Review into Flamingo Land plans to be led by official who approved it
Scottish Government reporter David Buylla, who gave the £43.5 million project in Balloch planning permission, is now set to advise SNP ministers who have called in the decision for reappraisal, the Sunday Mail reports.
The recall, undertaken by Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee, means that ministers will now consider the proposals directly.
READ MORE: Campaign against Flamingo Land reaches milestone with 50,000 letters sent to minister
If it goes ahead, the resort would see a waterpark, a monorail, hotels, restaurants, a brewery and 104 woodland chalets built.
The plans have been met with criticism from local campaigners and politicians, which have been branded as "hysteria" by developers Lomond Banks.
According to the Sunday Mail, Buylla is now tasked with writing a new report, including recommendations to inform McKee's decision.
Scottish Government reporters are civil servants within the Planning and Environmental Appeals Division (DPEA), who decide on planning appeals.
Buylla is one of five principal reporters at the DPEA, while there are also three assistant chief reporters and one chief reporter.
Alannah Maurer, campaigner with the Save Loch Lomond campaign, told the Sunday Mail: 'You'd assume someone else would have been assigned. You have to consider professional integrity because how does he say anything other than what he previously said?
READ MORE: All the reasons why approving Flamingo Land in Scotland is wrong
'It's absolutely clear there is no democracy, particularly where planning is concerned. The developer can appeal but the public has no right of appeal.
'Our best hope is that ministers will see sense, pay attention to the public – but it's clear public opinion counts for nothing.'
Scottish Greens MSP Ross Greer, who has been involved with the campaign against Flamingo Land's plans, said ministers "cannot hide behind officials" when making their decision.
Ross Greer MSP 'For a start, they must do what did not happen at the appeal stage; speak to the community, to myself and others like the Woodland Trust who submitted substantial evidence against Flamingo Land's destructive plans," he told the paper.
'They absolutely must speak to the National Park's own planning experts, whose report advising their board to reject the application was clearly badly misunderstood by Government officials.
READ MORE: Cabinet minister refuses to confirm if two-child cap will be scrapped
'The Planning Minister should call a public hearing and come to his own decision based on the evidence. Rehashing the same flawed report from officials and waiting until after next year's election to sign it off would be totally unacceptable."
A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: 'Ministers decided to recall the Lomond Banks appeal as the proposed development raises issues of national significance in view of its potential impact on Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park.
'As this is a live planning appeal it would not be appropriate to comment further.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Anas Sarwar urges Brian Leishman to show ‘team spirit'
Mr Leishman has been a prominent critic of the leadership's approach to welfare reform and its failure to intervene in the closure of the Grangemouth oil refinery. He, along with Rachael Maskell, Neil Duncan-Jordan and Chris Hinchliff, was suspended on Thursday. READ MORE At a joint press conference with the German chancellor, Friedrich Merz, the Prime Minister was asked whether punishing the MPs made him look weak. 'We are elected in to change this country for the better, and that means we've got to carry through that change, and we've got to carry through reforms,' he replied. 'I'm determined that we will change this country for the better, for millions of working people, and I'm not going to be deflected from that. 'And therefore we had to deal with people who repeatedly break the whip, because everyone was elected as a Labour MP on the manifesto of change and everybody needs to deliver as a Labour government. This is about what we're doing for the country.' Despite the suspension, Mr Leishman said he remained committed to Labour and would continue campaigning for the party ahead of the 2026 Holyrood election. 'That includes Anas Sarwar,' he told the Sunday Mail. 'I'm still going out campaigning and that includes him. I think he should be the next First Minister of Scotland.' He added: 'I still think that the Labour Party is the best and most likely vehicle for social change in the country and I want to be part of it. I want to get back in, but I don't regret what I've done in the first 12 months. I stand by it and I still think I'm right.' He said he had not heard from colleagues since his suspension, other than being told he was being removed from two Scottish Labour WhatsApp groups. Anas Sarwar said he want people committed to Labour (Image: Andrew Milligan/PA) Asked if he welcomed Mr Leishman's support, Mr Sarwar told the Sunday Mail: 'I want all of our MPs and all those that were elected as Labour MPs to work hard for their constituents, to argue the Labour case and to improve people's lives in Scotland. said. 'Brian Leishman himself has said he wants to remain a Labour MP, he remains committed to the Labour Party. 'I want people that are committed to the Labour Party. I want people that are committed to improving people's lives — but we all have to do it in a team spirit.' On Sunday, UK Environment Secretary Steve Reed defended the decision, saying there had been a 'pattern of behaviour' that undermined the party's unity. 'I think it is fair that if you're part of a team, you should be required to play the team game,' he told Sky News. 'You can make your views known, but if you go too far outside, you're actually undermining the whole team. We can't allow that.' He added: 'If people think they're more important than the team, they need to think again.' As well as the four left-wingers, the party also suspended Diane Abbott last week pending a new investigation into comments about racism. In an interview with the BBC, she said she did not regret remarks made more than two years ago when she said people of colour experienced racism 'all their lives', which was different from the 'prejudice' experienced by Jewish people, Irish people and Travellers. Ms Abbott, the first black woman elected to Parliament, had said: 'Clearly, there must be a difference between racism which is about colour and other types of racism because you can see a Traveller or a Jewish person walking down the street, you don't know. 'I just think that it's silly to try and claim that racism which is about skin colour is the same as other types of racism. I don't know why people would say that.' The clip of the interview was re-posted by Mr Leishman, who said: 'Diane Abbott has fought against racism her entire life.'
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Police braced for Trump visit with 5,000 officers deployed
Officers face cancelled rest days, extended shifts and deployment across multiple sites. David Kennedy, general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation, told the Sunday Mail: 'It's a recipe for disaster. We don't have enough cops. 'President Trump is a magnet to certain groups. There will be protests. And just because the President is in one place doesn't mean that's where the protests will take place. 'With this event, it is survival mode. That's the mentality that will set in.' He added: 'We'll survive but we shouldn't have to just survive. They will need plenty of help from the UK. 'All this costs money and Police Scotland's budget is already bust. Everybody working longer hours and days has a knock-on effect for months, if not years.' READ MORE: David Threadgold, the Federation's chair, told Scotland on Sunday the service would need to ask for help from other forces: 'This is a huge policing event for Scotland and we will require mutual aid because of the huge demand on my colleagues. 'Very few, if any, cops will not be impacted by next week's visit and beyond. 'I suppose the natural comparison in terms of scale is previous presidential visits and COP26. 'We are talking about bespoke workforce plans because although this is a well-established workforce, we are cognisant we cannot deliver this without impacting on individual officers across the country. 'What that means in simple terms is some may be required to work 12-hour shifts, for example, which normally wouldn't happen. 'That is the type of change cops will see during this event. 'We also need to consider how officers will eat and drink and rest during this policing, which will be a challenge.' He added: 'This is already a difficult time for Police Scotland as they are trying to organise and deliver this at short notice during a period of high annual leave.' Police Scotland is expected to deploy around 5,000 officers — nearly a third of its current headcount of 16,500. The overall bill for the visit could exceed £5 million. Trump's 2018 presidential visit triggered a UK-wide policing bill of £18m and a cost-sharing row between Holyrood and Westminster. Assistant Chief Constable Emma Bond told Scotland on Sunday, Police Scotland would deploy local, national and specialist resources to 'maintain public safety, balance rights to peaceful protest and minimise disruption'. 'We are not going to be telling officers they cannot go on holiday, but those who ask for time off at short notice are very unlikely to get it. 'Operation Roll is a very high demand event but we will continue to deliver community policing. 'Inevitably there will be an impact on our ability to do that, but the public should be reassured that emergencies will still be responded to — there just might be an impact on service delivery. 'There are so many people committed to this event but the [[pub]]lic should be confident that we are excellent at what we do, and our experience of policing things like Operation Unicorn and the Commonwealth Games shows we can deliver.' The Civil Aviation Authority has imposed strict flying restrictions around the Trump International Golf Links in Aberdeenshire. Until Saturday August 10, drones, kites, paramotors and parachutes are banned from flying below 1,000 feet within a one-mile radius of the site. Meanwhile, Patrick Harvie, the outgoing co-leader of the Scottish Greens, told the Sunday Post, the trip needed to be protested. He said: 'Donald Trump is a convicted criminal and extremist who works to undermine democracy and human rights at home and around the world. 'You should not and cannot appease someone like this. Nobody should be lending this increasingly fascist political project any credibility on the international stage. It must be opposed at every turn. 'Scotland has already made it amply clear that he isn't welcome here. And when he arrives in the coming weeks, Scotland will stand on the right side of history and make it amply clear once more.' The Stop Trump Coalition has organised a 'festival of resistance' in Aberdeen on Saturday. During his 2018 visit, tens of thousands take to the streets in Glasgow, Edinburgh and [[Aberdeen]]. During that trip, a paraglider flew over Trump's Turnberry resort carrying a banner that read 'Trump: well below par'. Police later said the stunt had placed the individual in 'grave danger' due to the presence of armed officers protecting the president. READ MORE Business leaders have urged ministers to use the visit to boost trade links with the US. Dr Liz Cameron, chief executive of the Scottish Chambers of Commerce, told The Sunday Post the visit was an opportunity: "This is about investment, exports and jobs, not politics. "Scotland's exports, from whisky and salmon to renewables and fintech, are world class. The US is a key market, and now's the time to reinforce our value. "We should be pushing for better trade terms, fewer barriers, and stronger commercial partnerships. This is about delivering real economic impact." Guy Hinks, chair of the Federation of Small Businesses Scotland, said nearly 60% of Scottish exporters trade with the US, making it the most important market outside the EU. 'Scotland should be making the most of every advantage it has,' he said. Mr Trump is expected to take part in the opening ceremony of a new course at his Balmedie resort, named after his Scottish-born mother, Mary Ann MacLeod. The venue will also host two major tournaments in the weeks following his visit — the PGA Seniors Championship beginning Wednesday July 31 and the DP World Tour Next Championship on Wednesday August 7. The visit will include meetings with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer in [[Aberdeen]] and First Minister John Swinney. Mr Trump, who last visited Scotland in 2023, is due to return to the UK in September for a state visit, where he will meet King Charles at Windsor Castle. Speaking to the BBC last week, the President described the north-east of Scotland as 'the oil and gas capital of Europe' and called for a return to fossil fuels, saying: 'Get rid of the windmills and bring back the oil.'
The Herald Scotland
8 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Scots firms get nothing from £350m of SNP-backed ferry deals
It can be revealed that there has been no agreement with Remontowa for any Scottish input in terms of providing products or other support or supply services for the construction of seven new electric ferries for Scotland signed off by CMAL at a cost of £147.5m. The only Scottish benefit is the company agreeing to match CMAL's charitable funding of £9000 a year and that 21 Scotland-based shipbuilding apprentices would get to attend an unstipulated number of sessions for training purposes when the vessels are delivered including involvement in sea trials. When Turkey landed a second £115m contract in 2023 to build two ferries for longsuffering islanders in a bid to shore up the nation's ageing ferry fleet, the only Scottish benefit set down was that an undefined number of Scottish apprentices would get an unspecified period on attachment at the Turkish yard. The community benefit of the first £91m contract award for two ferries given to Turkey was that up to three Scottish apprentices would gain one week's work experience at the Cemre shipyard every year over the course of the three year build and a total of £30,000 to CMAL's fund to support projects across Scotland. As of the start of last year, of the 58 companies providing products or services for ferries being built in Turkey - all are from overseas or based in England. Details of the lack of Scottish input has produced a new wave of anger over how vital vessels are being procured and has come two-and-a-half years after there was a political row over steel being sourced in China for two of the ferries being built in Turkey. CMAL then confirmed that steel from China was being used because sourcing materials from war-torn Ukraine had been ruled out. CMAL is directly funded and overseen by the SNP-led [[Scottish Government]], which provides loans and capital grants for ferry contracts and infrastructure projects. It comes amidst the continuing fall out over state-owned Inverclyde shipyard firm Ferguson Marine failing to win any of the publicly funded contracts to build the 11 ferries. Calls to the [[Scottish Government]] to give an uncontested direct award of ferry contracts to its shipyard were dismissed by deputy first minister Kate Forbes who cited legal risks. Ferguson Marine was told that the Ferguson bid for seven of the ferries did well in the technical evaluation but could not match the overseas yard on price. Read more: Why did ministers back awarding of Scots ferry contracts to foreign firms? Public inquiry demand over 'scandal' of hundreds of Scots jobs lost in ferry fiasco 'Laughable': Turkey-built ferry to be delivered seven years faster than fiasco ship Cost to repair CalMac ferry now £2m more than to buy replacement 'Final nail in coffin'. Scots fiasco firm loses out on big ferry contract to Poland 'Material uncertainty' over Scots ferry operator future amidst £45m funding hike 'Mismanagement': Public cost of Scots ferry fiasco firm hits £750m amidst overspends One industry body as said that overseas yards enjoyed more state support and cheaper labour costs, often able to undercut UK yards by 10-20%. The UK's refreshed national shipbuilding strategy has called for a minimum 10% social value element in public tenders to offset that. A 10% social value evaluation element is required where appropriate for high value public contracts in other parts of the UK but is not mandatory in Scotland. But CMAL said it did not include social value - which includes the likes of employment, training or environmental benefits - in the scoring for the small vessels contract because it was worried about a possible legal challenge. That came as concerns continue over wildly delayed and massively over-budget delivery of Glen Rosa and its sister ship Glen Sannox which both due to be online within first seven months of 2018, to serve Arran. In the midst of the delays and soaring costs, Ferguson Marine, under the control of tycoon Jim McColl, fell into administration and was nationalised at the end of 2019 with state-owned ferry and port-owning agency Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd and the yard's management blaming each other. Glen Sannox finally started taking passengers in January, while Glen Rosa's latest schedule for delivery is between April and June, next year - eight years after it was due. According to the latest Scottish Government details from last year of 58 companies said to be supporting the Scots ferries' build in Turkey, just one has any Scottish connection. Norway-based Kongsberg have an agreement in place with Cemre Marin Endustri for 50 retractable fin stabilisers for the first two vessels. They have a production facility based in Dunfermline. Chris McEleny, the ex-leader of the [[SNP]] group on [[Inverclyde]] Council who has long been fighting for direct awards of ferry contracts to [[Ferguson Marine]] as well as spin-off community benefit clauses said: "The renewal of Scotland's ferry fleet should've presented a pipeline of work that would've seen the creation of 1000 jobs, seen the Clyde re-emerge as a shipbuilding powerhouse and bring the Inchgreen dry dock back into industrial use. "It is Scotland's shame that this work, and the community benefits that should've come with it have been outsourced to abroad. For decades our ships proudly carried the badge of honour 'Clyde Built'. Now they will sail under a wind of shame that says built in Turkey or built in Poland paid for by us." He added: "CMAL is only focused on the bottom line and they couldn't care less in regard to where ferries are made from. "This is the ultimate failure of Government as it is their job to see the bigger picture to ensure that when we spend millions of pounds renewing our ferry fleet that the procurement exercise builds capacity in our community by upskilling the workforce, guaranteeing apprenticeships and ensuring that Scottish suppliers receive work." Former community safety minister Ash Regan said it was "obscene that a country with a shipbuilding heritage like Scotland's is sending hundreds of millions of pounds of contracts to Turkey and Poland". This means that instead of Scotland's vast amount of public money helping to sustain, build and secure more jobs and better resilience within our own manufacturing sector the Scottish taxpayer is instead subsidising jobs overseas instead of creating them in Scotland. The Alba Edinburgh Eastern MSP added: 'This is not how to show the ambition of a country driving towards independent statehood - this is settling for the devolved disempowerment of managed decline within a failing UK. 'It seems that time and time again community benefits - which are a legal requirement - in our procurement either receive lip service or the only communities that benefit from public sector procurement are those not in Scotland.' Ministers and CMAL have previously been condemned for the lack of community benefits which are defined in the ground-breaking Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 as a "contractual requirement" relating to training and recruitment and the availability of sub-contracting opportunities. The Scottish Government in its commentary on the Act said: "Community benefits have contributed to a range of national and local outcomes relating to employability, skills and tackling inequalities by focusing on under-represented groups. The Act aims to achieve the maximum use of these requirements in public procurement." The ground-breaking Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 when it was brought in was seen by many as a welcome move away from contracts awarded only on the basis of the lowest price towards those which offer the best long-term outcomes for Scotland's communities and the environment. Public contracts valued at £4m or above have specific requirements in relation to community benefits in the authority area that a contract is issued. These should include training and recruitment, the availability of sub-contracting and supplier opportunities, and that it is intended to improve the economic, social or environmental well-being of the area. If no community benefits are sought in a contract, a statement must be published justifying the decision. CMAL has previously denied that there is a breach of procurement laws saying there was no legal requirement to consider community benefits. They have said that the Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations requires contractors to treat economic operators "equally and without discrimination, and restricts CMAL from artificially narrowing competition by unduly favouring or disadvantaging any particular economic operator". They have said that to narrow the supply base to a particular location like Scotland could be construed as "favouring manufacturers, particularly as there is a limited supply base in Scotland, leading to potential challenge". In the initial two ferries contract award to Turkey, CMAL had invited four overseas companies to bid to build the two vessels bound for Islay - and excluded Ferguson Marine. Scottish Government-controlled Ferguson Marine, failed to get past the first Pre Qualification Questionnaire hurdle in the Islay ferries contract. CMAL said of the agreement with Norway-based Kongsberg that eight retractable fin stabilisers have so far been purchased and sourced in Scotland. A spokesperson said: "CMAL follows robust procurement process and complies with all applicable Scottish procurement law. The Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 does not legally require community benefits to be included in contracts. "However, at the SPDS [Single Procurement Document Scotland] stage of the procurement process for the small vessel replacement programme, we highlighted our commitment to community benefits, and advised yards there would be an option to include them in tender responses. None of the bidders included details of community benefits. "During contract discussions with Remontowa shipyard, two community benefits were agreed and included before signing. 'While Scottish public authorities can include social value considerations in procurements, they are not permitted to set requirements which would unlawfully discriminate against foreign shipyards and must at all times treat all bidders equally.'
