India says it will ‘never' restore Indus Waters Treaty with Pakistan
India will never restore the Indus Waters Treaty with neighbouring Pakistan, and the water flowing there will be diverted for internal use, says federal Home Minister Amit Shah.
India put into 'abeyance' its participation in the 1960 treaty, which governs the usage of the Indus River system, after 26 people were killed in Indian-administered Kashmir in April, in what New Delhi described as an act of terror backed by Pakistan.
Pakistan denied involvement in the incident, which led to days of fighting between the two nuclear powers – their worst military escalation in decades, bringing them to the brink of another war.
Despite a ceasefire agreed upon by the two nations last month, Shah said his government would not restore the treaty, which guaranteed water access for 80 percent of Pakistan's farms through three rivers originating in India.
'It will never be restored,' Shah told The Times of India newspaper in an interview on Saturday.
'We will take water that was flowing to Pakistan to Rajasthan by constructing a canal. Pakistan will be starved of water that it has been getting unjustifiably,' he added, referring to the northwestern Indian desert state.
The transboundary water agreement allows the two countries to share water flowing from the Indus basin, giving India control of three eastern Himalayan rivers – Ravi, Sutlej, and Beas – while Pakistan got control of the three western rivers – Jhelum, Chenab, and Indus.
The treaty also established the India-Pakistan Indus Commission, which is supposed to resolve any problems that arise. So far, it has survived previous armed conflicts and near-constant tensions between India and Pakistan over the past 65 years.
However, the comments from Shah, the most powerful minister in Prime Minister Narendra Modi's cabinet, have dimmed Islamabad's hopes for negotiations on the treaty in the near term.
Pakistan has not yet responded to Shah's comments. But it has said in the past that the treaty has no provision for one side to unilaterally pull back, and that any blocking of river water flowing to Pakistan will be considered 'an act of war'.
'The treaty can't be amended, nor can it be terminated by any party unless both agree,' Pakistani Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said last month.
Islamabad is also exploring a legal challenge to India's decision to hold the treaty in abeyance under international law.
Legal experts told Al Jazeera in April that the treaty cannot be unilaterally suspended, and that it can only be modified by mutual agreement between the parties.
'India has used the word 'abeyance', and there is no such provision to 'hold it in abeyance' in the treaty,' Ahmer Bilal Soofi, a Pakistani lawyer, told Al Jazeera. 'It also violates customary international laws relating to upper and lower riparian, where the upper riparian cannot stop the water promise for the lower riparian.'
Anuttama Banerji, a political analyst based in New Delhi, told Al Jazeera in April that the treaty might continue, but not in its present form.
'Instead, it will be up for 'revision', 'review' and 'modification' – all three meaning different things – considering newer challenges such as groundwater depletion and climate change were not catered for in the original treaty,' Banerji said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
11 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
EU-India FTA set to unlock economic opportunities
Agencies Brussels India and the European Union (EU) have nurtured a strong and evolving economic relations rooted in shared democratic values, strong complementarities, and a long-term vision of mutual prosperity. As the global trade architecture undergoes a profound transformation, driven by shifting supply chains, worsening -geopolitical conflicts, and sustainability imperatives, the proposed Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between India and the EU presents an unparalleled opportunity to redefine their economic partnership in the new global economic order. India's trade engagement with the EU dates back several decades, but the most significant turning point came in 1994 with the signing of the India–EU Cooperation Agreement. This accord laid the foundation for structured political and economic dialogue and paved the way for deeper commercial cooperation. Throughout the 2000s and early 2010s, India liberalized its trade regime and embraced global markets, leading to a surge in trade withthe EU. By 2006, India's exports to the EU stood at approximately $25 billion, and by 2018, they had nearly doubled. The trade basket expanded from traditional textiles and apparel to include pharmaceuticals, chemicals, auto components, and information technology services. Services trade witnessed rapid growth, with India consistently maintaining a surplus, particularly in IT and consulting. In recognition of this economic convergence, negotiations for a Broad-based Trade and Investment Agreement (BTIA) were launched in 2007. However, due to disagreements over tariff liberalization, intellectual property, and regulatory standards, talks stalled in 2013. Despite the pause, bilateral trade and investment ties remained resilient anddiversified. The post-COVID era provided a renewed impetus to reimagine global partnerships. Recognising the need for resilient supply chains and strategic diversification, India and the EU revived FTA negotiations in 2021. This time, the scope was broader and more forward-looking. Beyond trade in goods, the new talks aimed to cover services, investment protection, e-commerce, data governance, sustainability, and climate cooperation. The momentum received a further boost in March 2024 when India signed a landmark Trade and Economic Partnership Agreement (TEPA) with the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), comprising Switzerland, Norway, Iceland, and Liechtenstein. The TEPA, India's first FTA with a European economic bloc, is expected to act as a catalyst for the India–EU FTA. In early 2025, diplomatic exchanges intensified with high-level meetings aimed at addressing critical issues impeding the FTA. Discussions focused on India's tariff structures, particularly on automobiles, wines, and dairy products. European concerns about sustainability and climate alignment, and India's expectations around professional mobility and data adequacy. These exchanges underscored a shared political commitment to conclude the agreement, albeit with an understanding of its complexity. India's trade trajectory with the EU over the past decade reflects steady growth trajectory. In the financial year 2014–15, India exported goods worth approximately $49.3 billion from the EU and imported about $48.3 billion with a total trade of $97.3 billion. The bilateral trade in goods expanded substantially with EU in 2024-25 at $136.4 billion showing a growth of more than 40 percent with exports expanding to $75.75 billion and imports at $60 billion with a trade surplus of about $15.75 billion. The top 10 items of exports and imports with EU include include a variety of goods, with machinery and transport equipment, chemicals, and manufactured goods. India's top 10 import items from the EU include machinery and transport equipment, chemicals, manufactured goods, and mineral fuels. Specifically, India imports electrical machinery, organic chemicals, machinery (including nuclear reactors and boilers), mineral fuels, and manufactured goods. India-EU also hold a strong trade trajectory of more than $ 50 billion with India in a trade surplus with EU. The bilateral trade in goods and services is expected to double within the five years of comprehensive Free Trade Agreement with EU Alongside trade, investment flows between India and the EU have expanded considerably. The EU is India's largest source of foreign direct investment (FDI), accounting for nearly 16 percent of total FDI inflows since 2000. As of December 2024, the cumulative EU investment stock in India stood at approximately $119 billion, marking a sharp rise from around $91 billion in 2019. In the fiscal year 2024–25 alone, EU investments in India exceeded $17 billion. These flows have been directed towards high-growth sectors such as automotive manufacturing, renewable energy, pharmaceuticals, and digital infrastructure. Major European companies including Airbus, Siemens, Schneider Electric, and Bosch have not only expanded their Indian footprint but have also actively participated in technology transfers and skill development initiatives. Conversely, Indian investments in the EU have also shown a steady rise, reaching an estimated $11.2 billion by 2024. Indian firms such as Tata Motors, Infosys, Sun Pharma, and Wipro have made strategic investments into the European market through greenfield investments, joint ventures, and acquisitions. These ventures span across sectors such as automotive, life sciences, financial technology, and business consulting. This two-way investment flow reflects growing mutual confidence and underlines the interdependence of the two economies. As of 2025, the India–EU FTA negotiations have entered an advanced phase, though several complex issues are expected to come at conclusions soon. The EU is seeking substantial tariff cuts on sectors like automobiles and alcoholic beverages, India, in return, wants more liberal visa policies, mutual recognition of professional qualifications, and assurance on its data protection framework being deemed adequate under EU standards. A particularly contentious issue is the EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), which imposes levies on carbon-intensive imports such as steel and cement. Despite these challenges, both sides are exploring a phased or modular approach. A possible roadmap involves signing an 'early harvest' agreement covering low-sensitivity sectors such as textiles, pharmaceuticals, machinery, and IT services, followed by gradual liberalization in more sensitive areas. The successful implementation of the India–EFTA TEPA can offer useful lessons and establish trust around dispute resolution, labour standards, and environmental safeguards. Looking ahead, the future of India–EU bilateral economic relations appears promising. The EU is India's second-largest trading partner and a key source of capital, innovation, and clean technology. A comprehensive FTA could potentially double bilateral trade within five years and unlock new areas of cooperation. Digital trade stands out as a particularly promising domain, given India's prowess in IT and the EU's technological depth. Moreover, both partners are committed to climate goals under the Paris Agreement. This opens avenues for collaboration in green hydrogen, solar energy, electric vehicles, and circular economy models. Strategically, the India–EU partnership also serves as a hedge against rising protectionism and supply chain vulnerabilities. Amid growing geopolitical uncertainties, a robust India–EU economic corridor would not only strengthen regional stability but also reinforce global rules-based trade. The FTA, once concluded, could serve as a model for equitable, development-friendly trade agreements between developed and emerging economies. In conclusion, the proposed India–EU Free Trade Agreement holds transformative potential. While there are several hurdles to overcome, the long-term strategic and economic benefits make a compelling case for its early conclusion. A well-designed FTA would not only boost trade and investment but also enhance innovation, sustainability, and geopolitical cooperation. With sustained political will, stakeholder engagement, and creative diplomacy, the India–EU FTA could emerge as a landmark pact, reshaping global trade dynamics and advancing shared prosperity.
Al Jazeera
16 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Pakistan facing ‘crisis of injustice' in fight against climate change
Pakistan's climate change minister has slammed the 'crisis of injustice' facing the country and a 'lopsided allocation' of funding as heavy rains and the latest flash flooding cause more damage, destruction and loss of life. Officials in Pakistan said at least 32 people have been killed in the Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provinces since the start of the monsoon season. Last month, at least 32 people were also killed in severe storms in a country that has reported extreme weather events in the spring, including strong hailstorms. The Climate Rate Index report in 2025 put Pakistan top of the list of the most affected countries based on 2022 data. Then, extensive flooding submerged approximately a third of the country, affecting 33 million people – including killing more than 1,700, and caused $14.8bn worth of damages, as well as $15.2bn of economic losses. Last year, more floods affected thousands, and a heatwave killed almost 600 people. 'I don't look at this as a crisis of climate. I look at this as a crisis of justice and this lopsided allocation that we are talking about,' Pakistan's climate change minister, Musadiq Malik, told Al Jazeera. 'This lopsided allocation of green funding, I don't look at it as a funding gap. I look at it as a moral gap.' Funding shortfall Earlier this year, a former head of the country's central bank said Pakistan needed an annual investment of $40 to $50bn until 2050 to meet its looming climate change challenges despite being responsible for about half a percent of global CO2 emissions. In January 2023, pledges worth about $10bn from multilateral financial institutions and countries were reported. The following year, Pakistan received $2.8bn from international creditors against those pledges. Earlier this year, the International Monetary Fund said Pakistan will receive $1.3bn under a new climate resilience loan programme, which will span 28 months. But Malik said those pledges and loans were not enough given the situation Pakistan finds itself in. 'Two countries in the world [China and United States of America] produce 45 percent of the carbon emissions. The fact that the top 10 countries of the world account for almost 70 percent of the carbon burden is also something people are aware of. But 85 percent of the world's green financing is going to the same 10 countries, while the rest of the world – some 180-odd countries – are getting 10 to 15 percent green financing. 'We are paying for it through these erratic climate changes, floods, agriculture devastation.' According to a study done last year by the climate change ministry and Italian research institute EvK2CNR, Pakistan is home to 13,000-plus glaciers. However, the gradual rise in temperatures is also forcing the melting of those glaciers, increasing the risk of flooding, damage to infrastructure, loss of life and land, threat to communities and water scarcity. 'In addition to land and life, flooding [due to glacier melt] swept away thousands of years of civilisation [in Sindh province]. The mosques, temples, schools, hospitals, old buildings, monuments, everything got washed away. 'Add to that the loss of education and access to health care, safe drinking water, waterborne diseases, lack of access to hospitals and clinics, and infant mortality,' the report said. Last month, Amnesty International said in a report that 'Pakistan's healthcare and disaster response systems are failing to meet the needs of children and older people who are most at risk of death and disease amid extreme weather events related to climate change'. 'Children and older people in Pakistan are suffering on the front line of the climate crisis, exposed to extreme heat or floods that lead to disproportionate levels of death and disease,' said Laura Mills, researcher with Amnesty International's Crisis Response Programme. This story was produced in partnership with the Pulitzer Center.
Al Jazeera
a day ago
- Al Jazeera
At least 13 soldiers killed in suicide bombing in northwestern Pakistan
More than a dozen soldiers have been killed and dozens of people were wounded in a suicide attack in northwestern Pakistan's Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, officials said. Saturday's attack was carried out in Khadi Market, Mir Ali, North Waziristan, according to a local media outlet, Khyber Chronicles, which quoted security sources. Security officials said the attacker detonated explosives near a bomb disposal unit vehicle, killing 13 people. At least 24 personnel, including 14 civilians, were also injured in the attack, the report said. 'A suicide bomber rammed an explosive-laden vehicle into a military convoy,' a local government official in North Waziristan district of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province told the AFP news agency separately. Children among the injured 'The explosion also caused the roofs of two houses to collapse, injuring six children,' a police officer posted in the district told AFP. It was one of the deadliest single-day attacks on security forces in recent months in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. There was no immediate comment from the Pakistani military. The attack was claimed by the Hafiz Gul Bahadur armed group, a faction of the Pakistan Taliban, or TPP. Pakistan has witnessed a sharp rise in violence in its regions bordering Afghanistan since the Taliban returned to power in Kabul in 2021, with Islamabad accusing its western neighbour of allowing its soil to be used for attacks against Pakistan – a claim the Taliban denies. About 290 people, mostly security officials, have been killed in attacks since the start of the year by armed groups fighting the government in both Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan, according to an AFP tally.
