logo
The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation is a deadly shambles - it's time for a real aid effort

The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation is a deadly shambles - it's time for a real aid effort

The National2 days ago
When it was first established, in February, the main selling point of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) was that it was the best of bad options. The foundation's masterminds, Israel and the US, argued using private security contractors to hand out aid parcels from stations inside Israeli military zones would be safer and prevent them from being intercepted by Hamas.
Global aid organisations condemned the plan for flying in the face of international law and humanitarian principles. But Israel's government had already banned UNRWA, the UN relief agency for Palestinians, from operating inside Gaza, and either restricted the entrance of aid groups to scale their operations or stopped them altogether. For Gaza's two million civilians, suffering one of the world's most acute humanitarian crises, the only available alternative to the GHF experiment was certain mass starvation.
The experiment has failed. Since the GHF sites opened, more than 700 Palestinians have been killed approaching them or waiting in the queue – many of them, if not most, allegedly by the Israeli military. Some of the deaths have been attributed to stampedes, others to Hamas fighters and several to GHF security contractors themselves.
The experiment has failed
Some GHF contractors have come forward to the international media, which is barred by Israel's military from reporting freely in Gaza, to speak out about some of their colleagues' alleged conduct. The most appalling allegations describe behaviour that, if proved, would be criminal – treating guard towers at aid sites more like snipers' nests from which to pick off vulnerable Palestinians. In a statement on Monday, Philippe Lazzarini, UNRWA's Commissioner-General, described the GHF sites as "a sadistic death trap".
Incidents at GHF sites reflect a broader pattern of Palestinian civilians being targeted near aid delivery points throughout Gaza. The bloodiest yet occurred on Sunday, when 93 people were allegedly killed by the Israeli military while approaching a food bank near Gaza City. One eyewitness told The National Israeli forces fired 'from all directions' as civilians approached an aid lorry with their hands raised.
The GHF says shooting incidents at its sites, for which it denies responsibility, should not overshadow the organisation's work. It claims to have delivered as many as half a million meals a day. Even this figure, however, is underwhelming in comparison to the UN-backed meal delivery system, which delivered just over one million meals a day through a network of 180 kitchens in April, before new access restrictions imposed by Israeli authorities cut this figure down by 70 per cent.
Denying access to food, whether through restrictions or terrorising people queueing for aid, is a war crime – a point that has been made repeatedly by Michael Fakhri, the UN's special rapporteur on the right to food. Twenty-eight countries, including Britain and France, have now condemned Israel's aid policy as dangerous and destabilising.
On Sunday, talks began in Cairo and Doha between Israel, the US and several Arab countries on resuming aid airdrops to Gaza – an imperfect but far safer delivery method than the one in place now. In truth, the UN system for aid delivery, designed and implemented by seasoned humanitarians with global funding and oversight, is the only truly effective and morally acceptable one. Allowing Israel to set the terms for aid distribution has achieved little other than bolstering a perception that it has no intention of stopping the systematic starvation of Palestinians.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Children in Gaza show signs of malnutrition and abuse after detention in Israel
Children in Gaza show signs of malnutrition and abuse after detention in Israel

Middle East Eye

time7 minutes ago

  • Middle East Eye

Children in Gaza show signs of malnutrition and abuse after detention in Israel

Palestinian children released from Israeli prison have shown signs of malnutrition, according to testimony from former detainees. The Israeli army on Thursday released 10 teenage boys after detaining them for nearly a month. They had been captured at al-Shakoush aid distribution area in northwest Rafah. A reporter for Turkey's state-run Anadolu Agency, who saw the teens after the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) transferred them to Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, said they bore signs of severe physical abuse and exhaustion. Karam Hamdi Hussein, one of those taken, said they were subjected to regular beatings and mistreatment while they were detained. 'We spent an entire month under constant beatings and daily humiliation,' he said. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters He added that a group of children was being held in Israel's notorious Sde Teiman prison, which has gained notoriety for its abuse of detainees. Al Jazeera also reported on Friday on the abuse released Palestinian detainees said they had received in custody. One prisoner who reached the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital in Deir al-Balah was unable to move and showed visible signs of torture. He was seized from an aid area in the southern part of the enclave, and spoke of harsh conditions in Israel military camps. Starvation in Gaza: Dizziness, fatigue and people collapsing in the streets Read More » 'They electrocuted us and threw grenades at us,' said Asfour, who was arrested while trying to get food. 'We were under torture for a whole month." As of May, the Palestinian Prisoners' Media Office said the total number of Palestinians detained at some point since the start of the war on 7 October 2023 is above 12,000. Despite Thursday's releases, thousands of Palestinians from Gaza are still detained. At least 44 people have died in prison, the office added. The release of detainees comes as Gaza continues to suffer widespread famine as a result of Israel's blockade of the enclave. With basic food items vanishing from markets and families enduring days without enough to survive, scenes of people collapsing from hunger and sheer exhaustion have become increasingly common across Gaza's streets. Eyewitnesses have recounted the gruesome scenes to Middle East Eye reporters in Gaza.

Israel claims killing Hamas commander in northern Gaza
Israel claims killing Hamas commander in northern Gaza

Middle East Eye

timean hour ago

  • Middle East Eye

Israel claims killing Hamas commander in northern Gaza

Israeli military has said that it killed Amjad Muhammad Hassan Shaer, whom it identified as the head of the counterintelligence directorate in the general security apparatus of Hamas, in an air strike in northern Gaza on Wednesday. The statement by the Israeli forces claimed that the directorate is responsible for 'suppressing opposition to Hamas' rule, thwarting espionage against the terrorist organisation, and securing senior officials and assets of the terrorist organisation within the Gaza Strip and outside of it'. It added that Israeli warplanes have bombed areas across Gaza 'dozens of times' over the past 24 hours, in addition to ground attacks across the enclave. Earlier in the day, the death toll from Israeli attacks stood at 11.

US analysis found no evidence of Hamas aid theft in Gaza
US analysis found no evidence of Hamas aid theft in Gaza

Middle East Eye

timean hour ago

  • Middle East Eye

US analysis found no evidence of Hamas aid theft in Gaza

An internal US government review has found no evidence of systematic theft of US-funded humanitarian aid by Hamas, contradicting a claim frequently made by Israel and its allies in Washington. The analysis, revealed exclusively by Reuters on Friday, was conducted by a bureau within the US Agency for International Development (USAID). It examined 156 incidents of theft or loss of US-funded supplies reported by partner organisations between October 2023 and May 2025 and found 'no reports alleging Hamas' had benefited from the aid. Instead, 44 of the incidents of stolen or lost aid were found to be either directly or indirectly caused by the Israeli military. This included 11 attributed to direct Israeli actions, such as air strikes, and others linked to the military compelling aid organisations to use delivery routes known to carry a high risk of theft or looting. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Sixty-three of the incidents were attributed to unknown perpetrators, 35 to armed actors, 25 to unarmed individuals, 11 to corrupt subcontractors, five to corrupt aid group personnel and six to 'others' under unclear circumstances. The armed actors 'included gangs and other miscellaneous individuals who may have had weapons', said one slide of the analysis. Palestinians have accused the Israel-aligned Abu Shabab gang of involvement in the theft of aid. Another slide said "a review of all 156 incidents found no affiliations with" groups designated by the US as foreign terrorist organisations, including Hamas. The 156 reports were filed by UN agencies and other groups working in Gaza, as a condition of receiving US aid funds. The study was conducted by the Bureau for Humanitarian Assistance of USAID. A State Department spokesperson disputed the findings, telling Reuters that there was video evidence of Hamas looting aid. It did not provide the footage. 'Aid corruption' The spokesperson also accused international aid groups of covering up 'aid corruption'. The analysis was shared with USAID's Office of Inspector General and State Department officials involved in Middle East policy, sources told Reuters. A source familiar with the study said the absence of systematic theft by Hamas of aid 'does not mean that diversion has not occurred'. US ignored report saying GHF was not fit to deliver aid in Gaza: Report Read More » Israel controls all access to humanitarian aid into Gaza and has imposed a near-total blockade on the enclave since March. Officials in Israel have long claimed that Hamas steals food supplies from the UN and other organisations to boost its coffers and resells goods to civilians. The Israeli military told Reuters its allegations were based on intelligence that Hamas seized aid cargoes by 'both covertly and overtly' embedding themselves on trucks. Israel has not made any such intelligence report public. The USAID report casts even further doubt on the unverified allegations that were used as part of the rationale to set up the controversial US and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). The UN says that more than 1,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces while seeking aid supplies, mostly near the highly militarised GHF sites. The UN and other major international aid groups have refused US and Israeli calls to cooperate with GHF, stating that the organisation violates international humanitarian principles of neutrality. Israel's siege on Gaza since 2 March has blocked the entry of humanitarian supplies by the UN and its partner organisations to the enclave, bringing the 2.1 million population to the brink of famine. At least 115 Palestinians, including 80 children, have died of starvation since March, including 15 who died of malnutrition on Monday, according to the Palestinian health ministry. More than 59,000 Palestinians in Gaza have been killed by Israeli forces since October 2023 and over 142,000 others have been wounded.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store