Supreme Court to hear Rastafarian prisoner's suit over shaved dreadlocks
The first four months of Landor's incarceration were uneventful. Then he was transferred to the Raymond Laborde Correctional Center in Cottonport, La. According to his lawsuit, he presented a copy of the 2017 decision to a guard, who threw it in the trash.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
After consulting the warden, two guards handcuffed Landor to a chair, held him down, and shaved his head to the scalp.
'When I was strapped down and shaved, it felt like I was raped,' Landor said in a statement last year. 'And the guards, they just didn't care. They will treat you any kind of way. They knew better than to cut my hair, but they did it anyway.'
The question the justices agreed to decide is whether the 2000 religious freedom law allows suits against prison officials for money.
Advertisement
The case is in an early stage, and courts have assumed that Landor's account of what happened to him is true. Officials in Louisiana have so far not disputed it.
Elizabeth B. Murrill, Louisiana's attorney general, agreed the conduct Landor described was appalling, but she said the 2000 law did not allow his suit.
'The allegations in petitioner's complaint are antithetical to religious freedom and fair treatment of state prisoners,' Murrill wrote in a brief urging the justices to deny review. 'Without equivocation, the state condemns them in the strongest possible terms.'
She added that 'the state has amended its prison grooming policy to ensure that nothing like petitioner's alleged experience can occur.'
Last month, the Trump administration filed a supporting brief urging the justices to hear Landor's case and to rule that he may pursue his suit.
Landor's case does not seem to be an outlier. At least five other Rastafarians have filed lawsuits in Louisiana saying their dreadlocks were forcibly shaved by prison officials.
Landor sued the warden and the guards under the 2000 law, the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act. When the case reached the 5th Circuit, the same court that had ruled that the law protected Rastafarian prisoners' dreadlocks, a different three-judge panel said that 'we
emphatically
condemn the treatment that Landor endured."
But that condemnation was all the relief the panel was willing to offer Landor. It ruled that he was still not entitled to sue the prison officials for money because the 2000 law had not specifically authorized such suits.
In his petition asking the Supreme Court to hear his case, Landor said the 5th Circuit's ruling was at odds with a 2020 decision interpreting identical language in the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993.
Advertisement
In that case, the court ruled in favor of Muslim men who said their religious rights had been violated when FBI agents put them on the no-fly list in retaliation for refusing to become government informants.
The court did not find the question of whether they could sue for money difficult. In a brisk nine-page opinion for a unanimous court in 2020 in the case, Tanzin v. Tanvir, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that 'in the context of suits against government officials, damages have long been awarded as appropriate relief.'
In Landor's case, the 5th Circuit ruled that the 2000 law, which applies to the states, was meaningfully different from the 1993 law, which, after the Supreme Court limited its sweep, applies only to the federal government.
The full 5th Circuit declined to rehear the panel's ruling. But nine judges in the majority urged the Supreme Court to clarify matters in the case, Landor v. Louisiana Department of Corrections and Public Safety, No. 23-1197.
Prison officials, Judge Edith Brown Clement wrote, 'knowingly violated Damon Landor's rights in a stark and egregious manner, literally throwing in the trash our opinion holding that Louisiana's policy of cutting Rastafarians' hair violated the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act before pinning Landor down and shaving his head. Landor clearly suffered a grave legal wrong.'
But whether he can sue prison officials for money, Clement wrote, 'is a question only the Supreme Court can answer.'
Zack Tripp, a lawyer with Weil, Gotshal & Manges, which represents Landor, said he hoped the answer was yes.
Advertisement
'Nobody should have to experience what Mr. Landor endured,' he said in a statement. 'A decision in Mr. Landor's favor will go a long way towards holding officers accountable for egregious violations of religious liberty, and ensuring that what happened to Mr. Landor does not happen to anyone else.'
This article originally appeared in
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Shiprock man facing murder charge in connection to stabbing
ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (KRQE) — A Shiprock, New Mexico man is facing a second-degree murder charge for allegedly breaking into a home and stabbing a man. According to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of New Mexico, Armondo Paul, 25, faces up to life in prison if he is convicted of the charge. Rio Rancho Police investigate body found on Northern Boulevard Court documents show on Friday, June 27, Paul was arrested after Navajo Nation Police Department officers responded to a stabbing at a Shiprock home. The victim was found dead with a wound to their neck. Investigation revealed Paul went to a home after midnight and turned off the power. After a young woman and her father left the home to see what happened, Paul forced his way into the residence with a knife. There was a brief struggle and Paul stabbed the man, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office. He fled the scene and was arrested later that day. Paul is an enrolled member of the Navajo Nation. He remains in custody pending trial, which has yet to be scheduled. The Farmington Resident Agency of the Federal Bureau of Investigation's Albuquerque Field Office investigated this case with help from the Navajo Nation Police Department and Department of Criminal Investigations. Assistant U.S. Attorney Zachary C. Jones is prosecuting the case. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Washington Post
6 hours ago
- Washington Post
Trump signs ‘Big Beautiful Bill,' his sweeping policy legislation
President Donald Trump on Friday, with the nation at cookouts and preparing for sparkler-filled evenings, flooded the South Lawn of the White House with a mixture of patriotic festival and a celebration of his biggest legislative accomplishment. The president who has signed a historic number of executive orders finally got his dream of signing a signature policy bill that contains a collection of his campaign promises. And then, expected by dusk, the fireworks. It was the culmination of a string of successes in recent weeks and a remarkable display of how Trump has been able to bend to his will both allies and adversaries, world leaders and university presidents, media executives and judges. Even after moments when the legislation seemed uncertain of passage, with Republican lawmakers balking at its cost and cuts to safety net programs, Trump secured the narrow margins needed through both power of persuasion and more than a little intimidation. 'I think I have more power now, I do,' he said on Thursday, when asked about the difference between his first and second terms. 'More gravitas. More power.' The legislation, which he held aloft after signing it before 6 p.m., is the latest signal that other branches of government are ceding more influence to the executive branch. Last week, the Supreme Court sharply limited the ability of federal judges to block a presidential action nationwide, even if they find it unconstitutional. The Senate several days ago rejected a resolution that would let Congress decide whether Trump can attack Iran again. And the White House is expected to make a flurry of tariff announcements in the next week, as the legislative branch declines to assert its constitutional authority on levies. Trump on Friday also welcomed the B-2 bomber pilots who dropped 14 bunker-busting bombs on Iranian uranium enrichment facilities, in an operation that Trump has said 'obliterated' the country's nuclear program. Some of those same planes flew over the White House on Friday just before he signed the bill, alongside House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-Louisiana) and dozens of lawmakers. Johnson gave him a gavel that he banged to mark the signing, before handing out pens to those around him. 'This whole two weeks has been incredible, hasn't it? You know, when you think of all of the victories,' Trump marveled on Thursday night before a large crowd in Iowa. Twenty minutes later, he still couldn't believe it. 'This had to be the best two weeks,' he said. 'Has anybody ever had a better two weeks?' On Friday evening, the White House lawn was filled with people for what has been a traditional July Fourth picnic. Celebratory music played and many of his Cabinet members were gathered. 'I want to wish you a very happy Independence Day,' he said, with first lady Melania Trump standing by his side. 'This is going to be something special. … The spirit in this country we haven't seen anything like it in many many years — in decades!' He highlighted many of the congressional members in the crowd, several times singling out Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska), whose vote was crucial to advancing the bill after she won a number of concessions for her home state. 'Lisa, thank you very much,' Trump said. 'I have to thank you.' He also spoke about a number of past grievances, including news coverage, Democratic criticisms of the legislation, and investigations into whether Russia played a role in past elections. Reflecting on the past several weeks, he said, 'There has never been anything like it as far as winning, winning, winning.' He said the election results gave him a sweeping mandate, claiming that the legislation was the result. 'The people are happy,' he said. 'They're happy.' There are significant risks ahead, however, with a bill that is expected to add trillions of dollars to the national debt and could put millions of Americans off of Medicaid. The bill also massively infuses funding into immigration enforcement agencies, even as public approval of Trump's massive deportation agenda tumbles. Early polling indicates that most Americans don't yet know much about the mammoth bill, which will pit Trump's salesmanship against Democrats eager for an policy argument to rally around. Some of its provisions, particularly cuts to Medicaid, are unpopular and Democrats are already planning to make it a chief argument in the midterm elections. The extension of tax cuts that could help the wealthiest Americans, combined with cuts to safety net programs, could give them a potent case to make. 'This vote will haunt our Republican colleagues for years to come,' Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer (New York) said shortly after it passed the Senate. 'Because of this bill, tens of millions will lose health insurance. Millions of jobs will disappear. People will get sick and die.' Throughout the tortured negotiations in the House and Senate, Trump largely rejected warning signs even from some in his own party, and has rejected some of the projections from budget analysts over some of the far-reaching implications of the bill. Even as he has secured a signature domestic achievement, he faces other challenges abroad. The initial strikes in Iran were successful, and Trump has brushed aside any notion — including preliminary U.S. intelligence reports — that it wasn't 'total obliteration' of their nuclear program. But full inspections of the sites have not taken place, the decision to intervene in a foreign conflict deeply divided Trump's base, and the Middle East remains volatile. Trump is hoping to strike a ceasefire deal in Gaza next week when Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu comes to the White House. But he has also struggled in recent days to achieve a ceasefire in Russia's war against Ukraine. 'I'm very disappointed with the conversation I had today with President Putin,' he told reporters early Friday morning. 'I'm very disappointed. … I don't think he's looking to stop. It's too bad.' Trump on Friday morning spoke with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, a conversation that Zelensky said focused in part on Russian airstrikes and possibilities for air defense assistance. The White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the phone call. Trump earlier in the week halted some weapons shipments to the war-torn country as it faces new aerial attacks and a surging Russian offensive. But there are few achievements in recent weeks that compare to his ability to muscle through legislation that cemented many of his top priorities. Trump to date has largely governed through executive orders, which could be unwound by future presidents. Since January, he has signed 168 orders, according to The American Presidency Project. Biden signed 162 over the course of his entire four years in office. Republicans are in control of both chambers of Congress, giving him a window of partisan power to attempt to pass his priorities. But with extremely narrow margins, and warring factions within the Republican Party, there so far had not been any major legislative movement. Trump decided to package everything into one piece of legislation, which he branded his One Big Beautiful Bill. White House officials described him as 'the omnipresent force behind this legislation' and couched the bill signing with historic sweep. 'Not too many presidents get the opportunity to have unified government,' a senior White House official, speaking to reporters on the condition of anonymity after the bill passage. 'Not too many presidents get the opportunity to enact basically the vast majority of their campaign promises in a single piece of legislation.' Trump had set a deadline of July 4, and managed to secure it. He has staged a smattering of signings at the White House, including one for the Laken Riley Act. But until now, 165 days into his presidency, he has not had a major piece of legislation to sign. 'It's the biggest bill ever signed of its kind,' Trump said.
CNN
6 hours ago
- CNN
NYPD steps up security for NYC 4th of July festivities amid heightened threat level
Thousands of spectators are expected to flock to Manhattan and Brooklyn to watch fireworks burst through the air from the East River at the Macy's 4th of July Fireworks show, one of the country's largest fireworks displays. Law enforcement in New York is staying vigilant and the New York Police Department's security response will also be bigger than in previous years, the NYPD's counterterrorism chief told CNN, because the mix of large crowds at the high-profile event could make the evening a target for an attack. But conflicts overseas and incidents sparked by domestic extremists, along with a threat assessment from the Department of Homeland Security, the FBI and other law enforcement agencies warning about lone wolf attacks, have raised the threat level. Despite this, there are no known or credible threats to New York City, even though there are more potential threats to monitor than in years prior, Rebecca Weiner, deputy commissioner of the NYPD's intelligence and counterterrorism unit, told CNN in an interview on one of the counterterrorism boats the police department has deployed to the East River. 'We describe this as the 'everything everywhere all at once' threat environment,' Weiner said. Recent high-profile attacks – like the truck driver who rammed his vehicle into a crowd of revelers in New Orleans on New Year's, as well as several violent, antisemitic attacks linked to tensions over the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza – could spur lone wolf, small group or copycat attacks, authorities warn. The NYPD has been on high alert with extra enforcement at religious institutions since the Israel-Hamas war's start nearly two years ago. Now, emerging issues abroad such as the Israel-Iran conflict and at home, like the attacks on politicians and ongoing civil unrest over immigration enforcement actions, have all caused ripple effects in New York City. 'These are all individually threats that we've contended with for years but what's new is having them at the same time, requiring us to pivot from one to the other with our resources,' Weiner said. CNN goes aboard an NYPD patrol boat tasked with keeping New Yorkers safe during July 4th celebrations. In late June, the FBI, the Department of Homeland Security and other law enforcement agencies issued a joint bulletin saying the 'the most significant terrorism threat facing the Macy's 4th of July Fireworks stems from lone offenders and small groups of individuals seeking to commit acts of violence.' As 80,000 firework shells dazzle in the sky, thousands of NYPD officers, including plainclothes officers mixed in with crowds, will patrol the streets and drone and aviation units will surveil the skies. NYPD's marine units will be monitoring from the East River, each counterterrorism boat a high-tech vessel equipped with radiation detection and underwater surveillance capabilities designed to relay information and respond to incidents in real time. The massive police presence is bolstered with advanced technology, intelligence strategies and specialized units that are all designed to snuff out problems before they arise. The NYPD's Joint Operations Center, a massive intelligence hub where police can access over 50,000 cameras in the city and keep a watchful eye on possible threats emanating from crowds, will be active with other state and federal law enforcement agencies also sharing information. Strategic street closures around the viewing areas are all designed to insulate the festivities from incidents like the truck-ramming attack in New Orleans that killed 14 people and injured nearly 60 others, while officers on the ground check bags for weapons. This response is all part of what makes the massive July 4 deployment second only to New Year's Eve, according to Weiner. 'Our job is to have a combination of resources that you see, our heavy weapons teams, our explosive trace detection, our canines, our physical deployments, bomb squad, to protect an event like July 4th as well as many resources that you don't see,' Weiner said. 'The intelligence capabilities, monitoring those online and, of course, off-line threats, tips and leads. That isn't new. There's just a lot more of it.' The intelligence component is a significant part of the counterterrorism response, according to Weiner. The intelligence and partnerships with other state and federal agencies is what helps them identify, detect and disrupt bad actors and plots before they hatch, Weiner said. 'This is an incredibly challenging threat environment, and it has been since October 7th and, of course, that didn't start the terrorism threat environment at all for New York City, or across the country, but that did provide a real inflection point,' Weiner said. 'All of us have to be on top of our game because again, we're not just dealing with Iran. We're not just dealing with a lone actor inspired by ISIS. We're not dealing with just civil disobedience and unrest. (It's) all of them at the same time.' CNN's John Miller and Holly Yan contributed to this report.
