logo
PSU banks trading below book value despite healthy ROE: Krishna Sanghavi

PSU banks trading below book value despite healthy ROE: Krishna Sanghavi

Time of India11 hours ago
Despite healthy return ratios and minimal asset quality issues, several PSU
banks
are trading below book value, according to
Krishna Sanghavi
, CIO-Equity at Mahindra Manulife. This
valuation
anomaly comes at a time when the fund house is launching a dedicated
BFSI
sectoral fund, betting on India's demographic dividend and the ongoing financialization of savings in a formal economy.
In this conversation, Sanghavi explains why BFSI offers both cyclical rebound potential in lending and secular growth in non-lending businesses, while discussing how the sector's composition has evolved dramatically—with banks' share of BFSI market cap shrinking from 85% to 57% over two decades, creating opportunities across insurance, AMCs, NBFCs, and capital market intermediaries.
Edited excerpts from an interview:
What's the core thesis behind launching a sectoral fund focused on BFSI at this market juncture? Are you betting on a cyclical rebound or a structural re-rating?
BFSI is a core play on India's demographics, rising per capita income amidst the financialization of savings in a formal economy. Overall, we expect the penetration of different financial products to rise. More Indians are likely to enter higher income strata and can contribute to BFSI sectors' growth either as a saver or borrower (lending), investor (asset management or capital market or life insurance) or seeking protection (life insurance or general insurance). We see it as a combination of cyclical rebound (lending) in line with the economy and secular growth (non-lending businesses).
Additionally, there are opportunities for earnings growth and valuations within the various micro-segments in BFSI. Banks, both private and PSUs, have healthy balance sheets and return ratios with minimal asset quality issues. Moreover, the
Nifty Financial Services
index underperformed the Nifty 500 index in four out of the last five calendar years. Valuations are reasonable and earnings outlook is also improving. The Nifty Financial Services index has already shown signs of revival, outperforming the broader Nifty 500 index by nearly 9.8% in the January to June 25 period. While liquidity has improved, we are yet to see improvement in deposit and credit growth, which could play out as the year progresses, supporting our positive views on the overall BFSI sector.
Expect credit quality to remain good and steady growth to help BFSI maintain broad participation in the profit pool.
BFSI is already one-third of India's market cap and profit pool. What's the incremental opportunity you see, and how differentiated can this fund be from existing diversified funds?
Within BFSI, companies in sub-sectors such as lending, asset management, and wealth fund will thus be a standalone play on the BFSI theme, compared to our diversified funds where BFSI is only a part of the overall portfolio sectoral continuity of earnings from fund will thus be a standalone play on the BFSI theme compared to our diversified funds, where BFSI is only a part of the overall portfolio sectoral portfolio.
While banking has been the traditional heavyweight, how are you looking at the broader spectrum—insurance, AMCs, fintechs, NBFCs? Which segments excite you the most today?
As income levels rise, customers start shifting from savers to either borrowers or investors. This creates wider opportunities for those businesses. When we examine history, in March 2005, Banks constituted nearly 85% of the BFSI market capitalisation, now make up only 57% of the BFSI market capitalisation, while 2—Various from NBFCs and the remaining 20% from segment BFSI financial services companies has continued to rise with their strong earnings growth and news has kept on rising with their strong earnings growth and also newer listings. Each of these financial services segments brings in its own set of opportunities and challenges. Insurance companies have seen healthy growth, driven by rising penetration. Asset managers have seen rapid AUM growth in the last few years, thanks to rising incomes & shift towards investing, partly helped by strong market returns. On the fintech side, there have only been a couple of listings till now and a few others are expected to get listed soon. We believe these segments offer a reasonable growth opportunity.
With valuations in private banks and NBFCs at or below long-term averages, do you see this as a compelling entry point or is it more about selective positioning?
Yes, equity portfolio construct would always be about selective positioning based on stock specific criteria like growth, management and valuations. At times this gets impacted due to distortions of ownership or inclusion/exclusion in ETFs. Also, it is part of the investing cycles that at any point, some companies trade at higher or lower than long term average. Overall, we see a healthy environment with a supportive monetary policy on both lower rates as well as higher liquidity and this can help few lenders based on their asset liability mix.
How do you perceive the growth opportunity in PSU bank stocks?
The PSU banks have gone through a healthy consolidation (mergers), governance reforms & balance sheet improvement. The balance sheet has strengthened with higher capital adequacy, and the narrative on PSU stocks has improved due to diversification into retail lending and recoveries from corporate loans. Operationally, the digital rollout is helping and so is control over total employees. Higher capital would help them grow lending when the corporate capex cycle picks up. From a valuation perspective, quite a few PSU banks are trading below book value despite healthy ROA &
ROE
in FY25.
Capital market intermediaries have become significant in BFSI's narrative and an investor favourite as well. Do you see them as consistent compounders?
Capital market players have a good growth potential as India moves from being a nation of savers to a nation of investors. Rising per capita income as well as younger demography creates new customer segments who are looking at risk-return trade-offs on their investments. One advantage for these businesses is they don't require much capital for growth and hence a good execution led by digital distribution can help them grow sustainably at higher rates. The BFSI universe includes quite a few capital market intermediaries and we expect more investible opportunities from future listings. However, some of these businesses are cyclical and hence a focus on earning sustainability and valuations is a must.
In between the two ends of banks and NBFCs, the tilt has largely been in favour of the latter in a rate cut cycle. But given the valuations for both, which one would you be more biased towards?
The fact that banks may face margin pressure in a rate cut cycle and NBFCs may benefit is largely known. So, NBFCs have done well in the last year and now valuations for few NBFCs are higher relative to banks. Based on the investment timeframe being short or medium term, the rate cut cycle would start supporting the cost of funds for banks with a time-lag based on their liability franchise, maturity structure and rate cut on savings deposits. The CRR cut and easy liquidity too would help.
India's insurance sector remains underpenetrated despite a decade of liberalization. What's the investment case for life vs general insurance at this stage?
The outlook for the life insurance segment looks healthy at the moment given these companies faced VNB margin pressure in FY25 due to higher salience of ULIP sales in their mix. The product mix can be more balanced this year, aiding the margin growth. The general insurance segment is seeing slower growth on the motor segment while health insurance segment growth is strong though not very profitable. With the upcoming regulatory norms on expense management, the profitability of the general insurance sector could show improvement as insurers adhere to expense and commission caps. From the investor side, expected IFRS implementation in the next 2 years will help reduce the gap between accounting profits and VNB profits. Another regulatory support is the expected reduction in GST rate that can make insurance products more affordable. So, both Life & General insurance makes a good investment case from a longer term.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

INR slumps to one and half week low
INR slumps to one and half week low

Business Standard

time14 minutes ago

  • Business Standard

INR slumps to one and half week low

The Indian rupee fell sharply by 47 paise to close at 85.87 (provisional) against the US dollar, an over one week low on Monday amid recovering global crude oil prices and American currency regaining momentum after the sharp slide. Outflow of foreign funds fuelled by uncertainties over US President Donald Trump's trade tariffs put further pressure on the local unit. At the interbank foreign exchange, the rupee opened at 85.53 against the US dollar and traded in the range of 85.51-86.03 before settling at 85.87 (provisional), lower by 47 paise from its previous close. The domestic headline equity benchmarks closed little changed after a choppy session, as investors stayed cautious ahead of a potential breakthrough in US-India trade talks. Despite the uncertainty, the market managed a positive finish, supported by continued buying from domestic institutional investors. The Nifty ended above the 25,450 mark. The S&P BSE Sensex rose 9.61 points or 0.01% to 83,442.50. The Nifty 50 index rose 0.30 points or 0.0% to 25,461.30. Meanwhile, Indias foreign exchange reserves rose by $4.84 billion to $702.78 billion in the week ended June 27, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) said on Friday, July 4. Foreign currency assets surged by $5.75 billion to $594.82 billion. Gold reserves fell by $1.23 billion to $84.5 billion during the reported week, while special drawing rights (SDRs) rose by $158 million to $18.83 billion. Indias reserve position with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) also increased by $176 million to $4.62 billion, central bank data showed.

Benchmarks end flat amid US-India trade deal buzz
Benchmarks end flat amid US-India trade deal buzz

Business Standard

time19 minutes ago

  • Business Standard

Benchmarks end flat amid US-India trade deal buzz

The headline equity benchmarks closed little changed after a choppy session, as investors stayed cautious ahead of a potential breakthrough in US-India trade talks. Media reports hinted that a mini trade deal could be announced as early as this evening. Despite the uncertainty, the market managed a positive finish, supported by continued buying from domestic institutional investors. The Nifty ended above the 25,450 mark. FMCG and energy stocks saw strong interest, while IT and metal shares dragged on the indices. The S&P BSE Sensex rose 9.61 points or 0.01% to 83,442.50. The Nifty 50 index rose 0.30 points or 0.0% to 25,461.30. The broader market underperformed the frontline indices. The S&P BSE Mid-Cap index shed 0.15% and the S&P BSE Small-Cap index fell 0.33%. The market breadth was negative. On the BSE, 1,707 shares rose and 2,364 shares fell. A total of 190 shares were unchanged. The NSE's India VIX, a gauge of the market's expectation of volatility over the near term, added 1.98% to 12.56. India-US Trade Deal Update: India and the US are in a race against time to avoid a 26% reciprocal tariff on Indian exports. An Indian delegation recently returned from Washington after detailed talks. While India is pushing for full exemption, the USs baseline 10% tariff still stands. Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal has made it clear that India will not rush into any deal under pressure and will proceed only when the agreement is fully finalised, properly concluded, and aligned with national interest. Economy: Indias foreign exchange reserves rose by $4.84 billion to $702.78 billion in the week ended June 27, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) said on Friday, July 4. Foreign currency assets surged by $5.75 billion to $594.82 billion. Gold reserves fell by $1.23 billion to $84.5 billion during the reported week, while special drawing rights (SDRs) rose by $158 million to $18.83 billion. Indias reserve position with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) also increased by $176 million to $4.62 billion, central bank data showed. Numbers to Track: The yield on India's 10-year benchmark federal paper rose 0.03% to 6.292 from the previous close of 6.290. In the foreign exchange market, the rupee edged lower against the dollar. The partially convertible rupee was hovering at 85.8950 compared with its close of 85.4000 during the previous trading session. MCX Gold futures for 5 August 2025 settlement fell 0.36% to Rs 96,640. The US Dollar Index (DXY), which tracks the greenback's value against a basket of currencies, was up 0.23% to 97.04. The United States 10-year bond yield rose 0.95% to 4.357. In the commodities market, Brent crude for September 2025 settlement shed 03 cents or 0.04% to $ 68.77 a barrel. Global Markets: European indices traded higher on Monday, with investors alert for any trade-related headlines in the countdown to US president Donald Trumps tariff deadline. Asian equities ended mixed amid continued uncertainty surrounding US trade policy. President Donald Trump confirmed that the "reciprocal" tariffs announced in April will take effect on August 1 for countries that have not reached a trade agreement with the US. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent reiterated that the tariffs introduced in April will be enforced starting August 1. While he clarified that this date does not represent a new deadline, he noted it may provide additional time for trade partners to renegotiate terms. The Reserve Bank of Australia has commenced its two-day policy meeting, with markets widely expecting a 25 basis point rate cut, which would bring the benchmark rate down to 3.60%. On Thursday, US equity indices closed at record highs, supported by optimism that the administration may again delay the imposition of tariffs. The S&P 500 gained 0.8%, the NASDAQ Composite advanced 1%, and the Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 0.8%. U.S. market was closed Friday for the Independence Day holiday. Strength in technology stocks also contributed to the rally, with continued investor interest in major artificial intelligence firms such as Nvidia. Meanwhile, the US economy added 147,000 nonfarm payroll jobs in June, while the unemployment rate held steady at 4.1%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The labor market data suggests underlying resilience, prompting a reduction in expectations for imminent rate cuts. Stocks in Spotlight: Senco Gold rose 3.99% after the company reported a 28% year-on-year growth in total revenue during the AprilJune quarter, supported by festivals that significantly boosted footfalls across showrooms. Indusind Bank shed 0.17%. The banks total deposits fell 0.3% to Rs 3,97,233 crore as of 30th June 2025 compared with Rs 3,98,513 crore as of 30th June 2024. DCX Systems gained 3.21% after the company announced it had received an industrial license to manufacture high-end defence electronics. Hazoor Multi Projects zoomed 15.40% after the company announced that it has secured order worth Rs 913 crore from Apollo Green Energy (formerly Apollo International) for the execution of a 200 MW grid-connected solar photovoltaic (PV) project in Gujarat. Completion is expected by March 2026. Godrej Consumer Products rallied 6.46% after the company expects the consolidated double-digit revenue growth on the back of high-single-digit UVG in Q1 FY26. Dhanlaxmi Bank rose 1.40%. The banks gross advances grew 17.3% to Rs 12,484 crore as of 30 June 2025 from Rs 10,643 crore as of 30 June 2024. The private lender reported 14.7% growth in total deposits to Rs 16,570 crore in Q1 FY26 as against Rs 14,441 crore recorded in Q1 FY25. Tourism Finance Corporation of India (TFCI) rallied 6.28% after the companys board is scheduled to meet on 10 July 2025, to consider the proposal for the subdivision or split of the existing equity shares. Kalyan Jewellers India shed 0.24%. The company reported a consolidated revenue growth of 31% year-on-year in Q1FY26, despite intermittent demand disruptions during the quarter, largely attributed to gold price volatility and geopolitical tensions. Texmaco Rail & Engineering fell 0.58%. The company said that it has received an order worth Rs 36.27 crore from Transport Corporation of India (TCI) for the supply of two rakes, comprising 54 ACT-3 type wagons and two BVCM wagons. The order is scheduled to be executed within 24 months. IPO Update: The initial public offer (IPO) of Travel Food Services received bids for 13,62,153 shares as against 13,412,842 shares on offer, according to stock exchange data at 16:50 IST on Friday (7 July 2025). The issue was subscribed 0.10 times. The issue opened for bidding on Monday (7 July 2025) and it will close on Wednesday (9 July 2025). The price band of the IPO is fixed between Rs 1,045 and 1,100 per share. An investor can bid for a minimum of 13 equity shares and in multiples thereof.

Op Sindoor has boosted global demand for Indian defence products: Rajnath
Op Sindoor has boosted global demand for Indian defence products: Rajnath

United News of India

time27 minutes ago

  • United News of India

Op Sindoor has boosted global demand for Indian defence products: Rajnath

New Delhi, July 7 (UNI) Defence Minister Rajnath Singh, while highlighting the success of Operation Sindoor, said that the valour shown by the armed forces and the proven effectiveness of indigenous equipment have significantly boosted global demand for Indian-made defence products. 'The world is looking at our defence sector with new respect. A single delay or error in financial processes can directly affect operational preparedness,' Rajnath Singh said during the Controllers' Conference of the Defence Accounts Department (DAD) here today, a Defence Ministry statement said. He also called on the DAD to evolve from a 'controller' to a 'facilitator' in sync with increasing participation of the private sector in defence. Stating that India has moved towards Aatmanirbharta and structural reform in defence planning, finance, and innovation under the Modi government, Rajnath said, 'Most of the equipment we once imported is now being made in India. Our reforms are succeeding because of the clarity of vision and commitment at the highest level'. Addressing the larger geopolitical context, the Minister mentioned the rising global military expenditure reaching USD 2.7 trillion in 2024, as per Stockholm International Peace Research Institute and stated that this opens up tremendous opportunities for India's indigenous defence industries. He stressed that with the government's focus on 'Aatmanirbharta in Defence', India's industries must be prepared for the global demand shift and play a larger role in exports and innovation. 'Our effort is to ensure that decisions are taken swiftly so that we can begin manufacturing larger engines right here in India and that this journey begins with the hands of Indians,' he added, reaffirming the government's commitment to building advanced indigenous defence manufacturing capabilities. Highlighting the increasing strategic and economic significance of the defence sector, he called for a shift in perception from defence spending as mere expenditure to an economic investment with multiplier impact. 'Until recently, defence budgets were not seen as part of the national economy. Today, they are growth drivers,' he added. He mentioned that India, along with the rest of the world, is entering a new phase of re-armament, marked by capital-intensive investments in the defence sector. He urged the department to incorporate Defence Economics in their planning and assessments, including social impact analysis of R&D projects and dual-use technologies. The Defence Minister also referred to the recently launched Research, Development and Innovation (RDI) scheme with a budget of Rs one lakh crore, which prioritises defence sector innovation and procurement of high-end technology. He encouraged the DAD to become active enablers in ensuring smooth implementation and timely funding of such projects, particularly from start-ups, MSMEs, and the private sector. He highlighted the fact, for the first time, the Defence Acquisition Council (DAC) has approved the acquisition of weapon systems through the capital route, and urged the department to be prepared for financial activities related to this shift. Rajnath praised the department's new motto 'Alert, Agile, Adaptive' and noted that these are not mere words, but a reflection of the work culture required in today's rapidly evolving defence environment. He urged officials to undertake internal reform through self-introspection, rather than relying solely on external audits or consultants. 'Improvements made through internal evaluation create living organisations. These reforms are more organic, with fewer barriers,' he stated. 'Peace time is nothing but an illusion. Even during periods of relative calm, we must prepare for uncertainty. Sudden developments can force a complete shift in our financial and operational posture. Whether it's stepping up equipment production or adapting financial processes, we must be ready with innovative techniques and responsive systems at all times,' the defence Minister stated. He called upon DAD to incorporate this mindset into their planning, budgeting and decision-making systems. He also referred to upcoming digital initiatives such as the Comprehensive Pay System and Centralised Database Management System, which will simplify pay and personnel data management and support faster, real-time decision-making across services. He welcomed the department's work on the vision document and roadmap for Defence Finance & Economics, while urging timely implementation and the ability to make course corrections, if required. Rajnath emphasised that even small errors in the department's processes can have significant consequences. 'At the place where you are working, if you make even a small mistake, then the soldiers do not get the necessary resources on time. Due to our negligence, there can be a problem in budget allocation and it directly affects operational readiness,' he emphasized. The Defence Minister congratulated the Defence Secretary & CGDA for achieving full utilisation of the capital budget in the previous financial year, and expressed confidence that the department would maintain the same fiscal discipline going forward. He stressed that financial planning should focus not only on budget growth, but also on efficiency-led growth, ensuring the right deployment at the right time for the right objective. 'Let us all pledge to remain alert, agile, and adaptive so that our work remains relevant and impactful. Our responsibility is immense, and every decision we make contributes to the larger vision of national security and self-reliance,' Rajnath highlighted. He also commended the conference agenda, which includes sessions on Change Management, Budgeting, Internal Audit, Procurement, Industry Partnerships, and Capacity Building. Chief of Defence Staff General Anil Chauhan, Chief of the Naval Staff Admiral Dinesh K Tripathi, Chief of the Army Staff General Upendra Dwivedi, Chief of the Air Staff Air Chief Marshal AP Singh, Defence Secretary Rajesh Kumar Singh, Secretary Department of Defence R&D and Chairman DRDO Samir V Kamat, Financial Adviser (Defence Services) S G Dastidar, and Controller General of Defence Accounts Mayank Sharma were also present on the occasion. UNI RBE PRS

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store