‘Senior echelons' of NSW Police's failure before woman's ‘humiliating' strip search: court
Raya Meredith was forced to undress in front of a police officer, lift her breasts, and remove her tampon during a 'humiliating' and terrifying strip search at the Splendour in the Grass music festival in 2018 that police later admitted was illegal.
The then-27-year-old is the lead plaintiff in a class-action lawsuit brought by Slater and Gordon and the Redfern Legal Centre against the state of NSW on behalf of more than 3000 people likely subjected to illegal strip searches between 2016-2022.
Ms Meredith's lawyer, Kylie Nomchong SC, has argued in her closing statements, which continued on Wednesday, that there was an 'abject failure' on the part of NSW Police to ensure proper training and supervision given to police doing searches.
Under the law, strip searches – which are recognised as being 'highly invasive and humiliating' – are supposed to be undertaken within specific statutory guidelines, including preconditions of 'seriousness and urgency' that they be done.
Ms Nomchong told the court on Tuesday that not a single COPS event log contained why a strip search was necessary, and the general duties officers were 'defective in their understanding of the basis on which strip searches could be carried out'.
'They were not supervised. They were not trained. And, as a direct result, that is why my plaintiff was unlawfully strip searched … along with others who attended the music festival in 2018,' Ms Nomchong said in her more than six-hour statement.
Resuming on Wednesday, Ms Nomchong urged the court to award exemplary damages 'not only to express the court's disapprobation but because of the manifest breaches of the (Law Enforcement Powers and Responsibilities Act) by searching officers.
Ms Nomchong went on to add 'but also because of the … manifest failures on the part of the senior echelons of the NSW Police Force responsible for both general and focus training for conducting strip searches' in the state at the time.
The state of NSW has maintained searching Ms Meredith's breast and genital area were 'objectively reasonably necessary', a claim Ms Nomchong described as 'outrageous' and claimed there was no 'no basis for the strip search in the first place'.
She told Judge Dina Yehia that she would have to make factual findings in relation to Ms Meredith's pleadings in the case but admitted damages might be mitigated by changes since made by police – changes she said were available at the time, too.
The state of NSW for 2½ years denied the search was unlawful.
In her evidence, recited by Ms Nomchong on Tuesday, Ms Meredith said she remembered 'wanting to scream at her (the officer). I remember feeling disgusted that another woman was putting me through this. I was nauseated by this point. I felt like vomiting.'
Ms Nomchong is seeking $5000 in damages for the 'pat down' as well as aggravated damages because of the 'colossal magnitude' of the contraventions made during the search, which was not lawful and 'breached nearly every safeguard'.
She also alleged lawyers representing the state of NSW had issued a subpoena to Services Australia for Ms Meredith's entire medical history despite there not being a claim for personal injury damages, 'having the effect of intimidating the plaintiff'.
'The plaintiff's evidence was if 'I could have walked out of this case then and there I would have',' Ms Nomchong said.
Much of Tuesday's hearing centred on what training was given to police, including at the police academy, in regard to the carrying out of strip searches as well as what Ms Nomchong claimed could have been done to avoid the contraventions.
She told the court that plans had been drawn up in response to a complaint made following a 2013 Mardi Gras afterparty and an investigation by the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission as well as a sticker systems officers could have deployed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
SBS Australia
2 hours ago
- SBS Australia
Police offer $250,000 for information on disappearance
Police, family appeal over Simon Knight disappearance Prime Minister's pointed address to party on eve of new parliament Opals beat Japan to win Asia Cup The father of a Sydney man who disappeared 20 years ago to the day, has made a desperate appeal for any new information to shed light on the fate of his son. The appeal, made alongside New South Wales Police, is seeking clarity two decades after Simon Knight was last seen at a Surry Hills hotel on Crown Street. His parents reported the aspiring chef missing, after he failed to show up to work at a Newtown Cafe later that day. Police are currently offering a $250,000 reward for any credible information. His father, Bob Knight, says the family has been waiting 20 years for closure. "We have been waiting 20 years to find out what's happened to Simon. The family is still waiting, we're hoping that one day we will get the answers and closure. So please, if you do know anything, please get in touch with the police or Crimestoppers. Thank you." Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has told federal Labor politicians they must repay the faith of the Australian public who chose to re-elect his government to power, with a dominant majority. Mr Albanese made the remarks as he addressed the Labor party caucus, ahead of the first sitting day of the new Federal Parliament, tomorrow. He says members must reflect on the mandate Labor has been given and do their best to serve the interests of the Australian public above all else. "Each and every day, we must work hard to we repay the faith that has been shown in us. We should never, ever, ever take it for granted. People don't expect perfection. They understand that the world will throw things at us. But they expect that we will put them first, rather than be focused internally on what goes on in this building." Over 150 organisations have come together to warn the human rights of Australians are increasingly under threat, ahead of a major United Nations review. The coalition of organisations, including Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander, human rights, legal, disability, refugee, LGBTIQ+ and climate groups, have submitted a joint report to the United Nations Human Rights Council identifying critical issues that have gone unaddressed. They're calling for the establishment of an Australian Human Rights Act, to establish clear minimum human rights protections that must be considered by governments when designing policies and delivering services. Caitlin Reiger, CEO at the Human Rights Law Centre tells SBS that urgent action is needed to stem the rollback of fundamental rights. "We don't have a comprehensive set of human rights protections in our legal framework at the federal level. We've also seen a number of jurisdictions, wind areas of human rights and basic civil liberties protections back, both in terms of the quite repressive responses to public protests in recent times, we've seen backsliding around youth justice with the age of criminal responsibility going down in some places rather than up. And we have 10- and 11-year-olds sitting in police cells and not in classrooms or at home." Investigators are examining a light plane crash in south-eastern Queensland, which killed a pilot and flight examiner. The twin turboprop aircraft crashed into a grass area near Oakey, west of Toowoomba, about 3pm yesterday. Aero Logistics owns the craft. In a statement, chief executive Ben Smee says it's a terrible tragedy and that the pair were experienced, well-respected pilots. The Australian Transport Safety Bureau is now investigating the crash. Chief Commissioner Angus Mitchell says the pilot was undergoing an instrument proficiency check at the time, an annual requirement of instrument-rated pilots. "Exactly what's occurred here is still not entirely clear to us but we do know that it was conducting ILS, which is Instrument Landing System approaches into Oakey. Now something has obviously gone quite tragically wrong and our job is to piece together the sequence of events leading into what's occurred yesterday afternoon and more broadly the environments that may have influenced that." Mr Smee says Aero Logistics has offered its support to the families of the two men and counselling services to staff. In basketball, the Opals are celebrating after the Australian women have won their first Asia Cup, triumphing over defending champions Japan in the final. It was a dominant gold medal display with the Opals leading at the end of every quarter, finishing with 88 points to Japan's 79. While the six-time champions levelled the score twice in the final quarter, Australia polled ahead with the help of top-scorer Alexandra Fowler who led the charge with 15 points. She was followed by Alex Wilson's 14 points and Stephanie Reid's 13. Fowler says she's grateful for the opportunity to play for Australia and thanks her family and coaches for helping her improve her game. "As I continue to develop and get older my game continues to grow. It's a credit to all the coaches over the years, my parents, everyone, all the time they've put in to getting me to training, to putting in the extra hours with me. It's just so fun to be out on the stage and play in front of a crowd wearing the Australian jersey. I think we had an amazing group of girls come together and I couldn't be prouder of the group and the coaching staff and all the people who put in all the time and effort behind the scenes. It's been so much fun, this whole tournament."
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Search area expanded after fisher goes missing from Batemans Bay
A multi-agency search for a missing fisherman has been expanded to include about half of the New South Wales coastline. Marine Rescue vessels have been deployed between Port Stephens and the Victorian border to search for the man, who departed from Batemans Bay Marina at about 6am on Saturday. It is believed the 56-year-old was heading towards the continental shelf to catch tuna. In a statement NSW Police said the search was expanded on Monday afternoon "following unconfirmed sightings of the vessel by members of the public". Authorities have not verified any sightings of the man and his eight-metre-long Arvor cruiser vessel since the search commenced on Saturday evening. Marine Rescue Inspector Stuart Massey said up to 30 volunteers had been on the water during some days of the search. "When they were first out there they were out there till after midnight, then a lot of those crews backed up again the next morning," he said. "They are determined to get back out there and do their bit, but they've been working incredibly long hours out there." Inspector Massey said conditions on Monday morning were favourable for crews searching near Narooma and Bermagui. "There's not a great deal of swell or wind out there … that's making it a little bit more comfortable for the crews," he said. The search has been led by the NSW Police Marine Area Command alongside Marine Rescue and the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA). Multiple interstate aircraft are also involved, according to AMSA. Police have not confirmed the identity of the fisherman.
9 News
4 hours ago
- 9 News
Lehrmann inquiry head's leak was 'transparent, not corrupt', lawyer said
Your web browser is no longer supported. To improve your experience update it here A former judge's decision to leak confidential material from an inquiry into Bruce Lehrmann's criminal prosecution was an attempt at transparency not an act of corruption, his lawyers say. Walter Sofronoff KC has asked the Federal Court to toss a March finding by the ACT Integrity Commission that the former judge engaged in serious corrupt conduct. The commission's probe stemmed from Sofronoff's leaks to a journalist. Walter Sofronoff KC has asked a court to toss out a finding that he engaged in serious corrupt conduct. (Fairfax Media) But the watchdog's adverse finding was a "serious offence against the administration of justice", Sofronoff's barrister Adam Pomerenke KC said during a hearing today. Sofronoff was not corrupt, malicious or dishonest, the barrister told Justice Wendy Abrahams. Rather, he genuinely believed he was acting in the public interest by sending documents like witness statements to the media. "Even if Mr Sofronoff was wrong in his view, the fact remains that he genuinely and honestly held it," Pomerenke said. "At worst it could be characterised as an erroneous attempt to ensure accuracy and transparency in the public discourse." Sofronoff chaired a board of inquiry into the ACT's criminal justice system after Lehrmann's controversy-plagued prosecution. The former Liberal staffer was accused of raping then-colleague Brittany Higgins in a ministerial office at Parliament House in 2019. A 2022 criminal trial was abandoned without a verdict due to juror misconduct. Lehrmann lost a defamation lawsuit he brought over media reporting of Higgins' allegations but has appealed a judge's finding the rape claim was true on the balance of probabilities. The Sofronoff-led inquiry found the ACT's top prosecutor, Shane Drumgold, had lost objectivity over the Lehrmann case and knowingly lied about a note of his meeting with broadcaster Lisa Wilkinson. Drumgold resigned and launched a legal challenge to the findings in the ACT Supreme Court. Former ACT Director of Public Prosecutions Shane Drumgold. (Rhett Wyman / SMH) It found the majority of the inquiry's findings were not legally unreasonable, but it struck down an adverse finding about how Drumgold cross-examined then-Liberal senator Linda Reynolds during Lehrmann's criminal trial. In March, the ACT Integrity Commission also found the majority of the inquiry's findings were not legally unreasonable. But it found Sofronoff's behaviour during the inquiry gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias and he might have been influenced by the publicly expressed views of journalist Janet Albrechtsen. Sofronoff repeatedly messaged the News Corp columnist and eventually provided her an advance copy of his probe's final report. Pomerenke told the Federal Court today the ACT corruption body had admitted it made an error in finding Sofronoff might have engaged in contempt. The claimed contempt stemmed out of leaks to the media despite directions made to parties during the inquiry to suppress certain documents. But the notion that the head of an inquiry could be in contempt of himself was "absurd and irrational", Pomerenke said. This concession was enough to toss the findings against his client, he told the court. Any individual error could not be "disentangled" from the final finding that the former judge engaged in serious corrupt conduct, the barrister said. Support is available from 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) and the National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service on 1800 211 028. courts Bruce Lehrmann Australia national Australian Capital Territory CONTACT US
