Supreme Court of Canada agrees to weigh in on B.C. First Nations' title dispute
The overlapping claims involve the Gitanyow Nation, the Nisga'a Nation and the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation, and Canada's high court on Thursday agreed to hear appeals of decisions by lower courts in B.C.
The Gitanyow Nation's title claims overlap with the Nisga'a Nation's claims, which are covered by a treaty, and both the B.C. Supreme Court and Court of Appeal denied the Nisga'a's bid to be added as a defendant in the Gitanyow's case, which is scheduled for trial in B.C. Supreme Court next month.
The Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation also has overlapping claims with the Gitanyow, and the Supreme Court of Canada is now poised to decide how courts will handle complex title disputes between First Nations.
Lawyer Ryan Beaton, a member of the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation's legal team, says hearing the cases separately would have been 'inefficient' and the high court now has 'an opportunity to speak to how these overlapping cases should be litigated.'
Beaton says the top court has yet to address how courts should deal with overlapping title claims, and its decision will set down guidelines and principles 'for how these types of overlaps will be litigated' in the future.
'In B.C., especially with most First Nations not having treaties with the Crown, there are many title claims and many potential title cases that will involve overlapping claims,' he said.
During Elections
Get campaign news, insight, analysis and commentary delivered to your inbox during Canada's 2025 election.
'We said to the Supreme Court and, urging them to take this appeal, that there needs to be some guidance from the country's highest court on how the courts, lower courts, should deal with these cases as they start to come now.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 24, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
12 hours ago
- National Observer
Carney talking major projects with Inuit leaders in Inuvik
An Inuit leader who met Thursday with Prime Minister Mark Carney to discuss the federal government's controversial major projects legislation says he has been assured the bill respects treaty rights. Natan Obed, president of Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, told reporters in Inuvik, N.W.T., that leaders attending the meeting of the Inuit-Crown Partnership Committee with Carney have had a "fulsome conversation" about Bill C-5. "We've had reassurances that the bill … will not interrupt the processes under our modern treaties and that there will be full partnership of Inuit within these processes," he said. Carney spent much of Thursday meeting with Inuit leaders to discuss the legislation, also known as the One Canadian Economy Act. Ahead of the meeting, Inuit leaders said they had a lot to work through with the federal government. During an afternoon break in the meeting, Obed said Carney was unequivocal in saying the legislation would not violate modern treaties. "When it comes to project reviews, the focus has been on what types of nation-building projects are Inuit interested in building, how can we identify those projects together, and then, how can we make good on those projects by implementing them," he said. Inuit leaders said they've received reassurances that the bill will not interrupt the processes under their modern treaties with Canada, and that their people will be invited to participate in full partnership with Carney's government. "So the prime minister and his cabinet ministers couldn't have been any clearer in their assurances to Inuit leadership about the upholding of the constitutionally protected agreements that we have with the Crown." The recently passed One Canadian Economy Act gives Ottawa the power to fast-track projects it considers to be in the national interest by sidestepping environmental protections and other legislation. Some Indigenous leaders have accused the federal government of failing to consult with them adequately when the legislation was being drafted and amended. Obed previously criticized the federal government over the legislation and told senators studying it last month that Ottawa has been hypocritical in its approach to reconciliation. He said at the time the legislation doesn't respect Indigenous Peoples' rights and warned that fast-tracked projects could end up before the courts. One court challenge has already been launched by First Nations asking a judge to find the legislation unconstitutional. Carney promised the day the bill was passed to hold talks with First Nations, Inuit and Métis leaders to get input on how projects can proceed. After Carney met with First Nations leaders in Ottawa last week, some chiefs said they were left with more questions than answers and no clear idea of how the government plans to implement its agenda. In his opening remarks Thursday, Carney said there's much work to be done on closing infrastructure gaps and improving social services in the Arctic, and warned that the region's security is under threat. He also insisted that Bill C-5 "fully respects" treaty rights. "It fully respects treaty-based environmental assessment processes," said Carney. "In fact, those will be essential for anything that we move forward. "What the act does is it creates conditions for the federal government to be more effective and efficient in our part of the partnership." Several cabinet ministers, including Northern Affairs Minister Rebecca Chartrand and Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty, also attended Thursday's meeting. — With files from Alessia Passafiume and Dylan Robertson in Ottawa.
CTV News
13 hours ago
- CTV News
A quick history of B.C.'s Red Chris mine where three workers are trapped underground
The entrance to the Red Chris mine near Iskut, B.C., is shown on Wednesday, July 23, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Dave Middleton The eyes of many are on a northern British Columbia gold and copper mine as rescue efforts are underway to free three contractors trapped underground. This is not the first time the Red Chris mine has been in the spotlight. In its decades-long history, the property 80 km south of Dease Lake, B.C., has been the focus of a hostile takeover, a Supreme Court of Canada decision, a months-long blockade, and a more recent provincial plan to combat U.S. tariffs. Here's a look at the mine's background: Acquisition and Supreme Court of Canada case In 2003, Red Chris was under the control of bcMetals Corp., but it would eventually be taken over by Imperial Metals in April 2007 at a cost of $68.6 million The mine was the focus of a landmark decision in the Supreme Court of Canada in 2010. The top court ruled that the mine could go ahead, but said that the federal government needed to do more to ensure its environmental assessment laws are followed. At the time, the government had decided that it only needed to evaluated a proposed tailings pond at the site, without considering the rest of the project. Justice Marshall Rothstein ruled that the government is obligated under the Environmental Assessment Act to consider proposed mining projects in their entirety. The ruling did not stop the mine because the court said the non-profit organization that brought forward the case, did not have a direct financial interest and it didn't challenge the project's approval — only the way it was carried out. Protests and production In 2014, protesters from the Tahltan First Nation held a months-long blockade at the mine site in response to the catastrophic collapse of a tailings pond at Imperial Metals' Mount Polley Mine in August that year. The First Nation later instigated an environmental review of the mine, and then signed on to co-manage the mine with Imperial Metals. The mine's operator said in a letter earlier this year that Red Chris has 220 Tahltan employees and spends more than $100 million annually with the Tahltan Nation Development Corporation. The required permits were in place by 2015. Then-mines minister Bill Bennett said he was confident the mine wouldn't experience a similar breach to the Mount Polley mine because the Red Chris tailings storage facility has undergone three independent reviews. A post from Imperial says 2020 production at Red Chris was 88.3 million pounds copper and 73,787 ounces gold. Expansion and tariff fight The mine is currently undergoing an expansion project involving a transition from open-pit to a block-cave mining method. Imperial and Newcrest Mining Ltd. formed a joint venture for the operation of the mine in 2019, with Newcrest acting as operator. Imperial retains a 30 per cent interest. The company said the new deal would 'leverage Newcrest's unique technical expertise in block-caving operations.' Newcrest was acquired by the mine's current operator, Newmont Corporation, in 2023. In response to U.S. tariffs, the B.C. government announced earlier this year that the mine's expansion would be among 18 mining and energy projects that would be fast-tracked through some type of permit or approval from the province. Premier David Eby said the goal was to diversify the economy, assuming there would be 'four years of continual on-and-off tariff threats' from the United States under President Donald Trump. A letter from Newmont's general manager at Red Chris to the Tahltan Nation in February says the provincial decision to prioritize the block-cave project does not change Newmont's approach. 'We fully respect the Tahltan consent decision, and we are committed to building a strong partnership with Tahltan Nation based on trust, transparency, mutual benefit, and a shared vision for the future that respects Tahltan values and a Tahltan way of life,' it says. This report by Ashley Joannou, The Canadian Press, was first published July 24, 2025.
CBC
13 hours ago
- CBC
Lennox Island's new chief gets the prime minister's ear during national summit
Last week, Lennox Island Chief Tabatha Bernard attended the National Summit on the One Canadian Economy Act, along with Prime Minister Mark Carney and First Nations rights holders from across the country. CBC News: Compass host Louise Martin spoke with Bernard about what came out of the conference.
