Hakea Prison still breaching national and international human rights standards
An inspection found Hakea Prison in Canning Vale remained overcrowded, with some cells holding three prisoners despite being designed for one.
"The conditions are still in breach of international human rights," Inspector of Custodial Services Eamon Ryan told the ABC.
"The prison is full, way over capacity, and the prisoners that are being held there are not getting any sort of effective rehabilitation.
The prison is the state's main remand facility, mostly holding inmates who are yet to be sentenced.
Mr Ryan said the problem with a lack of rehabilitation went beyond individual prisoners.
"Most people who are in prison will one day be released from prison, and they'll be standing next to you in the shopping centre or on the street," he said.
"And if they don't get effective rehabilitation, they're more than likely to come out worse than they went in."
Longstanding problems came to a head in mid-2024 when Mr Ryan issued a show cause notice to the government over its running of the facility — one of the strongest warnings he can issue.
Since then, he said, there had been increased recruitment of prison officers to address staffing pressures and the creation of a task force to tackle other issues.
"Despite this, the men at Hakea are still being held in conditions that do not meet the basic level of decent treatment required under national and international human rights and standards," Mr Ryan's report reads.
"There is limited evidence available to me to show that the significant system level reform and change needed is likely to be achieved."
The report's first recommendation is for the government to hold a "formal inquiry" into problems at Hakea to work out a path forward.
"The problems in Hakea are symptomatic of the broader problems within the justice system," Mr Ryan said.
"I think we need to have a circuit breaker.
"We need to look at all options, not just how to manage prisons, not just how to have increased bed capacity.
"We need to look at diversion programs, we need to look at pre-release programs, we need to look at programs and rehabilitation within prison, and then better support once people are released from prison to help them not return to prison."
A family member of a prisoner who was recently in Hakea has described conditions as "barbaric", echoing many of Inspector Ryan's concerns.
The ABC has referred to the family member as Darren because he asked to remain anonymous due to an upcoming sentencing hearing.
"The conditions in the cells are unhygienic. There's cockroaches everywhere," he said.
"[They said] on one occasion there were 40 cockroaches overnight that they caught in one room, and three [people] to a cell.
Darren said he had tried to visit the family member six times over about two months, but half were cancelled before he could attend, which he blamed on short-staffing and lockdowns.
He said he used to believe in locking up prisoners and throwing away the key, but seeing a close family member's experience first-hand had completely changed his views.
"We should be putting money into the prisons to do rehabilitation because all we're doing in there is breeding offenders and turning them against the custodial system," he said.
The family member had recently been transferred to a different prison, Darren said, where they were doing "much better".
In a statement, the Justice Department said it was "actively implementing changes" at Hakea, including efforts to improve medical and custodial staffing.
"We remain committed to addressing issues identified by [the Inspector of Custodial Services] and delivering better conditions and outcomes for Hakea Prisoners," Director General Kylie Maj said.
Corrective Services Commissioner Brad Royce said a Hakea task force was working to improve the safety, care and welfare of prisoners and return to normal daily routines.
"Beyond Hakea, the department is also strategically managing the overall adult prisoner population across WA through a newly established adult prisoner population co-ordination working group," he said.
"This initiative demonstrates our commitment to systemic, state-wide solutions."
The department supported or supported in principle all of the recommendations it was responsible for, including allowing all prisoners access to at least one hour of fresh air each day, ensuring access to clean clothes and increasing access to social visits.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

ABC News
26 minutes ago
- ABC News
Clive Palmer's Mineralogy and Queensland Nickel Group say data stolen in cyber attack
The personal details of Clive Palmer's employees and associates, including bank records, may have been compromised during a ransomware cyber-attack last month. The data breach encompassed Mr Palmer's political parties and 11 entities associated with the entrepreneur and politician including Mineralogy and Queensland Nickel Group. A statement posted to the Mineralogy and Queensland Nickel websites said the breach extended to Waratah Coal Pty Ltd, Central Queensland Coal, Gladstone Pacific Nickel Limited, Palmer Coolum Resort, Blue Star Line, Palmer Motorama, Ausface, Drewmaster Pty Ltd, and Zeph Group entities. "The data records potentially include all emails to and from the Mineralogy and Queensland Nickel Group entities including their attachments," the statement read. Mineralogy and Queensland Nickel said they had secured systems and reported breaches to the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC) and the Australian Signals Directorate. Monash University cybersecurity expert Professor Nigel Phair said people associated with Mr Palmer's companies and political parties will not know if their data has been affected. "Once it's out there in the world the cyber criminals will use it for a variety of mechanisms," Dr Phair said. "We've really got no power in this, we can just be hyper-vigilant." It remains unclear whether any compromised data had been published by cyber criminals. Mineralogy and Queensland Nickel Group entities have been contacted for further comment. Dr Phair said unsophisticated cyber attacks on corporates had become too common. Dr Phair said Australia had enough legislation to hold corporates to account when data was not secured adequately. "We just need the legislation policed," he said. "The Australian Information Commissioner operates a notifiable data breach scheme, and they've got penalties including enforceable undertakings and in some cases fines of up to $50 million. "We haven't seen any fines handed out to organisations yet so it would be good to see a lot more of that happening." The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner said it was focused on ensuring all individuals were notified. An Australian Federal Police spokesperson said the AFP had not received a report of a crime in relation to the matter.

News.com.au
26 minutes ago
- News.com.au
‘Sweetest angel': Tragedy as beloved young mum and 2yo daughter killed in fiery car crash
A young mother and her toddler have been killed in a horror single-vehicle crash after their vehicle hit a tree and burst into flames in New South Wales, with bystanders claiming there was 'no possible way' to save them. Jendaya Stewart, 26, and her daughter Lillyannah, two, were travelling along Hat Head Road, in the tiny coastal town of Hat Head on the state's mid-north coast, about 9.40am on Thursday July 10 when their car smashed into the tree. Emergency services rushed to the scene and found the vehicle engulfed in flames. Fire and Rescue NSW crews extinguished the fire before police discovered the pair's bodies inside the vehicle. One local woman posted on social media that a friend was one of the first to see the crash and tried to save those inside. 'They tried to rescue them with a few others and sadly there was no way possible before the car went up,' she wrote. 'They are gutted.' Ms Stewart, affectionately known as 'Jen' or 'Jenny, was a proud Biripi and Thunggutti woman who had a passion for conservation and had worked with National Parks Conservation Association, The Green Army, and as an agricultural farm assistant at Orara High School over the years. The 26-year-old was remembered by her family as a 'loving mother' and 'beloved daughter', in a notice shared by Keith Logue & Sons funeral service on social media. 'Forever loved and deeply missed by all her family and friends,' the notice read. Her family said Lillyannah, nicknamed Lily, was 'beloved, adored and protected' by Ms Stewart, who welcomed her in September 2022. '(She was) nanny's sweetest angel and poppy's best mate,' the notice read. 'Loved to the moon and back by all her family. We will miss her sunshine and gorgeous smile in our lives'. Ms Stewart had shared a number of posts and photos of her daughter on social media 'Teaching my baby how to do the shuffle is so adorable,' she wrote in one post. Jo-Anne Dacker, Stewart's mother, told 7News her daughter had an 'immeasurable' love for Hat Head – the town where the crash occurred. 'She was so protective of the environment there,' she said. The small Hat Head community of 365 people expressed an outpouring of sympathy on social media following news of the crash. 'There has been an incredibly sad update on yesterday's crash on Hat Head Road,' an admin wrote on a community Facebook page earlier this month. 'The HHC Admin Team's deepest sympathies go to those in the car, and their friends and family. 'And to everyone in Hat Head and close by, we hope you all find the strength to get through this horrible event.' The federal MP for the region Pat Conaghan also shared the 'tragic news' on social media. 'My thoughts go to family and friends who are dealing with this unimaginable event,' the Nationals MP said at the time. 'To our community, a reminder to stay safe on our roads this holiday season, don't take risks, drive to the conditions and ensure your vehicle is maintained to safety standards. 'Any life lost on our roads is one life too many.' Ms Stewart and Lily will be farewelled in a funeral service at Coffs Harbour on August 2. Police are investigating the cause of the crash. A report will be prepared for the coroner.

ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
'What choice do we have?': SA Premier grapples with mounting demands for taxpayer bailouts
Who deserves a lifeline? That's the awkward question Premier Peter Malinauskas has been fielding during an eventful first week back from annual leave. In the government's view, the Whyalla steelworks and its more than 1,000 employees certainly fall into the deserving category. On Wednesday, the Premier announced the state government would stump up another $137.5 million to keep the steelworks running through its government-enforced administration process. That's on top of $192 million the government had already allocated to keep the steelworks afloat, bringing the total state contribution to $329.5 million. The Commonwealth has pledged an equal amount. Wednesday's extra funding, while lower than expected, is still a hefty chunk for a state government that's flagged it has limited capacity to fund major projects due to rising debt levels. And the steelworks are not the only ones in need of help. The Port Pirie lead smelter, which employs about 900 people on the Spencer Gulf, is losing tens of millions of dollars a month, according to owner Nyrstar Australia. The company, which also owns a zinc smelter in Hobart, is negotiating with the state and federal governments over a support package that could be worth hundreds of millions of dollars. Then, on Thursday, it was revealed SA's largest disability employment provider, Bedford Industries, was on the brink of administration — raising fears for the future of 1,400 people with disability. In both situations, the SA Premier has indicated the state government is ready to help with public money if need be. But does this set a precedent for every business or industry that is struggling? Asked this on Wednesday, the Premier said: "Well, what choice do we have?" "I think we have to be balanced and careful in the approach that we take and deliberate in our considerations," he said. "But I don't think there's anybody seriously suggesting that we should allow Port Pirie or Whyalla or our farmers or for people operating our coastline [affected by the algal bloom] just to be left to rack and ruin — that's not my view. "Governments have always played a role. Whenever there's been a crisis or a challenge, people turn to government, and that's a responsibility you have to be willing to take on." On Friday, after the Bedford situation came to light, Mr Malinauskas said: 'It's not my DNA just to sit back and watch a group of vulnerable people potentially be left in a situation where they're more vulnerable than they are already". James Hancock, deputy director of the University of Adelaide's SA Centre for Economic Studies, said the situations with Whyalla, Port Pirie and Bedford had left the government "between a rock and a hard place". He said government intervention to save a business meant "you then potentially have a queue of other businesses approaching you for support when they're in difficulty". "The state budget can afford to do it for an extended period, but the real issue is if you're doing this for an extended period, what are you doing for other sectors that come under pressure?" he said. "If it's not just Whyalla [and] you sort of end up with five, 10 sectors that need a lot of help on an ongoing basis, then that actually starts to become a really large budget burden. "There's a tension there and there's no easy answer." South Australia is not short of examples of what happens when a long-standing industry collapses and there is no white knight to save it. The death of the car manufacturing industry left its mark on Adelaide following the closure of Mitsubishi in 2008 and Holden in 2017. Meanwhile, the end of coal mining in Leigh Creek in 2015 saw that town's population shrink from 2,000 residents to just 100. Mr Hancock said the stakes were particularly high for regional cities that were reliant on a major employer. "Holden was located in the Adelaide metropolitan area … and people that were displaced from Holden in many instances were able to get employment elsewhere," he said. "If you think about the house values of those workers, there was no sort of real impact of any significance. "If you compare that with Whyalla, and if you had a situation where half the town was out of work and having to leave a job, it becomes almost impossible for people to sell housing. "The human consequences of a Whyalla closure would really be very large." That's the case Port Pirie Mayor Leon Stephens is now making amid the troubles associated with the Nyrstar plant. Mr Stephens, who is also a Liberal Party candidate at the 2026 state election, said the closure of the Port Pirie smelter would cause economic "devastation". "My perception of what a government should be doing, it should be looking after all sectors of community," he said. "When you've got … a major employer in a city and that person is struggling and it looks like it will bring the city to its knees, I think there's definitely a catalyst [for intervention]." The Premier was asked on Wednesday where he drew the line on whether to give an industry a bailout. He said it depended on "whether or not there's a future" for the industry in question. "While it is true that there's creative disruption in the marketplace all the time and we see businesses that's better years are past, the question is what are the years in front of us," he said. "Unless you can see a future, then maybe you have to say, 'look, something hit the fence and that's life'. "But for steelmaking … we know this country needs steel, for critical minerals [like at Port Pirie], the demand is going up not down. "So, there are futures there that are worthy of contemplation."