Toronto's 2005 Boxing Day gunman faces first-degree murder charge in Montreal
MONTREAL — Jeremiah Valentine, who went to prison for taking part in the 2005 Boxing Day shootout in Toronto that killed a 15-year-old girl, has been charged with murder in Montreal.
Article content
The 43-year-old faces one count of first-degree murder in the killing of Abdeck Kenedith Ibrahim, 33, who was gunned down in a downtown Montreal square around 12:45 a.m. Tuesday.
Article content
Article content
Article content
Valentine was among several people convicted in the 2005 shootout in downtown Toronto between rival gangs that killed 15-year-old Jane Creba and injured six others. Creba was shopping with her mother and sister on Yonge Street, traditionally one of Toronto's busiest strips for Boxing Day bargain hunters, when she was caught in the crossfire.
Article content
Article content
The Crown said forensics had determined it was 'very likely' he fired the bullet that killed the Grade 10 student, but admitted those tests were not definitive and that the bullet could have come from two other weapons.
Article content
In 2009, Valentine pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and was given a life sentence with no chance of parole for 12 years for a crime that became a flashpoint for the city's anger over a rise in gun-related killings. Valentine would have had to wait much longer than 12 years for parole eligibility if he hadn't pleaded guilty, Ontario Superior Court Justice John McMahon said at the time.
Article content
Article content
The Crown says the Montreal case was put off until Oct. 23, following a brief hearing at the city's courthouse on Thursday. According to the charging document, Valentine was living in downtown Montreal.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
4 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
News briefs for Tuesday, July 29, 2025
A collection of breaking news briefs filed on Tuesday, July 29, 2025 3:43 PM Homicide detectives have charged a woman with manslaughter in the death of her husband in the Maples in 2022. Winnipeg Police Service officers were sent to a home on Sardelle Crescent on Dec. 8, 2022, about the 65-year-old man's death, which was initially considered suspicious. He has been identified as David Brian Zurawell. Homicide detectives arrested a suspect last week after consulting with Crown prosecutors, police said Tuesday. Alma Zurawell, 67, has been charged with manslaughter and was detained in custody. 3:05 PM Two teens were arrested this weekend after escaping from the Manitoba Youth Centre hours earlier. The males, both 16, escaped shortly after 7:15 p.m. Saturday. They found a way outside and met up with an 18-year-old woman and a 17-year-old female who were waiting in a vehicle nearby, the Winnipeg Police Service said in a news release Tuesday. Shortly before midnight, officers — using a drone and a police dog — found three people at a home on the 300 block of Flora Avenue. The two escapees tried to run away and were arrested after a brief chase, the WPS said. The woman was arrested at the home. Police arrested the younger female at a home on the 100 block of North Point Boulevard shortly after 8:30 p.m. Sunday. Both males have been charged with escaping lawful custody, and one was also charged with being unlawfully at large. The females are facing two counts each of rescue or permitting escape and were released. 11:35 AM The Winnipeg Blue Bombers were scheduled to return to practice on Tuesday for the first time since suffering a 31-17 loss on Saturday in Toronto. They will now have to wait until at least Wednesday as today's session was cancelled owing to the air quality conditions, as per the CFL/CFLPA policy. This is the first time the Bombers have had to cancel a practice this season. Environment Canada issued an air quality warning for Winnipeg which had an air quality forecast of 10+ or, very high risk. 11:33 AM The city has denied a permit for Christian singer Sean Feucht to perform in Winnipeg's Central Park in August, citing 'operational challenges.' The American artist has spoken in opposition to gender diversity, abortion rights and the LGBTTQ+ community. He had planned to perform in Winnipeg on Aug. 20. Planned Feucht concerts across Canada have been cancelled recently, and some in Winnipeg called on the city to do the same. A city spokeswoman said concerns about a possible high number of visitors could impact access to the park and calls for service in the surrounding supportive housing and personal care homes. 'On summer days, the small park is highly utilized by community members — many of whom rely on it as a consistent space to gather and play,' she said in an email. 'It is also frequently used by daycares and day camps. An influx of the more than 2,000 people the applicant expects would detract from the service the park provides to area residents.' 8:48 AM A firefighter suffered minor injuries Monday night while battling a blaze in a vacant North End home. Crews were sent to the property on the 800 block of Pritchard Avenue at 7:58 p.m. and declared the fire under control by 8:15 p.m., the Winnipeg Fire Paramedic Service said in a news release Tuesday. Paramedics assessed an injured firefighter at the scene. Earlier Monday, at 5:29 p.m., WFPS members were sent to a fire on Fossil Creek Crescent in the South Pointe West area. Crews found smoke coming from the house and declared the fire under control by 6:20 p.m.
Global News
4 hours ago
- Global News
Man pleads guilty to 2nd-degree murder in ‘brutal' death of ex-wife, dog
Tears were shed by many in a Saskatoon courtroom on Tuesday, as 64-year-old Vernon Knorr pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison for second-degree murder of his ex-wife, Tanice Roberts. Knorr admitted to killing Roberts, 63, at her Nutana home on 10th Street East on July 20, 2023. While the two had been separated for 10 years, he had been invited over for lunch that day. An agreed statement of facts read into the record on Tuesday said Roberts was found by police shortly after 5 p.m., her body face down in a pool of blood partially blocking the back door to her home. Her dog, a boxer named Gus, was discovered dead in the home's main bathroom. Senior Crown prosecutor Aaron Martens said no motive was ever mentioned by Knorr, despite him immediately admitting his actions to his own brother after the murder. Story continues below advertisement 'It truly was something unexpected and out of the blue,' he said, noting a murder weapon was never definitively determined, though an autopsy indicated Roberts died of a combination of blunt and sharp force trauma to the head. Knorr, wearing an orange T-shirt, slumped in the prisoner's box with visible tears at times as family and friends of Roberts shared their anguish and heartbreak in a series of victim impact statements. Roberts was described as a 'happy, go lucky' woman who was at the centre of a vibrant friend group, as well as a loving mother generous with her time and energy. Her eldest daughter, Paige Knorr, told court the murder had 'ripped a hole' in the lives of her entire family, and she and her sister had essentially lost both their parents in the violent attack. View image in full screen Tanice Roberts was known for artistic nature photography, particularly of flowers like peonies. Shawna Roberts/Submitted Roberts' sisters, Cheryl Peddie and Shawna Roberts, both noted their oldest sibling's artistic spirit — describing her passion for artistic photography and gardening, as well as her knack for interior design. Story continues below advertisement Many of Roberts friends attested to Roberts love for her dog Gus, and the boxer's penchant for wishing to bunk with friends who stayed the night. View image in full screen Gus, a 20-year-old boxer, was found dead in the home of Tanice Roberts on July 20, 2023. Shawna Roberts/Submitted After listening to the victim impact statements and reading more in private, presiding Justice Dovall said it was clear 'Gussy' was a 'big, clumsy, loveable goofball.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Martens described the death of the dog, seen as a member of the Roberts family, as an aggravating factor in the case. 'Dogs are truly some of the most vulnerable in our society,' he said. Several of Roberts' family members and friends also described the fear the murder struck into their hearts, leaving some unable to answer their own doors or properly socialize. Story continues below advertisement Paige Knorr described losing faith in the advancement of women's rights, saying 'male entitlement syndrome is still dangerous to women.' Martens noted to the court there continues to be a 'plague' of domestic violence in Saskatchewan. 'Domestic violence is a huge problem in this province,' he said outside the courthouse. 'The facts are gruesome, but sadly they're not unique. We're hoping that sentences like this can help this happen less.' A joint submission from the Crown and defence, accepted by Justice Dovall, recommended the mandatory life sentence for Knorr be accompanied by a parole ineligibility period of 13 years from his arrest. The sentence means Knorr won't be eligible for a parole hearing until July 2036. Knorr accepted his sentence, despite a brief dispute with the justice about whether his actions against Roberts were 'intentional.' He later apologized to the 30 family members and friends in the gallery, pleading for his daughters to maintain contact with him. 'Don't let hatred and bitterness prevail,' he said through sobs. Shawna Roberts, Tanice's middle sister, told Global News the proceedings didn't provide closure for her and others. 'But this part of the nightmare is complete, and we can start the actual grieving process.'
CBC
7 hours ago
- CBC
Sask. judge stays immigration fraud convictions after 'systemic collapse' during border agency investigation
A man found guilty for his role in an immigration fraud scheme has had the charges stayed because a Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) agent working on the case was accused of intimidating witnesses, then allowed to investigate and clear himself. Saskatoon Court of King's Bench Justice Naheed Bardai's 106-page decision, issued on July 23, found that even though it is "quite probable" the allegations of intimidation were false, the self-investigation violated the accused's Section 7 Charter rights to life, liberty, and security of the person. The ruling is the latest in a legal process that began in 2018, when Gurpreet Singh was arrested as part of an investigation by CBSA. Singh would eventually face 12 charges, all of which were related to his preparation of false letters of employment promising foreign nationals jobs as religious workers at Gurdwars, houses of worship for members of the Sikh faith. Bardai oversaw Singh's 2022 trial and convicted Singh on 10 of the 12 charges, but before sentencing could take place, Singh's defence lawyers brought an application for a mistrial. They alleged that the Crown failed to fully disclose information about the CBSA and Crown being accused of intimidating witnesses, and that the nature of the relationship between the Crown and the CBSA resulted in a loss of objectivity and independence. The defence argued this was grounds for the conviction to be revisited, the charges to be stayed, or the trial to be reopened or declared a mistrial. The Crown disagreed, saying Singh received a fair trial. 'Serious lapse of judgement' Bardai found there had been problems with disclosure, but they were inadvertent and didn't affect the outcome of the trial. He also ruled that he not satisfied "that the evidence establishes any sort of actual intimidation." The issue was that Toban Tisdale, the lead CBSA investigator on Singh's case, was accused of intimidating witnesses, then allowed to investigate those allegations himself. "The decision of Officer Toban to involve himself in an investigation that concerned his own behaviour represents a serious lapse in judgment," Bardai wrote in his decision. Bardai said we cannot simply trust the findings of an investigation conducted by the person accused of wrongdoing. "The problems with this sort of abuse of power and self-investigation are obvious," the decision said. "This type of conduct undermines the integrity of the justice system." The judge concluded that "there is now way to turn back the clock to address this problem," since many of the witnesses that testified at the trial had now been tainted by Toban's inquiries about the alleged intimidation. Bardai ruled that he was therefore not prepared to rule on Singh's innocence. Instead, he said this was the "clearest of cases" in which a stay had to be issued. A stay is a "remedy of last resort" and halts the legal process, but doesn't determine guilt or innocence. Tavengwa Runyowa was part of Singh's legal team and agreed the stay was the correct decision. "A police officer and an agency cannot investigate and and exonerate itself for wrongdoing," Runyowa said. 'This was not a single lapse in judgment' Bardai spent part of the decision taking the CBSA to task over allowing Toban to investigate himself. He said the Crown could have stopped Toban, other officers at the CBSA office in Regina could have stepped in, or senior CBSA managers could have directed Toban to remove himself. None chose to do so, Bardai said. "This was not a single lapse in judgment by a single individual. This was a systemic collapse," Bardai wrote. Runyowa said his client is elated about Bardai's decision. He said this is not just a single officer's mistake, but a system that is so dysfunctional that people within it "don't recognize that it is broken." "That should trouble the public, that an organization as large and powerful as the CBSA, which deals with all sorts of issues, national security, border security, immigration enforcement, can have such a faulty and defective structure that it could allow something like this to happen," Runyowa said.
