The secret of why Mars grew cold and dry may be locked away in its rocks
The discovery by the Mars rovers of carbonate in sedimentary rock on the Red Planet has enabled planetary scientists to rewind the clock and tell the tale of how Mars' warmer, watery climate 3.5 billion years ago changed to the barren, dry and cold environment that it is today.
We know that, in the distant past, Mars was warmer than it is today and had liquid water on its surface. We can see evidence for this in the form of ancient river channels, deltas, lakes and even the eroded coastlines of a large sea in the north. Sometime in the past 3.5 billion years, Mars' atmosphere thinned and its water either froze or was lost to space. The question is, how did that happen?
NASA's MAVEN – Mars Atmosphere and Volatile EvolutioN – mission arrived at the Red Planet in 2014 charged with studying the loss rate of Mars' atmospheric molecules to space. However, scientists know that the carbon in Mars' atmosphere, mostly in the form of carbon dioxide, cannot have been mostly lost to space. That's because the lighter carbon-12 would preferentially escape rather than the marginally heavier carbon-13 (the difference between the two being one extra neutron), but we don't see an excess of carbon-13 in Mars' atmosphere today.
The alternative is that Mars' atmospheric carbon must have rained out of the atmosphere and subsequently been locked away in the ground, in the form of carbonates embedded in sedimentary rock. The trouble is, searches for carbonates on Mars had always found nothing, until relatively recently.
Both current Mars rover missions – Curiosity climbing Mount Sharp in Gale crater and Perseverance exploring the river delta in Jezero Crater – have discovered carbonates, in the sedimentary rock that form Mount Sharp, and stretching tens of kilometers along the rim of Jezero.
Because carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas, it can therefore regulate a planet's climate. Losing that carbon dioxide as it transforms into carbonate rocks would have had a drastic effect on Mars' climate.
To determine just how drastic, planetary scientists led by Edwin Kite of the University of Chicago modeled how losing its atmospheric carbon in carbonate rocks has affected how Mars' climate has changed over the past 3.5 billion years. This is coupled with the increase in solar luminosity as the sun brightens with age (in just over a billion years' time the sun will be too luminous and hot for life on Earth to survive). As the sun grew hotter, it breathed more heat onto Mars, increasing the planet's average temperature. This led to more precipitation, causing the carbon dioxide to rain out and become locked away as carbonate.
With the loss of the carbon dioxide's greenhouse effects, Mars cooled and grew drier. Intermittent spells of high temperatures and shallow liquid water were caused by orbital variations, similar to the Milankovitch cycles on Earth, which are periodic variations in the shape of Earth's orbit and the tilt of our planet's axis caused by the gravitational forces of the other planets, and which affect our long-term climate.
The difference between Earth and Mars is that our planet has been able to manage a continuous outgassing of carbon dioxide, mostly from volcanism, to maintain its presence in our atmosphere. Mars, which is about half the diameter of Earth, lost heat from its core more rapidly, which slowed down and ultimately – as far as we can tell – stopped Mars' volcanic activity. With no active volcanoes, or at least very few, there was nothing to replenish the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.
These findings help explain the geological evidence of subsequent but increasingly less frequent bursts of liquid water on the surface of Mars during the past 3.5 billion years.
RELATED STORIES
— Early visions of Mars: Meet the 19th-century astronomer who used science fiction to imagine the Red Planet
— Is the US forfeiting its Red Planet leadership to China's Mars Sample Return plan?
— NASA's Curiosity rover takes a closer look at 'spiderwebs' on Mars | Space photo of the day for July 1, 2025
There is one caveat, which is that the study assumes that the abundance of carbonates at Gale crater is typical of the entire Red Planet. Carbonate samples need to be identified in many locations before we can say for sure that this was how Mars lost its greenhouse gas.
The research is published in Nature.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
2 hours ago
- CNBC
Investing in Space: NASA's months of reckoning
For half a year now, NASA's been weathering a storm on every front, from its budget to its chain of command and potential program terminations. Employee uproar was an inevitable chapter of the saga. A group of 360 current and former NASA employees have penned a letter rebuking "rapid and wasteful changes" across staffing, mission and budgetary cuts at the space agency. "The last six months have seen rapid and wasteful changes which have undermined our mission and caused catastrophic impacts on NASA's workforce," the letter says, noting concerns that the proposed downsizing in personnel and funding are "arbitrary and have been enacted in defiance of congressional appropriations law" and that "the consequences for the agency and the country alike are dire." Signatories of the letter, titled the Voyager Declaration, urge the U.S. leadership not to implement "harmful" cuts and dispute "non-strategic staffing reductions," curtailing research projects, as well as cancelling contracts and participation in international missions or assignments for which Congress has already appropriated funding. It's no small list of objections raised at a time of broader uncertainty at NASA, which faces significant — and long chronicled — declines in funding and staff, amid a broader White House push to shrink down the federal workforce. "NASA will never compromise on safety. Any reductions—including our current voluntary reduction—will be designed to protect safety-critical roles," NASA Spokesperson Bethany Stevens said in an emailed statement. "The reality is that President Trump has proposed billions of dollars for NASA science, demonstrating an ongoing commitment to communicating our scientific achievements. To ensure NASA delivers for the American people, we are continually evaluating mission lifecycles, not on sustaining outdated or lower-priority missions." Adding to the tumult, NASA on Monday announced the high-level exit of Makenzie Lystrup, who will end her two-year stint as Goddard Space Flight Center director on Aug. 1. NASA says the step was communicated internally before any knowledge of the letter. It's not the first loss from the agency's senior ranks in recent months: Laurie Leshin stepped down from the director post of NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in June. And more exits could be forthcoming: at the start of the month, Politico reported that at least 2,145 senior-level employees could depart NASA, many serving in core mission sets. Throughout, NASA — notable for both its own achievements and its substantial contracts to the U.S. private space industry — has remained without long-term leadership, after U.S. President Donald Trump's initial pick, tech billionaire and Elon Musk ally Jared Isaacman, was unexpectedly removed from consideration back in May. Sean Duffy, Trump's transportation secretary, was appointed to hold up the fort as NASA's interim administrator just this month. Inevitably, there's money on the line. NASA clinched a budget of $24.875 billion last year — 8.5% under its initial request and 2% below the funding of 2023 — that was matched in 2025. Under the Trump administration, the agency battled the possibility of a roughly 25% budget trim in 2026, although the U.S. House of Appropriations subcommittee has pushed back on these cuts. If enacted, the Trump funding proposal of $18.8 billion would have been the smallest NASA budget since before the U.S.' first crewed Moon landing via the Apollo 11 mission, commemorated this week on July 20. In a Monday statement, Trump said his administration is "building on the legacy of Apollo 11" and endorsed NASA's initiatives focused on "returning Americans to the Moon —this time to stay — and putting the first boots on Mars." Colonizing the red planet has been a vocally stated objective of the U.S. president since his January return to office, echoing the ambitions of his then-ally Musk. The two have since parted ways through an explosive rift, but the dream to land U.S. astronauts on the Moon and Mars has gripped the nation, with a respective 67% and 65% of those surveyed in a CBS News/YouGov pollv now in favor.
Digital Trends
3 hours ago
- Digital Trends
Elon Musk to give an update on Starship status and future plans
SpaceX boss Elon Musk has promised to lay out his company's plans for the mighty Starship rocket in an upcoming event. In a post on X on Thursday night, he said the presentation will take place shortly before the rocket's 10th flight test, which is expected to take place next in the first half of next month. 'Shortly before the next flight, I will do a live technical update on Starship, going over progress to date and engineering/production/launch plans for the future,' Musk said in the post. Recommended Videos The presentation, which is likely to take place at SpaceX's Starbase facility in Boca Chica, Texas, should offer some details on what his team has learned from recent flight tests and how it's used that knowledge to improve the rocket, which, packing some 17 million pounds of thrust at launch, makes it the most powerful launch vehicle ever. Recent Starship flights have been a mixed bag of impressive booster landings and lost spacecraft. There was also the spectacular explosion of the Starship spacecraft, which occurred shortly after a ground-based engine test in June. No one was hurt in the incident. Musk will also offer some information on how many Starship vehicles and boosters are currently being built, and possibly touch on any supply chain challenges. Many people will also be keen to hear about the launch plans for the Starship. Musk has spoken before about his desire to dramatically increase the launch frequency of the Starship so that SpaceX can work more quickly toward making it operational. NASA is planning to use the Starship to carry crew and cargo to the moon in highly anticipated missions before the end of this decade. It could also be used for the first crewed voyage to the surface of Mars. Musk had originally planned to hold the update event at around the time of the ninth flight test in late May, but it was called off at the last minute. The SpaceX chief has now confirmed it'll be happening in the coming weeks, and we'll know exact timings just as soon as SpaceX confirms the launch schedule for the 10th flight test.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump Megabill Tosses $1 Billion At Space Force's Boeing Spaceplane
It's difficult to believe that any legislator read all 940 pages of President Donald Trump's Big, Beautiful Bill before it was passed by Congress earlier this month. I wonder if the Senate was aware that the megabill allocated $1 billion to the U.S. Space Force's Boeing X-37B Orbit Test Vehicle. The American military's newest branch is proud to boast about how maneuverable the uncrewed spaceplane is in orbit. Still, little else is known about what the Boeing spacecraft is actually doing while looping the planet. The budget increase is certainly a statement of intent from the White House, especially when NASA's budget is slated to be slashed by $3.4 billion. The Boeing X-37B has been in service since 2010, back when the Space Force was Air Force Space Command. The spaceplane's familiar white and black thermal clad appearance is reminiscent of NASA's Space Shuttle, and it fulfills a similar role for the Pentagon, based on the publicly available information. Air Force Space Command didn't reveal the X-37B's payload for its first three flights. While the flights are still considered classified, the Space Force will reveal orbital deployment and experiments done in collaboration with other agencies. The seventh X-37B mission ended in March with the spaceflight landing at Vandenberg Space Force Base after 434 days in orbit. The mission conducted experiments with NASA to observe the effects of space radiation on plant seeds. Read more: You'd Only Drive These Cars If They Were Free Military Wants The Highest Ground Possible No, the X-37B's primary reason for spending over a year in orbit wasn't seeing if you could turn a packet of seeds into the Fantastic Four. The Space Force stated it tested the spaceplane's ability to complete maneuvers using atmospheric drag. The branch is gradually getting its feet wet in what space combat could look like with our spacefaring geopolitical rivals, like China and Russia. General Chance Saltzman, Chief of Space Operations, said: "Mission 7 broke new ground by showcasing the X-37B's ability to flexibly accomplish its test and experimentation objectives across orbital regimes. The successful execution of the aerobraking maneuver underscores the U.S. Space Force's commitment to pushing the bounds of novel space operations in a safe and responsible manner." Air Force Space Command's independence from the Air Force in 2019 wasn't just a Trump vanity project, but a push to militarize space. The $1 billion dedicated to the X-35B is part of a $11.3 billion budget increase for Space Force. This is happening amid the White House leaving civilian spaceflight on a shoestring budget and reliant on private companies. NASA's Artemis Program is still scheduled to return astronauts to the Moon, but is unclear how it'll get there. The Trump administration is trying to cancel the Space Launch System, but the agency won't halt the rocket's testing and development efforts. Want more like this? Join the Jalopnik newsletter to get the latest auto news sent straight to your inbox... Read the original article on Jalopnik.
