More than 90 per cent of barristers oppose controversial plan to axe jury trials
The Criminal Bar Association (CBA) asked members for views on Sir Brian Leveson's proposals for a radical overhaul of the courts.
The retired judge was tasked by Sir Keir Starmer's government with coming up with a plan to solve the justice crisis, with court backlogs spiralling out of control and prisons being full.
The centrepiece of his reform plan is scrapping juries for all but the most serious cases, with panels containing a judge and two magistrates deciding trials instead.
The CBA's poll, of more than 2000 members, found 88.5 per cent opposed the creation of the new juryless division of the Crown Court to deal with offences with sentences of up to three years in prison.
More than 94 per cent supported the retention of jury trial for 'either way' offences - crimes that can either be settled in the Crown Court or Magistrates Court, while almost 92 per cent opposed the scrapping of juries for trials involving allegations of sexual offences against children.
The poll also found 86 per cent opposed a judge and magistrate panel deciding on cases involving violence against women and girls, stalking, and voyeurism.
The CBA survey found 75 per cent of the barristers who responded are against a judge, with expert assessors, deciding on complex fraud trials instead of a jury.
The body, which represents practising barristers in courts across England and Wales, suggested the currently justice crisis could be tackled by increasing court sitting days, greater efficiency including ensuring prisoners are brought to court on time, and investment in building repairs as well as hiring judges with a criminal law background.
The government is considering Sir Brian's recommendations, and is expected to announce the reforms it is adopting in the autumn.
When his report was published earlier this month, Sir Brian conceded his proposals are driven by the crisis and he does not 'rejoice in these recommendations'.
He claimed the courts are on the brink of total collapse, that radical action is essential, and he stressed that his proposals will need to be properly financed to stand a chance of working.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a few seconds ago
- Yahoo
Boy, 11, thought ‘he was going to die' after being knocked down in hit and run
A young boy who suffered two broken hips in a hit-and-run crash while riding an e-scooter has said: "I thought I was going to die." Bradley Hooper, 11, was riding his cousin's e-scooter when he was hit by a black Vauxhall coming from Sullivan Road into Montague Avenue, Sholing. His mum Hollie Hooper, 30, was told by a witness he went "down like a ragdoll' in the incident on Wednesday just after 7.20pm. Speaking while still in hospital, Bradley said the people in the car 'drove off and left me'. He said: 'I thought I was going to die and thought: 'I love my family, and my mum is my angel'. 'I have scary dreams of them coming to get me and running me over again." Bradley added: 'Thank you to everyone who cares for me and loves me.' Devastated mum-of-four Hollie said Bradley is waiting to see if he needs surgery. She said he is worried about returning home to Sholing in case the drive comes back. Some of the injuries sustained by Bradley Hooper (Image: Hollie Hooper) She said: 'I want to get justice for my son and find out who did this. 'Bradley went flying off the scooter and was screaming in pain. He moved out of the road and onto the pavement where he collapsed. It happened so fast.' Hollie was out shopping at the time and first heard about the crash when her nephew and brother called her. 'I rushed there as soon as I could when they told me and the police were on the scene straight away', she said. 'The driver nearly killed Bradley and I am disgusted and mortified.' READ MORE: Why council wants to change 'fragmented' anti-social behaviour system Bradley Hooper with mum Hollie and dad Harry (Image: Hollie Hooper) Hollie said she has not slept since the incident as she is trying to find out the identity of the driver. In a plea to the public, she said: 'Please come forward. If you are a parent, how would you feel if this was your child? 'It is horrific that someone could leave a child for dead – they left before realising Bradley was alive. 'I want to thank the Sholing and Thornhill community and everyone who has helped us so far.' Hampshire Constabulary confirmed an investigation into the incident is underway. A spokesperson said: 'We were called at 7.21pm on July 30 with reports of a car colliding with a pedestrian on Montague Avenue. 'The pedestrian, an 11-year-old boy, sustained fractures to his hips. 'The car involved did not remain at the scene. 'Enquiries remain ongoing and anyone with information is encouraged to report this directly to police on 101, quoting 44250342256. You can also submit information to us online.'
Yahoo
a few seconds ago
- Yahoo
Council warns residents to check details or risk losing their vote
Fareham residents could risk losing their vote if they are not registered. People living in the town are being asked to check their electoral registration details to ensure they can have their say on decisions that affect them. The annual canvass allows Fareham Borough Council to keep the electoral register up to date. Andrew Wannell, electoral registration officer at Fareham Borough Council, said: "Keep an eye out for important updates from Fareham Borough Council. READ MORE: Hampshire town to get its first padel courts as application backed "The annual canvass is our way of making sure that the information on the electoral register for every address is accurate and up to date." Recent home movers are particularly at risk of not being registered. Research from the Electoral Commission has found that people who have recently moved house are less likely to be registered to vote than those who have lived at the same address for a long time. With elections taking place in Fareham in May next year, this is a chance for residents to make sure they're ready to vote.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Kemi Badenoch says she no longer considers herself Nigerian
Kemi Badenoch has said she no longer identifies as Nigerian and has not renewed her Nigerian passport since the early 2000s. Speaking to Gyles Brandreth's Rosebud podcast, the Conservative leader, who was born in London and raised in Lagos and the United States, said: 'I'm Nigerian through ancestry, by birth, despite not being born there because of my parents, but by identity I'm not really." Ms Badenoch explained she felt "home is where my now family is'. The Tory politician was born in Wimbledon in 1980 before her parents took her home to Nigeria. She was one of the last people to receive birthright citizenship because she was born in the UK before these rules were abolished by Margaret Thatcher the following year.
