
Limerick hospital offers 'sincere and heartfelt apologies' to mother of baby who died due to 'failure' in care
'We are deeply sorry for your loss and for the profound sorrow of being denied the opportunity to watch your beloved son grow and thrive,' the hospital said in a letter read out in the High Court.
The mother of the baby, who was 16 weeks old when he died, has settled a High Court action against the HSE over his death.
The mother or child cannot be identified by order of the court.
The family's counsel, Dr John O'Mahony SC with Doireann O Mahony BL, instructed by solicitor Brigid O'Donnell, told the High Court it was a sad and tragic case.
Counsel said when the little boy was born at the Limerick hospital in January 2021, he was doing well until two weeks later his condition deteriorated and tests including lumbar punctures showed he had an E coli meningitis infection and he was started on antibiotics.
Counsel said the baby's condition later suddenly deteriorated and he had a fever. He deteriorated further and needed to be intubated and ventilated.
An MRI scan showed global ischaemia, which is when blood flow to the brain is reduced. The baby later received palliative care and he died when he was 16 weeks old.
In the letter from the chief executive of HSE Midwest Acute Services Ian Carter, University Maternity Hospital, Limerick offered 'sincere and heartfelt apologies" to the mother and wider family 'for this failure'.
It said: 'On behalf of the management and staff at University Maternity Hospital, Limerick, I wish to acknowledge the breach in our duty of care to your baby, which resulted in a delayed diagnosis with devastating consequences for you and your extended family.'
It added: 'Please know that our thoughts are with you, and we extend our deepest sympathy to you and your family at this incredibly difficult time.'
In the proceedings, it was claimed there was an alleged failure to take any or any proper action which such was warranted by the baby's condition and an alleged delay had been caused in enabling the baby to receive proper urgent care and treatment for his condition.
It was further claimed there was an alleged failure to recognise the baby's obvious signs of sepsis when he was moved into intensive care on February 19, 2021, and to ensure the administration of the appropriate antibiotics urgently or in a timely fashion.
There was, it was claimed, an alleged delay in the administration of broad spectrum antibiotics when it ought to have bene known such a delay would expose the baby to a serious risk of injury or death.
The claims had been denied.
Noting the settlement and the division of the statutory mental distress solatium payment, Mr Justice Paul Coffey extended his deepest sympathy to the baby's mother and extended family.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Family of woman who died after getting wrong medicine settle case with pharmacy
The family of a woman who it was claimed collapsed and later died after taking medicine supplied by her local pharmacy which was intended for another customer has settled a High Court action over her death. Mother of two and grandmother of six, Margaret Corcoran, 73, was found in a collapsed state at her Tymonville Park, Tallaght, Dublin, home on October 9, 2022. She was transferred to hospital, where she was found to have suffered a brain injury. Ms Corcoran did not recover and died in hospital 11 days later on October 20, 2022. In the proceedings, it was claimed that a blister pack of medication, which was prescribed for another person with the same first name, was mistakenly delivered to Ms Corcoran six days before she was found collapsed in her home. The family's counsel Esther Earley BL, instructed by O'Brien & Co Solicitors, told the High Court the case had been settled and it was before the court for approval of the division of the statutory €35,000 mental distress solatium payment. The settlement is without an admission of liability. Ms Corcoran's sister, Marian Reilly, of Lucan, Dublin, had sued Glenview Pharmacy Ltd with a registered address at Upper Baggot Street, Dublin and trading as Meaghers Pharmacy over the death of her sister. On October 3, 2022, it was claimed that a blister pack of tablets was prepared at Meaghers Pharmacy, Castletymon Park Shopping Centre, Tymon Road, Tallaght for dispatch to Ms Corcoran, but it was alleged that that an incorrect blister pack meant for someone else was sent to Ms Corcoran. In the proceedings, it was claimed there was an alleged failure to exercise the appropriate level of care, skill and diligence that Ms Corcoran was entitled to expect in relation to dispatching her prescription medication to her home. It was also claimed there was an alleged failure to have any or any adequate system of checks and safeguards in place to ensure that prescriptions and medication dispensed were checked and rechecked to ensure that they were dispatched to the correct customer. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Somebody else's prescription, it was alleged, was wrongly and mistakenly delivered to Ms Corcoran and it was contended there was an alleged failure to contact Ms Corcoran urgently or at all to ensure that she did not consume the medication when they ought to have known the significant risks the medication posed for her. It was claimed that alleged sub-standard pharmacy services had been provided to Ms Corcoran. At an inquest in March of last year into the death of Ms Corcoran, her sister Ms Reilly described finding her sister on the ground beside her bed in an unresponsive state with 'frothing from her mouth'. A representative of Meaghers Pharmacy Group at the inquest offered the company's 'most heartfelt condolences' to Ms Corcoran's family. She said the pharmacy only became aware that the wrong medication had been given to Ms Corcoran after it had been contacted by a nurse following Ms Corcoran's admission to the hospital. The Coroner's Court also heard that afterwards, storage at the nine Meaghers Pharmacy outlets had been rearranged and labels on all prescription bags are now double checked by two staff members, including one who must be a pharmacist A verdict of death by misadventure was returned.


Irish Examiner
16 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Preventing avoidable baby deaths means having all the information
Ask the HSE what the main risk factors for stillbirths are and it will tell you, but ask how many avoidable baby deaths there have been in maternity units since 2013 and it won't. It does know, but it just won't tell you. While the HSE will accept that 'all elements of healthcare have adverse events', it will always insist every effort is made to learn from these events and reduce the risk of recurrence. But 'every effort' so far does not extend to acceding to calls by maternity reform advocates to publicly announce a review of 50-plus baby death inquests since 2013. The HSE's determination to learn from these tragedies also does not extend to publicly acknowledging any attempt to find out what were the outcomes of all 655 baby deaths and injuries classed as Serious Reportable Events reported to the HSE's National Incident Management System between 2016 and 2023. No matter how many times the HSE or the Department of Health are asked, they insist there is little or no point in reviewing either of these sources of information. Last spring, this reporter was informed by a senior HSE executive that 'we know about all of these deaths' — so perhaps they feel they have all the answers. But if that is the case, why are babies still dying avoidable deaths in Ireland? Perhaps the answer lies in a growing view among women that they are being gaslighted into believing they are among the main reasons for their babies' deaths. On the list of risk factors for stillbirths, for example, the HSE says there are congenital anomalies (birth defects) in babies and things like the age, BMI, and the socioeconomic background of mothers. It will say risk factors centre around lifestyle choices such as drinking, smoking, and taking drugs. But what gets little attention in the panoply of health service information is the elephant in the room of Irish health services, and in particular maternity services; human error. Hardly a few months go by and another anguished mother is sobbing at the steps of either a coroner's court or the High Court as she recounts how what happened to her baby shouldn't have happened. Like so many others since 2013, Lisa Duffy received an apology from the HSE for care failings. She was promised that lessons would be learned. The apology came at her son Luke's inquest in January 2022, which resulted in a verdict of medical misadventure. Luke was stillborn in 2018 at Portlaoise Hospital, after — among other things — midwives failed to spot that Lisa was in labour. Since experiencing Baby Luke's 'needless loss', she has been at the forefront of maternity reform advocacy. Mel and Lisa Duffy holding a framed photo of Baby Luke after he was stillborn. Since experiencing Baby Luke's 'needless loss', Lisa has been at the forefront of maternity reform advocacy. 'You don't realise the extent to which things can go wrong despite you and your baby being perfectly fit and healthy,' she recalls. 'You also just take it for granted that you will be cared for and trained staff will do their jobs properly. 'But bitter experience has shown me and so many other mums and dads that you can take nothing for granted. They will tell you there are lifestyle factors and there are these congenital anomalies but what they won't talk about in any great detail are the mistakes that get made. Women are gaslighted into believing the main reasons are themselves or their babies. 'Yet, as I and so many others have discovered, human error is also a big cause not just of avoidable baby deaths but also birth injuries.' It was Lisa's help with Irish Examiner-initiated research in 2023 that led to the discovery that there have been at least 56 avoidable baby deaths in maternity units in less than a decade. Cardiotocography (CTG) monitoring The research, based on a review of reports of inquests into babies who died between 2013 and 2022, led to calls for a review of avoidable baby death. The research threw up a number of factors common to cases, such as delayed deliveries, a lack of appropriate training and communications failures by staff. The biggest single factor in 28 of the 56 deaths was related to cardiotocography (CTG) monitoring of babies' hearts and the mothers' contractions. On December 21, 2023, the then health minister denied in an RTÉ interview that there was any 'trend' in relation to CTG playing a factor in baby deaths. Stephen Donnelly's response came weeks after the State Claims Agency itself stated, in a review of 'Catastrophic Claims relating to Babies in Maternity Services', that issues around CTG had indeed played a major factor in claims. In its review of 80 catastrophic claims concluded between 2015 and 2019, it noted health staff 'failed to interpret or recognise' abnormal CTG trace results in more than 60% of claims over the five-year period. Rise in baby deaths Research, again by the Irish Examiner, has discovered there have been five times more baby deaths and baby birth-related injuries reported to the HSE in 2023 compared to 2016. The figures, released under Freedom of Information legislation, relate solely to near-term and term babies weighing more than 2,500g or 5.5lbs. In total, there were 655 Serious Reportable Events (SREs) involving babies reported to the HSE between 2016 and 2023. But the agency can't say how many of the 655 baby deaths and birth injuries reported to its National Incident Management System resulted in a negative outcome. This is because they don't collate the information centrally. Instead they say each hospital is left with primary responsibility — 'and accountability' — for the effective management of incidents. Indeed, if you ask them why they can't just ask each hospital what the outcomes were, the HSE will insist that it is not as simple as 'sending around a few emails'. Instead of going back over the SRE reports, the HSE instead launched a new initiative that will take years to complete. This is the confidential inquiry the National Women and Infants Health Programme (NWIHP) launched last year into data about still and newborn baby deaths between 2021 and 2023. Cases to be examined have been identified from existing perinatal death audit data from the National Perinatal Epidemiology Centre (NPEC), based in Cork. When asked why a new process was started instead of studying the outcomes of 655 baby deaths and baby injury related SREs, the message was the same; it's just not that simple. England has a huge problem with preventable deaths, with a parliamentary report in 2021 openly acknowledging thousands of babies die preventable deaths in NHS maternity units every year. Is it not time for the Irish health service to do the same? Or is it just not that simple?


Irish Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'I got drunk after one glass of wine - my doctor called and said to sit down'
Simon Bowler was baffled when he began feeling tipsy after just one drink, a symptom that turned out to be an early sign of skin cancer. In October 2023, Simon noticed he would feel a "strange" head fuzz and become intoxicated after a single alcoholic beverage. A few weeks later, Simon discovered a lump on his neck, which was initially brushed off as a cyst by medics. Persistent health concerns led him back to his GP and eventually to OSD Healthcare in Hemel Hempstead near London, where an ultrasound uncovered the grim reality of cancer, reports The Mirror. Simon successfully underwent surgery to remove neck lumps in February 2024. He started immunotherapy and repeatedly went through MRI and CT scans for monitoring. But a November 2024 scan revealed that the cancer had metastasised to his brain. Simon, 50, from Thorley Wood in Hertfordshire, UK, then received Gamma Knife radiotherapy, a precise treatment attacking brain tumours with gamma radiation, and continued immunotherapy from March 2025. He is currently considering his future treatment options during a break. The tennis coach shared his peculiar experience, saying: "I can usually drink a bottle of wine and not feel anything. But after I noticed the lump in my neck, I realised I was getting drunk after just a glass of red wine. "I was experiencing blurred vision when trying to switch off from the day. I couldn't relax. I felt a strange head fuzz - it lasted for a few weeks before I started taking steps to sort it out. "I had an ultrasound and a blood test. The ultrasound showed something suspicious, but I needed a biopsy to confirm the type of cancer. "I was driving to work when I got a call from my doctor. He asked if I was sitting down. I told him I was driving and he asked me to pull over. "Then I knew it was bad news. He said they suspected cancer and would need to do a biopsy." Speaking about the successful surgery to remove lumps in his neck, Simon said: "It was beautiful - the operation was successful as far as they were concerned. However, it involved my neck being cut open and I had over 100 stitches." Forward-looking treatment included a year-long regimen of nine rounds of immunotherapy, starting in June 2024, complemented by scheduled CT and MRI scans to track his health status. However, a routine scan later on in November 2024 unveiled that despite previous surgical efforts, the cancer had migrated to his brain. "To be honest, I didn't feel right in my head. I started having blurred vision again and I couldn't switch off at night," Simon said. "You cross your fingers that it's not going to be bad news. When they told me it had spread, they said it was just two minuscule melanoma cells. As soon as they said that - and not a mass or tumour - it gave me hope." In December, Simon turned to Gamma Knife radiotherapy and earlier this year, his medical team recommended a powerful combination of immunotherapy drugs known for their harsh side effects. The drugs, nivolumab and ipilimumab, proved too much after just one treatment in March 2025, making Simon violently ill and leading to severe complications. Simon ended up in hospital for ten days and was treated with high-dose steroids that unfortunately resulted in nerve damage to his legs and hands. Simon said: "I felt numb, battered, lethargic - it was like I'd been hit by a truck. I've got wobbly legs now and a right hand that can barely grip a racket, let alone type. But I'm still trying. "That hospital stay nearly broke me. When I got home, I'd just burst into tears for days. It stripped away everything that felt like me." While pausing his treatment, Simon is in talks with his oncology team to plot the way forward. In May, he started a GoFundMe campaign and has since seen generous support, raising almost £7,000 (approximately €8,175). He will channel the proceeds into launching a new enterprise dealing in tennis gear and has pledged to contribute part of his sales to Macmillan, the NHS, and various mental health organisations. Simon said: "It's OK to cry. It's OK to admit you're not OK. I've been stripped of a lot of my identity - but I haven't lost my will to keep going. "I just want to get back to helping people, mentoring young players and showing them what resilience looks like." You can visit Simon's GoFundMe page here. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week