Tasmac scam: Madras HC questions ED's powers to seal premises of bizmen
A division bench of Justices M S Ramesh and V Lakshminarayanan pilloried the central agency over the legality to seal the premises owned by the two persons only because they were not available when it went for a search. The questions were raised while hearing the petitions filed by Ravindran challenging the ED's action.
'Your people often say the money laundering act (PMLA) is evolving but we find the authorities are evolving by expanding the scope (of powers),' the bench commented.
The ED's counsel explained that premises were not sealed but notices were pasted to the effect that the premises 'shall not be opened', besides asking them to contact the agency. The counsel said that the agency wanted to search the premises and since no one was available, they had to paste the notices.
Stating that the agency has not even treated them as accused in the money laundering proceedings, the counsel said it has to search the premises based on credible information and independent materials. He also filed a sealed cover to the court.The bench wondered why should the petitioners cooperate with the agency when they are not an accused in the laundering proceedings?
The bench likened the action of the ED to a particular method used by the police, which, the bench said, would arrest the brother of an accused if the latter is not available.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
21 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Pune cop battling cancer gets his job back, was acquitted twice in ‘unaccounted cash' case
Battling cancer for nearly three years, assistant police inspector Giridhar Yadav is back in service and is overwhelmed to wear his uniform again while performing his duty at the control room of the Pune city police. Dismissed from service in 2018, the 50-year-old Yadav won a long legal battle to get back his police job while undergoing treatment for cancer. Yadav was acquitted, then convicted, and again acquitted by courts in Pune in a 2015 case related to 'unaccounted cash' of Rs 96 lakh belonging to Vasan Eye Care, a Chennai-based healthcare group, which has in the past faced Enforcement Directorate (ED) probe for forex violations. As Yadav's dismissal was not revoked even after his acquittal in the case for the second time, he filed an application before the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal (MAT) seeking an order that he should be reinstated. The Indian Express had reported the case on May 1, 2025. On June 18, the Pune city police passed an order to reinstate Yadav and police constable Ganesh More, who too was dismissed along with him. Yadav said he joined duty on June 26 and is deployed as the control room officer (CRO) in the premises of Pune city police commissionerate. 'I got my uniform and respect back,' said Yadav. As per case records, on November 4, 2015, Yadav and constable Ganesh More, both then attached to the Hadapsar police station in Pune city, found a huge cash (several bundles of Rs 1,000 and Rs 500 notes) in a car near the Gandharva lodge in Manjari area. Yadav issued summons to car driver Vishal Dhende, asking him to produce details of the source of this money. Yadav said the cash was seized as per legal procedure and taken to the police station. A panchanama (property search and seizure form) was prepared, which was signed by Dhende and two panch witnesses Avinash Deokar and Ravindra Mane. Around 7.30pm on the same day, based on Dhende's complaint, an FIR was lodged against Yadav, constable More and the two 'panch witnesses' for allegedly robbing the cash of Vasan Eye Care. All four were arrested under Indian Penal Code (IPC) Sections 392 and 34. According to the FIR, officials of Vasan Eye Care told the police that the cash was meant for 'salary and Diwali bonus' of their company staff. But the accused (Yadav) allegedly looted the cash (Rs 96 lakh) by threatening to frame the car driver in a case of possessing sharp weapons, said the FIR. The police team 'investigating' the case claimed to have recovered Rs 15 lakh from Yadav's house, Rs 70 lakh from Deokar, Rs 10 lakh from Mane and Rs 50,000 from More. The seized cash was returned to Vasan Eye Care, while Yadav and More were suspended from service. On February 18, 2017, judicial magistrate first class (JMFC) Y P Pujari in Pune acquitted all four accused in the case. During the trial, the defence lawyer Sangram Kolhatkar told the court that as per the statement of a police officer who had registered the FIR, the cash that investigators claimed to have recovered from the accused, was in the police station at the time of lodging of the FIR. Following the acquittal, Yadav and More's suspension was revoked. Soon they joined police duty. But on September 4, 2018, additional sessions judge A S Bhaisare set the JMFC court's order aside and convicted them along with other two accused in this case, granting them three years of rigorous imprisonment. Subsequently, Yadav and More were dismissed from service. Yadav challenged the conviction in the Bombay High Court (HC). On April 4, 2024, the high court ordered a retrial of the case. Accordingly, the case was then tried before additional sessions judge Ajit Mare. On September 26, 2024, Judge Mare passed a judgment acquitting Yadav and other three accused, stating, 'There is no record to establish the source of money' and that 'no report of the Income-Tax department about the same was ever placed.' Judge Mare also ordered Vasan Eye Care to deposit Rs 95,90,000 with 12 per cent interest per annum with chief judicial magistrate (CJM), Pune. Mare directed the CJM to conduct an inquiry about the disposal of this 'unaccounted money.' When contacted, a witness who had deposed before the court as a Vasan Eye Care official, said the company was taken over by 'ASG Eye Hospitals' in 2023, following approval from the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT). In 2017, the NCLT had slapped a corporate insolvency resolution process against Vasan Eye Care, which failed to repay debts of over Rs 2,000 crore to several creditors. Meanwhile, Yadav was diagnosed with lung cancer about three years ago. 'I took advanced treatment for cancer at the Tata Hospital in Mumbai. My health is improving. There is some weakness. But I am happy to adorn the uniform again. I will have to do medical check ups at regular intervals. But I manage to perform my eight hours daily duty at the control room properly,' he said. Yadav is residing in Pune with his wife and two daughters. Chandan Haygunde is an assistant editor with The Indian Express with 15 + years of experience in covering issues related to Crime, Courts, National Security and Human Rights. He has been associated with The Indian Express since 2007. Chandan has done investigative reporting on incidents of terrorism, left wing extremism, espionage cases, wildlife crimes, narcotics racket, cyber crimes and sensational murder cases in Pune and other parts of Maharashtra. While working on the 'Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) Fellowship on Tigers, Tiger Habitats and Conservation' in 2012, he reported extensively on the illegal activities in the Sahyadri Tiger Reserve in Maharashtra. He has done in-depth reporting on the cases related to the Koregaon Bhima violence in Pune and hearings of the 'Koregaon Bhima Commission of Inquiry'. ... Read More
Hans India
28 minutes ago
- Hans India
Prime accused in Bengal coal smuggling case residing in Vanuatu Islands: CBI
Former Trinamool Congress leader and the prime accused in a multi-crore coal smuggling case in West Bengal, Vinay Mishra is currently hiding at Vanuatu Islands with a different name, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) informed a special court at Asansol in West Burdwan district of West Bengal on Monday. According to the CBI, although it was known for quite some time that he was hiding in the Vanuatu Islands, taking citizenship there after surrendering his Indian citizenship, is residing there with a different name has surfaced recently. The CBI also informed the court that this factor of his residing there had posed a new hurdle for bringing him back to India. The court had already declared Vinay Mishra as an 'absconding accused'. CBI also admitted that further progress in the investigation of the coal smuggling case was getting hampered because of the legal hurdles in bringing back Mishra to India considering that he is the prime accused in the case. As per CBI's records, Mishra left India in 2020, soon after CBI as well as the Enforcement Directorate (ED) started parallel probes in the coal smuggling case. In the same year, he gave up his Indian citizenship and started residing in the Vanuatu Islands. Both CBI and ED have identified Mishra as the main person responsible for channelling the proceeds in the coal smuggling case to different bank accounts, including overseas accounts and shell companies. CBI earlier declared an award of Rs 100,000 on him. Earlier, he had intimated to both CBI and ED through an advocate that he would return to India only if he was guaranteed that he would not be arrested by any of the two agencies. Mishra was reportedly very close to a number of top leaders in the ruling Trinamool Congress. His brother Bikas Mishra is also one of the accused in the coal smuggling case. Recently, Bikas claimed that if he opens his mouth, the incumbent Trinaool Congress-ruled government will be toppled, and that is why there are attempts to get him murdered in judicial custody.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Bengal, Odisha failed to act against illegal NRI quota admissions in pvt medical colleges: ED
The Enforcement Directorate Monday said authorities in West Bengal and Odisha did not take any action against admission of ineligible candidates in certain private medical colleges under the NRI quota despite the MEA providing "categorical" information of "forgery". The federal probe agency said it has seized "incriminating" evidence during searches in this case in the past. A fixed deposit worth Rs 6.42 crore of a private college in West Bengal has been provisionally attached, the ED said. It had earlier attached assets worth Rs 12.33 crore of some colleges and individuals involved in these alleged irregularities. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Remember Him? Sit Down Before You See What He Looks Like Now 33 Bridges Undo Probe has found that the managements of certain private colleges -- offering MBBS, MD and MS courses -- in these states colluded with agents to create "fake" papers for candidates, such as embassy documents of NRIs and family tree, the ED said. "These private medical colleges were paying agents to prepare fake documents. The agents approached and obtained credentials of unrelated NRIs by paying money and used these to prepare fake documents and projected these NRIs as sponsors for students." Live Events "In some cases, the agents and medical colleges used the same set of NRI sponsor documents for two to three different and unrelated candidates," the agency said. It claimed that this has been done to show compliance with guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in this matter. The ED said "huge commissions" were being paid for this illegal act. "Despite categorical information of forgery in cases of certain NRI sponsors provided by the Ministry of External Affairs, no action has been taken by concerned state authorities," the probe agency said. Various Indian consulates/embassies in foreign countries have informed that NRI certificates of sponsor in many cases, which were used to secure admissions in these private medical colleges under the NRI quota, are "not genuine", it added.
