Michael Gove ‘wanted to circumvent watchdog' to push through Dyson bid, Covid inquiry told
Gove, who was the chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster (CDL), denied seeking to pressure the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) to approve the product as he gave evidence on Monday.
Reading from an email sent by Graeme Tunbridge, the director of devices at the MHRA in March 2020, the counsel to the inquiry, Richard Wald KC, said: 'CDL was keen to press forward with Dyson's proposal to a timescale that is totally unrealistic, based in part on promises made by Dyson that are already not being fulfilled.
'In addition, however, CDL did not appreciate the level of risk involved in the manufacture and use of ventilators and wanted to circumvent the expedited regulatory process that has been put in place.'
Asked whether he had been seeking to circumvent the role of the MHRA, Gove said: 'No, and it's ludicrous to think that any minister could have done.
'Just imagine the situation, if you will. A minister – Matt Hancock, I, Boris Johnson – says we want to have a potentially lethal machine in hospitals deliberately so that we can meet an arbitrary deadline. It's inconceivable.'
Gove said that Dyson's prototype ultimately 'did not get through testing' and that 'whenever confronted with brute facts about safety or otherwise, I would always accept them'.
The former minister accepted he had more 'direct involvement' with Dyson's proposal than with other applicants, but said he 'could not tell the MHRA what to approve and would not'.
Elsewhere, the inquiry was shown an extract from an email from Gove's private office that read: 'MHRA and GRW [Gareth Rhys Williams, then the chief commercial officer at the Cabinet Office] to ensure that by the end of Friday, the Dyson product has been tested and approved by MHRA, a small number of products have been provided to hospitals for human testing, and the final product has started to be manufactured. GRW to escalate any blockages to ministers.'
Asked about why he had been able to give 'clear instruction that not only would the Dyson product have been tested three days later, but also approved by MHRA by that time', Gove said: 'I could not tell the MHRA what to approve and would not. I think that this is the private office's shorthand for 'we would hope that it had been tested and if tested satisfactorily approved by the MHRA to that timescale'.
'It's absurd to imagine that I or any other minister would instruct the MHRA, an independent regulatory agency, to approve a product. If I had told the MHRA to approve a product, they would have told me where to get off.'
Meanwhile, the inquiry heard that the senior Cabinet Office civil servant John Manzoni had been 'concerned' that 'indirect pressure was being placed on the MHRA to approve the supplier's design' after a meeting with Gove, Dyson and Rhys Williams.
'I felt I had to, and did, intervene in this meeting to ensure that the MHRA approval system, as the regulatory system, was properly applied and to protect the integrity of the process,' Manzoni said in a statement.
In a separate exchange with Manzoni on 25 March that year, Rhys Williams had said he felt Gove was 'being unreasonable'.
'Even if he was correct that we had delayed anything, which I don't believe he is at all, his tone is … regrettable. But see below. It would appear that the Dyson sample is not yet ready to be shipped by them.
'MHRA could have been testing something else this evening.'
Gove also told the inquiry he did not believe that time and effort spent on Dyson's ventilator proposal meant that the same resources could not be devoted to other bids.
The inquiry continues on Tuesday.
The inquiry previously heard that Lord Agnew, a Tory Treasury minister, had warned a senior official that ventilators might need to be bought from Dyson 'so that he [could] then market [them] internationally' as 'being used in UK hospitals' after the businessman spoke to Boris Johnson.
A Dyson spokesperson said last week: 'Sir James Dyson responded to a personal call from the prime minister … to develop and make a medical-grade ventilator in 30 days during the national emergency.
'Dyson had no intention of manufacturing ventilators for profit. Far from receiving any commercial benefit, there was significant commercial cost to Dyson, which diverted 450 engineers away from commercial projects.
'Mercifully, treatments changed, and mass use of ventilators was no longer seen as an effective remedy, the UK government cancelled the order it had placed, and none were ever sold overseas.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
12 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
'I was fit and healthy until I noticed cough that led to devastating diagnosis
Flight attendant Warren, 39, was a health enthusiast and loved running until he noticed a persistent cough that changed his life in a way he never would have expected For many of us, a tickly cough is fleeting and quickly dissipates, but for one "fit and healthy" cabin crew member, a persistent led to an unexpected and life-altering diagnosis that landed him in hospital. Warren - who enjoys running, has never smoked, and maintains good health - initially dismissed the intermittent cough when he first noticed it in 2021. During the Covid pandemic, the flight attendant was frequently tested for the virus as part of his job, with all results coming back negative. In a conversation with Cancer Research, Warren recounted his experience, saying he wasn't particularly worried when he first visited his GP in June 2021. He explained: "I was prescribed antihistamines, which didn't make any difference, and then omeprazole when I went back, as it was then thought the problem might be acid reflux." Eager to understand what was affecting his health, Warren underwent a chest X-ray and a CT scan. It wasn't until a consultant noticed something unusual in one of his lungs and mentioned the need for surgery just after Christmas. Warren revealed: "In February 2022, finally got a diagnosis of Stage 3a lung cancer. Some of my lymph nodes had been taken out during the surgery, and cancer was found in two of them." READ MORE: Man orders a latte in Spain and 'unfair' bill leaves him floored He reflected on his lifestyle and health, adding: "I'm a runner, I've always been fit and healthy and never smoked, so I didn't think it would be cancer." Warren's operation was subsequently followed by rounds of chemotherapy treatment. He described experiencing "horrendous" adverse effects, including hair loss and persistent feelings of exhaustion and nausea. Lung cancer ranks as the third most prevalent cancer across the UK and stands as the leading cause of cancer-related deaths. With lung cancer awareness month currently underway, Warren has shared a stark warning based on his personal journey. In a message posted across Cancer Research's social media platforms, Warren stated: "Even if you've never smoked or think you're too young - anyone can get cancer, and I would encourage you to speak to your GP if you feel something isn't quite right. You should never think it can't happen to you." By January 2023, after undergoing four monthly examinations that all returned clear results, Warren received medical clearance to resume flying and was able to get back to his career. He has since returned to long-haul aviation work and has rediscovered his passion for running, covering roughly 15-20 miles weekly. Nevertheless, Warren acknowledged: "Although I am living my best life again, I am planning to start counselling to help me cope with the anxiety over whether my cancer will come back, as I have been agitating at every little sign of illness. I am also planning to do some fundraising runs for Cancer Research UK and other charities like the Roy Castle Trust." Lung cancer warning signs The NHS cautions that lung cancer frequently presents no clear symptoms during its initial phases. A persistent cough lasting beyond three weeks could signal concern, particularly one that continues to deteriorate. Recurring chest infections, discomfort or pain when coughing, persistent breathlessness, fatigue or low energy could all be indicators of lung cancer. A loss of appetite or unexplained weight loss might also signal the disease. If you're experiencing any of these primary symptoms of lung cancer, or if you have any health concerns at all, it's crucial to consult a GP. Further information can be found on the NHS website.
Daily Record
12 hours ago
- Daily Record
£36m Perthshire recreation centre is delayed again
Mid-July estimate for handover of new Blairgowrie Recreation Centre to Perth and Kinross Council was not met. The long-awaited handover of Blairgowrie's new £36m recreation centre to Perth and Kinross Council has been delayed. It is the latest in a series of setbacks surrounding the state-of-the-art facility, which was expected to open in December last year. Leaks were discovered after its swimming pool - which has a moveable floor - was filled with water. Contractors spent months working to resolve the issue. Building work on replacing Blairgowrie Recreation Centre began in June 2023 - after years of delays blamed on Brexit, the Covid pandemic and market volatility caused by Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Councillors were told by PKC property chief Stephen Crawford earlier this year that the delays were 'not acceptable' . He also said in June: 'The pool is now full and we're working through commissioning of the centre — hopefully to get handover mid-July.' But this week a PKC councillor said the delay again relates to continuing issues with leaks. Blairgowrie and Glens Conservative councillor Bob Brawn told the PA this week: 'It is my understanding that we are close to handover for the new recreation centre. 'After so many years of preparation, design and finally building, it is frustrating that we've had delays at the last minute. 'This relates to a leaking pool liner. 'However, PKC cannot take on the facility until it's in full order which is all we're waiting for. 'The pool has a moving floor which understandably is of complicated design and any problems would not necessarily be unexpected. All being well, these may well be behind us. 'As a result, the proposed phase two demolition of the existing building will be delayed just to ensure all is well in the new one.' Blairgowrie and Glens SNP councillor Tom McEwan said he understood final legal and practical details are currently being sorted out with an announcement on the opening expected very soon. At a council meeting in April Conservative councillor Caroline Shiers called for a clear timeline and said: 'We were heading for a post-Christmas opening and then we were going to go and work off our Easter eggs and now we're looking at maybe it's our summer bodies we'll be working on. 'I think the community has been very, very patient and that has been appreciated but an indication of a projected handover and then opening time would be helpful.' Work on the replacement centre got underway in June 2023 after the project was continually held up. It was agreed that the centre would open early 2025 to avoid disruption to Blairgowrie High School's prelim timetable with pupils sitting exams there both before and after the Christmas holidays. As well as the swimming pool the new centre has a four-court sports hall, two-court sports hall/gymnasium, fitness suite; dance studio, changing facilities, PE classroom, office and a floodlit synthetic outdoor pitch. It has been hailed as being Scotland's first leisure centre to be built to environmentally-friendly Passivhaus standards, for the use of both Blairgowrie High School and the wider community. Earlier this year PKC leader Grant Laing — who described the catalogue of delays as 'extremely frustrating' — asked PKC's scrutiny and performance committee to carry out a review of the issues which led to the delays. A Perth and Kinross Council spokesperson told the PA this week that the 'mid-July' assurance was 'not a firm date' and added: 'We will announce the opening date in due course.'
Metro
15 hours ago
- Metro
Lyme disease destroyed my life - it all started with a tick
Nine years ago, my life turned upside down. In 2016, aged 31, I went on a solo trip travelling the world. I started in South America, followed by New Zealand, ending up in Asia and India. It was an amazing experience, but I had no idea that I would contract Lyme disease and have my life changed beyond recognition. It is because of my experience that I can empathise so whole-heartedly with Justin Timberlake, who has revealed his diagnosis. I can't exactly remember when I was bitten by a tick but, that May when I was in Thailand, I had a circular rash over the back of my legs – it wasn't painful or itchy so I put it down to an allergic reaction and carried on. But in India six months later, I fell ill with digestive issues and excruciating pains in my legs. I couldn't stand, let alone walk, and I flew back to the UK. I didn't know what was happening to me – and being alone in a foreign country I was terrified. Although I was due to start a new job back home, I felt too poorly to work and I spent several weeks in bed with flu-like symptoms. I deteriorated, and spent the next few months in and out of hospital. I was kept in isolation for a while as medics initially thought I had contracted a tropical disease – after that it was a long road to being diagnosed with Lyme disease. In March of 2017, I was initially diagnosed with Stage IV endometriosis, and I had several surgeries, including a hysterectomy. I thought my problems would be sorted. That was a year of treatment, and by the following spring my pain had hugely improved, but I was still battling a host of debilitating symptoms, including seizures, shortness of breath, migraines, and insomnia. Bites aren't always painful, so it's important to check your skin for ticks and bites after you've been outdoors The distinctive red rash associated with Lyme disease is circular and forms a pattern not unlike a bullseye Find out more I couldn't leave my flat, and I struggled to walk between rooms – my mum stayed with me throughout this time to look after me. I began to suffer from anxiety, OCD, panic attacks and depression. Between 2018 and 2020, I went back-and-forth to doctors, with none able to figure out what was wrong. My experiences were put down to the fact I was recovering from the surgeries I had and mental health issues – with one GP even telling me my symptoms were from loneliness because I lived on my own. But I knew something was seriously wrong. I could see the stark contrast in me between pre- and post-travels and – when I kept fighting for a diagnosis, it was my nutritionist Laila, who had helped me through my endometriosis, that raised the possibility of Lyme disease. She encouraged me to push for a different kind of diagnostic test; it eventually came back highly positive for Borrelia, the bacteria that causes Lyme disease, an infection caught from the bite of an infected tick. That was in March 2020, shortly before the world shut down due to Covid. I was shocked but it was also a relief to know I wasn't crazy and there was a cause to my symptoms. I had been right all along. I felt validated. I can't even begin to express how powerful it was for someone to say they believed me. Had I been diagnosed straight away or known about the risk of Lyme Disease it would have been treatable with a few weeks of antibiotics. Instead, I've been housebound, largely bedbound, for nine years and use a wheelchair for appointments. Lyme Disease when undiagnosed, or diagnosed as late as mine was, is notoriously difficult to treat, and can develop into Chronic Lyme Disease – also known as late stage Lyme Disease. Nine years on from that bite, I've still not reached remission. I have tried various treatments including oral antibiotics, five weeks of IV antibiotics, and have even tried alternative and herbal medicines. Lyme Disease has caused so much loss for me. I lost my career when I stopped working in January 2017, mine and my mum's savings were spent on private treatments, and my independence. I've lost most of my friends after being unable to see them, my social life, my self worth and confidence and my life as I knew it. But something that has really helped me, as well as my family support and counsellor, is finding a focus, which is something I stumbled on accidentally – writing poetry. I started writing one night when I was wide awake with insomnia and it was cathartic to see my thoughts just come out in a poem. I was encouraged by my mum and my counsellor to enter a UK competition – winning first place! Since then I have written countless poems – it's therapeutic to get thoughts out that I have difficulty expressing verbally. But I want to stop anyone else suffering like I have. I hope that more people become aware of what to do if they get bitten and know how to protect themselves from Lyme. More Trending There are several things you need to know like what a tick looks like, the type of rash you may get, and how to remove a tick. The best place to go for advice on all of this is the Lyme Disease UK website. Personally, while I have a long way to go, I hope one day I can reach remission like others that have been in my position and start to slowly rebuild the life that Lyme Disease has torn apart. View More » This article was fist published on July 13, 2023. Do you have a story you'd like to share? Get in touch by emailing Share your views in the comments below. MORE: The school special needs crisis that will impact every one of us MORE: Never heard of bruxism? You're probably suffering from it MORE: I played 'check-in chicken' and it backfired spectacularly – be careful Your free newsletter guide to the best London has on offer, from drinks deals to restaurant reviews.
