Will British and Irish Lions sue Rugby Australia over player eligibility row?
If you were to list the top moments from each of the last five British and Irish Lions tours then you'd almost certainly find that at least one entry didn't happen on the pitch.
In 2021 it was South African coach Rassie Erasmus breaking down the flaws in refereeing calls, and in 2017 it was the sight of then-British and Irish Lions coach Warren Gatland wearing a clown nose to mock his New Zealand doubters.
Days before the 2025 tour officially starts on Saturday, it may have already found its off-field moment, with British and Irish Lions chief executive Ben Calveley warning that their Wallaby hosts could be in breach of contract if they do not field their best players in the warm-up games.
'The agreement is very clear – it says that Test players have to be released to play in fixtures leading into that series,' he said. 'That is our expectation.'
Australia head coach Joe Schmidt wants to lessen the chances of his best players getting injured, which is understandable, and is set to hold back those stars from playing for their clubs – such as the Queensland Reds and Waratahs – in tour matches against the British and Irish Lions before the first Test next month in Brisbane.
But has his call set the British and Irish Lions and Rugby Australia on a legal collision course, and what could the tourists do about it?
'If the formal tour agreement includes a specific clause governing which Test players must be released to participate in fixtures leading up to the series, then the Lions would likely have grounds for a breach of contract claim,' William Bowyer, associate in the sports and entertainment team at Lawrence Stephens, tells City AM.
The two parties would be keen to not see the matter escalate, with the ideal scenario for the tourists being the best teams – with their Australia players taking part – facing the Lions.
'Should matters escalate legally, the Lions would likely be eager to obtain the unusual remedy of a mandatory injunction, which would order that the Australian players are released to play,' Richard Coopey, partner at Grosvenor Law, adds. 'It may be that the mere threat of litigation brings the parties to a compromise, as the Lions would no doubt prefer to battle the Australians on the pitch rather than in the courtroom.'
The British and Irish Lions has never been a conventional rugby brand, but it has become a powerful enough commercial juggernaut and its managers will believe they'll be able to compel Australia to play their best team. But is that enough?
'If matters were to proceed in England,' Coopey continues, 'the Lions may be able to show that the contract does indeed require the release but the question for the court would then be how to remedy that breach.
'However, it may prove challenging for the Lions to show a clear financial loss for which they should be compensated with cash [because the matches are sold out and TV deals complete].'
Bowyer, though, says time is of the essence: 'With major commercial stakes – from broadcast rights to sponsorship and ticketing – both parties are under pressure to find a swift, negotiated resolution, while leveraging their respective contractual positions.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
British and Irish Lions dominate Force in the opening game of their Australian tour
PERTH, Australia (AP) — Dan Sheehan made the perfect start on debut for the British and Irish Lions. The Ireland hooker led the Lions for the first game of their Australian tour, scored in the second minute and steered the team to a commanding 54-7 win over the Perth-based Western Force on Saturday. After an arm-wrestle of a first half where the Lions led 21-7 despite having only 40% of possession and spending most of the time in their own half, the bigger, more polished British and Irish lineup opened up and put five unanswered tries on a tiring defense in the second. Scrumhalf Tomos Williams scored a pair of tries before limping off with a left hamstring issue, fullback Elliot Daly scored two tries and flyhalf Finn Russell created two tries with his spur-of-the-moment judgement. He also kicked five goals. Henry Pollock, the 20-year-old England No. 8, played an integral hand in two tries and also spent 10 minutes in the sin-bin in his eventful debut start for the Lions. Early exchanges The Lions made changes after a 28-24 loss to Argentina in a warmup last week in Dublin, putting more emphasis on short, sharp passing. The Lions had the ball for 11 phases until Russell kicked high and wide to the right touchline where Sheehan took the ball high and tapped infield for winger James Low, who flicked an inside pass back to him to score. The Force equalized quickly after 14 phases of attack with veteran Wallabies scrumhalf Nic White sniping over from the base of a ruck in the fifth minute. The Force opted against taking penalty goals in order to keep up attacking intensity but the Lions held firm and relieved pressure with some crucial turnovers. Flyhalf Russell set up the first try with his pinpoint kick wide and the third with a quick penalty tap and go in the 35th, scooting up to the five-yard line before popping up a ball off the ground for fullback Daly to score. In between, Pollock was instrumental in the Lions' second try, bursting onto a sharp inside ball from openside flanker Josh van der Flier, stepping inside and out and going to ground before popping a ball up to scrumhalf Williams to score. The tourists went into halftime with a man down after Pollock was yellow carded for a ruck infringement deep inside his own quarter. The Force crossed the line from the resulting penalty but were held up. Williams finished off an 80-meter counter-attacking try seven minutes into the second half. Both wingers were involved, with Lowe making an initial break and then exchanging passes with Williams at the end. Williams limped off after scoring, and was replaced by Alex Mitchell. The Lions' attacking intent led directly to Garry Ringrose's try soon after that gave the Lions a 33-7 lead. Pollock, the youngest member of the Lions squad, was back in the attack quickly, chipping over the defense, regathering and almost scoring himself before the Lions shifted it quickly through the hands for lock Joe McCarthy to score out wide in the 55th. Daly scored in the 71st minute after sustained attack to help the Lions take a 40-point buffer. It was extended to 47 when Mitchell scored after the siren, taking the last pass from Australian-born Ireland winger Mack Hansen to put the final touches on the victory. The Lions are playing nine games in their first tour to Australia since 2013, including tests in Brisbane on July 19, in Melbourne on July 26 and in Sydney on Aug. 2.
Hamilton Spectator
an hour ago
- Hamilton Spectator
British and Irish Lions dominate Force in the opening game of their Australian tour
PERTH, Australia (AP) — Dan Sheehan made the perfect start on debut for the British and Irish Lions. The Ireland hooker led the Lions for the first game of their Australian tour , scored in the second minute and steered the team to a commanding 54-7 win over the Perth-based Western Force on Saturday. After an arm-wrestle of a first half where the Lions led 21-7 despite having only 40% of possession and spending most of the time in their own half, the bigger, more polished British and Irish lineup opened up and put five unanswered tries on a tiring defense in the second. Scrumhalf Tomos Williams scored a pair of tries before limping off with a left hamstring issue, fullback Elliot Daly scored two tries and flyhalf Finn Russell created two tries with his spur-of-the-moment judgement. He also kicked five goals. Henry Pollock, the 20-year-old England No. 8, played an integral hand in two tries and also spent 10 minutes in the sin-bin in his eventful debut start for the Lions. Early exchanges The Lions made changes after a 28-24 loss to Argentina in a warmup last week in Dublin, putting more emphasis on short, sharp passing. The Lions had the ball for 11 phases until Russell kicked high and wide to the right touchline where Sheehan took the ball high and tapped infield for winger James Low, who flicked an inside pass back to him to score. The Force equalized quickly after 14 phases of attack with veteran Wallabies scrumhalf Nic White sniping over from the base of a ruck in the fifth minute. The Force opted against taking penalty goals in order to keep up attacking intensity but the Lions held firm and relieved pressure with some crucial turnovers. Flyhalf Russell set up the first try with his pinpoint kick wide and the third with a quick penalty tap and go in the 35th, scooting up to the five-yard line before popping up a ball off the ground for fullback Daly to score. In between, Pollock was instrumental in the Lions' second try, bursting onto a sharp inside ball from openside flanker Josh van der Flier, stepping inside and out and going to ground before popping a ball up to scrumhalf Williams to score. The tourists went into halftime with a man down after Pollock was yellow carded for a ruck infringement deep inside his own quarter. The Force crossed the line from the resulting penalty but were held up. A key moment Williams finished off an 80-meter counter-attacking try seven minutes into the second half. Both wingers were involved, with Lowe making an initial break and then exchanging passes with Williams at the end. Williams limped off after scoring, and was replaced by Alex Mitchell. The Lions' attacking intent led directly to Garry Ringrose's try soon after that gave the Lions a 33-7 lead. Pollock, the youngest member of the Lions squad, was back in the attack quickly, chipping over the defense, regathering and almost scoring himself before the Lions shifted it quickly through the hands for lock Joe McCarthy to score out wide in the 55th. Daly scored in the 71st minute after sustained attack to help the Lions take a 40-point buffer. It was extended to 47 when Mitchell scored after the siren, taking the last pass from Australian-born Ireland winger Mack Hansen to put the final touches on the victory. The Lions are playing nine games in their first tour to Australia since 2013, including tests in Brisbane on July 19, in Melbourne on July 26 and in Sydney on Aug. 2. ___ AP rugby:
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Lions run in eight tries in win over Western Force
Western Force: (7) 7 Try: White Con: Donaldson British and Irish Lions: (21) 54 Tries: Sheehan, Williams 2, Daly 2, Ringrose, McCarthy, Mitchell Cons: Russell 5, M Smith 2 The British and Irish Lions eased to an eight-try 54-7 victory against Western Force in the first game of their tour on Australian soil. Captain Dan Sheehan, Tomos Williams and Elliot Daly scored in a first half largely dominated by the profligate hosts in terms of territory but not on the scoreboard. Advertisement The Lions led 21-7 at the break, the Force's own skipper Nic White crossing for their only try in front of 46,656, a record crowd for a rugby union game in Perth. Beyond the break, it was all Lions, though. Williams scored a blistering, breakaway second while Henry Pollock was in the sin-bin. The moment was overshadowed by Williams' worrying looking injury in the process. Garry Ringrose, the towering Joe McCarthy, a second for Daly and a last-gasp score for Alex Mitchell brought up the 50-point mark as the Lions blew away their hosts. A flawed start and a worrying amount of possession and opportunity for the Force gave way to a strong win in the end for the Lions. Advertisement McCarthy was a compelling force up front as the Lions backline eventually ran amok. They will sweat on what looked like a hamstring injury for Williams, who had been playing like a thoroughbred. Jamison Gibson-Park has not yet played for these Lions, although he is expected to be available for midweek in Brisbane. It is a worry for coach Andy Farrell. The Lions got off to a flyer on the night after a sustained bout of possession when Russell dipped into his box of tricks with a sumptuous cross-kick to Sheehan on the right wing. Sheehan tapped to James Lowe, who gave it back to his captain for the score. The creator banged over the conversion. Advertisement A blistering beginning, but there was trouble ahead. Just as the Lions scored with their first attack, so too did the Force. Again it was a slow turning of the screw before White sprung from the bottom of a ruck just short the line. Ben Donaldson was good with the conversion. The Force were heavy underdogs but for 40 minutes they played with a confidence that belied their poor season in Super Rugby. They repeatedly got into the Lions 22 and time and again the tourists got pinged. The Lions conceded five penalties in 80 minutes against the Pumas in Dublin. They conceded four in 10 minutes in Perth. Sheehan was warned about the ill discipline of his team as early as the 11th minute. This is not how it was supposed to be. Advertisement If the Force had been more accurate they would have capitalised on all those entries into the Lions 22. They won a penalty and went for touch on the right, but nothing came of it. They won another penalty and went for touch on the left, but nothing came of that either. Credit the tenacity of the Lions defence too, but they were doing much of it. When they got ball in hand, they were the polar opposite of the Force. It must have been a sickener for the hosts when the visitors lifted the siege in their own territory only to score straight away. A break from Ireland's Josh van der Flier, a big bust from England's Pollock and a support line from Wales' Williams and over they went. Ruthless. More Force wastefulness followed and soon another Lions try arrived. Advertisement Like the first, it was Russell at the root of it, his tap penalty, break and offload putting Daly over. A minor scuffle broke out in the aftermath. The Force's angst carried on. Once more they had a close-range lineout - and a one-man advantage after Pollock saw yellow at breakdown - but they could not execute. A 14-point half-time lead for the Lions felt out of kilter with the flow of the game. It got better, though. A lot better. Even with Pollock in the bin, the Lions struck out for a majestic score from inside their own 22. Hansen got them moving but it was Lowe and Williams who did a supreme job in pulling the trigger, running and offloading before the scrum-half went over for his second score. Advertisement The downside - and it was a significant one - was the injury he picked up in the act of scoring. It had everyone in the media seats scurrying around determining the whereabouts of Scotland's Ben White (handily placed in New Zealand) and England's Jack van Poortvliet (not so handy in Argentina). As the Force tired, the Lions piled on the heat. Ringrose went over for try number five after fine work by Hansen, and the combative and impressive McCarthy went over for number six after more terrific work from Pollock. Russell's conversion brought up the 40-point mark. Daly completed his double and replacement Mitchell went over in the last act to bring up the half-century. Line-ups Western Force: Donaldson, Grealy, Proctor, Stewart, Pietsch, Harford, White (capt); T Robertson, Paenga-Amosa, Hoskins, Carter, Swain, Harris, Champion de-Crespigny, Ekuasi Advertisement Replacements: Dolly, Pearce, Tauakipulu, Faifua, Prinsep, H Robertson, Burey, Kuenzie British and Irish Lions: Daly, Hansen, Ringrose, Tuipulotu, Lowe, Russell, Williams; Schoeman, Sheehan (capt), Furlong, Cummings, McCarthy, Beirne, Van der Flier, Pollock Replacements: Kelleher, Porter, Stuart, Chessum, Conan, Mitchell, Jones, M Smith Match officials Referee: Ben O'Keeffe (New Zealand) Assistant referee 1: Paul Williams (New Zealand) Assistant referee 2: James Doleman (New Zealand) TMO: Marius van der Westhuizen (South Africa) Foul play review officer (FPRO): Glenn Newman (New Zealand)
