Kinew's centrist political balancing act a long way from Pallister's scorched-earth production
Former NDP executive Chris Wiebe accused Premier Wab Kinew this week of governing more like a conservative than a New Democrat.
It's a bit of a stretch.
Wiebe, who ran unsuccessfully for the party in Dawson Trail during the 2023 provincial election, is so upset with Kinew, he quit the party in March.
MIKAELA MACKENZIE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Premier Wab Kinew has taken a page from former NDP premier Gary Doer's political playbook by trying to strike a balance between keeping his partisan base happy and appeasing the business community and centrist voters.
The University of Winnipeg professor says the NDP premier's recent comments about wanting to build an oil or gas pipeline in the North is so off-base with the party's progressive principles that he felt he had to speak out.
But is Wiebe correct in his assertions, including his claim that Kinew is governing like former Tory premier Brian Pallister, who chopped hospital funding, slashed the public service and froze City of Winnipeg grants for multiple years?
The evidence would suggest otherwise.
There's no doubt Kinew has taken a page from former NDP premier Gary Doer's political playbook by trying to strike a balance between keeping his partisan base happy and appeasing the business community and centrist voters. It worked well for Doer and it seems to be doing the trick for Kinew.
It's true, Kinew did keep most of the former Tory government's income tax cuts. He also temporarily eliminated the fuel tax last year (he brought in a permanent, but much smaller fuel tax cut in the 2025 budget).
Kinew also threw business a bone by raising the threshold for the Health and Post Secondary Education Tax Levy (the so-called payroll tax). And he maintained some semblance of the former government's education property tax rebate, although he made it less generous.
Also, after criticizing the Tories for maintaining a fully-private lab service for medical tests while in opposition, the NDP under Kinew just signed a new five-year contract with Dynacare — a private, for-profit company.
But to say the NDP is governing like conservatives and abandoning its party roots is a reach.
Let's start with taxes. While Kinew maintained the Tories' income tax cuts, he also quietly de-indexed income tax brackets this year.
That means Manitobans who receive cost-of-living wage increases will see a larger chunk of their income taxed at higher rates. That's a tax hike, just a less-visible one.
According to the 2025 budget, the move will generate $82 million a year in additional government revenue.
Meanwhile, the province under Kinew has been spending liberally, as NDP governments often do. The NDP is spending billions more than the former Tory administration ever did. Overall spending is up nearly 14 per cent compared to the last PC budget in 2023. That's not a tweak — it's a spending spree.
Wiebe described the NDP's fiscal policies as austere. Either he's spent little time going through the last two provincial budgets, or he doesn't know how to read them.
Some of the NDP's heavy spending is needed, especially after years of cuts under the former PC government. Health care, education and infrastructure are in desperate need of additional resources.
Whether it's too much or too little, it's definitely not austere. The party's appetite for public-sector expansion and left-leaning policies has been in full swing since Kinew was sworn into office in October 2023.
Nowhere is that more obvious than the pro-union labour legislation the NDP brought in last year, including the elimination of secret-ballot voting during certification drives — making it easier to unionize workplaces — and a ban on replacement workers during strikes or lockouts.
The NDP changes to the Labour Relations Act also prevent workers from crossing a picket line if they choose to work during a strike, a significant departure from what many considered to be balanced labour laws in Manitoba pre-Kinew. It's definitely not how conservatives would govern.
Even Doer didn't dare enact anti-scab legislation, despite fierce lobbying from organized labour at the time.
Kinew also announced plans to open Manitoba's first supervised consumption site, vowed to end chronic homelessness and has budgeted $30 million for new social housing projects — hardly the kind of policies one would expect from a Tory government.
Just this week the NDP announced plans to build a $1-billion centre for CancerCare Manitoba, something the former PC government cancelled.
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
Even Kinew's musings about supporting a northern oil or gas pipeline shouldn't distract from the bigger picture. The pipeline talk is just that: talk. There's no plan, no clear investor interest, and no timeline.
It's more likely a strategic communications move than a genuine pivot to energy development.
If anything, the pipeline talk is symbolic of the political balancing act Kinew is trying to pull off: keeping progressives happy while reassuring rural and suburban voters he won't scare off investment or business.
But governing more like a conservative than a New Democrat? I think not.
tom.brodbeck@freepress.mb.ca
Tom BrodbeckColumnist
Tom Brodbeck is a columnist with the Free Press and has over 30 years experience in print media. He joined the Free Press in 2019. Born and raised in Montreal, Tom graduated from the University of Manitoba in 1993 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in economics and commerce. Read more about Tom.
Tom provides commentary and analysis on political and related issues at the municipal, provincial and federal level. His columns are built on research and coverage of local events. The Free Press's editing team reviews Tom's columns before they are posted online or published in print – part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Vancouver Sun
an hour ago
- Vancouver Sun
Christy Clark takes a — deserved — victory lap on LNG
VICTORIA — Ex-premier Christy Clark took an LNG victory lap this week on behalf of the B.C. Liberal government she headed between 2011 and 2017 — because, well, if not her, who else was going to do it? 'When I became B.C. premier in 2011, LNG processing and shipping on the west coast was considered a far-fetched pipe dream by the folks in Ottawa,' Clark said in a post marking the first shipment from LNG Canada's Kitimat terminal. 'I made the decision that LNG processing and export was crucial not just to B.C., but to Canada,' she continued at her website. 'If our economy depended on natural resources, as it does, then we had a duty to make sure as much of the value of those resources would stay here to build schools, hospitals and future economic opportunities.' Stay on top of the latest real estate news and home design trends. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Westcoast Homes will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. There was no lack of obstacles, she noted. 'The major stumbling blocks were the impossibly long and complicated permitting processes. How would it be possible to approve such a massive piece of resource infrastructure in a timely fashion? And would the private sector commit billions of dollars to a project that could get sidetracked by special interests or shifting market conditions?' 'Investors dropped out. Environmental lobbyists twisted the facts to whip up opposition. A global pandemic created havoc with supply chain and inflation challenges. She was mocked, too. The headline on this column when the Clark government laid out its LNG plan at the outset of the 2013 legislature session: 'When the gruel is this thin, fantasy looks like a good alternative; Liberal throne speech focused on dreams of riches from unbuilt LNG plants.' Those impossibly long and complicated permitting processes took longer than even she expected. Her initial call was for the first shipment by 2015, then 2017. But nothing was running by the time she lost her legislative majority in May 2017. 'There will always be challenges to establishing large infrastructure,' Clark acknowledged this week. 'But it was frustrating to also see the United States finish eight LNG export projects in the time it took to get LNG Canada on line.' Shell and its partners greenlighted LNG Canada in the fall of 2018, a final investment decision that was secured by a last round of tax and regulatory relief from the John Horgan-led NDP government. Clark had doubts about Horgan because he had been sharply critical of her LNG plan. His partner-in-power-sharing, Green Leader Andrew Weaver, threatened to bring down the government if it went ahead with LNG. But when Horgan did make the changes that ensured LNG Canada would go ahead, Clark had the good grace to praise the NDP premier for his boldness. 'There was a lot of pressure on the NDP to stop it,' she told Postmedia at the time. 'There were 100 things they could have done to stop it and they didn't. 'So thanks to them for letting it go ahead. That's a real thing. I'm sure lots of their supporters are not happy about this.' This week, Clark noted another factor in putting it all together — Indigenous partnership. The LNG Canada facility is on the traditional land of the Haisla Nation, a partner in and promoter of the project. 'I went immediately up to Kitimat, talked to the chief up there, Ellis Ross, and said we should do this thing. And that was how it got started,' she told Harjinder Thind on radio CKYE/Red FM. Ross was briefly a member of Clark's last cabinet. Today, the two are on opposing sides in federal politics. Clark floated the idea of seeking the leadership of the federal Liberal party when Justin Trudeau stepped down. She believes that current leader Mark Carney will build on the success of LNG Canada. 'Prime Minister Carney declared that he wanted to make Canada an energy superpower, noting the need to speed up the review process and interest in an east-west energy corridor,' wrote Clark. 'The Liberal government has taken important steps early on to back up this policy with action.' Ross, the former B.C. Liberal MLA, is the newly elected Conservative MP for Skeena-Bulkley Valley, the federal riding including Kitimat. He has expressed doubts about Carney's commitment to making the country an energy superpower. Ross also took a victory lap this week, having been present Monday when the first tanker, the GasLog Gasgow, left Kitimat with a load of LNG. 'Today, after 21 years of trying to get LNG exports going, I watched this tanker leave Kitimat,' the former chief councillor of the Haisla Nation wrote on his X account. 'It brings back so many good and bad memories. This and the Kitimat LNG project is the blueprint! Just cut back on the politics.' Originally, there was a plan to mark Monday's first sailing with a ceremony in Kitimat. It was postponed, owing to the death of a Haisla Nation elder. But I gather there are plans for a proper ceremony at a later date with federal, provincial and Indigenous leaders in attendance. Nice if they were to invite Christy Clark to be there as well. vpalmer@
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Many Sask. childcare operators can't continue $10-a-day childcare without extension of federal program
A recent survey of Saskatchewan childcare operators shows that most respondents feel they will not be able to continue offering $10-per-day childcare if the province does not sign an extension of the program with Ottawa. The survey, conducted by Child Care Now Saskatchewan and shared by the Opposition NDP on Friday, revealed that more than 77 per cent of respondents feel they would be unable to continue offering $10-a-day childcare. Child Care Now Saskatchewan says it surveyed around 50 operators across the province in March, with 22 individual or multi-centre organizations responding - which represents 1,526 $10 per day spaces. The Saskatchewan Government's current agreement with Ottawa expires March 31, 2026. Saskatchewan and Alberta are the only two provinces without a new agreement to extend the program to 2031. Ontario currently has an agreement in principle. On Friday, NDP MLA Joan Pratchler said Saskatchewan is facing a childcare crisis and parents need reassurance that they'll have a place to care for their children in the near future. Pratchler recently sent a letter to Minister of Education Everett Hindley, indicating that affordable high-quality childcare is being put in a precarious position without a signed deal. The NDP says that parents, operators and early childhood educators have been calling on the province to get a deal done since the start of 2025. 'There is money on the table, and we need answers as to why they are not signing the extension – the livelihood of every family in Saskatchewan that uses childcare is at stake,' Cara Werner from the Southeast Saskatchewan Directors Association said in a news release. Cara Steiner, executive director of Prairie Lily Early Learning Centre in Regina, said in the release that without a new federal deal and provincial funding formula, many businesses are not sustainable and will be forced to close. 'Time is up. People are losing patience. Get moving already and sign the thing,' Pratchler said in the release. Throughout 2025, the provincial government has indicated it plans to sign an agreement with Ottawa to extend the federal program and is ready to negotiate. In an emailed statement on Friday the province indicated that it is continuing to call on the federal government to sit down and re-negotiate an extension to the childcare agreement. 'Ministry of Education officials have had ongoing meetings with federal counterparts as part of the current agreement, during which time they have re-affirmed our commitment to signing an extension,' the statement read. 'Education Minister Everett Hindley has also written numerous letters to the previous and now current federal minister to set up a meeting to discuss the extension,' the province said. The province also feels the NDP simply wants it to sign the offer on the table, adding that the current agreement doesn't expire until March 2026 and there is room to negotiate a better offer that would benefit Saskatchewan people. During an interview with CTV Morning Live on April 17, Hindley indicated that the province would be ready to begin negotiations with Ottawa once the April 28 federal election was done. In the interview, Hindley said provinces that signed a new agreement early on were now starting to come back to the table to ask questions, and Saskatchewan wanted to prioritize a fair deal over moving quickly to sign. 'You are seeing some of the other provinces now start to come back and say we signed this deal rather quickly back in February and now we want to make some changes,' he said. Hindley also indicated at the time that the province was presented with an offer from Ottawa in February and given a two-week window to negotiate. 'We said we need to bring forward some concerns that are being brought to our attention by families and childcare operators around the province,' he said. One of those concerns, according to Hindley, was how Ottawa's offer to Saskatchewan differed from Manitoba's. A main question surrounded Saskatchewan children aging out of the $10 program when they turn six. 'And in Manitoba that is not the case they've got a limit of [seven-years-old], so we are saying that's a commonsense thing we think should be applied here in Saskatchewan, why wouldn't we negotiate that into the new deal,' Hindley said. Hindley indicated that the province does not want substantive major changes to the current offer it has, but wanted to ensure any agreement they sign is long-term, sustainable and ensures the addition of more childcare spaces.
Cision Canada
7 hours ago
- Cision Canada
Canada announces the grand opening of 69 homes in Winnipeg Français
WINNIPEG, MB, July 4, 2025 /CNW/ - Solving Canada's housing crisis requires immediate action to bring down costs. To provide Canadians with increased access to affordable and sustainable housing, the government today announced the grand opening of 380 Young Street, a previously announced combined investment of over $17 million for the construction of 69 housing units for Indigenous people, Indigenous students attending the University of Winnipeg, and those in need of affordable housing in Winnipeg, Manitoba. The announcement was made by The Honourable Rebecca Chartrand, Minister of Northern and Arctic Affairs, Minister responsible for the Canadian Northern Economic Development Agency, Member of Parliament for Churchill-Keewatinook Aski, alongside Chief Maureen Brown of the Opaskwayak Cree Nation. The property at 380 Young Street, a 69-unit apartment building owned by Opaskwayak Cree Nation (OCN), is located adjacent to the University of Winnipeg. Developed in partnership with Paragon Living, over 40 % of the rents at 380 Young are heavily discounted in order to address the significant shortage of affordable rental units in Winnipeg. Rents for these units start at $681 per month, including high speed internet and water. The building is fully leased, with 40% of tenants being First Nation members, who have either moved off reserve to attend the University of Winnipeg or are currently living in Winnipeg. Historically, the transition from moving off reserve to the city to attend university has been a challenging experience for many. A new apartment building located next to the University of Winnipeg, owned by OCN and having affordable rents will aim to ease that transition. As we build a strong Canadian housing sector, purposeful collaboration will be essential. That means working hand-in-hand with the non-profit sector to bring down costs and build homes at a scale and speed not seen since the Second World War. Quotes: "Our Government is investing in affordable housing here in Winnipeg and across Canada to help create jobs and improve the quality of life for those who need it most. With our partners, Opaskwayak Cree Nation, we are providing a helping hand for Indigenous people, Indigenous students attending the University of Winnipeg, and those in need of affordable housing and in doing so, we are contributing to the economic and social well-being of the entire community." – The Honourable Rebecca Chartrand, Minister of Northern and Arctic Affairs, Minister responsible for the Canadian Northern Economic Development Agency, Member of Parliament for Churchill-Keewatinook Aski on behalf of the Honourable Gregor Robertson, Minister of Housing and Infrastructure and Minister responsible for Pacific Economic Development Canada "First Nations must be at the heart of our country's economic development. True economic reconciliation means ensuring Indigenous communities lead and benefit from growth – not just as participants but as partners and decision makers. Projects like the new apartment development in Winnipeg demonstrates the power of inclusion. When we invest in Indigenous led projects, we are investing in sustainable growth for everyone." – Chief Maureen Brown of the Opaskwayak Cree Nation "We are incredibly proud to have partnered with Opaskwayak Cree Nation and CMHC to bring these new homes at 380 Young Street to Winnipeg. This project is a testament to our commitment to creating affordable, sustainable housing solutions that meet the needs of Indigenous people, students, and those in need of affordable housing. By providing high-quality, affordable living spaces, we hope to ease the transition for Indigenous students moving to the city and contribute to the overall well-being of the community." – Nigel Furgus, Paragon Living Quick Facts: The National Housing Strategy (NHS) is a 10+ year, $115+ billion plan to give more Canadians a place to call home. Progress on programs and initiatives are updated quarterly on the Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada (HICC) website. The Housing and Infrastructure Project Map shows affordable housing projects that have been developed. As of March 2025, the federal government has committed $65.84 billion to support the creation of over 166,000 units and the repair of over 322,000 units. These measures prioritize those in greatest need, including seniors, Indigenous Peoples, people experiencing or at risk of homelessness, and women and children fleeing violence The Affordable Housing Fund (AHF) provides funding through low-interest and/or forgivable loans or contributions to partnered organizations for new affordable housing and the renovation and repair of existing, affordable and community housing. This is a $14.6 billion program under the National Housing Strategy (NHS) that gives priority to projects that help people who need it most, including women and children fleeing family violence, seniors, Indigenous Peoples, people living with disabilities, those with mental health or addiction issues, Veterans, and young adults. As of March 2025, the Government of Canada has committed $11.99 billion to support the creation of over 46,000 units and the repair of over 174,000 units through the Affordable Housing Fund. Funding previously provided for 380 Young Street is as follows: $15.6 million from the federal government, through the National Housing Strategy's Affordable Housing Fund $1.8 million from the Opaskwayak Cree Nation in land and cash equity Additional Information: Visit for the most-requested Government of Canada housing information. CMHC plays a critical role as a national facilitator to promote stability and sustainability in Canada's housing finance system. Our mortgage insurance products support access to homeownership and the creation and maintenance of rental supply. We also actively support the Government of Canada in delivering on its commitment to make housing more affordable. Our research and data help inform housing policy. By facilitating cooperation between all levels of government, private and non-profit sectors, we contribute to advancing housing affordability, equity, and climate compatibility. Follow us on X, YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook and Instagram.
