Ex-deputy PM Therese Coffey claims civil servants advised her to break the law
She told the House of Lords on Friday: 'There were several occasions when I was advised by civil servants to knowingly break the law.
'Now, they may have only been minor infringements, but I challenge about how is that possible under the Civil Service Code that, in your advice and in your inaction, you are advising me to knowingly break the law? And I wasn't prepared to do it.'
Lady Coffey went on to recall another situation when she felt the Civil Service Code was not adhered to.
She said: 'I learned that my shadow secretary of state had written to me on Twitter, and I knew it because he also published my response to him on Twitter.
'I'd never seen the letter from the shadow secretary of state. I had never seen the letter written in my name, but there it was: my response and my signature.
'And these sorts of things, unfortunately, in the Civil Service Code should be more serious than it was.'
The Tory peer added: 'Sometimes people try and suggest it's just politicians trying to do this, that and the other.
'I'm not accusing the Civil Service, but their job is to try and manage and, ultimately, I could go on about another legal case where I was named as the defendant.
'I didn't know until a ruling had come against me, formally.
Then-prime minister Liz Truss and deputy prime minister Therese Coffey in 2022 (Jacob King/PA)
'These things, I'm afraid, do happen.'
Her comments came as peers debated a report from the Constitution Select Committee entitled Executive Oversight And Responsibility For The UK Constitution.
Lady Coffey was deputy prime minister in the Liz Truss government in September and October of 2022.
After her brief premiership, Ms Truss took swipes at the Civil Service and blamed the so-called deep state for 'sabotaging' her.
Speaking at a conference in the US in 2024, the former prime minister said: 'I wanted to cut taxes, reduce the administrative state, take back control as people talked about in the Brexit referendum.
'What I did face was a huge establishment backlash and a lot of it actually came from the state itself.'
Ms Truss added: 'Now people are joining the Civil Service who are essentially activists.
'They might be trans activists, they might be environmental extremists, but they are now having a voice within the Civil Service in a way I don't think was true 30 or 40 years ago.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
TONY HETHERINGTON: What's the Civil Service done to my pension after I retired?
Tony Hetherington is Financial Mail on Sunday's ace investigator, fighting readers corners, revealing the truth that lies behind closed doors and winning victories for those who have been left out-of-pocket. Find out how to contact him below. Ms R.F writes: I retired from the Civil Service in February, after 26 years. I gave the required four months notice and claimed my pension, but so far I have received no payment and nothing to say when I will start receiving it. I have been trying constantly to contact the pension scheme by phone and email, but without getting anywhere. Tony Hetherington replies: The Civil Service pension scheme is financed by the taxpayer and by contributions deducted from civil servants' pay. It is the responsibility of the Cabinet Office in Whitehall, headed by Pat McFadden MP. But the Government contracted out the running of the scheme to MyCSP Ltd – and this is where things have gone badly wrong. You told me you contacted MyCSP when your first pension payment failed to arrive, but nobody could help you. You then contacted Equiniti, the American-owned financial services firm behind MyCSP, but they simply put your call through to MyCSP again, which put you on hold, with no pension, no advice, and no explanation. I think politicians should be held responsible for the failures of companies they hire to carry out what would at one time have been public services. So, armed with your signed authority allowing me to make enquiries on your behalf, I by-passed MyCSP and went straight to the Cabinet Office. Two days later, your pension arrived. This was excellent, but what had gone wrong in the first place, I asked? Was four months not long enough to allow for the start of your pension? And whether it was or not, why was nobody able to explain what was going on? The Cabinet Office, like MyCSP itself, failed to offer any explanation. Officials there seemed to think once you got your pension, you and I would lose interest. Wrong! This is not a one-off incident. Your experience is symptomatic of what can happen when the Government pays an outside contractor to do its job and fails to keep hold of the reins as the contractor goes off course. Who says so? The Government's own National Audit Office (NAO) says so. It opened an investigation after seeing a sharp rise in complaints from Civil Service pensioners. Last year there were over 4,800 complaints, with the NAO identifying repeated failures by MyCSP to start pension payments on time. Some pensioners were waiting for months. And a spot check last November on how long it took MyCSP's contact centre to answer the phone showed on average callers were forced to wait 24 minutes. The NAO concluded: 'Cabinet Office has been unable to hold the current pension scheme administrator, MyCSP, accountable for when performance has fallen below agreed service levels or incentivise improvement through its contract.' There was really little reason for MyCSP to up its game. The Government had already decided in 2023 it would dump it in favour of Capita – but there are already signs tomorrow's mess will be no better than today's. Capita was due to take over the pension scheme in December this year, earning itself £239million to run it for the next seven years. But Capita has already missed three deadlines in its transition work, so the takeover has been pushed back to next March at the earliest. It does not look as if Civil Service pensioners can count on a future that is any brighter than today's failures. WE'RE WATCHING YOU A former Nasa scientist is facing prison after pleading guilty to a £1 million investment fraud. John Burford, 85, who now lives in Mansfield in Nottinghamshire, owned and ran Financial Trading Strategies Ltd. He had worked at Nasa on a team to send men to Mars before he became a trading adviser in the US – but he had never been authorised to offer advice or manage funds in the UK. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) found that he had recruited more than 100 investors to his VIP Traders' Club, and made more than £1 million from them which he used for 'living expenses'. The FCA said he 'repeatedly lied to investors' and 'hid the full extent' of his losses. In December 2023 it put his company on its list of unauthorised firms, but no action was taken. Last August I warned Burford was still breaking the law, but he was not charged until April. He pleaded guilty at Westminster Magistrates' Court and will be sentenced at Southwark Crown Court at a later date. He faces an unlimited fine, and between his unlicensed business and fraud charge could be handed 12 years. The FCA said: 'Burford fleeced unwitting investors to enrich his life – not theirs.'
Belfast Telegraph
4 hours ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Jim Allister rages at NI Protocol as ‘building block to Irish unity' during Glasgow Twelfth
He said the very substance and existence of the United Kingdom was at risk because of the NI Protocol and Windsor Framework as NI now shares identical 'foreign laws' with the Republic of Ireland. The Windsor Framework was agreed between the government and EU in 2023 following unionist concerns over trade barriers under their original post-Brexit deal, the Northern Ireland Protocol. Allister has previously said the framework was "the original protocol by another name". Speaking in Glasgow he said the constitutional basis of Scotland's membership of the UK, the Act of Union 1707, and Northern Ireland's, the Act of Union 1800, are identical in form and substance. 'Each is built on the twin pillars of a political union and an economic union,' he told those in attendance. 'Article 3 of each of our Acts of Union affirm a political union through a single sovereign parliament for the whole nation; and each of our Articles 6 guarantee unfettered trade between and within all parts of the Kingdom. 'It is the latter, of course, that has been trashed by the union-dismantling Windsor Framework, because it fetters trade with NI by establishing an EU border to entrap NI within its territory and control. 'Whereas England, Scotland and Wales left the EU, Northern Ireland was left behind under its Customs Code and in its single market for goods, meaning in 300 areas of law we are governed by foreign laws we don't make and can't change.' He described it as 'a democratic outrage' and 'a deliberate building block for Irish unity' as NI is now governed in those 300 areas by the identical laws as the Republic of Ireland. Mr Allister added: 'And as these are the laws that shape our trade and economy they are inexorably building the stepping stone of an all-Ireland economy, which always was the intended design of the Windsor Framework. 'Hence, why anyone worthy of the name 'unionist' rejects the Windsor Framework in all its parts.'
Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Labour is already making a difference, writes Labour chair Ellie Reeves
One year ago, the British people voted for change — and today, we mark the first anniversary of a Labour government committed to delivering just that. Over the past 12 months, we have begun to turn the page on 14 years of Tory chaos and decline. And while it hasn't been easy, and we know there is much more to do, our Plan for Change is already making a difference. The first phase of this government was about taking immediate action to fix the foundations and stabilise our economy. Because of this action, Britain had the highest growth of any G7 economy in the first quarter of this year. Interest rates have been cut four times, lowering people's mortgages. Wages are rising faster than prices. NHS waiting lists are falling, with the delivery of four million extra NHS appointments. And breakfast clubs are being rolled out across the country, to give kids a healthy start to the day and to put more money in parents' pockets. Yes, we know the job is far from done and we won't sugarcoat the scale of the challenge. But if the first phase of this government was about taking immediate action to fix the foundations and clean up the mess the Tories left behind, the second phase is now about making working people better off. And as our focus shifts firmly to the future, we are going further and faster to deliver the change we promised. While the Conservatives and Reform UK risk the economy by making unfunded promises they cannot keep, we are working tirelessly to improve living standards for people across the country. Striving to build a renewed Britain, where your hard work is rewarded. Where your NHS is there when you need it. Where your community is safe, and your future is secure. That is the country we're building together. This is not about quick fixes. It's about rebuilding Britain — to make it fairer, stronger, and more secure. To put money back in working people's pockets and build a better future together. Follow our Mirror Politics account on Bluesky here. And follow our Mirror Politics team here - Lizzy Buchan, Mikey Smith, Kevin Maguire, Sophie Huskisson, Dave Burke and Ashley Cowburn. Be first to get the biggest bombshells and breaking news by joining our Politics WhatsApp group here. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you want to leave our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Or sign up here to the Mirror's Politics newsletter for all the best exclusives and opinions straight to your inbox. And listen to our exciting new political podcast The Division Bell, hosted by the Mirror and the Express every Thursday.
