Overcrowding sees man who spat at garda in Cork turned away from prison
Judge Colm Roberts had jailed the man for five months in Midleton District Court. However, due to overcrowding in Cork prison, he was turned away.
Prisons are so overcrowded that whenever a person is jailed, someone else often has to be released, legal sources said.
Legal sources questioned why "bracelets" or electronic tagging are not being used to tackle overcrowding.
'These are already used in the North, and would cost a fraction of the cost of a cell,' one legal source said.
'With bracelets, someone can be confined to their house for 24 hours a day. If they leave, gardaí will be notified. I can't understand why bracelets are not being used.'
A service provider is to be procured and a request for information was published on eTenders on June 5.
'This is a key step in engaging with the market and preparing for a future request for tender,' the Justice Department said.
Electronic tagging
Implementing electronic tagging for appropriate categories of prisoner is a commitment in the programme for government. Justice minister Jim O'Callaghan has asked his officials to complete the necessary procurement requirements so an initial rollout of electronic tagging can be expected by the end of the year, the department said.
Existing legislation provides for electronic monitoring in certain circumstances.
'Work is underway involving representatives from the various agencies to prepare to operationalise electronic monitoring," the Department of Justice said.
Penalties have increased for those who assault gardaí and other emergency service workers, with the maximum sentence rising from seven to 12 years in 2023.
However, increased penalties are irrelevant if the jails are too full to take offenders, legal sources said.
Wednesday saw yet another record set for prison overcrowding in Ireland, reaching 120% capacity.
There were 5,581 people in custody, with 471 people sleeping on mattresses, and an overall bed capacity of 4,672.
There were 390 people in custody in Cork Prison, with 86 mattresses on the floor to accommodate the significant overcrowding, and a bed capacity of 296. Cork Prison was at 132% capacity. Some 55 people were also on temporary day release.
The most overcrowded was Limerick Women's Prison at 159% capacity, with 89 people in custody, and a bed capacity of 56 — however, the new facility did not require mattresses on the floor.
Mountjoy Women's Prison came in second at 134% capacity, with 196 in custody, a bed capacity of 146, and 16 mattresses on the floor.
Midlands Prison had the most mattresses on the floor, at 96, with 1,064 in custody and 891 beds, with capacity at 119%.
Mountjoy Men's Prison had 77 people sleeping on mattresses, 1,022 in custody, 814 beds, and a capacity rate of 126%.
Risk to the public
All people sentenced to prison will go through the committal process, a prison source said. This will involve them being searched, their details taken, healthcare checks, and meeting the governor.
Only people eligible for temporary release and not deemed a risk to the public will be released following the committal process, but before being actually brought to a cell, a prison source said.
Due to overcrowding, all prisoners within the system eligible for temporary release have already been let out, a prison source said.
Convicted criminals escaping jail time due to overcrowding — even after assaults on gardaí — is a concern, the general secretary of the Garda Representative Association (GRA), Ronan Slevin, said.
While we do not comment on individual cases, instances such as these are a growing frustration for many members that the GRA represents
"This is neither the fault of the judicial system nor our colleagues in the Prison Service, who have consistently warned of chronic overcrowding in Irish prisons,' Mr Slevin said.
"Assaults on gardaí and other members of the emergency services are never acceptable, and when such cases are pursued and successfully prosecuted, there must be full accountability with prison spaces available to serve as a deterrent for anyone who carries out such attacks."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Number of teenage offenders reaches highest level in ten years
THE NUMBER OF children referred to the Irish Probation Service last year was the highest in ten years. According to the Probation Service's annual report, there were 609 referrals for children aged between 12 and 17 in 2024. This is a 10% increase on the previous year, and higher than any other time since 2015. Some 567 boys and 42 girls were referred for probation, which sees a sentence for a crime served in the community under the supervision of a probation officer, rather than in custody. The figures echo other findings which show a significant increase in teenagers committing crime. Minister for Children Norma Foley recently rejected claims that Oberstown Children's Detention facility is experiencing 'dangerously low staffing levels', after a serious incident there in June left nine staff members injured . In February, The Journal reported that judges were unable to send a number of alleged child offenders to Oberstown because it is at full capacity. The Probation Service, which is part of the Department of Justice, works with offenders and the courts service to help change offender behaviour and reintegrate them back into society. According to the report, there were 764 new court referrals to the service in relation to 'young people' – defined as those aged under 18, and those aged 18 and over who were allocated to Young Persons Probation to ensure an age and need-appropriate response. There were 690 supervision orders granted to young people last year. Supervision orders can refer to various types of court-ordered supervision and may be imposed in addition to or alongside other sentences. Advertisement Of these, 333 were orders for supervision while a penalty was deferred. Some 291 were probation orders, which places a person under the supervision of a probation officer, while 35 were community service orders. Minister of State at the Department of Justice Niall Collins, who has special responsibility for youth justice, said the report highlights the increased demand for Young People's Probation (YPP) services. 'We are committed to improving outcomes for young people at risk of a life of criminality, and the work highlighted by the Probation Service in their annual report underlines their vital importance to the success of our youth justice system,' he said. The service dealt with a total of 17,150 offenders – both adults and children – in the community last year, the highest level on record. It also worked with 3,521 offenders in prison in 2024, up 11% on the previous year. There were also 9,720 court referrals to the service last year, a 5% increase on 2023. The offences which resulted in the most referrals to the service were theft (18.5%), assault (17.4%), drug offences (16.1%), public order offences (9.9%), road traffic offences (7.5%), and burglary (5.7%). The Probation Service managed 1,723 community service orders last year, an increase of 6.8% on 2023. Some 222,245 hours of community service – which is the equivalent of 856 years in prison – were ordered in lieu of a custodial sentence in 2024. This resulted in over €2.8 million worth of unpaid work. The duration of the most frequently imposed community service order last year was 40-70 hours, while the duration of the most frequently imposed probation order was 12 months. Mark Wilson, the director of the Probation Service, said that while prison capacity, rising court referrals, and the increasing complexity of client needs continue to pose a challenge, 'I am confident that we enter 2025 in a stronger position as a service'. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Examiner
8 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Prisoner died day before his scheduled transfer to psychiatric unit, report says
The death of a prisoner in Cloverhill Prison occurred a day before he was due to be transferred to a psychiatric unit, according to the Office of the Inspector of Prisons. A report into the death of the inmate has been submitted by the office to justice minister Jim O'Callaghan. The prisoner, identified only as Mr O, died on August 10, 2022, at the age of 52, while on remand for minor offences. The report said the man's cause of death is 'a matter for the coroner'. He was arrested in Dublin Airport six days earlier, 'due to his behaviour and for refusing to comply with the direction' of gardaí. The man had arrived in Ireland the previous month from Spain to visit a friend. However, his friend asked him to leave their home 'due to his erratic behaviour' prior to his arrest for a public order offence. He had been granted a nil cash bond and would have been required to sign a bail bond confirming that he would not commit an offence and be of good behaviour following release. However, the report into his death outlined: 'The investigation team were informed by Governor A that he considered that Mr O was not in a fit state of mind to take up his bail bond.' The report said that Mr O's behaviour on committal was 'erratic' and he was accommodated in a 'close supervision cell'. He was medically assessed by the prison's healthcare staff and the Prison In-reach and Court Liaison Service team, whose task is to identify people suffering mental health issues when remanded to prison. The report continued: 'Mr O was scheduled to be released from Cloverhill Prison under the Mental Health Act 2001 to St Vincent's Psychiatric Unit on 11 August 2022. However, Mr O was discovered unresponsive in his cell on August 10, 2022.' The report also outlined that on August 8, a psychiatrist, A, recorded on the Prisoner Healthcare Management System that a call had been received from gardaí saying that the judge 'would be striking out charges' against Mr O 'if treatment could be arranged, given his current mental state'. The investigation team were told that Mr O had spent time in a psychiatric hospital outside the jurisdiction, "and it was believed he had not taken his prescribed medication over the previous 10 months'. A second psychiatrist, B, told the investigation team that 'accessing treatment in a community-based psychiatric facility is extremely challenging'. Referencing the 2006 Vision for Change document on mental health services, the psychiatrist 'pointed out that, 17 years later, mentally ill persons in prison custody still cannot easily gain access to psychiatric community-based facilities', said the report, adding that 'this lack of access results in prisoner-patients not receiving the mental health treatment they require.' The report continued: 'This is consistent with the Inspectorate's findings during its recent thematic evaluation of the provision of psychiatric care in the Irish prison system.' The report also said: 'Mr O died in prison before his legitimate mental health treatment needs could be met. This only serves to underscore the urgent need to forge new system-wide clinical care pathways, including rapid transfer to local civil psychiatric hospitals, for prisoner-patients such as Mr O.' The report is calling for 'urgent consideration' to be given to 'the systemic changes that are required to facilitate the swift transfer of persons suspected or convicted' of minor offences, 'who have mental disorders, to local psychiatric hospitals'. It added: 'As this is likely to require the development and opening of appropriately secure, intensive care facilities/designated beds in civil psychiatric hospitals, this calls for a multi-agency approach.' Falsification of records Meanwhile, the report also said that it 'is imperative that the falsification of records is treated with the utmost seriousness', after the investigation team found that three entries confirming special observation checks were conducted at Mr O's cell were carried out after the time of Mr O's death. The report outlined the three checks were recorded as being conducted at 7am, 7.15am, and 7.30am on the morning of Mr O's death – after he was found unresponsive at 6.50am. 'The investigation team noted that an (unsuccessful) effort had been made to erase the three entries,' stated the report, adding that it 'clearly suggests' that the entries 'were being pre-filled by staff, entirely negating the value of this recording safeguard'.
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Letters to the Editor, August 4th: On a dangerous time to be a woman, landlords and rent, and President Trump's favour
Sir, – Three times over the past week I have watched news reports on women survivors of physical, sexual, emotional and psychological violence perpetrated by trusted males, some of them close family members. I heard sisters Paula Fay and Catherine Wrightstone describe the lifelong sentence of emotional pain, broken trust, and struggle to reclaim self-worth that their brother inflicted upon them. I heard Niamh Herbert talk about the feeling of giving a piece of herself away on every step of her path to justice. I heard Nikita Hand say that the legal case has retraumatised her over and over again. And I listened as each one of these brave women encouraged others who have experienced similar abuse to speak out, reminding them that they have strength within, that their voice matters and that justice can eventually prevail. READ MORE All this, as the horrific news about the killing of Vanessa Whyte and her two children unfolded over the week. At what stage do we call a halt to the head-shaking, the hand-wringing, the repeated expressions of shock and bewilderment and acknowledge the fact that Ireland is not a safe place to be female? Why are we not collectively howling from the rafters at the violence, the depravity, the pervasive level of threat that is endemic in our society today? How many more women must be traumatised, brutalised or even die, how many more candlelit vigils take place before we take educational and legislative steps to ensure that this stops now? To position ourselves in the world as a liberal democratic state, and to uphold the values of such, presumes a basic equity among citizens. Have we fallen at this first step? – Yours, etc, CAROLANNE HENRY, Churchtown, Dublin 14. Landlords and rental income Sir, – If the article written by Dr Lorcan Sirr was an essay for one of his own economic courses with the title 'What do landlords actually earn?' I think he'd get a D at best. It's a scattergun attack on landlords premised by the claim that we're all part of a secret club milking it. The only actual earnings quoted are general income which include the salary from a job or business. I'm one of the small landlords he's trying to vilify. Not having the luxury of a defined benefit pension from a taxpayer's funded job, the properties are my pension. When the ECB increased rates recently the repayments on one property increased from €1,200 a month to €1,650, while because of rent controls my rent was stuck at €1,100. And yes those figures are correct, a pre-2008 property. There are plenty of landlords who aren't creaming it. – Yours, etc, CHARLES McLAUGHLIN, Portobello, Dublin 8. Is Trump doing us a favour? Sir, – The Department of Finance feels that up to 70,000 fewer jobs will be created over the next five years as a result of the US tariffs as these tariffs will result in a reduction of economic activity of roughly 1.5 per cent (' US tariffs will mean 70,000 fewer jobs created in Irish economy, Department of Finance warns ,' August 1st). However, we have been informed that our economy is operating at full employment (full employment equates with 4 per cent unemployment), our population has increased by 20 per cent over the past five years resulting in an acute shortage of housing, huge waiting lists for medical treatment, a shortage of school places and lastly our infrastructure is incapable of catering for our expanding population. So perhaps Trump has come to our rescue after all? – Yours, etc, JO TRESTON, Blackrock, Co Dublin. Sir, – The report that Department of Finance officials warned that up to 70,000 fewer jobs will be created in the next five years due to US tariffs should not be a cause for concern. The solution can be found by copying the action of president Trump last Friday when the Bureau of Labour Statistics revealed higher unemployment numbers. He simply sacked the commissioner, to be replaced by someone who will alter the figures in his favour! – Yours, etc, GERARD CLARKE, Dundrum, Dublin. Policing the traffic and gardaí Sir, – Regarding 'S ome frontline gardaí expressed lack of interest in doing their jobs, review finds ,' (August, 1st). Yesterday, I was almost knocked to the ground by a passing scooter on the pedestrianised South King Street, close to Grafton Street. I then noticed the scooter turning left down Grafton Street. As I approached the top of Grafton Street, I noticed two gardaí on duty, observing the throngs of people down along Grafton Street. I brought the matter of the scooter to their attention. Yes, they had seen it go down Grafton Street, and further, scooters are going up and down the street all day. Surprised at this ready acceptance of this situation, there was more to follow; 'And we can't do anything about it,' they said. Startled by this, I reminded them that what they were observing was an act of law-breaking. I got the same answer about not being able to do anything to stop it. In frustration, I terminated the conversation, leaving them to continue their important job of observing the laws of the land being blatantly ignored in front of their eyes. – Yours, etc, EAMON O'FLYNN, Merrion Road, Dublin 4. Bargain cycling lanes Sir, – Rita O Brien (Letters, July 31st) claims that the ¤45 million spent on the Dundrum to Dún Laoghaire cycle lane is a bargain since the users will not be expected to pay a cent in road tax, insurance or licensing. By this reasoning, will all cyclists, pedestrians and EV drivers be exempt from any share in the massive fine coming our way due to massively exceeding our carbon budgets? – Yours, etc, COLETTE McNAMEE, Dublin 19. Sir, – Roads in Ireland are funded by the exchequer. Most taxes in the State are paid into the exchequer (income, VAT, etc). There is no 'road tax', although there is a 'motor tax' levied on most motorised vehicles. These funds also go to the exchequer. Since almost everyone pays some tax, everyone contributes to the cost of road construction (including cycle lanes) even if they don't drive or cycle. Introducing requirements such as motor tax, licensing, etc, for cyclists would dramatically reduce the rate of cycling, with the attendant negative effects on traffic congestion, public health, climate change, traffic congestion and so on. Whether or not the ¤45 million cost represents value for money is a different issue. – Yours, etc, CONALL DORAN, Co Sligo. Sir, – With reference to Rita O'Brien's letter, I wish to inform your correspondent that as a motorist I do not pay a cent in road tax. I do however pay motor tax, based on the CO2 emissions of my car, to offset the environmental impact of my car. As for insurance, that's paid to a private company that has nothing to do with the provision of transport infrastructure. Let's make cycling as difficult as possible to stop the indignity of motorists sitting in a traffic jam having to watch cyclists sail by. – Yours, etc, DECLAN RYAN, Blackhorse Avenue, Dublin 7. A generous offer Sir, –Frank McNally, Irishman's Diary (August 1st), writes about his annual jaunt to Ballybrit, bemoaning the lack of breakfast at his digs. I hereby offer him a bed with the full Irish for 2026 on condition he doesn't write about it! – Yours, etc, ANNE MARIE KENNEDY, Craughwell, Co Galway. Asylum and statistics Sir, – Nick Henderson of the Irish Refugee Council, in rebutting Senator Michael McDowell's suggestion that many asylum applicants are economic migrants, states that 'The data does not support this claim,' (Letters, July 31st). The only statistic he provides is that 60 per cent of asylum applications this year have been refused. He subjectively concludes that these were refused on technicalities such as insufficient paperwork, but that they were genuine asylum seekers. He then partly attributes blame for the IPA accommodation crisis to McDowell himself, as he did nothing about it during his five years as minister for justice. McDowell ceased in that role 18 years ago. I know we ideally want far-sighted politicians, but expecting clairvoyance is not realistic. – Yours, etc, DAVE SLATER, Kilkea, Co Kildare. Not so bonny photograph Sir, – I am in accord with Finn McRedmond's opinions in her Bonnie Blue article – apart perhaps from this being the best time to be alive (' Bonnie Blue: Why the free-sex 'content creator' is nauseating and wrong ,' July 31st) But why on earth is the article illustrated with a large, unavoidable and rather silly picture of Miss Blue? The Irish Times isn't social media and should avoid the 'Oh you are awful, tell me more' redtop vibe. Why publicise this person's image? Please, Irish Times remember your journalistic standards! – Yours, etc, MAIRIDE WOODS, Dublin 13. Filler thriller Sir, – I always smile when I turn over to the Letters page and see a smattering of short ones or 'fillers' as I like to call them. You just can't beat an eclectic and diverse mix of opinions. – Yours, etc, DEE DELANY, Raheny, Dublin 5. Germ supporter Sir, – Recent correspondence on our immune system and germs (Letters, July 31st and August 1st) reminded me of an expression often used by my late mother. When, as children, my brothers and I would often arrive home from an evening exploring in the fields or scrambling through the nearby woods stained from top to toe with soil and any other detritus that came our way and she would smile saying it was just 'clean dirt'. Looking back it's clear she knew the importance of beneficial bacteria and of building a robust immune system. Her philosophy has stood me in good stead to this day. Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater in an obsessive desire to cleanse our environment of all germs, be they good or bad. – Yours, etc, PAT MULLEN, Kilkerley, Co Louth.
