Bengaluru cardiologist on private vs govt medical college for MBBS or PG education
medical training in India
is far more complex than the 'private vs government' binary suggests.
It all began when
Dr Vivek Pandey
, an orthopaedic doctor and teacher, took to Twitter to share a troubling observation from his OPD. He asked basic clinical questions about nerve weakness to an intern and two first-year postgraduates — all of whom couldn't answer. Despite their competitive entrance scores and coaching experience, the students were unable to respond without multiple-choice prompts. 'Something has terribly gone wrong with our medical education system,' he tweeted, noting that easy access to information via apps like ChatGPT or Grok hasn't translated into clinical competence.
A user responded bluntly, pointing to the fact that these students were from a top private medical college. The user wrote, "Had they studied well, they wouldn't be paying crores for a seat' in a private university. But Dr Pandey was quick to defend his students. 'Don't judge my kids,' he replied, explaining that many miss out on government seats by just a few marks in an intensely competitive, reservation-heavy system, leaving private colleges as the only practical option. 'They aren't dumb. Most are good and hardworking. Their parents have earned the money to ensure their kids don't lose years chasing a seat.' He added that top-quality doctors also emerge from private institutions and that "only greats manage govt seats" is a myth.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Unsold Container Homes in National Capital Region - Prices You Won't Believe!
Shipping Container Homes | Search Ads
Search Now
Undo
This back-and-forth triggered a wider discussion. One user, reflecting on personal experience, stressed that clinical competence stems from training in government hospitals, where students work under renowned faculty and face a heavy patient load, giving them unmatched hands-on experience. 'Clinical training happens in wards, not in AC classrooms,' they wrote.
Bengaluru cardiologist
Dr Deepak Krishnamurthy joined the conversation, striking a balanced note. 'Teaching should happen in wards,' he agreed, but added that not all government colleges are ideal.
— DrDeepakKrishn1 (@DrDeepakKrishn1)
'Many have no one to guide students.' He added that most of the time, they are on their own and only a few medical colleges, both government and private, offer truly good teaching.' He concluded by saying that not all government colleges are good, and not all private ones are bad.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
28 minutes ago
- India Today
US bill proposes 500% tariff on India, China over Russia business ties
A proposed US Senate bill, backed by President Donald Trump, could impose 500% tariffs on countries, including India and China, that continue trading with Russia, Republican Senator Lindsey Graham said in an interview with ABC to ABC News, Graham stated, "If you're buying products from Russia, and you're not helping Ukraine, then there's a 500% tariff on your products coming into the United States. India and China buy 70% of Putin's oil. They keep his war machine going."advertisementThe bill is reportedly expected to be introduced in August, marking a significant escalation in US efforts to isolate Russia economically. If enacted, the bill could severely impact India and China, the largest buyers of discounted Russian crude. For India, the move also risks tariffs on exports like pharmaceuticals, textiles, and IT is a major buyer of Russian oil, and imported EUR 49 billion worth of crude oil in the third year of the Ukraine invasion. Traditionally, India sourced its oil from the Middle East, but began importing a large volume of oil from Russia soon after the invasion of Ukraine in February development also comes on the heels of the much-expected India-US bilateral trade agreement. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent stated on Tuesday that the trade deal is "very close", even as an Indian delegation continued discussions with US officials in Washington after trade talks hit a deadlock over key agricultural demands, sources told India proposed bill, co-sponsored by Graham and Democratic Senator Richard Blumenthal, reportedly has 84 co-sponsors and aims to pressure nations into halting Russian oil purchases, weakening "Moscow's war economy" and pushing it toward peace negotiations in told ABC News that Trump gave the green light during a golf game. "For the first time yesterday, the President told me I was playing golf with him. He says, 'It's time to move your bill.'"Originally proposed in March, the legislation faced delays after the White House signalled Wall Street Journal reported that the Trump administration had 'quietly pressured' the Senate to soften the bill by changing mandatory language ("shall") to discretionary ("may").Graham later reportedly proposed a carve-out for countries supporting Ukraine, likely to ease concerns among the US's European allies. "We are going to give President Trump a tool in the toolbox," Graham this bill becomes law, it may alter US's trade relationships with both China and India. Given that the US is India's primary export market, the policy could also trigger substantial economic repercussions and diplomatic tensions.- EndsTune InMust Watch
India Today
28 minutes ago
- India Today
Officers, not Tom, Dick and Harry: Karnataka High Court to X on Railway's notice
The Karnataka High Court backed the Union government after it told the court that its officers are 'not Tom, Dick and Harry.' This came as X Corp India, the Indian arm of Elon Musk-owned X (formerly Twitter), challenged a Ministry of Railways notice asking the platform to take down a video of a woman driving a car on railway tracks in Advocate KG Raghavan, appearing for X, questioned the legality of the notice. 'What if every Tom, Dick and Harry officer sends notice to me? See how this is being misused,' he argued. He also asked whether posting such videos amounts to unlawful content, adding, 'Dog biting man is not news, but man biting dog is,' as reported by Live General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Union of India, objected to the remarks. 'They are officers, not Tom, Dick and Harry. International bodies should not have this arrogance,' he said. He added that no social media company can expect unregulated functioning in India.'They are bound by regulations in all other countries but in India they want this luxury,' he M Nagaprasanna backed the objection and said, 'These are officers of the Union of India. I take objection to this.'advertisementX Corp has sought a declaration that Section 79(3)(b) of the IT Act does not empower authorities to block content directly, and that such orders must follow the procedure under Section 69A and its Advocate Aditya Sondhi, appearing for a digital media association, said content creators are affected by takedown orders. But the bench questioned how the association is aggrieved when the dispute is between X and the government. Mehta objected to the intervention, saying, 'Twitter is competent. It does not require external support.'The court posted the matter for final hearing on July 8. It allowed X Corp to amend its petition and include various ministries as parties. The Union government was directed to file its objections.- EndsTune InTrending Reel IN THIS STORY#Karnataka
India Today
28 minutes ago
- India Today
It's a shame: Vivek Ramaswamy slams troll targeting Zohran Mamdani, Usha Vance
Republican leader Vivek Ramaswamy has condemned what he called the 'race-obsessed fringe of the right' after being lumped into a xenophobic tirade alongside fellow Indian-origin leaders New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani and US Second Lady Usha comments came in response to a post by white supremacist influencer Nick Fuentes, who called on conservatives attacking Mamdani to apply the same scrutiny to Ramaswamy and Usha wrote on X, 'When conservatives attack Zohran Mamdani for being a foreigner, I just want them to keep the same energy with Vivek Ramaswamy and Usha Vance. Let's be consistent.' Vivek Ramaswamy hits back at influencer Ramaswamy, retweeting the post, fired back, 'It's a shame to watch the race-obsessed fringe of the right try to outdo the race-obsessed woke left.'The exchange comes amid a broader controversy surrounding Zohran Mamdani after a viral video showing him eating rice and dal with his hands during an interview triggered a heated culture war online. The video, captioned 'Zohran says his worldview is inspired by the 3rd world while eating rice with his hands,' quickly became a Congressman Brandon Gill joined the backlash, tweeting, 'Civilised people in America don't eat like this. If you refuse to adopt Western customs, go back to the Third World.'The remarks drew immediate criticism, with many accusing Gill and others of racial intolerance and cultural ignorance. While some accused Mamdani of using cultural traditions for 'performative politics,' others argued the criticism reflected deep-seated controversy has escalated into calls from some Republican-aligned groups for a federal investigation into Mamdani's citizenship status. Former ICE director Tom Homan even threatened tougher enforcement on 'sanctuary cities,' implicitly targeting Mamdani, 33, is an Indian-American Muslim and the son of renowned filmmaker Mira Nair. This week, he made history as the first Muslim nominee for the Democratic Party in the New York City mayoral race, following the withdrawal of former Governor Andrew pop culture with progressive politics—frequently through Bollywood-inspired campaign videos—Mamdani has cultivated a strong online following. But his groundbreaking candidacy now faces intense scrutiny amid a deepening cultural and political backlash.- Ends
