounts and benefits should be limited to one investment property,' Ms McManus told The Australian. 'There should be attention paid to making sure that productivity gains are fairly distributed, just as much as we focus on an increasing the rate of productivity growth,' Representatives from the ACTU have received four of 24 invitations to the upcoming economic reform roundtable, with Ms McManus set to have a front row seat to productivity deliberations. She poured cold water on the Productivity Commission's claim that workers would score an estimated $14,000 a year if higher productivity expectations were met within the next decade and insisted that productivity gains needed to be shared equally. If negative gearing and the capital gains tax discount were limited to one property then this would generate $1.5 billion in savings and earnings. Ms McManus said the ACTU's proposal would exempt existing properties from being impacted by the new laws for five years. She also said on the ABC's Insiders program that the government needed to "bite the bullet' and that since 2019 'the problem has just got worse.' Nearly half of all Australian landlords had negatively geared properties according to Treasury's annual report released in December. She said that the government should no longer subsidise the ownership of numerous investment properties and that capital needed to flow throughout the economy and workforce equitably. The ACTU is also advocating for a significant shake-up of the resource and mining sector, including replacing the current petroleum resource rent tax with a 25 per cent export levy on revenues made from liquefied natural gas. Australia exported $65.2 billion in LNG in the 2024-25 financial year, and if applied a 25 per cent export levy would have collected $16.3 billion in tax as opposed to the $2 billion in revenue generated from the PRRT over the same period. The policy proposals will spark the ire of the housing and resources sector, who have not secured a spot at the upcoming roundtable. The ACTU will also implore the government to hike taxes for billionaires and family trusts with Ms McManus adding that the current taxation system needed a seismic overhaul centred on redistribution. 'We need to raise more revenue because if we want a living standards really good quality health system and education system and the NDIS, then you've got to make sure that you've got money to pay for it,' she said. If applied, the ACTU's tax proposals would generate $25 billion per year in fresh taxes, almost halving the governments forecasted deficits.
