logo
For Trump's ‘no tax on tips,' the devil is in the details

For Trump's ‘no tax on tips,' the devil is in the details

Yahoo11-06-2025
(Photo: Las Vegas News Bureau)
President Donald Trump's promise to eliminate taxes on tips may sound like a windfall for service workers — but the fine print in Congress' latest tax bill tells a more complex story.
Right now, Republican lawmakers are advancing the 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' — a sprawling, 1,100-page proposal that aims to change everything from tax incentives for electric vehicles to health care. It also includes a proposal to end taxes on tips, which could potentially affect around 4 million American workers. The Senate has recently passed its own version – the No Tax on Tips Act.
The idea started getting attention when Trump raised it during a 2024 campaign stop in Las Vegas, a place where tipping is woven into the economy. And the headlines and press releases sound great — especially if you're a waiter, bartender or anyone else who depends on tips for a living. That may be why both Democrats and Republicans alike broadly support the concept. However, like most of life, the devil is in the details.
I'm a business-school economist who has written about tipping, and I've looked closely at the language of the proposed laws. So, what exactly has Trump promised, and how does it measure up to what's in the bills? Let's start with his pledge.
Back in January 2025, Trump said, 'If you're a restaurant worker, a server, a valet, a bellhop, a bartender, one of my caddies … your tips will be 100% yours.' That sounds like a boost in tipped workers' income.
But when you look at the current situation, it becomes clear that the reality is far more complicated.
First, the new tax break only applies to tips the government knows about — and a lot of that income currently flies under the radar. Tipped workers who get cash tips are supposed to report it to the IRS via form 4137 if their employer doesn't report it for them. If a worker gets a cash tip today and doesn't report it, they already get 100% of the money. No one really knows what percentage of tips are unreported, but an old IRS estimate pegs it at about 40%.
What's more, the current tax code defines tips only as payments where the customer determines the tip amount. If a restaurant charges a fixed 18% service charge, or there's an extra fee for room service, those aren't tips in the government's eyes. This means some tipped workers who think service charges are tips will overestimate the new rule's impact on their finances.
The 'Big Beautiful Bill' would create a new tax code section under 'itemized deductions' This area of the tax code already includes text that creates health savings accounts and gives students deductions for interest on their college loans.
What's in the new section?
First, the bill specifies that this tax break applies just to 'any cash tip.' The IRS classifies payments by credit card, debit card and even checks as 'cash tips.' Unfortunately for workers in Las Vegas, noncash tips, like casino chips, aren't part of the bill.
While the House bill limits the deduction to people earning less than US$160,000 the Senate bill caps the deduction to the first $25,000 of tips earned. Everything over that is taxed.
Second, the current House bill ends this special tax-free deal on Dec. 31, 2028. That means these special benefits would only last three years, unless Congress extends the law. The Senate bill does not include such a deadline.
Third, the exemption is only available to jobs that typically receive tips. The Treasury secretary is required to define the list of tipped occupations. If an occupation isn't on the list, the law doesn't apply.
I wonder how many occupations won't make the list. For example, some camp counselors get tips at the end of the summer. But it's unclear the Treasury Department will include these workers as a covered group, since counselors only make up a proportion of summer camp staff. Not making the list is a real problem.
And while the new proposal gives workers an income tax break, there's nothing in either bill about skipping FICA payments on the tipped earnings. Workers are still required to contribute slightly more than 7% in Social Security and Medicare taxes on all tips they report, which won't benefit them until retirement. This isn't an oversight — the bill specifically says employees must furnish a valid Social Security number to get the tax benefits.
There are a few other ways the legislation might benefit workers less than it seems at first glance. Instituting no taxes on tips could mean tipped employees feel more pressure to split their tips with other employees, like busboys, chefs and hosts. After all, these untipped workers also contribute to the customer experience, and often at low wages.
And finally, many Americans are tired of tipping. Knowing that servers don't have to pay taxes might make some to cut back on it even more.
The specifics of any piece of legislation are subject to change until the moment Congress sends it to the president to be signed. However, as now written, I think the bills aren't as generous to tipped workers as Trump made it sound on the campaign trail.
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

EU member states adopt retaliatory hit list in response to US tariffs
EU member states adopt retaliatory hit list in response to US tariffs

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

EU member states adopt retaliatory hit list in response to US tariffs

The member states on Thursday approved the list of retaliatory tariffs proposed by the European Commission to counter US trade measures, with only Hungary voting against. The list includes an initial package of measures adopted in early April and targets products including aircraft, cars and car parts, orange juice, poultry, soybeans, steel and aluminium, yachts. Bourbon whiskey was also included in the list despite intense lobbying by France and Ireland which fear US retaliation on wine and spirits. EU Industries were also consulted before the Commission proposed the list to the member states. The countermeasures will only enter into force if no deal is reached by the 1 August, the deadline set by US president Donald Trump from when he's set to impose 30% tariffs on EU imports. Anti-coercion instrument A qualified majority of member states also appears willing to trigger the anti-coercion instrument, which would enable the EU to hit US services if no deal is reached. Germany was for a long time resistant to using this powerful bazooka, but has now joined France, which has long been a strong advocate of the anti-coercion instrument. Following a dinner on Wednesday between German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and French President Emmanuel Macron, a source from the Élysée stated the shared vision of both leaders on the ongoing negotiations between the EU and the US. 'They hoped for a satisfactory outcome to the discussions that would safeguard the EU's interests,' the source said, adding 'while simultaneously accelerating work on countermeasures — including the anti-coercion instrument — in coordination with the Commission, should an agreement not be reached.' The US currently impose 50% on EU steel and aluminium, 25% on cars and 10% on all imports.

White House says claims Trump in Epstein files 'fake news' - as judge blocks bid to unseal court documents
White House says claims Trump in Epstein files 'fake news' - as judge blocks bid to unseal court documents

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

White House says claims Trump in Epstein files 'fake news' - as judge blocks bid to unseal court documents

The White House has dismissed claims that Donald Trump is among hundreds of names mentioned in justice department documents related to late convicted paedophile Jeffrey Epstein as 'fake news'.The Wall Street Journal reported the US president was informed of the fact in May by Attorney General Pam Bondi during a routine briefing, noting that his name appearing in the documents did not indicate any wrongdoing. One official told the news outlet that hundreds of names are in the documents.

ECB leaves interest rates unchanged as it assesses impact of Trump tariffs
ECB leaves interest rates unchanged as it assesses impact of Trump tariffs

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

ECB leaves interest rates unchanged as it assesses impact of Trump tariffs

The European Central Bank has left interest rates unchanged as it waits to see how big a blow US President Donald Trump's tariffs will inflict on the economy before deciding whether to cut rates again. The bank's governing council announced on Thursday at its headquarters in Frankfurt that it would leave its benchmark deposit rate at 2%. 'The economy has so far proven resilient overall in a challenging global environment,' said bank president Christine Lagarde at her post-decision news conference. 'At the same time, the environment remains exceptionally uncertain, especially because of trade disputes.' The ECB has already cut rates eight times since June of last year and Ms Lagarde said after the last policy meeting on June 5 that the central bank is 'getting to the end of a monetary policy cycle'. The monetary authority for the 20 countries that use the euro currency has been lowering rates to support growth after raising them in 2022-2023 to snuff out inflation caused by Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the rebound after the pandemic. With the benchmark rate now at 2%, down from a record high of 4%, analysts think there could be one more rate cut coming, but only in September. The reason, say analysts: The ECB's policymakers simply do not know the outcome of talks between the EU's executive commission and the Trump administration. Mr Trump first set a 20% tariff for EU goods, then threatened 50% after expressing displeasure at the pace of talks, then sent the EU a letter informing officials of a potential 30% tariff. EU officials earlier held out hope of winning at least the 10% baseline that applies to almost all trade partners, and analysts think the actual rate may be lower than Mr Trump's tariff threats. The talks are up against an August 1 deadline, but earlier deadlines have slipped as the sides kept talking. With signs of economic activity holding up reasonably well, the ECB can afford to wait and see what the outcome of trade negotiations will be. Higher tariffs, or import taxes, on European goods would mean sellers would have to either increase prices for US consumers – risking loss of market share – or swallow the added cost in terms of lower profits. In either case, higher tariffs would hurt export earnings for European firms and slow the economy, which would strengthen the case for another rate cut in September. The ECB's rate cuts have helped support economic activity by lowering the cost of credit for consumers and businesses to purchase goods. Higher rates have the opposite effect and are used to cool off inflation by reducing demand for goods. Growth in the eurozone was relatively strong at 0.6% in the first quarter – though that was partly thanks to rushed shipments of goods trying to beat the tariffs. Inflation has fallen from double digits in late 2022 to 2% in June, in line with the ECB's target. A stronger euro, which lowers the price of imports, and softer global prices for oil have helped keep inflation moderate. The stronger euro, up 13% this year at 1.17 dollars, has attracted attention as a potential damper on growth and ECB vice president Luis de Guindos said any rapid moves over 1.20 dollars could be 'much more complicated'. But the ECB typically does not target the exchange rate, and the euro's rise is considered to be less the result of Europe's strength and more the result of a weaker dollar weighed down by investor uncertainty about the future path of inflation, growth and government debt in the US.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store